Research knowledge among the participants in the Treatment for Adolescents With Depression Study (TADS)

Older Adolescents' Understanding of Participant Rights in the BlackBerry Project, a Longitudinal Ambulatory Assessment Study

For a long-term, longitudinal study that used BlackBerry smartphones for passive ambulatory assessment among older adolescents, this study focused on three areas of ethical concern: (1) adolescents' competence to give assent; (2) understanding of confidentiality, the protection of information, and project goals; and (3) awareness of procedures and benefits, and comfort with the research design. One hundred and seventy-eight participants were 17 and 18 years old (84 girls). Results suggested that participants freely gave consent and understood most, but not all of the informed consent information. Participants reported a high level of satisfaction. Participants showed less understanding of when their confidentiality would be broken and how data would be protected.

Understanding Ethical Issues of Research Participation From the Perspective of Participating Children and Adolescents: A Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

The past 20 years have seen distinct shifts in the way the participation of children and adolescents in research is viewed. This has been emphasized by the growing pediatric research enterprise. Additional information on children's and adolescents' experiences during research participation is needed to better inform researchers on the ethical conduct of research with this vulnerable population.

AIMS

The objective of this analysis was to examine ethical issues in research with children and adolescents from their perspective as participants, including: assent, parental consent, risk perception, impact of research participation, and incentives.

METHODS

This systematic review was conducted per the Long, Godfrey, Randall, Brettle, and Grant framework by means of an iterative searching process. Using the key words "research ethics" and "child or pediatric or adolescent," PubMed, CINAHL, and EBSCOhost databases were searched to identify articles. Limitations placed on the searches were: English language, year of publication between 2003 and 2014, humans, abstract available, and age birth-18 years.

FINDINGS

Twenty-three empiric studies were identified and formed the sample. Included studies represented a diverse range of areas of research, methods, settings, sample demographics, authors, and journals.

LINKING EVIDENCE TO ACTION

Even young children demonstrated the ability to understand essential elements of research, although there is variability in children's level of understanding. Trust was a significant contributing factor to children's and adolescents' participation in research, and also shaped their assessments of risk. Research participation was mainly beneficial for children and adolescents. Incentives were mainly viewed positively, although concerns of possible undue influence were expressed.

Recruiting underserved mothers to medical research: findings from North Carolina

Representative samples are required for ethical, valid, and useful health research. Yet, recruiting participants, especially from historically underserved communities, can be challenging. This paper presents findings from in-depth interviews with 40 mothers about factors that might influence their willingness to participate or allow their children to participate in medical research. Saliency analysis organizes the findings. Frequent and important salient themes about research participation included concerns that it might cause participants harm, hope that participants might gain a health benefit, and recognition that time and transportation resources could limit participation. Ultimately, we propose that a theoretical model, such as the Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB), will facilitate more systematic evaluation of effective methods for recruitment and retention of participants in medical research. Future research should explore the utility of such a model for development of effective recruitment and retention strategies.

Attitudes and beliefs toward biobehavioural research participation: voices and concerns of urban adolescent females receiving outpatient mental health treatment

BACKGROUND

Biobehavioural research methodology can be invasive and burdensome for participants - particularly adolescents with mental illnesses. Human biological researchers should consider how methodological impositions may hinder adolescent research participation. However, literature on adolescent's voices and concerns toward biobehavioural research participation is virtually non-existent.

AIM

This study was designed to determine adolescents' perceptions of participation in research involving the collection of biomarkers via blood, saliva and/or urine samples.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

Urban adolescent females (aged 12-19) receiving outpatient mental health treatment (n = 37) participated in focus groups with concurrent survey administration to explore attitudes, beliefs and willingness/intentions toward biobehavioural research participation.

RESULTS

Participants had favourable attitudes toward biobehavioural research and were amenable to provide each specimen type. Mistrust for research emerged, however, and concerns related to privacy and confidentiality were expressed.

CONCLUSION

Participant recruitment is a critical component in study design and implementation; this includes knowledge of population-specific recruitment barriers and facilitators. This innovative paper provides a context for the research participants' decision-making process, strategies to allay fears and concerns and concrete areas to target in research-related interventions. Although the findings are from a specific, US-based sample, the implications warrant replication of the research in other geosocial settings.

Ethics in child and adolescent psychiatric care: An international perspective

In the treatment of children with psychiatric disorders as a vulnerable population, ethical issues arise that seldom come into play with adults. The UN Conventions on the Rights of the Child and the Rights of Persons with Disabilities set out rights to be respected in child and adolescent psychiatric treatment. Rights of participation and inclusion (minimizing of barriers to the involvement of disabled people) can create complex problems in cases of restraint or deprivation of liberty. This paper analyses the consequences of these conventions and other ethics guidelines on child and adolescent psychiatric treatment and research. Beneficence, justice and autonomy are core principles that are mirrored in the problems of inclusion and protection, confidentiality, and the safety of psychopharmacological interventions. Factors of inclusion are involved in the areas of availability of care, participation in best evidence-based treatment, and research. The right of the child to protection, the right of inclusion, and parents' rights and duties to safeguard their child's wellbeing form a triangle. National laws to regulate the treatment of psychiatrically ill children should be created and implemented and these should be non-discriminatory but at the same time safeguard the developing human being.

Report of an initial pilot study on the feasibility of using the MacArthur competence assessment tool for clinical research in children and adolescents with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder

INTRODUCTION

The MacArthur Competence Assessment Tool for Clinical Research (MacCAT-CR) was used in children and adolescents with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and co-morbid oppositional defiant disorder (ODD) and in their parents. The aims were to test feasibility and to determine children's understanding of the elements of disclosure for a clinical drug trial and their competence to assent.

METHOD

The contents and language of MacCAT-CR were adapted to be age appropriate for the children. Twelve children (mean age, 9.87 [7.7-12.2]; mean intelligence quotient [IQ], 97 [72-122]) and either the mother or father of each child were interviewed. Psychologists rated the interviews and, in addition to MacCAT-CR, competence was assessed by trained clinicians.

RESULTS

The MacCAT-CR was practicable, and the time required was acceptable. Interrater reliability was excellent in children. Children performed less well than parents on this test (children;s vs. parents' scores: Understanding 5.86 vs. 9.08, appreciation 2.64 vs. 4.96, reasoning 3.05 vs. 4.63, respectively). Whereas clinicians assessed all children as competent, lack of competence became apparent in the MacCAT-CR.

CONCLUSIONS

The practicability and the interrater reliability suggest that the MacCAT-CR is feasible in children, but the question of whether competence is assessed validly remains unsolved in the absence of external validation. The differences between assessment by clinicians and the low scores obtained in the MacCAT-CR suggest that children may give assent even if they do not understand completely. The results of this initial pilot study may help in the planning of further investigations intended to improve information about studies and assessment of assent/consent.

A critical evaluation of the role of cognitive behaviour therapy in children and adolescents with depression

Depressive disorders are relatively common in adolescents although less so in younger children. They accrue significant morbidity and frequent long-term sequelae as well as increased suicide risk in sufferers. Evidence-based treatment of depression in children and adolescents is the subject of intense investigation and debate. This article reviews the current evidence base for cognitive behaviour therapy in this group and makes recommendations for further areas of research.

Psychotropic medication research in children and adolescents: empirical findings and ethical implications

WITH THE ESCALATION IN PRESCRIPTIONS of psychotropic medicine to young people over the last 11.2 decades, there has been increased scrutiny of psychopharmacological research with children and adults. There is a small but growing literature on participant knowledge of consent form information and of subject satisfaction in psychopharmacological studies. The data thus far suggest that parents and their participating children generally have had a good knowledge of the purposes of the trials, experimental conditions, possibility of receiving placebo, and right to withdraw from pharmacological trials; however, understanding of randomization is relatively poor. Social validity surveys indicate high levels of satisfaction with choice of outcome measures, clinical recommendations emanating from the research, and treatment received; most participants indicate that they would recommend the studies to other parents and children having similar conditions. None of the studies reviewed appears in a journal dedicated to research ethics or bioethics and in this sense may be hidden from IRB members and bioethicists. Nevertheless, the findings are pertinent to IRB deliberations. More research on participant knowledge and satisfaction is needed, with some emphasis on the perspectives of the youth themselves.

Ethical issues in psychopharmacology of children and adolescents

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

This summary of the literature published over recent years focuses on the ethical aspects of interventions with psychotropic medication in child and adolescent psychiatry. Ethical issues of pharmacotherapy concern aspects of research, safety, indicated use, enhancement, information and evidence-based practice.

RECENT FINDINGS

The literature on pharmacological interventions suggests changes in prescribing patterns for some substance classes owing to regulatory authorities' warnings. For most of the commonly used medications in children and adolescents no sound database about efficacy and safety is available and knowledge about adverse events and long-term safety remains poor. This is due to a general lack of clinical trials in this population. Legislative efforts have tried to improve safety and labelling of medicines for children. Ethical issues of enhancement in minors have been increasingly discussed over recent years.

SUMMARY

The ethical aspects of psychopharmacotherapy in minors are still rarely discussed in the literature. Practical questions of research and treatment ethics such as a need for information for children and parents are pointed out; conflicts of evocation and access to care for special populations in need are identified in a field lacking adequate ethical and clinical research.