Cutaneous granulomas and epidermodysplasia verruciformis in early onset combined immunodeficiency syndrome

What Works When Treating Granulomatous Disease in Genetically Undefined CVID? A Systematic Review

Background

Granulomatous disease is reported in at least 8–20% of patients with common variable immunodeficiency (CVID). Granulomatous disease mainly affects the lungs, and is associated with significantly higher morbidity and mortality. In half of patients with granulomatous disease, extrapulmonary manifestations are found, affecting e.g. skin, liver, and lymph nodes. In literature various therapies have been reported, with varying effects on remission of granulomas and related clinical symptoms. However, consensus recommendations for optimal management of extrapulmonary granulomatous disease are lacking.

Objective

To present a literature overview of the efficacy of currently described therapies for extrapulmonary granulomatous disease in CVID (CVID+EGD), compared to known treatment regimens for pulmonary granulomatous disease in CVID (CVID+PGD).

Methods

The following databases were searched: Embase, Medline (Ovid), Web-of-Science Core Collection, Cochrane Central, and Google Scholar. Inclusion criteria were 1) CVID patients with granulomatous disease, 2) treatment for granulomatous disease reported, and 3) outcome of treatment reported. Patient characteristics, localization of granuloma, treatment, and association with remission of granulomatous disease were extracted from articles.

Results

We identified 64 articles presenting 95 CVID patients with granulomatous disease, wherein 117 different treatment courses were described. Steroid monotherapy was most frequently described in CVID+EGD (21 out of 53 treatment courses) and resulted in remission in 85.7% of cases. In CVID+PGD steroid monotherapy was described in 15 out of 64 treatment courses, and was associated with remission in 66.7% of cases. Infliximab was reported in CVID+EGD in six out of 53 treatment courses and was mostly used in granulomatous disease affecting the skin (four out of six cases). All patients (n = 9) treated with anti-TNF-α therapies (infliximab and etanercept) showed remission of extrapulmonary granulomatous disease. Rituximab with or without azathioprine was rarely used for CVID+EGD, but frequently used in CVID+PGD where it was associated with remission of granulomatous disease in 94.4% (17 of 18 treatment courses).

Conclusion

Although the number of CVID+EGD patients was limited, data indicate that steroid monotherapy often results in remission, and that anti-TNF-α treatment is effective for granulomatous disease affecting the skin. Also, rituximab with or without azathioprine was mainly described in CVID+PGD, and only in few cases of CVID+EGD.

Progressive B Cell Loss in Revertant X-SCID

We report the case of a patient with X-linked severe combined immunodeficiency (X-SCID) who survived for over 20 years without hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT) because of a somatic reversion mutation. An important feature of this rare case included the strategy to validate the pathogenicity of a variant of the IL2RG gene when the T and B cell lineages comprised only revertant cells. We studied the X-inactivation of sorted T cells from the mother to show that the pathogenic variant was indeed the cause of his SCID. One interesting feature was a progressive loss of B cells over 20 years. CyTOF (cytometry time of flight) analysis of bone marrow offered a potential explanation of the B cell failure, with expansions of progenitor populations that suggest a developmental block. Another interesting feature was that the patient bore extensive granulomatous disease and skin cancers that contained T cells, despite severe T cell lymphopenia in the blood. Finally, the patient had a few hundred T cells on presentation but his TCRs comprised a very limited repertoire, supporting the important conclusion that repertoire size trumps numbers of T cells.