What is the Natural History of the Triangular Fibrocartilage Complex Tear Without Distal Radioulnar Joint Instability?

Current concepts and new trends in management of isolated triangular fibrocartilage complex injuries

The triangular fibrocartilaginous complex is made of multiple components, of which the palmar and dorsal radioulnar ligaments play an important role in distal radioulnar joint stability. The ulnar wrist ligaments may be injured during forearm and wrist trauma. There are several aspects of triangular fibrocartilaginous complex management that are still open to debate. The aim of the present study was to review the current concepts and discuss emerging trends to better elucidate and treat this important ligament complex.Level of evidence: V.

Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Early versus Late Debridement of Superficial Triangular Fibrocartilage Complex Tears

Background

While initial nonoperative management is the conventional approach for superficial triangular fibrocartilage complex (TFCC) tears, a substantial portion of these cases go on to require surgery, and the optimal duration of nonoperative treatment is unknown. In this study, we evaluate the cost-effectiveness of early versus late arthroscopic debridement for the treatment of superficial TFCC tears without distal radioulnar joint (DRUJ) instability.

Methods

We created a decision tree to compare the following strategies from a healthcare payer perspective: immediate arthroscopic debridement versus immobilization for 4 or 6 weeks with late debridement as needed. Costs were obtained from the Centers for Medicaid and Medicare Services and a national administrative claims database. Probabilities and health-related quality-of-life measures were obtained from published sources. We conducted sensitivity analyses on model inputs, including a probabilistic sensitivity analysis consisting of 10,000 Monte Carlo simulations.

Results

Immobilization for 6 weeks while reserving arthroscopic debridement for refractory cases was both the least costly and most effective strategy. Immediate arthroscopic debridement became cost-effective when success rates of immobilization for 4 or 6 weeks were less than 7.7 or 10.5%, respectively. Our probabilistic sensitivity analysis showed that immobilization for 6 weeks was preferred 97.6% of the time, and immobilization for 4 weeks was preferred 2.4% of the time.

Conclusion

Although various early and late debridement strategies can be used to treat superficial TFCC tears without DRUJ instability, immobilization for 6 weeks while reserving arthroscopic debridement for refractory cases is the optimal strategy from a cost-effectiveness standpoint.

A Simple Surgical Technique for Arthroscopic Repair of Traumatic Radial-Side Peripheral TFCC Tear

Conventionally, The Triangular Fibrocartilage Complex (TFCC) surgical procedures are complex in nature with open explorations and long hospital stays not to mention the added costs and the psychological stress for both the surgeon and the patient. Nowadays, surgical procedures are looked at in a different scope with the rapid progress of arthroscopic technology and equipment. To elaborate, here we introduce a simple surgical technique for arthroscopic repair of traumatic radial - side peripheral TFCC tear. In spite of the various surgical techniques found in the literature, we just used a k-wire and a couple of needles in order to repair Radial-sided peripheral TFCC tear. the simplicity of the current technique, adequate satisfaction and eliminating the use of a targeting device, is what sets this apart. For emphasis, this technique is less time consuming and is cost-effective with satisfactory result.

Outcome in TFCC repair using micro anchor and trans‑osseous technique

The triangular fibrocartilage complex (TFCC) is an intrinsic stabiliser of the distal radioulnar joint (DRUJ), which serves an important role in wrist movement, forearm rotation and grip strength. A stable DRUJ is a key requirement for pain-free movement of the wrist. TFCC tears are a common ulnar-sided wrist pain associated with decreased grip strength and impaired function. TFCC tears are classified according to the location and cause. The Palmer classification delineates tears into traumatic type 1 and degenerative type 2. The present study investigated the clinical outcomes of using micro suture anchors in open repair in comparison with trans-osseous TFCC repair. From July 2017 to July 2020, 51 patients underwent open repair of TFCC tear by hand and upper limb surgeons in Royal Rehabilitation Center at King Hussein Medical Center (Amman, Jordan). Stability of DRUJ and tenderness at the ulnar aspect of the wrist were evaluated by Disability of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand (DASH) and Modified Mayo Wrist Score (MMWS) pre- and post-operatively. A total of 38 patients (27 male and 11 females) underwent open repair using micro suture anchors and 13 (7 male and 6 female) by trans-osseous repair. A total of 51 patients in the follow-up 6-48 months had significant improvement in pain and range of motion. A total of 45 patients showed improved grip strength and were pain-free; six patients showed improvement of grip strength and decreased pain. For the patients who underwent TFCC repair by micro suture anchors, there was an improvement of MMWS from 70 to 90%, and for those who underwent TFCC repair by trans-osseous technique, MMWS improved from 65 to 85%. There was also significant improvement in DASH score post-operatively with both techniques, from 60 to 15% in the trans-osseous technique and from 70 to 15% in the suture anchors. Open repair of TFCC tears using either micro anchor or trans-osseous repair led to pain-free range of motion, improved grip strength, stable DRUJ and improvement in DASH and MMWS scores, with no significant differences in clinical outcome between techniques.

All-Inside Versus Outside-in Repair of Triangular Fibrocartilage Complex Peripheral Tears

PURPOSE

Triangular fibrocartilage complex (TFCC) peripheral tears with persistent wrist pain can be treated with arthroscopic surgical repair owing to vascularization of the peripheral region. The safety and efficacy of all-inside repair has been shown in prior case series. The purpose of this study was to compare two methods of arthroscopic peripheral TFCC repair: all-inside vertical mattress and outside-in horizontal mattress.

METHODS

A 5-year retrospective review was performed on patients treated from 2016 to 2021 with wrist arthroscopy and TFCC repair for Palmer 1B tears. Patients with ulnar extrinsic ligament repair, distal radioulnar joint instability, concomitant ulnar shortening osteotomy, and extensor carpi ulnaris instability were excluded. Patient therapy and office visit records were reviewed. Outcomes including Quick Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand (QuickDASH); range of motion; grip strength; immobilization time; complications; and need for revision procedures were compared.

RESULTS

Fifty-two patients were included in the study, 32 in the outside-in group and 20 in the all-inside group. The average follow-up length was 24.8 weeks, with similar range of motion and strength in both groups. The average postoperative QuickDASH score was 13 in the outside-in group and 9 in the all-inside group at 43.5 months, compared with the preoperative QuickDASH scores of 47 and 50, respectively. Mean immobilization time was longer for outside-in than for all-inside (5.25 vs 2.0 weeks, respectively).

CONCLUSIONS

All-inside arthroscopic peripheral TFCC repair showed range of motion, grip strength, complications, revisions, and postoperative improvement in QuickDASH scores similar to those with the outside-in technique.

TYPE OF STUDY/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic IV; retrospective comparative study.

Return to Activity After Arthroscopically Assisted Triangular Fibrocartilage Complex Repair: A Systematic Review

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate patients' ability to return to preinjury activity level after arthroscopically assisted triangular fibrocartilage complex (TFCC) repair.

DATA SOURCES

The PubMed electronic library was systematically searched from inception to August 2021 for any eligible articles using a combination of the phrases "TFCC," "return to sport," "return to work," and "athlete."

RESULTS

Studies that evaluated patients who had undergone arthroscopic repair of isolated TFCC injury and reported objective or patient-reported outcome measures were included. Fifteen studies representing 478 patients fulfilled the inclusion criteria. An average of 84% of patients were able to fully return to their previous work or sport activities. Most studies reported that range of motion (ROM) and grip strength (GS) both returned to >90% of the contralateral side, and every study that evaluated pain levels found a significant reduction in pain postoperatively. Mayo Modified Wrist Score was reported as excellent or good in 83% of patients, and the average Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand score was 13.8 postoperatively.

CONCLUSION

Patients were able to return to their previous work or sport activities at a high rate after TFCC repair, even those participating in more strenuous activities. Measurable functional outcomes of ROM and GS were also reliably restored to near preinjury levels. Patient-reported outcomes of pain and disability were similarly improved after TFCC repair. Current literature has established the long-term success of TFCC repair but is lacking in evaluation of the time points at which patients can expect functional status to be restored.

Lesiones traumáticas crónicas del complejo fibrocartílago triangular: ¿Cómo enfrentarlas?

Las lesiones crónicas del complejo fibrocartílago triangular (CFCT) son una entidad que no ha sido descrita previamente como tal y no existe consenso en su manejo. La temporalidad de la lesión y su potencial de reparación son aspectos fundamentales a la hora de indicar un tratamiento. Proponemos un esquema de enfrentamiento a lesiones traumáticas crónicas del CFCT y describimos una técnica novedosa de reconstrucción con injerto de brachioradialis con asistencia artroscópica. Mostramos los resultados y el seguimiento de dos pacientes intervenidos con esta técnica.

Stabilization of the Distal Radioulnar Joint with or without Triangular Fibrocartilage Complex Tear by an External Wrist Band Brace: A Cadaveric Study

The purpose of this study was to investigate whether a watch-shaped external wrist band brace improves distal radioulnar joint (DRUJ) stability. Seven fresh cadaveric arms were used. Using a customized testing system, volar and dorsal translation forces were applied to the radius externally while the ulna was fixed. The test was performed with the forearm in neutral, 60° pronated, and 60° supinated positions, once without the brace and once with the brace applied. In each condition, the amount of translation was measured. Then, the triangular fibrocartilage complex (TFCC) was detached from the ulnar styloid process and the fovea ulnaris, and the same tests were performed again. Detachment of the TFCC significantly increased volar and dorsal translations in all forearm rotations compared to the intact condition (p < 0.05), except for the pronated dorsal translation of the radius (p = 0.091). Brace application significantly reduced volar and dorsal translations in all forearm rotations both in intact specimens and in TFCC-detached specimens (p < 0.05), except for pronated volar and dorsal translations in TFCC-detached specimens (p = 0.101 and p = 0.131, respectively). With the brace applied, the TFCC-detached specimens showed no significant difference in volar or dorsal translation in all forearm rotations compared to the intact specimens (p > 0.05). The external wrist band brace improved DRUJ stability in both normal and TFCC-torn wrists and reduced the DRUJ instability caused by TFCC tear to a near-normal level.

The Triangular Fibrocartilage Complex In The Human Wrist: A Scoping Review Towards Uniform And Clinically Relevant Terminology

The aim of this scoping review was to assess the composition, terminology, and anatomy of the triangular fibrocartilage complex (TFCC) of the wrist and propose unambiguous terminology regarding the individual components. The review was conducted according to the methodological framework by Arksey and O'Malley (International Journal of Social Research Methodology, 2005, 8, 19–32). Electronic databases were searched from inception until September 1, 2021 for original anatomical studies, using MeSH terms and keywords on terminology and anatomy of TFCC components. Studies using gross dissections or macro‐ or microscopic histology were included. Animal studies, fetal studies and studies with unknown disease status, were excluded. A total of 24 studies were included. The articular disc, the radioulnar ligaments, the meniscus homologue and the extensor carpi ulnaris tendon (sub)sheath were unanimously classified as TFCC components. One study did not include the ulnolunate and ulnotriquetral ligaments and only one study did include the ligamentum subcruentum. The largest disagreement existed regarding the inclusion of the ulnar collateral ligament. Terminological ambiguity was seen in “triangular fibrocartilage,” “triangular ligament,” “igamentum subcruentum,” and the “proximal and distal lamina.” Anatomical ambiguity existed especially regarding the radioulnar ligaments, the ulnar attachments of the TFCC and the ulnar collateral ligament. Definitions of the individual TFCC components are redundant, ambiguous, and ill‐defined and therefore subject to different interpretations. In order to preclude confusion, consensus regarding terminology is recommended. We proposed a concise definition of the healthy TFCC that can be used as a starting point for future studies and current clinical practice.

Experience with Diagnosis and Management of Distal Radioulnar Joint Instability

Objective  The aim of this study is to review our cumulative experience with diagnosis and treatment of distal radioulnar joint (DRUJ) instability and to present our treatment algorithm. Materials and Methods  Retrospective review identified 112 patients who had 126 episodes of care for DRUJ instability at a single institution over a 21-year period. Those diagnosed acutely or subacutely were treated with immobilization of the wrist and elbow for 6 weeks, while those with chronic instability had anatomic reconstruction of the dorsal and palmar radioulnar ligaments with tendon autograft or an alternative arthroscopic treatment with our thermal annealing technique. Short-term treatment failures and surgical complications were recorded. Nonparametric statistical tests were used to analyze key long-term outcome measures including ulnar wrist pain and DRUJ stability indicated by the dorsopalmar stress test. Results  At mean 7-year follow-up, eight patients in the acute-injury cohort had statistically significant improvements in wrist pain and DRUJ instability ( p  < 0.001). In both the 22-patient anatomic reconstruction cohort and the 37-patient arthroscopically treated group, there were also statistically significant improvements in wrist pain and DRUJ stability ( p  < 0.001) at mean 9-year follow-up. The majority of patients in all three groups was satisfied with treatment outcome, though some required secondary procedures. Conclusion  Early clinical diagnosis of DRUJ instability using the dorsopalmar stress test provides an opportunity for effective nonsurgical treatment. For chronic presentation, we recommend our arthroscopic thermal annealing technique for mild or moderate instability and open anatomic reconstruction of the radioulnar ligaments for severe instability. Level of Evidence  This is a Level IV, therapeutic study.

Predictors for poor outcome for conservatively treated traumatic triangular fibrocartilage complex tears

AIMS

The primary aim of this study was to assess if traumatic triangular fibrocartilage complex (TFCC) tears can be treated successfully with immobilization alone. Our secondary aims were to identify clinical factors that may predict a poor prognosis.

METHODS

This was a retrospective analysis of 89 wrists in 88 patients between January 2015 and January 2019. All patients were managed conservatively initially with either a short-arm or above-elbow custom-moulded thermoplastic splint for six weeks. Outcome measures recorded included a visual analogue scale for pain, Patient-Rated Wrist Evaluation, Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand score, and the modified Mayo Wrist Score (MMWS). Patients were considered to have had a poor outcome if their final MMWS was less than 80 points, or if they required eventual surgical intervention. Univariate and logistic regression analyses were used to identify independent predictors for a poor outcome.

RESULTS

In total, 76% of wrists (42/55) treated with an above-elbow splint had a good outcome, compared to only 29% (10/34) with a short-arm splint (p < 0.001). The presence of a complete foveal TFCC tear (p = 0.009) and a dorsally subluxated distal radioulnar joint (DRUJ) (p = 0.032) were significantly associated with a poor outcome on univariate analysis. Sex, age, energy of injury, hand dominance, manual occupation, ulnar variance, and a delay in initial treatment demonstrated no significant association. Multiple logistic regression revealed that short-arm immobilization (p < 0.001) and DRUJ subluxation (p = 0.020) were significant independent predictive factors of an eventual poor outcome.

CONCLUSION

Nonoperative management of traumatic TFCC injuries with above-elbow immobilization is a viable treatment method, particularly in patients without DRUJ subluxation. Early surgery should be considered for patients with dorsal ulnar subluxation treated with short-arm splints to prevent prolonged morbidity. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2021;103-B(8):1386-1391.

Open and Arthroscopic Triangular Fibrocartilage Complex (TFCC) Repair

Triangular fibrocartilage complex (TFCC) tears, whether acute or chronic, can result in persistent ulnar-sided wrist pain. Although diagnosis and nonsurgical management of TFCC tears is well described, there remains ongoing discussion about the optimal surgical technique, specifically open or arthroscopic. This article reviews the most up-to-date literature regarding TFCC injury including demographics, risk factors for TFCC injury, classification of acute and chronic TFCC tears, history and physical examination, appropriate diagnostic imaging, surgical indications, pertinent surgical anatomy, open and arthroscopic TFCC repair, fixation biomechanics and techniques, postoperative rehabilitation, and clinical outcomes.

Editorial Commentary: The Hook Test Is More Accurate for Detecting Foveal Triangular Fibrocartilage Complex Tears but Not More Important Than the Trampoline Test

Wrist arthroscopy is a successful tool to diagnose and treat several intra-articular wrist pathologies. To assess the stability and integrity of the triangular fibrocartilage complex (TFCC), the most commonly injured structure in the ulnocarpal compartment, the trampoline and hook tests are frequently used in daily practice. However, their arthroscopic performance measures have not been well elucidated to date. While the hook test may primarily be seen as a sensitive tool to detect foveal TFCC tears, the trampoline test is of equal importance for the clinician because it can detect frequently occurring superficial (distal) tears in the peripheral TFCC area. As opposed to the hook test, however, the trampoline test might more easily lead to interrater disagreement since the rebound after probing is rather a continuum than a binary measure and might be related to a different severity of peripheral TFCC disruption. The combination of both tests should thus be pursued since they complement each other very well. Proper interpretation of the tests needs sufficient experience and should be done in concordance with the clinical evaluation (ie, fovea sign, distal radioulnar joint ballottement test). Hence, the hook test may be more accurate to detect foveal TFCC tears but all together not more important than the trampoline test to establish the correct diagnosis. For once, Captain Hook has won!

Surgical Repair of Triangular Fibrocartilage Complex Tears: A Systematic Review

Objective  This study systematically reviews the outcomes of surgical repair of triangular fibrocartilage complex (TFCC) tears. Existing surgical techniques include capsular sutures, suture anchors, and transosseous sutures. However, there is still no consensus as to which is the most reliable method for ulnar-sided peripheral and foveal TFCC tears. Methods  A systematic review of MEDLINE and EMBASE was performed according to PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) guidelines. The focus was on traumatic Palmer 1B ulna-sided tears. Twenty-seven studies were included, including three comparative cohort studies. Results  There was improvement in all functional outcome measures after repair of TFCC tears. The outcomes following peripheral and foveal repairs were good overall: Mayo Modified Wrist Evaluation (MMWE) score of 80.1 and 85.1, Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand (DASH) score of 15.7 and 15.8, grip strength of 80.3 and 92.7% (of the nonoperated hand), and pain intensity score of 2.1 and 1.7, respectively. For peripheral tears, transosseous suture technique achieved better outcomes compared with capsular sutures in terms of grip strength, pain, Patient-Rated Wrist Evaluation (PRWE), and DASH scores (grip 85.8 vs. 77.7%; pain 1.5 vs. 2.2; PRWE 11.6 vs. 15.8; DASH 14.4 vs. 16.1). For foveal tears, transosseous sutures achieved overall better functional outcomes compared with suture anchors (MMWE 85.4 vs. 84.9, DASH 10.9 vs. 20.6, pain score 1.3 vs. 2.1), but did report slightly lower grip strength than the group with suture anchors (90.2 vs. 96.2%). Arthroscopic techniques achieved overall better outcomes compared with open repair technique. Conclusion  Current evidence demonstrates that TFCC repair achieves good clinical outcomes, with low complication rates. Level of Evidence  This is a Level IV, therapeutic study.

Ulnar-Side Wrist Pain Management Guidelines: All That Hurts is Not the TFCC!

BACKGROUND

Ulnar-sided wrist pain is a common clinical problem, most often misdiagnosed as triangular fibrocartilage complex (TFCC) injury. It may be frustrating to the patient, as one may end up wearing a wrist splint for an unusually long period, disrupting their routine.

PURPOSE

Because of the dilemmas in the diagnosing the cause of ulnar-sided wrist pain, various algorithms have been suggested but it is an individual's choice to do a systematic assessment and follow in their routine clinical practice. We propose the 'storey concept' for examining the ulnar side of the wrist, with ulnar styloid as the reference point. The lower storey identifies the pathologies of the DRUJ, the intermediate storey identifies the pathologies of the radiocarpal joint and the upper storey identifies the pathologies of midcarpal and carpometacarpal joint.

CONCLUSION

Also, it is important to ramify the cause of pain into stable or unstable wrist, with or without arthritis, as this will guide us in managing the pain arising from distal radioulnar joint. In addition to methodical clinical examination, ideal radiographs and high-resolution MRI are critical to diagnose wrist pathologies. The role of wrist arthroscopy has consistently increased, and complements in both diagnosis and treatment of wrist pain especially in ambiguous situations.

The triangular fibrocartilage complex on high-resolution 3 T MRI in healthy adolescents: the thin line between asymptomatic findings and pathology

OBJECTIVE

The objective of the study is to provide a reference for morphology, homogeneity, and signal intensity of triangular fibrocartilage complex (TFCC) and TFCC-related MRI features in adolescents.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Prospectively collected data on asymptomatic participants aged 12-18 years, between June 2015 and November 2017, were retrospectively analyzed. A radiograph was performed in all participants to determine skeletal age and ulnar variance. A 3-T MRI followed to assess TFCC components and TFCC-related features. A standardized scoring form, based on MRI definitions used in literature on adults, was used for individual assessment of all participants by four observers. Results per item were expressed as frequencies (percentages) of observations by all observers for all participants combined (n = 92). Inter-observer agreement was determined by the unweighted Fleiss' kappa with 95% confidence intervals (95% CI).

RESULTS

The cohort consisted of 23 asymptomatic adolescents (12 girls and 11 boys). Median age was 13.5 years (range 12.0-17.0). Median ulnar variance was -0.7 mm (range - 2.7-1.4). Median triangular fibrocartilage (TFC) thickness was 1.4 mm (range 0.1-2.9). Diffuse increased TFC signal intensity not reaching the articular surface was observed in 30 (33%) observations and a vertical linear increased signal intensity with TFC discontinuation in 19 (20%) observations. Discontinuation between the volar radioulnar ligament and the TFC in the sagittal plane was seen in 23 (25%) observations. The extensor carpi ulnaris was completely dislocated in 10 (11%) observations, more frequent in supinated wrists (p = 0.031). Inter-observer agreement ranged from poor to fair for scoring items on the individual TFCC components.

CONCLUSION

MRI findings, whether normal variation or asymptomatic abnormality, can be observed in TFCC and TFCC-related features of asymptomatic adolescents. The rather low inter-observer agreement underscores the challenges in interpreting these small structures on MRI. This should be taken into consideration when interpreting clinical MRIs and deciding upon arthroscopy.

What Is the Effect of the Ulnar-Plus Variance on the Outcomes of Arthroscopic Repair of the Peripheral Ulnar-Side Triangular Fibrocartilage Complex Tear?

PURPOSE

To compare the outcomes of arthroscopic repair of peripheral ulnar-side triangular fibrocartilage complex (TFCC) tears between patients with and without ulnar-plus variance (UPV) and to identify factors associated with index surgery failure in these patients.

METHODS

We retrospectively analyzed 50 consecutive patients who underwent arthroscopic repair of peripheral ulnar-side TFCC tears from June 2014 to February 2018. We selected patients who were aged at least 18 years and underwent arthroscopic repair of peripheral ulnar-side TFCC tears. We excluded those with a fractured or dislocated wrist, ulnar impaction syndrome, degenerative or inflammatory arthritis of the wrist, or neurologic conditions that affect upper-extremity function, as well as those who received less than 12 months' follow-up. We evaluated the patients with a visual analog scale for pain in 3 domains (overall, with hard work, and at rest), the Patient-rated Wrist Evaluation, range of motion, and grip strength. Clinical outcomes and arthroscopic findings were compared between patients with and without UPV (UPV group and non-UPV group, respectively). We calculated the relative risk and 95% confidence interval for younger age (<30 years), sex, UPV, and coexisting degenerative central TFCC tear (type 2 tear) to determine the risk factors for arthroscopic repair failure.

RESULTS

No significant differences were noted between the 2 groups regarding visual analog scale pain and Patient-rated Wrist Evaluation scores and rates of excellent or improved outcomes (P > .05). Arthroscopic repair failure was found in 4 patients. A coexisting type 2 TFCC tear was the only significant risk factor (relative risk, 49.5; 95% confidence interval, 2.94-83.96; P = .007) for arthroscopic repair failure.

CONCLUSIONS

UPV did not significantly affect the outcomes of arthroscopic repair of peripheral ulnar-side TFCC tears. However, coexisting type 2 TFCC tears significantly increased the risk of index surgery failure in these patients.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV, prognostic study.