Comparison of the clinical usefulness of different urinary tests for the initial detection of bladder cancer: a systematic review

New Challenges in Bladder Cancer Diagnosis: How Biosensing Tools Can Lead to Population Screening Opportunities

Bladder cancer is one of the most common cancers worldwide. Despite its high incidence, cystoscopy remains the currently used diagnostic gold standard, although it is invasive, expensive and has low sensitivity. As a result, the cancer diagnosis is mostly late, as it occurs following the presence of hematuria in urine, and population screening is not allowed. It would therefore be desirable to be able to act promptly in the early stage of the disease with the aid of biosensing. The use of devices/tools based on genetic assessments would be of great help in this field. However, the genetic differences between populations do not allow accurate analysis in the context of population screening. Current research is directed towards the discovery of universal biomarkers present in urine with the aim of providing an approach based on a non-invasive, easy-to-perform, rapid, and accurate test that can be widely used in clinical practice for the early diagnosis and follow-up of bladder cancer. An efficient biosensing device may have a disruptive impact in terms of patient health and disease management, contributing to a decrease in mortality rate, as well as easing the social and economic burden on the national healthcare system. Considering the advantage of accessing population screening for early diagnosis of cancer, the main challenges and future perspectives are critically discussed to address the research towards the selection of suitable biomarkers for the development of a very sensitive biosensor for bladder cancer.

Real-world performance of Uromonitor® in urothelial bladder cancer detection: a multicentric trial

OBJECTIVES

To compare Uromonitor® (U-Monitor Lda, Porto, Portugal), a multitarget DNA assay that detects mutated proto-oncogenes (telomerase reverse transcriptase [TERT], fibroblast growth factor receptor 3 [FGFR-3], Kirsten rat sarcoma viral oncogene homologue [KRAS]), with urine cytology in the urine-based diagnosis of urothelial carcinoma of the bladder (UCB) within a multicentre real-world setting.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

This multicentre, prospective, double-blind study was conducted across four German urological centres from 2019 to 2024. We evaluated the diagnostic performance of Uromonitor compared to urine cytology in a cohort of patients with UCB and in healthy controls within a real-world setting. Sensitivity, specificity, positive-predictive value (PPV), negative-predictive value (NPV), and accuracy of the tests were measured, in addition to multivariate analyses to assess the ability of individual proto-oncogene mutations in detecting UCB. The biometric sample size was designed to achieve a 10% difference in sensitivity.

RESULTS

Patients with UCB comprised 63.7% (339/532) of the study group. Uromonitor showed a sensitivity, specificity, PPV, NPV, accuracy, and an area-under-the-curve of 49.3%, 93.3%, 92.8%, 51.1%, 65.2%, and 0.713%, respectively. These metrics did not demonstrate statistical superiority over urine cytology in terms of sensitivity (44.6%; P = 0.316). Moreover, the comparison of additional test parameters, as well as the comparison within various sensitivity analyses, yielded no significant disparity between the two urinary tests. Multivariate logistic regression underscored the significant predictive value of a positive Uromonitor for detecting UCB (odds ratio [OR] 9.03; P < 0.001). Furthermore, mutations in TERT and FGFR-3 were independently associated with high odds of UCB detection (OR 13.30 and 7.04, respectively), while KRAS mutations did not exhibit predictive capability.

CONCLUSION

Despite its innovative approach, Uromonitor fell short of confirming the superior results anticipated from previous studies in this real-world setting. The search for an optimal urine-based biomarker for detecting and monitoring UCB remains ongoing. Results from this study highlight the complexity of developing non-invasive diagnostic tools and emphasise the importance of continued research efforts to refine these technologies.

Potential molecular biomarkers for the diagnosis and prognosis of bladder cancer

Bladder cancer (BC) is a common malignant tumor of urinary system, which can be divided into muscle-invasive BC (MIBC) and nonmuscle-invasive BC (NMIBC). The number of BC patients has been gradually increasing currently. At present, bladder tumours are diagnosed and followed-up using a combination of cystoscopic examination, cytology and histology. However, the detection of early grade tumors, which is much easier to treat effectively than advanced stage disease, is still insufficient. It frequently recurs and can progress when not expeditiously diagnosed and monitored following initial therapy for NMIBC. Treatment strategies are totally different for different stage diseases. Therefore, it is of great practical significance to study new biomarkers for diagnosis and prognosis. In this review, we summarize the current state of biomarker development in BC diagnosis and prognosis prediction. We retrospectively analyse eight diagnostic biomarkers and eight prognostic biomarkers, in which CK, P53, PPARγ, PTEN and ncRNA are emphasized for discussion. Eight molecular subtype systems are also identified. Clinical translation of biomarkers for diagnosis, prognosis, monitoring and treatment will hopefully improve outcomes for patients. These potential biomarkers provide an opportunity to diagnose tumors earlier and with greater accuracy, and help identify those patients most at risk of disease recurrence.

Bladder Epicheck Test: A Novel Tool to Support Urothelial Carcinoma Diagnosis in Urine Samples

Bladder cancer and upper urothelial tract carcinoma are common diseases with a high risk of recurrence, thus necessitating follow-up after initial treatment. The management of non-muscle invasive bladder carcinoma (NMIBC) after transurethral resection involves surveillance, intravesical therapy, and cytology with cystoscopy. Urinary cytology, cystoscopy, and radiological evaluation of the upper urinary tract are recommended during follow-up in the international urological guidelines. Cystoscopy is the standard examination for the first assessment and follow-up of NMIBC, and urine cytology is a widely used urinary test with high sensitivity for high-grade urothelial carcinoma (HGUC) and carcinoma in situ (CIS). In recent years, various urinary assays, including DNA methylation markers, have been used to detect bladder tumors. Among these, the Bladder EpiCheck test is one of the most widely used and is based on analysis of the methylation profile of urothelial cells to detect bladder neoplasms. This review assesses the importance of methylation analysis and the Bladder EpiCheck test as urinary biomarkers for diagnosing urothelial carcinomas in patients in follow-up for NMIBC, helping cytology and cystoscopy in doubtful cases. A combined approach of cytology and methylation analysis is suggested not only to diagnose HGUC, but also to predict clinical and histological recurrences.

Artificial Intelligence in the Advanced Diagnosis of Bladder Cancer-Comprehensive Literature Review and Future Advancement

Artificial intelligence is highly regarded as the most promising future technology that will have a great impact on healthcare across all specialties. Its subsets, machine learning, deep learning, and artificial neural networks, are able to automatically learn from massive amounts of data and can improve the prediction algorithms to enhance their performance. This area is still under development, but the latest evidence shows great potential in the diagnosis, prognosis, and treatment of urological diseases, including bladder cancer, which are currently using old prediction tools and historical nomograms. This review focuses on highly significant and comprehensive literature evidence of artificial intelligence in the management of bladder cancer and investigates the near introduction in clinical practice.

Beyond blood biomarkers: the role of SelectMDX in clinically significant prostate cancer identification

INTRODUCTION

New potential biomarkers to pre-intervention identification of a clinically significant prostate cancer (csPCa) will prevent overdiagnosis and overtreatment and limit quality of life impairment of PCa patients.

AREAS COVERED

We have developed a comprehensive review focusing our research on the increasing knowledge of the role of SelectMDX® in csPCa detection. Areas identified as clinically relevant are the ability of SelectMDX® to predict csPCa in active surveillance setting, its predictive ability when combined with multiparametric MRI and the role of SelectMDX® in the landscape of urinary biomarkers.

EXPERT OPINION

Several PCa biomarkers have been developed either alone or in combination with clinical variables to improve csPCa detection. SelectMDX® score includes genomic markers, age, PSA, prostate volume, and digital rectal examination. Several studies have shown consistency in the ability to improve detection of csPCa, avoidance of unnecessary prostate biopsies, helpful in decision-making for clinical benefit of PCa patients with future well designed, and impactful studies.

A Novel Urine Test Biosensor Platform for Early Lung Cancer Detection

Lung cancer is the leading cause of cancer-related mortality worldwide. Early detection is essential to achieving a better outcome and prognosis. Volatile organic compounds (VOCs) reflect alterations in the pathophysiology and body metabolism processes, as shown in various types of cancers. The biosensor platform (BSP) urine test uses animals' unique, proficient, and accurate ability to scent lung cancer VOCs. The BSP is a testing platform for the binary (negative/positive) recognition of the signature VOCs of lung cancer by trained and qualified Long-Evans rats as biosensors (BSs). The results of the current double-blind study show high accuracy in lung cancer VOC recognition, with 93% sensitivity and 91% specificity. The BSP test is safe, rapid, objective and can be performed repetitively, enabling periodic cancer monitoring as well as an aid to existing diagnostic methods. The future implementation of such urine tests as routine screening and monitoring tools has the potential to significantly increase detection rate as well as curability rates with lower healthcare expenditure. This paper offers a first instructive clinical platform utilizing VOC's in urine for detection of lung cancer using the innovative BSP to deal with the pressing need for an early lung cancer detection test tool.

Diagnostic Performance of Biomarkers for Bladder Cancer Detection Suitable for Community and Primary Care Settings: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Evidence on the use of biomarkers to detect bladder cancer in the general population is scarce. This study aimed to systematically review evidence on the diagnostic performance of biomarkers which might be suitable for use in community and primary care settings [PROSPERO Registration: CRD42021258754]. Database searches on MEDLINE and EMBASE from January 2000 to May 2022 resulted in 4914 unique citations, 44 of which met inclusion criteria. Included studies reported on 112 biomarkers and combinations. Heterogeneity of designs, populations and outcomes allowed for the meta-analysis of three biomarkers identified in at least five studies (NMP-22, UroVysion, uCyt+). These three biomarkers showed similar discriminative ability (adjusted AUC estimates ranging from 0.650 to 0.707), although for NMP-22 and UroVysion there was significant unexplained heterogeneity between included studies. Narrative synthesis revealed the potential of these biomarkers for use in the general population based on their reported clinical utility, including effects on clinicians, patients, and the healthcare system. Finally, we identified some promising novel biomarkers and biomarker combinations (N < 3 studies for each biomarker/combination) with negative predictive values of ≥90%. These biomarkers have potential for use as a triage tool in community and primary care settings for reducing unnecessary specialist referrals. Despite promising emerging evidence, further validation studies in the general population are required at different stages within the diagnostic pathway.

Large-scale longitudinal comparison of urine cytological classification systems reveals potential early adoption of The Paris System criteria

INTRODUCTION

Urine cytology is used to screen for urothelial carcinoma in patients with hematuria or risk factors (eg, smoking, industrial dye exposure) and is an essential clinical triage and longitudinal monitoring tool for patients with known bladder cancer. However, urine cytology is semisubjective and thus susceptible to issues including specimen quality, interobserver variability, and "hedging" towards equivocal ("atypical") diagnoses. These factors limit the predictive value of urine cytology and increase reliance on invasive procedures (cystoscopy). The Paris System for Reporting Urine Cytology (TPS) was formulated to provide more quantitative/reproducible endpoints with well-defined criteria for urothelial atypia. TPS is often compared to other assessment techniques to justify its adoption. TPS results in decreased use of the atypical category and better reproducibility. Previous reports comparing diagnoses pre- and post-TPS have not considered temporal differences between diagnoses made under prior systems and TPS. By aggregating across time, studies may underestimate the magnitude of differences between assessment methods.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We conducted a large-scale longitudinal reassessment of urine cytology using TPS criteria from specimens collected from 2008 to 2018, prior to the mid-2018 adoption of TPS at an academic medical center.

RESULTS

Findings indicate that differences in atypical assignment were largest at the start of the period and these differences progressively decreased towards insignificance just prior to TPS implementation.

CONCLUSIONS

This finding suggests that cytopathologists had begun to utilize the quantitative TPS criteria prior to official adoption, which may more broadly inform adoption strategies, communication, and understanding for evolving classification systems in cytology.

AHNAK2 Urinary Protein Expression as Potential Biomarker for Bladder Cancer Detection: A Pilot Study

OBJECTIVE

This study aimed to measure the AHNAK2 urinary levels in bladder cancer patients.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

This prospective case-control study enrolled 67 participants between January and March 2019 and were categorized into bladder cancer group (n=37), with histologically proven bladder can cer, and control group (n=30), with histologically verified benign lesions or with no bladder cancer indica tion during follow-up. Urine samples of 15 mL were collected in the mid-morning before cystoscopy/surger y and an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay was performed as per the manufacturer's protocol. Bladder malignancies were classified according to the World Health Organization Tumor Classification. Group's associations were evaluated with the Student t-test, Spearman's rank correlation, and Mann-Whitney U test, while receiver operating curve was plotted for assessing the test's performance.

RESULTS

Mean age of the bladder cancer group was 66.41 years (standard deviation=10.04, range=43-82 years) and the control group was 59.67 years (standard deviation=10.44, range=38-77 years). All bladder cancers were of the urothelial histotype, with the following pT distribution: pTa/papillary urothelial neoplasm of low malignant potential (n=19; 28.4%), Primary tumor (pT) in situ (n=4; 6%), pT1 (n=7; 10.4%), and pT≥2 (n=7; 10.48%). Mean AHNAK2 levels were higher in bladder cancer patients 49.08 pg/mL (standard deviation=114.91) compared to controls 5.28 pg/mL (standard devia tion=6.65), P < .05). Significant differences were noted between non-invasive bladder cancer (n=23; mean=7.14 pg/mL; standard deviation=7.26) and invasive bladder cancer (n=14; mean=117.99 pg/mL; standard deviation=168.08) and between non-muscle invasive bladder cancer (mean=23.19 pg/mL; standard deviation=66.93) and muscle-invasive bladder cancer (mean=160.05 pg/mL; standard devia tion=199.65) (P < .001). The result of the assays was given as follows: sensitivity: 64.19%, specificity: 66.67%, positive predictive value: 22.07%, negative predictive value: 92.37%, area under curve: 0.695, and 95% CI: 0.57-0.82.

CONCLUSION

AHNAK2 protein could be used as bladder cancer surveillance biomarker. The inclusion of AHNAK2 levels in stratification nomograms might reduce the number of unnecessary cystoscopies.

Intermediate-risk Non-muscle-invasive Bladder Cancer: Updated Consensus Definition and Management Recommendations from the International Bladder Cancer Group

CONTEXT

Intermediate-risk (IR) non-muscle-invasive bladder cancer (NMIBC) is a heterogeneous disease.

OBJECTIVE

To update the International Bladder Cancer Group (IBCG) guidance and provide practical recommendations on IR NMIBC management.

EVIDENCE ACQUISITION

A collaborative review of published randomized clinical trials, meta-analyses, systematic reviews, and clinical practice guidance on IR NMIBC published before January 2022 was undertaken using PubMed/Medline.

EVIDENCE SYNTHESIS

Variation exists between guidelines in defining IR NMIBC. The IBCG recommends defining IR NMIBC as any TaLG tumor that is either recurrent or multifocal or has size ≥3 cm, OR any T1LG tumor. If the 3 tier grading system is used, than any TaG2 tumor would also be considered IR diease regardless of whether new diagnosis or recurrent. Accurate grading and staging of tumor, particularly in ruling out HG/G3 disease and/or carcinoma in situ, are crucial. The IBCG recommends that management of IR NMIBC should be further based on the following risk factors: multifocal tumor (more than one), early recurrence (<1 yr), frequent recurrence (>1/yr), tumor size (≥3 cm), and failure of prior intravesical treatment. Patients with no risk factors are best managed by one dose of postoperative intravesical chemotherapy. Patients with one to two risk factors should be offered additional adjuvant induction intravesical chemotherapy (or bacillus Calmette-Guérin (BCG) if prior chemotherapy has been used). Patients with three or more risk factors should be offered induction plus 1-yr maintenance BCG. Where BCG is not available or recurrent disease following BCG is present, alternative intravesical treatments such as chemotherapy (single agent, combination, or chemohyperthermia) or a clinical trial are recommended.

CONCLUSIONS

Standardizing the definition of IR NMIBC is critical for appropriate management of patients and for allowing a comparison of outcomes across clinical trials. The IBCG recommends defining IR NMIBC as any TaLG tumor that is either recurrent or multifocal or  ≥3 cm, OR any T1LG tumor. If the 3 tier grading system is used, than any TaG2 tumor would also be considered IR disease regardless of whether new diagnosis or recurrent.  Adjunctive management should then be based on established risk factors.

PATIENT SUMMARY

Standardizing the definition of intermediate-risk (IR) non-muscle-invasive bladder cancer (NMIBC), which is a heterogeneous disease, is critical for appropriate management of patients. The International Bladder Cancer Group recommends classification of IR NMIBC tumors and personalized management based on the following risk factors: multifocal tumor (more than one), early recurrence (<1 yr), frequent recurrence (>1/yr), tumor size (≥3 cm), and previous intravesical treatment.

Detection of Microsatellite Instability in Colonoscopic Biopsies and Postal Urine Samples from Lynch Syndrome Cancer Patients Using a Multiplex PCR Assay

Identification of mismatch repair (MMR)-deficient colorectal cancers (CRCs) is recommended for Lynch syndrome (LS) screening, and supports targeting of immune checkpoint inhibitors. Microsatellite instability (MSI) analysis is commonly used to test for MMR deficiency. Testing biopsies prior to tumour resection can inform surgical and therapeutic decisions, but can be limited by DNA quantity. MSI analysis of voided urine could also provide much needed surveillance for genitourinary tract cancers in LS. Here, we reconfigure an existing molecular inversion probe-based MSI and BRAF c.1799T > A assay to a multiplex PCR (mPCR) format, and demonstrate that it can sample >140 unique molecules per marker from <1 ng of DNA and classify CRCs with 96−100% sensitivity and specificity. We also show that it can detect increased MSI within individual and composite CRC biopsies from LS patients, and within preoperative urine cell free DNA (cfDNA) from two LS patients, one with an upper tract urothelial cancer, the other an undiagnosed endometrial cancer. Approximately 60−70% of the urine cfDNAs were tumour-derived. Our results suggest that mPCR sequence-based analysis of MSI and mutation hotspots in CRC biopsies could facilitate presurgery decision making, and could enable postal-based screening for urinary tract and endometrial tumours in LS patients.

Xpert Bladder Cancer Monitor May Avoid Cystoscopies in Patients Under "Active Surveillance" for Recurrent Bladder Cancer (BIAS Project): Longitudinal Cohort Study

Objectives

To test the hypothesis that patients under active surveillance (AS) for Non-muscle Invasive Bladder Cancer (NMIBC) who were negative on longitudinal re-testing by the Xpert^® Bladder Cancer Monitor (Xpert BC Monitor) assay may avoid unnecessary cystoscopies and urine cytology (UC).

Subjects/Patients (or Materials) and Methods

This is a prospective cohort study of patients enrolled in the AS protocol for recurrent NMIBC (Bladder Cancer Italian Active Surveillance, BIAS project), whose urine samples were analyzed by Xpert BC Monitor upon entry in the study (T0). Patients who had a negative Xpert test and did not fail AS, underwent additional Xpert tests after 4 (T1), 8 (T2), and 12 (T3) months. The clinical utility of Xpert was assessed by determining the number of cystoscopies and UC that could be avoided within 1 year.

Results

Overall, 139 patients were tested with Xpert at T0. Median follow-up was 23 (IQR 17–27) months. Sixty-eight (48.9%) patients failed AS, 65 (46.7%) are currently on AS, and 6 (4.3%) were lost at follow-up. At T0 57 (41.0%) patients had a negative test and 36 (63.2%) are still in AS. In patients with 2 consecutives negative Xpert tests, we could have avoided 73.9% of unnecessary cystoscopies, missing 26.4% failure, up to avoid all cystoscopies with 4 negative tests missing only 12% of failure. All the patients with negative Xpert had negative UC. Failure-free-survival at median follow-up (23 month) stratified for having 0, 1, or ≥2 negative tests was 67.0, 55.1. and 84.1, respectively.

Conclusion

Our findings suggest that Xpert BC Monitor assay, when it is longitudinally repeated, could significantly reduce the number of unnecessary cystoscopies and UC during their follow-up.

Improved Non-Invasive Diagnosis of Bladder Cancer with an Electronic Nose: A Large Pilot Study

BACKGROUND

Bladder cancer (BCa) emits specific volatile organic compounds (VOCs) in the urine headspace that can be detected by an electronic nose. The diagnostic performance of an electronic nose in detecting BCa was investigated in a pilot study.

METHODS

A prospective, single-center, controlled, non-randomized, phase 2 study was carried out on 198 consecutive subjects (102 with proven BCa, 96 controls). Urine samples were evaluated with an electronic nose provided with 32 volatile gas analyzer sensors. The tests were repeated at least two times per sample. Accuracy, sensitivity, specificity, and variability were evaluated using mainly the non-parametric combination method, permutation tests, and discriminant analysis classification.

RESULTS

Statistically significant differences between BCa patients and controls were reported by 28 (87.5%) of the 32 sensors. The overall discriminatory power, sensitivity, and specificity were 78.8%, 74.1%, and 76%, respectively; 13/96 (13.5%) controls and 29/102 (28.4%) BCa patients were misclassified as false positive and false negative, respectively. Where the most efficient sensors were selected, the sensitivity and specificity increased up to 91.1% (72.5-100) and 89.1% (81-95.8), respectively. None of the tumor characteristics represented independent predictors of device responsiveness.

CONCLUSIONS

The electronic nose might represent a potentially reliable, quick, accurate, and cost-effective tool for non-invasive BCa diagnosis.

PLAUR as a Potential Biomarker Associated with Immune Infiltration in Bladder Urothelial Carcinoma

Background

Bladder urothelial carcinoma (BLCA) is one of the most lethal and aggressive malignancies of genitourinary system that affects human health. The urokinase plasminogen activator receptor (PLAUR) plays essential roles in tumorigenesis and immune modulation, and its aberrant expression is closely correlated with cancer progression. However, whether PLAUR has the potential to be one promising biomarker or immunotherapy target for BLCA is unknown.

Methodology

Various online databases were applied to assess the expression profile and prognostic value of PLAUR, as well as its correlation with immune infiltration in BLCA, including Oncomine, PrognoScan, TCGA, cBioPortal, TIMER, TISIDB, UALCAN, and MethSurv. The expression of PLAUR in BLCA was confirmed with ELISA assay for serum samples and immunohistochemistry for tissue samples.

Results

The results showed that the expression of PLAUR was elevated in BLCA, which was further confirmed by ELISA and immunohistochemistry. Patients with higher PLAUR level were predicted to have lower overall survival and disease specific survival rates, which were not impacted by the genetic alterations of PLAUR. In addition, the expression of PLAUR was positively associated with immune infiltration, and also the expression levels of gene markers of various immune cells. The negative correlation between PLAUR expression and PLAUR methylation level was observed, among which PLAUR expression was positively correlated with the abundance of 28 kinds of tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes, while PLAUR methylation level was negatively correlated with the abundance of 11 types of tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes. Moreover, the methylation level of PLAUR was closely correlated with patients’ clinicopathological features, and hypomethylation of PLAUR was associated with better outcomes of BLCA patients.

Conclusion

These findings suggested that PLAUR had the potential to serve as a valuable detection and prognostic biomarker or immunotherapeutic target for BLCA.