Surgical and Nonsurgical Pediatric Hand Fractures: A Cohort Study

Anatomical distribution and treatment of paediatric hand fractures: a multi-centre study of 749 patients in the Netherlands

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

II.

Management of paediatric fifth metacarpal neck fractures: a systematic review

BACKGROUND

Fifth metacarpal neck fractures (FMCNFs) are common among paediatric patients. Complications include reduced metacarpophalangeal (MCP) range of motion and grip strength, which impede the hand's functional abilities. Various management options are available, but indications are not standardised. This systematic review aims to assimilate all available evidence on the management of paediatric FMCNFs to determine appropriate treatment pathways.

METHODS

PubMed (Medline), EMBASE, Scopus and Google Scholar were used to identify evidence pertaining to the management of these fractures.

RESULTS

Ten studies were identified, involving 237 patients with a mean age of 14.4 years (Range 9-17). Ninety percent of patients were male. Sixty-one (26%) patients, with an average fracture angulation of 27° (Range 16°-33°) and no rotational deformities, were managed with immobilisation alone. These patients returned to normal metacarpophalangeal range of motion and grip strength. Fifty-four (23%) patients, with an average fracture angulation of 42.7° (Range 33°-54°), were managed with fracture reduction and immobilisation. This technique did not yield sustained reduction of fractures with significant angulation or rotation after intervention. One hundred twenty-two (51%) patients, with an average fracture angulation of 48.3° (Range 30°-58°) and including cases of malrotation, were managed with fracture reduction and surgical fixation. These patients experienced good functional outcomes.

CONCLUSIONS

This review suggests paediatric FMCNFs can be safely managed with immobilisation alone when there is an absence of rotational deformity and an angulation of < 30°. In the case of a higher fracture angulation or rotational deformity, fracture reduction and surgical fixation is an appropriate method of management.

Prospective Validation of the Calgary Kids' Hand Rule: A Clinical Prediction Rule for Pediatric Hand Fracture Triage

Introduction: Pediatric hand fractures are common and routinely referred to surgeons, yet most heal well without surgical intervention. This trend inspired the development of the Calgary Kids' Hand Rule (CKHR), a clinical prediction rule designed to predict "complex" fractures that require surgical referral. The CKHR was adapted into a checklist whereby the presence of any 1 of 6 clinically or radiologically identifiable fracture characteristics predicts a complex fracture. The aim of this study was to assess the accuracy of the CKHR in a prospective sample of children with hand fractures. Methods: Physicians were asked to complete the CKHR checklist when referring pediatric patients (< 18 years) to hand surgeons at a Canadian pediatric hospital (April 2019-September 2020). Completed checklists represented predicted outcomes and were compared to observed outcomes (determined via chart review). Predictive accuracy (primary outcome) was evaluated based on sensitivity and specificity. Secondary outcomes were interrater reliability between referring physicians and surgeons, and survey assessment of CKHR user satisfaction. Results: In total 365 fractures were included, with only 16 requiring surgical intervention. Overall performance of the CKHR was good with 84% sensitivity and 71% specificity. Percent agreement between referring physicians and surgeons ranged from 84.1% to 96.3% on individual predictors, with 78.1% agreement on the presence of any predictors. Survey results showed general user satisfaction but also identified areas for improvement. Conclusion: This study posits the CKHR as an accurate and clinically useful prediction rule and highlights the importance of education for its effective use and eventual scale and spread.

Clinical Characteristics and Treatment Patterns of Open Hand Fractures in the Pediatric Population

BACKGROUND

Open hand fractures are one of the most common injuries in the pediatric population. These injuries are at higher risk of infection, especially in cases of frank contamination. Several studies on adult hand fractures are available in the literature; however, pediatric open hand fractures have yet to be extensively studied. This study aimed to define pediatric open hand fracture's demographics, clinical characteristics, and treatment patterns.

METHODS

Using the Protected Health Information database, pediatric patients (<18 y old) with the diagnosis of open hand fracture from June 2016 to June 2018 were extracted. Demographic, treatment, and follow-up data were collected. Clinical outcomes included readmission and postoperative infection rates.

RESULTS

There were a total of 4516 patients who met the inclusion criteria; the median age was 7 years (interquartile range: 3 to 11); 60% males; 60% white. Displaced fractures occurred in 74% of patients, with the right hand (52%) and middle finger (27%) predominance. The most common mechanism of injury was a crushing injury in-between objects (56%). Associated nerve injury occurred in 78 patients (4%) and vascular injury in 43 patients (2%). Open reduction and internal fixation were performed in 30% of patients. Cephalosporins were the most commonly prescribed antibiotics (73%), followed by aminopenicillins (7%). Nine patients had complications related to surgical intervention (0.2%), and postoperative infection occurred in 44 patients (1%).

CONCLUSIONS

Pediatric open hand fractures most often occur during childhood and more frequently in males. These fractures tend to be more distal and displaced; reduction and fixation are required in one-third of the cases. Despite the absence of treatment guidelines and variability, this injury exhibits low complication rates.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III, retrospective study.

Distribution and pattern of hand fractures in children and adolescents

Hand fractures represent commonly encountered injuries in pediatric patients. However, due to modern means of mobility and product safety, the occurrence and distribution of these fractures have changed during the last decades. Therefore, it was the aim of this study to present an update of the epidemiology, pattern, and treatment of hand fractures in a large pediatric cohort. All patients aged between 0 and 17 years treated in our Department in 2019 with fractures of the phalanges, metacarpus, or carpus were included. The medical records were reviewed for age, gender, injury mechanism, fracture localization, season, and treatment. Patients were divided into three different age groups (0-5, 6-12, and 13-17 years). A total of 731 patients with 761 hand fractures were treated during the 1-year study period. The mean age was 11.1 ± 3.5 years, and the majority was male (65%). Male patients were significantly older compared to female patients (p = 0.008). Also, 78.7% of the fractures affected the phalanges, 17.6% the metacarpals, and 3.7% the carpal bones. The proximal phalanges were the most commonly fractured bones (41.5%). Patients with fractures of the carpus were significantly older compared to children sustaining fractures of the metacarpus or phalangeal bones (p < 0.001). Sixteen percent of our patients were treated surgically; these patients were significantly older compared to conservatively treated patients (p = 0.011).  Conclusion: The epidemiology, mechanisms of injury, distribution, and treatment of hand fractures significantly varies among different age groups. This knowledge is of importance for educational purposes of younger colleagues entrusted with care of children and adolescents as well as development of effective prevention strategies. What is Known: • Pediatric hand fractures represent the second most common fractures in children. • The epidemiology of pediatric hand fractures has changed during the last decades and therefore there is a need for an update regarding distribution and epidemiology of pediatric hand fractures. What is New: • In this retrospective cohort study, 761 pediatric hand fractures of 731 patients were analyzed in detail. • The main mechanisms of younger patients were entrapment injuries, older children most commonly sustained their fractures due to ball sport injuries. There was an increasing rate of metacarpal and carpal fractures with increasing age, and these fractures had to be treated operatively more often than phalangeal fractures.

Phalangeal and Metacarpal Fractures in Children: A 10-Year Comparison of Factors Affecting Functional Outcomes in 313 Patients

Introduction  It is widely believed that fractures in children have excellent clinical outcomes due to their capacity to remodel. There are, however, certain fractures that require careful management to avoid long-lasting functional impairment. Functional outcomes following hand fractures in children are poorly studied. Materials and Methods  We performed a retrospective cohort study of consecutive children and adolescents who had operative treatment for metacarpal and phalangeal fractures (2008-2018). Tuft fractures and replantations were excluded. Functional outcomes were measured by total active motion (TAM) scoring, where a "good" outcome = TAM > 75%. Fractures were categorized by location, classification, and by the fixation they required. Results  Three hundred thirteen children were included. For proximal phalangeal fractures, those treated by manipulation under anesthesia, had a higher proportion of "good" functional outcomes than Kirschner-wire or open reduction internal fixation at discharge from hand therapy ( p  = 0.043). Middle phalanx fractures had excellent functional outcomes, with no difference between fixation methods ( p  = 0.81). For metacarpals, there was no statistically significant difference in functional outcomes across all managements ( p  = 0.134). Fractures in the thumb had poorer postoperative function at mean 7.26 weeks than those in the long fingers ( p  < 0.0001), and the data suggested a trend toward worse outcomes in the distal phalanx, pediatric Bennett fractures, Seymour fractures, and oblique fractures. Conclusions  Fractures in the thumb and phalangeal fractures that require percutaneous or open fixation may need closer early postoperative monitoring in children to optimize their potential for good function.

Strategies Addressing Barriers to the Implementation of a Pediatric Hand Fracture Care Pathway

We recently highlighted shortcomings in the care of pediatric hand fractures in our local context. The Calgary Kids’ Hand Rule (CKHR) was developed to predict hand fractures that require referral to a hand surgeon. The aims of this study were to identify barriers to a new care pathway for pediatric hand fractures, based on the CKHR and to generate tailored strategies to support its implementation.

Healthcare Providers and Parents Highlight Challenges of Pediatric Hand Fracture Care

Pediatric hand fractures are common, and many are referred to hand surgeons despite less than 10% of referrals requiring surgical intervention. We explored healthcare provider and parent perspectives to inform a new care pathway.

Methods

We conducted a qualitative descriptive study using virtual focus groups. Emergency physicians, hand therapists, plastic surgeons, and parents of children treated for hand fractures were asked to discuss their experiences with existing care for pediatric hand fractures, and perceptions surrounding the implementation of a new care pathway. Data were analyzed using directed content analysis with an inductive approach.

Results

Four focus groups included 24 participants: 18 healthcare providers and six parents. Four themes were identified: educating parents throughout the hand fracture journey, streamlining the referral process for simple hand fractures, identifying the most appropriate care provider for simple hand fractures, and maintaining strong multidisciplinary connections to facilitate care. Participants described gaps in the current care, including a need to better inform parents, and elucidated the motivations behind emergency medicine physicians' existing referral practices. Participants also generally agreed on the need for more efficient management of simple hand fractures that do not require surgical care. Healthcare providers believed the strong preexisting relationship between surgeons and hand therapists would facilitate the changes brought forward by the new care pathway.

Conclusion

These findings highlighted shortcomings of existing care for pediatric hand fractures and will inform the co-development and implementation of a new care pathway to enable more efficient management while preserving good patient outcomes.

Distribution of pediatric hand fractures: age- and bone maturation-dependent differences

PURPOSE

To investigate the distribution and characteristics of fractures of bones of the hand on radiographs with respect to age and skeletal maturity of the fractured bone, and to identify predictors of surgery.

METHODS

This cross-sectional, retrospective study included children (≤ 18 years) with hand fractures who underwent radiographic examinations (2019-2021). Fracture location, presence of displacement (≥ 2 mm), angulation (≥ 10°), articular extension, and if skeletally immature, then physeal involvement and Salter-Harris grade were recorded. Mann-Whitney U, Kruskal-Wallis, Fisher's exact, and chi-square tests as well as logistic regression analyses were used.

RESULTS

Study group of 508 (350 boys, 158 girls; median age, 11.9 years) included 575 (63% phalangeal, 37% metacarpal, and 0.3% carpal) fractures. Younger children were more likely to sustain phalangeal and older children carpal and metacarpal fractures (median ages: 10.8 vs 12.3 and 13.8 years, p < 0.001); and fractures of the small finger accounted for 50% of metacarpal and 43% of phalangeal fractures. Fracture displacement (12% vs 22%, p = 0.02) and angulation (25% vs 49%, p < 0.001) were more common with mature than immature bones. A third of immature bones had physeal involvement and the most common pattern was Salter-Harris type II (89%). Surgical intervention was uncommon (11%) and independent predictors were displacement (OR = 3.99, 95% CI 1.95-8.19, p < 0.001) and articular extension (OR = 5.11, 95% CI 2.00-13.07, p < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

While younger children were more likely to sustain phalangeal than metacarpal fractures and less likely to have displacement and angulation when compared to older children; only displacement and articular extension were significant independent predictors of surgery.

Pediatric hand fractures detection on radiographs: do localization cues improve diagnostic performance?

OBJECTIVE

To compare the diagnostic accuracy and interpretation time for detection of pediatric fractures on hand radiographs with and without localization cues.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Consecutive children, who underwent radiographic examinations after injury, over 2 years (2019-2021) and with > 2 weeks of follow-up to confirm the presence or absence of a fracture, were included. Four readers, blinded to history and diagnosis, retrospectively reviewed all images twice, without and with cue, at least 1 week apart and after randomization, to determine the presence or absence of a fracture, and if present, anatomic location and diagnostic confidence were recorded. Interpretation time for each study was also recorded and averaged across readers. Inter-reader agreement was calculated using Fleiss' kappa. Diagnostic accuracy and interpretation time were compared between examinations using sensitivity, specificity, and Mann-Whitney U correlation.

RESULTS

Study group included 92 children (61 boys, 31 girls; 10.8 ± 3.4 years) with and 40 (31 boys, 9 girls; 10.9 ± 3.7 years) without fractures. Cue improved inter-reader agreement (κ = 0.47 to 0.62). While the specificity decreased (63 to 62%), sensitivity (75 to 78%), diagnostic accuracy (71 to 73%), and confidence improved (78 to 87%, p < 0.01), and interpretation time (median: 40 to 22 s, p < 0.001) reduced with examinations with localization cue. Specifically, examinations with fracture and cue had the shortest interpretation time (median: 16 s), whereas examinations without fracture and without cue had the longest interpretation time (median: 48 s).

CONCLUSION

Localization cues increased inter-reader agreement and diagnostic confidence, reduced interpretation time in the detection of fractures on pediatric hand radiographs, while maintaining diagnostic accuracy.

Clinical characteristics and distribution of paediatric hand fractures at a tertiary hospital in South China: a retrospective analysis

The aim of this study was to evaluate the characteristics of paediatric hand fractures (PHF) at a tertiary hospital in South China based on sex, age, mechanism of injury and anatomical region. A retrospective observational study was performed on children aged 15 years and younger who were referred for actual or suspected hand fractures between January 2016 and December 2020. Medical records and radiographs were reviewed for age at the time of injury, sex, site and fracture pattern and mechanism of injury. A total of 436 consecutive children with 478 hand fractures were reviewed. Hand fractures was more common in boys (281/436; 64.4%) than in girls (155/436; 35.6%), although most fractures occurred in children aged 0-3 years (198/436; 45.4%). Distal phalanges were the most commonly injured bones (184/478; 38.5%), and the base fractures were most common (151/476; 31.7%); the fifth digit was most commonly injured (150/478; 31.3%). Crush injuries were the leading cause of fracture in children younger than 6 years of age (207/325; 63.7%), whereas punch injuries were the major cause of injury in older age groups (55/153; 35.9%); 60.1% of the fractures were managed nonsurgically. This study showed patterns of PHF in a tertiary hospital in South China. It illustrates the local variability across sex, age group, injury type and injury mechanism. Such demographic data will be valuable for optimally resourcing healthcare systems locally and help guide prevention policies.