Stepwise Improvement of Surgical Quality in Robotic Lateral Pelvic Node Dissection: Lessons From 100 Consecutive Patients With Locally Advanced Rectal Cancer

The Learning Curve for Robotic Lateral Pelvic Lymph Node Dissection for Rectal Cancer: A View From the West

BACKGROUND

Lateral pelvic lymph node dissection is performed for selected patients with rectal cancer with persistent lateral nodal disease after neoadjuvant therapy. This technique has been slow to be adopted in the West because of concerns regarding technical difficulty. This is the first report on the learning curve for lateral pelvic lymph node dissection in the United States or Europe.

OBJECTIVE

This study aimed to analyze the learning curve associated with robotic lateral pelvic lymph node dissection.

DESIGN

Retrospective observational cohort.

SETTING

Tertiary academic cancer center.

PATIENTS

Consecutive patients from 2012 to 2021.

INTERVENTION

All patients underwent robotic lateral pelvic lymph node dissection.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

The primary end points were the learning curves for the maximum number of nodes retrieved and urinary retention, which was evaluated with simple cumulative sum and 2-sided Bernoulli cumulative sum charts.

RESULTS

Fifty-four procedures were included. A single-surgeon learning curve (n = 35) and an institutional learning curve are presented in the analysis. In the single-surgeon learning curve, a turning point marking the end of a learning phase was detected at the 12th procedure for the number of retrieved nodes and at the 20th procedure for urinary retention. In the institutional learning curve analysis, 2 turning points were identified at the 13th procedure, indicating progressive improvements for the number of retrieved nodes, and at the 27th procedure for urinary retention. No sustained alarm signals were detected at any time point.

LIMITATIONS

The retrospective nature, small sample size, and the referral center nature of the reporting institution may limit generalizability.

CONCLUSIONS

In a setting of institutional experience with robotic colorectal surgery, including beyond total mesorectal excision resections, the learning curve for robotic lateral pelvic lymph node dissection is acceptably short. Our results demonstrate the feasibility of the acquisition of this technique in a controlled setting, with sufficient case volume and proctoring to optimize the learning curve. See Video Abstract.

LA CURVA DE APRENDIZAJE DE LA DISECCIN ROBTICA DE LOS GANGLIOS LINFTICOS PLVICOS LATERALES EN EL CNCER DE RECTO UNA VISIN DESDE OCCIDENTE

ANTECEDENTES:La disección lateral de los ganglios linfáticos pélvicos se realiza en pacientes seleccionados con cáncer de recto con enfermedad ganglionar lateral persistente tras el tratamiento neoadyuvante. La adopción de esta técnica en Occidente ha sido lenta debido a la preocupación por su dificultad técnica. Éste es el primer informe sobre la curva de aprendizaje de la disección de los ganglios linfáticos pélvicos laterales en EE.UU. o Europa.OBJETIVO:El objetivo de este estudio fue analizar la curva de aprendizaje asociada a la disección robótica de los ganglios linfáticos pélvicos laterales.DISEÑO:Cohorte observacional retrospectiva.LUGAR:Centro oncológico académico terciario.PACIENTES:Pacientes consecutivos desde 2012 al 2021.INTERVENCIÓN:Todos los pacientes fueron sometieron a disección robótica de ganglios linfáticos pélvicos laterales.PRINCIPALES MEDIDAS DE RESULTADO:Los criterios de valoración primarios fueron las curvas de aprendizaje tomando en cuenta el mayor número de ganglios recuperados y la retención urinaria que fueron evaluados con gráficos de suma acumulativa simple y de suma acumulativa de Bernoulli de dos caras.RESULTADOS:Fueron incluidos 54 procedimientos. En el análisis se presentan una curva de aprendizaje de un solo cirujano (n = 35) y una curva de aprendizaje institucional. En la curva de aprendizaje de un solo cirujano, se detectó un punto de inflexión que marcaba el final de una fase de aprendizaje en el duodécimo procedimiento para el número de ganglios extraídos y en el vigésimo para la retención urinaria. En el análisis de la curva de aprendizaje institucional, se identificaron dos puntos de inflexión en las intervenciones 13.ª y 26.ª, que indicaron mejoras progresivas en el número de ganglios extraídos, y en la 27.ª en la retención urinaria. No se detectaron señales de alarma sostenidas en ningún momento.LIMITACIONES:La naturaleza retrospectiva, el pequeño tamaño de la muestra y la naturaleza de centro de referencia de la institución informante que pueden limitar la capacidad de generalizarse.CONCLUSIONES:En un entorno de experiencia institucional con cirugía robótica colorrectal incluyendo más allá de las resecciones TME, la curva de aprendizaje para la disección robótica de ganglios linfáticos pélvicos laterales es aceptablemente corta. Nuestros resultados demuestran la viabilidad de la adquisición de esta técnica en un entorno controlado, con un volumen de casos suficiente y una supervisión que puede optimizar la curva de aprendizaje. (Traducción-Dr. Osvaldo Gauto ).

The role of lateral pelvic lymph node dissection in advanced rectal cancer: a review of current evidence and outcomes

Metastatic lateral pelvic lymph nodes (LPNs) in rectal cancer significantly impact the prognosis and treatment strategies. Western practices emphasize neoadjuvant chemoradiotherapy (CRT), whereas Eastern approaches often rely on LPN dissection (LPND). This review examines the evolving role of LPND in the context of modern treatments, including total neoadjuvant therapy (TNT), and the impact of CRT on the management of clinically suspicious LPNs. We comprehensively reviewed the key literature comparing the outcomes of LPND versus preoperative CRT for rectal cancer, focusing on recent advancements and ongoing debates. Key studies, including the JCOG0212 trial and recent multicenter trials, were analyzed to assess the efficacy of LPND, particularly in conjunction with preoperative CRT or TNT. Current evidence indicates that LPND can reduce local recurrence rates compared to total mesorectal excision alone in patients not receiving radiation therapy. However, the benefit of LPND in the context of neoadjuvant CRT is influenced by the size and pretreatment characteristics of LPNs. While CRT can effectively control smaller metastatic LPNs, larger or clinically suspicious LPNs may require LPND for optimal outcomes. Advances in surgical techniques, such as robotic-assisted LPND, offer potential benefits but also present challenges and complications. The role of TNT in controlling metastatic LPNs and improving patient outcomes is emerging but remains underexplored. The decision to perform LPND should be individualized based on patient-specific factors, including LPN size, response to neoadjuvant treatment, and surgeon expertise. Future research should focus on optimizing treatment protocols and further evaluating the role of TNT in managing metastatic LPNs.

Long-term Complications of Laparoscopic or Robotic Lateral Pelvic Node Dissection After Preoperative Chemoradiotherapy for Locally Advanced Rectal Cancer

BACKGROUND

Patients with rectal cancer who underwent lateral pelvic node dissection might be at a higher risk of postoperative complications derived from technical complexity. However, little is known regarding the long-term complications after lateral pelvic node dissection.

OBJECTIVES

The study aimed to investigate the long-term complications of preoperative chemoradiotherapy, followed by total mesorectal excision with lateral pelvic node dissection for locally advanced rectal cancers.

DESIGN

A retrospective analysis of a prospectively collected database.

SETTINGS

This study was conducted in a tertiary cancer center.

PATIENTS

Patients with rectal cancer who underwent total mesorectal excision with lateral pelvic node dissection after preoperative chemoradiotherapy between 2011 and 2019 were analyzed. All operations were performed via a laparoscopic or robotic approach.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Long-term complications were defined as adverse events that persisted or newly appeared ≥90 days after surgery and could be related to the surgery.

RESULTS

A total of 164 patients underwent total mesorectal excision with lateral pelvic node dissection after preoperative chemoradiotherapy. Short-term and long-term complication rates were 36.0% and 36.6%, respectively. Lymphocele was the most common long-term complication (17.7% of patients), and 11.6% had anastomotic leakage with chronic sinus. Of the patients with long-term complications, 20.7% of patients needed readmission for treatment. Of the 29 patients with lymphocele, 13 (41.0%) experienced spontaneous absorption and 11 (37.9%) required surgical or percutaneous catheter drainage or antibiotics use. Multivariate analysis showed pathologic pelvic node metastases ( p = 0.008), and a higher number of unilateral harvested pelvic nodes ( p = 0.001) were significantly associated with long-term complications. At the last follow-up (median duration of 43 months), 15.9% of patients had unresolved complications.

LIMITATIONS

The retrospective design.

CONCLUSIONS

Patients undergoing lateral pelvic node dissection experienced a higher frequency of long-term complications, but half of them had asymptomatic lymphoceles, most of which resolved spontaneously. However, further efforts should be paid to reduce anticipated complications related to lateral pelvic node dissection. See Video Abstract .

COMPLICACIONES A LARGO PLAZO DE LA DISECCIN DE LOS GANGLIOS LIFTICOS PLVICOS LATERALES LAPAROSCPICA O ROBTICA DESPUS DE LA QUIMIORRADIOTERAPIA PREOPERATORIA CONTRA EL CNCER DEL RECTO LOCALMENTE AVANZADO

ANTECEDENTES:Los pacientes con cáncer del recto sometidos a disección ganglionar linfática pélvica lateral podrían tener mayor riesgo de complicaciones postoperatorias derivadas de la complejidad técnica. Sin embargo, se sabe poco sobre las complicaciones a largo plazo después de la disección de los ganglios linfáticos pélvicos laterales.OBJETIVOS:Investigar las complicaciones a largo plazo de la quimiorradioterapia preoperatoria, seguida de escisión mesorrectal total con disección de los ganglios linfáticos pélvicos laterales contra el cáncer de recto localmente avanzado.DISEÑO:Un análisis retrospectivo de una base de datos recopilada prospectivamente.AJUSTES:Este estudio se llevó a cabo en un centro oncológico terciario.PACIENTES:Se analizaron pacientes con cáncer de recto que se sometieron a escisión mesorrectal total con disección de ganglios linfáticos pélvicos laterales después de quimiorradioterapia preoperatoria entre 2011 y 2019. Todas las operaciones se realizaron mediante abordaje laparoscópico o robótico.PRINCIPALES MEDIDAS DE RESULTADO:Las complicaciones a largo plazo se definieron como eventos adversos que persistieron o aparecieron recientemente ≥ 90 días después de la cirugía y podrían estar relacionados con la cirugía.RESULTADOS:Un total de 164 pacientes se sometieron a escisión mesorrectal total con disección de los ganglios linfáticos pélvicos laterales después de quimiorradioterapia preoperatoria. Las tasas de complicaciones a corto y largo plazo fueron del 36,0% y 36,6%, respectivamente. El linfocele fue la complicación a largo plazo más común (17,7% de los pacientes) y el 11,6% tuvo fuga anastomótica con seno crónico. De los pacientes con complicaciones a largo plazo, el 20,7% de los pacientes necesitaron reingreso para recibir tratamiento. De 29 pacientes con linfocele, 13 (41,0%) experimentaron absorción espontánea y 11 (37,9%) requirieron drenaje quirúrgico o percutáneo con catéter o uso de antibióticos. El análisis multivariado mostró metástasis patológicas en los ganglios linfáticos pélvicos ( p = 0,008) y un mayor número de ganglios pélvicos extraídos unilateralmente ( p = 0,001) se asociaron significativamente con complicaciones a largo plazo. En el último seguimiento (mediana de 43 meses), el 15,9% de los pacientes tuvieron complicaciones no resueltas.LIMITACIÓN:El diseño retrospectivo.CONCLUSIONES:Los pacientes sometidos a disección de ganglios pélvicos linfáticos laterales experimentaron una mayor frecuencia de complicaciones a largo plazo, pero la mitad de ellos tuvieron linfoceles asintomáticos, la mayoría de los cuales se resolvieron espontáneamente. Sin embargo, se deben realizar mayores esfuerzos para reducir las complicaciones previstas relacionadas con la disección de los ganglios linfáticos pélvicos laterales. (Traducción-Dr. Aurian Garcia Gonzalez ).

Sequential Lateral Lymphatic Metastasis Shows Similar Oncologic Outcomes to Upward Spread in Advanced Rectal Cancer After Preoperative Chemoradiotherapy

BACKGROUND

Whether lateral pelvic node metastasis should be considered as a regional or systemic disease is a long-standing debate. Although previous Japanese studies have considered it to be locoregional disease, Western countries consider it a systemic disease and do not perform lateral pelvic node dissection after preoperative chemoradiotherapy.

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate whether lateral pelvic node metastasis is a systemic or regional disease that is amenable to curative resection.

DESIGN

Retrospective analysis of a prospectively collected database.

SETTING

This study was conducted at a tertiary cancer center.

PATIENTS

There were 616 consecutive patients who underwent curative total mesorectal excision alone or with lateral pelvic node dissection after preoperative chemoradiotherapy for locally advanced rectal cancer between 2011 and 2019.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Three-year disease-free and overall survival.

RESULTS

A total of 360 patients underwent total mesorectal excision, and 160 patients underwent total mesorectal excision with lateral pelvic node dissection. There was no difference in the 3-year disease-free survival (DFS; p = 0.844) or overall survival rates ( p = 0.921) between the groups. Patients with lateral pelvic node metastasis showed DFS similar to those with perirectal lymph node metastasis in the total mesorectal excision group. In a subgroup analysis, patients with internal iliac pelvic node metastasis showed a disease-free survival comparable to those with perirectal node involvement, and patients with other lateral pelvic node metastasis showed a DFS similar to those with intermediate node involvement. In the lateral pelvic node dissection group, the lateral pelvic node metastatic rate was 32.5%. On multivariate analysis, fewer than 8 of the unilateral harvested lateral pelvic nodes and advanced ypT stage were significantly associated with poor disease-free survival.

LIMITATION

The retrospective design.

CONCLUSIONS

Lateral lymphatic metastasis showed oncologic outcomes similar to those of upward spread, especially perirectal lymph nodes metastasis. Large cohort studies with long-term follow-up are required to confirm these results. See Video Abstract .

LAS METSTASIS LINFTICAS SECUENCIALES LATERALES MUESTRAN RESULTADOS ONCOLGICOS SIMILARES EN LA PROPAGACIN ASCENDENTE DEL CNCER RECTAL AVANZADO DESPUS DE LA RADIOQUIMIOTERAPIA PREOPERATORIA

ANTECEDENTES:Es un debate muy antiguo si las metástasis en los ganglios pélvicos laterales deben considerarse una enfermedad regional o sistémica. Si bien estudios japoneses anteriores las consideran como una enfermedad locorregional, en los países de occidente se las considera como una enfermedad sistémica por la cual no se realiza disección de ganglios pélvicos laterales después de una radioquimioterapia preoperatoria.OBJETIVOS:Evaluar si la metástasis en los ganglios pélvicos laterales se consideran como enfermedad sistémica o enfermedad regional susceptible de resección curativa.DISEÑO:Análisis retrospectivo de una base de datos recopilada prospectivamente.AJUSTE:Este estudio se realizó en un centro oncológico terciario.PACIENTES:616 pacientes consecutivos se sometieron a excisión total del mesorrecto curativa sola o con disección de los ganglios pélvicos laterales después de radioquimioterapia preoperatoria en casos de cáncer de recto localmente avanzado entre 2011 y 2019.PRINCIPALES MEDIDAS DE RESULTADO:Sobrevida global y libre de enfermedad a 3 años.RESULTADOS:Un total de 360 pacientes se sometieron a excisión total del mesorrecto y 160 pacientes se sometieron a excisión total del mesorrecto con disección de ganglios pélvicos laterales.No hubo diferencias en la sobrevida libre de enfermedad a 3 años (p = 0,844) ni en las tasas de sobrevida general (p = 0,921) entre los grupos. Los pacientes con metástasis en los ganglios pélvicos laterales mostraron una sobrevida libre de enfermedad similar a aquellos con metástasis en los ganglios linfáticos perirrectales que se encontraban en el grupo de excisión total del mesorrecto.En el análisis de subgrupos, los pacientes con metástasis en los ganglios pélvicos ilíacos internos mostraron una sobrevida libre de enfermedad comparable a aquellos con afección de los ganglios perirrectales y los pacientes con otras metástasis en los ganglios pélvicos laterales mostraron una sobrevida libre de enfermedad similar a aquellos con afección de los ganglios intermedios.En el grupo de disección de los ganglios pélvicos laterales, la tasa de metástasis en dichos ganglios fué del 32,5%. En el análisis multivariado, < de 8 ganglios pélvicos laterales resecados unilateralmente y el estadio ypT avanzado se asociaron significativamente con una menor sobrevida libre de enfermedad.LIMITACIÓN:El diseño retrospectivo del estudio.CONCLUSIONES:Las metástasis linfáticas laterales mostraron resultados oncológicos similares a la diseminación ascendente, especialmente las metástasis en los ganglios linfáticos perirrectales. Se requieren grandes estudios de cohortes con seguimiento a largo plazo para confirmar estos resultados. (Traducción-Dr. Xavier Delgadillo ).

A risk-adjusted cumulative sum analysis of the progression from a novice to an expert surgeon at a single institution

BACKGROUND/OBJECTIVE

Laparoscopic surgery for rectal cancer is challenging for novice surgeons because it requires a sharp dissection in a narrow pelvis with visual limitations. Therefore, this study aimed to analyze the learning curve and clinical outcomes of laparoscopic surgery for rectal cancer performed by a novice surgeon en route to becoming an expert.

METHODS

In total, 119 patients who underwent laparoscopic surgery for rectal cancer performed by a single surgeon between June 2010 and December 2019 were analyzed. A single hybrid model based on the operative time, open conversion, complications, and resection margin involvement was generated to assess the success of laparoscopic surgery. Furthermore, the learning curve was evaluated using the risk-adjusted cumulative sum (RA-CUSUM) method.

RESULTS

The learning period was categorized into three phases according to the RA-CUSUM method (phase 1, 1st-33rd cases; phase 2, 34th-84th cases; and phase 3, 85th-119th cases). Tumor size (p = 0.004), distal resection margin (p = 0.003), and the number of harvested lymph nodes (p < 0.001) significantly increased with the learning period. The time to tolerable soft diet became shorter according to the learning period (p = 0.017). Advanced T stage (p = 0.024) and adjuvant chemotherapy (p = 0.012) were more common in phase 3.

CONCLUSIONS

This study suggested that the initial technical competence of laparoscopic surgery for rectal cancer was acquired in the 33rd case. Technical mastery was achieved in the 84th case. After mastering the technique, the surgeon tended to challenge more advanced cases, however, the complication rates did not increase.

Indocyanine Green (ICG) and Colorectal Surgery: A Literature Review on Qualitative and Quantitative Methods of Usage

Background: Due to its many benefits, indocyanine green (ICG) has gained progressive popularity in operating rooms (ORs) globally. This literature review examines its qualitative and quantitative usage in surgical treatment. Method: Relevant terms were searched in five international databases (1. Pubmed, 2. Sciencedirect, 3. Scopus, 4. Oxfordjournals, 5. Reaxys) for a comprehensive literature review. The main benefits of using ICG in colorectal surgery are: intraoperative fluorescence angiography; fluorescence-guided lymph node involvement detection and the sentinel technique; the fluorescent emphasis of a minute liver tumour, counting just 200 tumour cells; facilitation of fistula diagnosis; and tumour tattooing. This methodology can also be used with quantitative characteristics such as maximum intensity, relative maximum intensity, and in-flow parameters such as time-to-peak, slope, and t1/2max. This article concludes that fluorescence surgery with ICG and near-infrared (NIR) light is a relatively new technology that improves anatomical and functional information, allowing more comprehensive and safer tumour removal and the preservation of important structures.

Effect of self-reported clinician experience level on perceptions of the relative rankings of risk factors for biological complications with dental implant therapy

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

The effect of clinician experience on the perception of risks for biological complications associated with dental implant therapy is unknown.

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to determine whether clinician experience levels, as assessed by the number of implants placed and/or restored, as well as by type of clinical experience (restorative/prosthodontic and/or surgical), influence the perception of risk for biological complications with dental implant therapy.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A 10-item survey instrument was developed that asked participants from a convenience sample to rank different risk factors for peri-implant complications in the areas of patient history, clinical findings, and clinician choices and postimplant placement findings. Information about participant experience (number of implants placed and restored and type of experience) was also captured. The Kruskal-Wallis and Mann-Whitney U test statistical analyses were performed to determine the degree, if any, to which the level of clinician experience influenced risk factor rankings (α=.05).

RESULTS

Clinicians with more experience viewed the use of selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor (SSRI) medications and clinician inexperience as more important risk factors than did less experienced clinicians. Clinicians with less experience viewed treated moderate or severe chronic periodontitis and thin tissue biotype as more important risk factors than did more experienced clinicians. Clinicians with predominantly surgical experience viewed a heavy plaque index as a more important risk factor than clinicians with predominantly restorative experience.

CONCLUSIONS

The data indicate that the level of clinical experience influences how risk factors associated with biological complications of dental implant therapy are viewed by clinicians.