Facial Malformation in Crouzon's Syndrome Is Consistent with Cranial Base Development in Time and Space

Mystery of the Muenke midface: spheno-occipital synchondrosis fusion and craniofacial skeletal patterns

PURPOSE

The spheno-occipital synchondrosis (SOS) is an important site of endochondral ossification in the cranial base that closes prematurely in Apert, Crouzon, and Pfeiffer syndromes, which contributes to varying degrees of midface hypoplasia. The facial dysmorphology of Muenke syndrome, in contrast, is less severe with low rates of midface hypoplasia. We thus evaluated the timing of SOS fusion and cephalometric landmarks in patients with Muenke syndrome compared to normal controls.

METHODS

Patients with Muenke syndrome who had at least one fine-cut head computed tomography scan performed from 2000 to 2020 were retrospectively reviewed. A case-control study was performed of patient scans and age- and sex-matched control scans. SOS fusion status was evaluated as open, partially closed, or closed.

RESULTS

We included 28 patients and compared 77 patient scans with 77 control scans. Kaplan-Meier analysis demonstrated an insignificantly earlier timeline of SOS fusion in Muenke syndrome (p = 0.300). Mean sella-orbitale (SO) distance was shorter (44.0 ± 6.6 vs. 47.7 ± 6.7 mm, p < 0.001) and mean sella-nasion-Frankfort horizontal (SN-FH) angle was greater (12.1° ± 3.8° vs. 10.1° ± 3.2°, p < 0.001) in the Muenke group, whereas mean sella-nasion-A point (SNA) angle was similar and normal (81.1° ± 5.7° vs. 81.4° ± 4.7°, p = 0.762).

CONCLUSION

Muenke syndrome is characterized by mild and often absent midfacial hypoplasia, with the exception of slight retropositioning of the infraorbital rim. Interestingly, SOS fusion patterns in these patients are not significantly different from age- and sex-matched controls despite an increased odds of fusion. It is possible that differences in timing of SOS fusion may manifest phenotypically at the infraorbital rim rather than at the maxilla.

A 3-Dimensional Morphometric Analysis of 4 Midsagittal Planes for CT Scan Reference Determination in Children with Syndromic Craniosynostosis

OBJECTIVE

To identify the suitable and practical midsagittal plane (MSP) reference for computed tomography (CT) scan skull analysis in patients with syndromic craniosynostosis.

DESIGN

Retrospective study.

SETTING

Tertiary referral hospital.

PATIENTS AND PARTICIPANTS

A total of 19 full skull CT scans of syndromic craniosynostosis patients.

METHODS

Seven craniofacial landmarks located on the midline and 4 MSPs that was previously published and clinically recognized (Planes: SPBaS, SPNSANS, SPLOrPo and SPZFTP) were constructed from the CT images. The absolute distance of every plane from 7 landmarks were then calculated. These distances were subsequently subjected to statistical analysis.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

The absolute distance of different MSPs from 7 landmarks.

RESULTS

The distances of landmarks measured to SPBaS were the highest, with the most prominent fluctuation. The fluctuation of the SPNSANS, SPLOrPo and SPZFTP had similar direction changes, with the latter being the closest. Pairwise comparisons demonstrated statistical differences (P < .008 using the Bonferroni correction) between the measured distances of A point (M = 0.25, SD = 0.16) and B point (M = 2.21, SD = 1.6) to SPNSANS. There were statistical significances between distances of B point (M = 1.68, SD = 1.07) and CG point (M = 0.55, SD = 0.37) to SPZFTP plane. There was no statistical significance on each landmark to SPLOrPo.

CONCLUSIONS

The study demonstrates that SPBaS is not recommended for MSP reference. While SPNSANS should be carefully selected, the application of SPLOrPo and SPZFTP are interchangeable, with the SPZFTP plane slightly exaggerating the mandible deviation relative to the superior and posterior of the midface.

Craniofacial characteristics in Crouzon's syndrome: A systematic review and meta-analysis

The purpose of this meta-analysis was to strengthen the credibility of primary research results by combining open-source scientific material, namely a comparison of craniofacial features (Cfc) between Crouzon's syndrome (CS) patients and non-CS populations. All articles published up to October 7, 2021, were included in the search of PubMed, Google Scholar, Scopus, Medline, and Web of Science. The PRISMA guidelines were followed to conduct this study. PECO framework was applied in the following ways: Those who have CS are denoted by the letter P, those who have been diagnosed with CS via clinical or genetic means by the letter E, those who do not have CS by the letter C, and those who have a Cfc of CS by the letter O. Independent reviewers collected the data and ranked the publications based on their adherence to the Newcastle-Ottawa Quality Assessment Scale. A total of six case-control studies were reviewed for this meta-analysis. Due to the large variation in cephalometric measures, only those published in at least two previous studies were included. This analysis found that CS patients had a smaller skull and mandible volumes than those without CS.in terms of SNA° (MD = -2.33, p = <0.001, I2 = 83.6%) and ANB°(MD = -1.89, p = <0.005, I2 = 93.1%)), as well as ANS (MD = -1.87, p = 0.001, I2 = 96.5%)) and SN/PP (MD = -1.99, p = 0.036, I2 = 77.3%)). In comparison to the general population, people with CS tend to have shorter and flatter cranial bases, smaller orbital volumes, and cleft palates. They differ from the general population in having a shorter skull base and more V-shaped maxillary arches.

Orbital and Periorbital Dysmorphology in Untreated Pfeiffer Syndrome

BACKGROUND

Visual impairment secondary to orbital and periorbital dysmorphology is frequent in Pfeiffer syndrome patients. The etiopathogenesis of this aberrancy, however, remains unclear.

METHODS

Untreated Pfeiffer syndrome patients (n = 31) and normal control subjects (n = 43) were compared. Craniometric and volumetric analyses related to the orbital and periorbital anatomy were performed using Materialise (Leuven, Belgium) software.

RESULTS

Overall, orbital cavity volume of Pfeiffer patients is reduced by 28 percent (p < 0.001), compared to normal, starting before 3 months of age (p = 0.004). Globe volume was diminished by 10 percent (p = 0.041) before 3 months of age, yet tended to catch up thereafter. However, the retrobulbar soft-tissue volume remained smaller beyond 1 year of age (17 percent, p = 0.003). Globe volume projection beyond the bony orbit increased in all observed ages (82 percent, p < 0.001). The volumes of sphenoid bone, maxilla, and mandible proportionately were restricted by 24 to 25 percent (p = 0.003 to 0.035) before 3 months of age. The volume of maxilla and mandible gradually approximate normal; however, the sphenoid bone volume in Pfeiffer patients remains less than normal (p = 0.002) into childhood. The anteroposterior length of both the zygoma and the maxilla was reduced by 14 percent (p < 0.001). Anterior positioning of the zygoma is less by 23 percent (p < 0.001) in Pfeiffer patients overall, with anterior positioning of maxilla reduced similarly by 23 percent (p < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Pfeiffer syndrome patients develop decreased retrobulbar soft-tissue and globe volume, along with a restricted orbital cavity volume in infancy. Significant hypoplasia of the sphenoid bone is associated with more severe central facial (maxilla) retrusion, compared to lateral facial structures (zygoma).

CLINICAL QUESTION/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Risk, II.

Morphology of the Occipital Bones and Foramen Magnum Resulting From Premature Minor Suture Fusion in Crouzon Syndrome

To identify skull-base growth patterns in Crouzon syndrome, we hypothesized premature minor suture fusion restricts occipital bone development, secondarily limiting foramen magnum expansion.

Skull-base suture closure degree and cephalometric measurements were retrospectively studied using preoperative computed tomography (CT) scans and multiple linear regression analysis.

Evaluation of multi-institutional CT images and 3D reconstructions from Wake Forest's Craniofacial Imaging Database (WFCID).

Sixty preoperative patients with Crouzon syndrome under 12 years-old were selected from WFCID. The control group included 60 age- and sex-matched patients without craniosynostosis or prior craniofacial surgery.

None.

2D and 3D cephalometric measurements.

3D volumetric evaluation of the basioccipital, exo-occipital, and supraoccipital bones revealed decreased growth in Crouzon syndrome, attributed solely to premature minor suture fusion. Spheno-occipital (β = -398.75; P < .05) and petrous-occipital (β = -727.5; P < .001) suture fusion reduced growth of the basioccipital bone; lambdoid suture (β = -14 723.1; P < .001) and occipitomastoid synchondrosis (β = -16 419.3; P < .001) fusion reduced growth of the supraoccipital bone; and petrous-occipital suture (β = -673.3; P < .001), anterior intraoccipital synchondrosis (β = -368.47; P < .05), and posterior intraoccipital synchondrosis (β = -6261.42; P < .01) fusion reduced growth of the exo-occipital bone. Foramen magnum morphology is restricted in Crouzon syndrome but not directly caused by early suture fusion.

Premature minor suture fusion restricts the volume of developing occipital bones providing a plausible mechanism for observed foramen magnum anomalies.

Craniofacial development in patients of Tessier No.0 cleft with a bifid nose using 3D computed tomography

OBJECTIVE

Considerable studies have focused mainly on the facial deformity of Tessier No.0 cleft with a bifid nose, but the deformity of the skull is not well understood. Therefore, our study aimed to explore the evolution of cranial dysmorphology and the chronology of Tessier No.0 cleft with a bifid nose, by three-dimensional measurements.

METHODS

Ninety-six non-surgical patients and computed tomographic scans were included (Tessier No.0 cleft with a bifid nose, n = 48; controls, n = 48) and divided into five age subgroups. Craniofacial cephalometric measurements were analyzed by Mimics software.

RESULTS

The widening of nasal bone was the most remarkable and persistent from 2 years old appropriately. The overall cranial base length in patients compared with controls increased 11.8% (p < 0.01) on average. The middle and posterior cranial fossa increasing accounted for most of this change. The cranial base angles also showed increased obviously. By analyzing the linear of the nasopharynx and respiratory tract, it was found that its development did not affect respiration.

CONCLUSIONS

The cranial base deformity of Tessier No.0 cleft with a bifid nose consists of the whole skull base and particularly the middle and posterior cranial base length increase. At the same time, there may be late closure of the spheno-occipital synchondrosis and sella displacement. We believe this study is unique in providing valuable data for elucidating the pathological and morphological abnormalities of skull base development in Tessier No.0 cleft with a bifid nose.

Facial Dysmorphology in Saethre-Chotzen Syndrome

PURPOSE

Classic features of Saethre-Chotzen syndrome (SCS) described in the literature include a prominent nasal bridge, eyelid ptosis, telorbitism, maxillary hypoplasia, and mandibular prognathism. The purpose of this study was to evaluate objectively the bony features of SCS.

METHODS

Preoperative computer tomography scans of 15 SCS patients, 23 normal controls, 13 bicoronal nonsyndromic, and 7 unicoronal nonsyndromic craniosynostosis patients were included for analysis. Unaffected controls and nonsyndromic patients were age- and sex-matched to SCS patients. Morphometric cephalometrics were analyzed using three-dimensional computer tomography reconstructions. Mann-Whitney U were used to compare facial measurements between SCS and normal and nonsyndromic craniosynostosis controls.

RESULTS

Telorbitism was present in bicoronal SCS patients only (P = 0.04) but absent in the unicoronal and bicoronal/metopic cohorts. The angle of the nasal bone relative to the sella was not different between SCS and controls (P = 0.536), although the angle of the nasal bone relative to the forehead was decreased in SCS by 15.5° (P < 0.001). Saethre-Chotzen syndrome had a 2.6° maxillary retrusion relative to controls (P = 0.03). In addition, SCS patients aged 4 to 7 months had a wider (39.34 versus 35.04, P = 0.017) and anteroposteriorly foreshortened (32.12 versus 35.06, P = 0.039) maxilla. There was no difference in mandibular prognathism among SCS patients as measured by the sella-nasion-B point angle compared to controls (P = 0.705).

CONCLUSIONS

Despite classic descriptions, on morphometric analysis SCS patients did not demonstrate consistency across all suture subtypes in terms of telorbitism, a broad nasal bridge, or mandibular prognathism. Rather, SCS subtypes of SCS based on suture pathology more closely resemble nonsyndromic patients.

Effect of Early Spheno-Occipital Synchondrosis Fusion in Preadolescent Patients With Syndromic Craniosynostosis on Craniofacial Skeletal Patterns: A Preliminary Study Using Cephalometric Analysis

ABSTRACT

The purpose of this study was to investigate the effects of early spheno-occipital synchondrosis (SOS) fusion in preadolescent patients with syndromic craniosynostosis (SC) on the craniofacial skeletal patterns. Twenty preadolescent SC patients were divided into the fused SOS (FS, n = 10; 8 Crouzon and 2 Apert) and not-fused SOS groups (NFS, n = 10; 9 Crouzon and 1 Apert). Lateral cephalograms (mean age: 9.60 years, cervical vertebral maturation index: stage I and II) were used to investigate the skeletal sagittal (ANB) and vertical patterns (SN-GoMe), upward inclination of the anterior cranial base (ACB; SN-FH), degree of midface hypoplasia (MH, SNA), retrusive position of orbitale (SNO), and forward position of the condyle in relation to sella (saddle angle). Using the ordinal values calculated by ethnic norm (criteria: moderate, over ±1 standard deviation, severe, over ±2 standard deviation), statistical analysis was performed. The FS group showed a higher percentage of severe MH than the NFS group (70% versus 10%, P < 0.05). Although the 2 groups did not differ in the distribution of ANB, SN-GoMe, saddle angle, and SN-FH (all P > 0.05), the FS group showed relatively higher percentages of severe Class III (100% versus 70%), severe hyper-divergent pattern (40% versus 10%), severely forward condyle position (30% versus 0%), and moderate and severe upward anterior cranial base inclination (90% versus 50%) than the NFS group. However, the 2 groups exhibited the same distribution of moderately and severely retrusive orbitale position ([50%, 20%], P > 0.05). Early SOS fusion in preadolescent SC patients might not be related to retrusive orbitale position, but to severe MH.

Virtual Coordinate System in Unicoronal Synostosis

We propose a landmark-based, virtual coordinate system, specifically designed for assessment of asymmetrical craniofacial anatomy associated with unicoronal synostosis.

Method

CT scans of 33 patients with nonsyndromic unicoronal synostosis were included. Proposed mid-sagittal plane was compared with commonly used sagittal planes: (1) nasion, sella, and basion (N-S-BA); (2) midplane of bilateral frontozygomatic sutures (midFZ); and (3) the skull gravity center plane, to evaluate reliability and validity in the assessments of the anterior and posterior skull base.

Results

The proposed midplane is similar to the midFZ plane in describing the direction of the anterior skull base. However, it has less bias than the N-S-BA (P < 0.001), and the gravity center planes (P < 0.001). The proposed midplane measures the direction of the posterior skull base plane, similar to the midFZ and gravity center planes, but it has less measurement deviation than the N-S-BA plane (P < 0.001). The most protrusive point on the frontal bone in unicoronal patients is contralateral to the fused suture and distant from the mid-sagittal plane by 13.93 ± 4.01 mm. In addition, it is more anteriorly positioned, by 5.32 mm (P < 0.001), when compared with the corresponding point on the synostotic side. The uppermost point of the supraorbital rim on the synostotic side is cephalic to that of the contralateral side by 4.09 mm (P < 0.001).

Conclusions

Prioritized orientation of an averaged Frankfort horizontal plane, followed by the location of the mid-sagittal and coronal planes, can generate a reliable and valid coordinate framework for the assessment of asymmetric skull shape in unicoronal synostosis.

Distinguishing Craniomorphometric Characteristics of Unilateral Lambdoid Craniosynostosis

BACKGROUND

Unilateral lambdoid synostosis (ULS) represents the rarest form of single suture nonsyndromic craniosynostosis. Differentiating between posterior deformational plagiocephaly (DP) and ULS has been difficult due to overlapping clinical findings. Past analyses have been limited by sample size. This study was undertaken to clarify anatomical features of ULS.

METHODS

A multiinstitution study was undertaken, analyzing CT imaging from patients with documented ULS to determine clinical and pathological characteristics. Similar analyses were performed on DP patients to differentiate the 2 conditions.

RESULTS

Twenty-seven ULS patient scans and 10 DP scans were included. For ULS patients mean age was 6.6 months, majority male (75%), and majority left-sided ULS (71%). The synostosed side ear was anteriorly displaced in 100% of ULS patients, mean difference of 9.6° (P < 0.001), and inferiorly in 96.3% of patients, mean difference of 4.4 mm, relative to the nonsynostosed side. The posterior fossa deflection (PFD) was deviated 5.9° toward the synostosed side relative to the anterior midline. In DP, there was no significant difference between sides in EAC measurements. The PFD and EAC displacements were significantly smaller in DP relative to ULS (P < 0.001 for each). An ipsilateral mastoid bulge was found in 100% of ULS and 0% of DP on CT imaging.

CONCLUSION

Contrary to some previously published findings, the ear is more anteriorly displaced ipsilateral to the fused lambdoid suture in 100% of ULS patients. Ear position alone is not a reliable indicator to differentiate between DP and ULS. A mastoid bulge is a more reliable indicator of ULS.

Racial disparity in orbital morphology and spatial relations in unoperated Crouzon patients

The altered orbital morphology of patients with Crouzon syndrome could have an impact on the planning of treatment in diverse populations, in spite of the confounding influences of different cranial suture synostosis. This study attempted to explore the differences in orbital characteristics between Asian, Caucasian patients with Crouzon syndrome, associated pansynostosis. Eighty-six preoperative computed tomograms (CT) were included (Asian Crouzon syndrome: n=10; Asian controls: n=24; Caucasian Crouzon syndrome: n=19; Caucasian controls: n=33) and measured using Mimics software (Materialise). Unique cephalometric measurements related to orbital morphology and position were designed. Crouzon syndrome and race both have interactive effects on protrusion of the globe (p=0.009) and medial horizontal angle (p=0.012) in the assessment of orbital morphology. They also interact in the width of the ethmoid sinus (p=0.009) and influence bilateral orbital relations. The anteroposterior orbital roof in Caucasian patients with Crouzon syndrome was shortened by 4.09mm (p=0.002) compared with Caucasian controls. However, in Asian patients this dimension developed normally. The anteroposterior orbital floor was significantly reduced to a similar extent in both Asian and Caucasian Crouzon patients (both p<0.001). The visual axes in Caucasian patients with Crouzon showed more inferior rotation, by 4.38° (p=0.031) than they did in Caucasian controls, but did not achieve a statistically significant difference in other comparisons. The effect of Crouzon syndrome on orbital malformation and placement is influenced by race, especially structures related to the ethmoid sinus. Asian patients need greater infraorbital advancement for better correction of orbital proptosis and aesthetic benefits, but may require less fronto-orbital advancement than Caucasian patients.

Cranial Fossa Volume and Morphology Development in Apert Syndrome

BACKGROUND

Apert syndrome causes normal or enlarged intracranial volume overall as patients grow. This study aimed to trace the segmental anterior, middle, and posterior cranial fossae volume and structural morphology in these patients, to help discern a more focused and individualized surgical treatment plan for patients with Apert syndrome.

METHODS

This study included 82 preoperative computed tomographic scans (Apert, n = 32; control, n = 50) divided into five age-related subgroups. The scans were measured using image processing and three-dimensional modeling software.

RESULTS

The middle cranial fossa volume was increased and was the earliest change noted. It was increased by 45 percent (p = 0.023) compared with controls before 6 months of age and remained increased into adulthood (161 percent, p = 0.016), with gradually increasing severity. The anterior and posterior cranial fossae volumes also increased, by 35 percent (p = 0.032) and 39 percent (p = 0.007), respectively. Increased depth of cranial fossae contributed most to the increase in volumes of patients with Apert syndrome, with correlation coefficients of 0.799, 0.908, and 0.888 for anterior, middle, and posterior cranial fossa, respectively. The intracranial volume was increased 12 percent (p = 0.098) across the entire test age range (0 to 26 years old), but only had statistical significance during the age range of 6 to 18 years (22 percent, p = 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Malformation of the middle cranial fossa is an early, perhaps the initial, pivotal cranial morphologic change in Apert syndrome. Increased cranial fossae depth is an inherent characteristic of the maldevelopment. Normalization of cranial volume and circumference overall may not achieve a normal skull structure, as it does not correct regional craniocerebral disproportion.

Racial disparity of Crouzon syndrome in maxilla and mandible

The racial disparity of facial features in craniosynostosis patients is not fully understood. The aim of this study was to explore the difference in maxillary and mandibular morphology and spatial position in Asian and Caucasian Crouzon syndrome patients. Ninety-one computed tomography scans were included (12 Asian Crouzon syndrome patients, 22 Asian controls; 16 Caucasian Crouzon syndrome patients, 41 Caucasian controls) and measured using Materialise software. The maxillary and mandibular volumes of Asian patients were both reduced by 19% (P=0.102 and P=0.187), and those of Caucasian patients were reduced by 15% (P=0.142) and 14% (P=0.211) when compared to the respective race-specific controls. Maxilla length of Asian patients was reduced by 6.36mm (14%, P=0.003), while the reduction in Caucasian patients was 4.88mm (10%, P=0.038). ANS was retracted 11.99mm (P<0.001) in Asian patients and 11.54mm (P<0.001) in Caucasian patients. The ANB angle was narrowed by 13.17° (P<0.001) in Asian patients compared to Asian controls, and by 7.02° (P<0.001) in Caucasian patients compared to Caucasian controls. The retrusive midface profiles of Asian and Caucasian Crouzon syndrome look similar; both result from the combined effect of hypoplastic size and backward displacement. However, the insufficiency was found to be more a failure of the anteroposterior maxillary length in Asian patients, and more due to posterior maxillary positioning in Caucasian patients. Therefore, prognathism in Crouzon syndrome patients is more likely caused by displacement rather than elongation of mandibular length in both races. Crouzon syndrome results in the same extent of overall volume deficiency of the maxilla and mandible in these races.