Technical Feasibility of Whole-eye Vascular Composite Allotransplantation: A Systematic Review

Whole-Eye Transplantation: How Far Are We From a Breakthrough?

PURPOSE

Traumatic facial injuries and resultant eye enucleation remain a devastating life-changing event for many. However, whole-eye transplantation (WET) has remained a distant goal until recently. This narrative review explores the existing literature on WET, assesses current hurdles to its success, and considers the ethical challenges to the expansion of WET programs globally.

METHOD

The authors identified pertinent keywords by conducting an initial literature exploration which were subsequently used to search scientific databases. In line with the narrative methodology employed in this article, specific inclusion and exclusion criteria were not explicitly defined. Nevertheless, the review focused exclusively on articles relating to ocular restoration and reconstructive surgery.

RESULTS

Though vision restoration remains elusive, burgeoning surgical techniques such as vascularized composite allotransplantation have opened the scope for surgeons to consider WET when planning facial transplants. Dr. Rodriguez and the New York University Langone team's success supports the recent advancements made in surgical innovation and the potential of CD34-positive stem cells as neuroprotective agents when injected at the optic nerve connection of the recipient. For WET to succeed, vascular and neural structures and the transplanted eye must be considered. Such requirements have been strengthened by the development of microsurgical techniques. In addition to addressing the technical feasibility of WET, it is crucial to deliberate on ethical considerations such as the lifelong implications associated with immunosuppression and, challenges related to the fair division of ocular tissue for WET versus keratoplasty.

CONCLUSION

WET amid significant facial trauma has great potential to restore the quality of life in patients, however, more research is required to demonstrate its long-term viability.

Combined Whole Eye and Face Transplant: Microsurgical Strategy and 1-Year Clinical Course

Importance

Catastrophic facial injury with globe loss remains a formidable clinical problem with no previous reports of reconstruction by whole eye or combined whole eye and facial transplant.

Objective

To develop a microsurgical strategy for combined whole eye and facial transplant and describe the clinical findings during the first year following transplant.

Design, Setting, and Participant

A 46-year-old man who sustained a high-voltage electrical injury with catastrophic tissue loss to his face and left globe underwent combined whole eye and face transplant using personalized surgical devices and a novel microsurgical strategy at a specialized center for vascularized composite allotransplantation.

Main Outcomes and Measures

Reperfusion and viability of the whole eye and facial allografts, retinal function, and incidence of acute rejection.

Results

The patient underwent a combined whole eye and face transplant from an immunologically compatible donor with primary optic nerve coaptation and conventional postoperative immunosuppression. Globe and retinal perfusion were maintained throughout the immediate postoperative period, evidenced by fluorescein angiography. Optical coherence tomography demonstrated atrophy of inner retinal layers and attenuation and disruption of the ellipsoid zone. Serial electroretinography confirmed retinal responses to light in the transplanted eye. Using structural and functional magnetic resonance imaging, the integrity of the transplanted visual pathways and potential occipital cortical response to light stimulation of the transplanted eye was demonstrated. At 1 year post transplant (postoperative day 366), there was no perception of light in the transplanted eye.

Conclusions and Relevance

This is the first report of whole eye transplant combined with facial transplant, demonstrating allograft survival including rejection-free graft survival and electroretinographic measurements indicating retinal response to light stimuli. These data highlight the potential for clinical allotransplantation for globe loss.

Whole-eye transplantation: Current challenges and future perspectives

Whole-eye transplantation emerges as a frontier in ophthalmology, promising a transformative approach to irreversible blindness. Despite advancements, formidable challenges persist. Preservation of donor eye viability post-enucleation necessitates meticulous surgical techniques to optimize retinal integrity and ganglion cell survival. Overcoming the inhibitory milieu of the central nervous system for successful optic nerve regeneration remains elusive, prompting the exploration of neurotrophic support and immunomodulatory interventions. Immunological tolerance, paramount for graft acceptance, confronts the distinctive immunogenicity of ocular tissues, driving research into targeted immunosuppression strategies. Ethical and legal considerations underscore the necessity for stringent standards and ethical frameworks. Interdisciplinary collaboration and ongoing research endeavors are imperative to navigate these complexities. Biomaterials, stem cell therapies, and precision immunomodulation represent promising avenues in this pursuit. Ultimately, the aim of this review is to critically assess the current landscape of whole-eye transplantation, elucidating the challenges and advancements while delineating future directions for research and clinical practice. Through concerted efforts, whole-eye transplantation stands to revolutionize ophthalmic care, offering hope for restored vision and enhanced quality of life for those afflicted with blindness.

Successful Extension of Vascularized Composite Allograft Perfusion Cold Storage to 24 h in a Rat Hindlimb Transplant Model

Background

Vascularized composite allograft transplantation is a treatment option for complex tissue injuries; however, ischemia reperfusion injury and high acute rejection rates remain a challenge. Hypothermic machine perfusion using acellular storage perfusate is a potential solution. This study evaluated the University of Wisconsin Kidney Preservation Solution-1 (KPS-1) compared with normal saline (NS) for preservation of donor rat hindlimbs subjected to 24 h of ex vivo perfusion cold storage.

Methods

Hindlimbs were subjected to 24-h perfusion cold storage with heparinized KPS-1 (n = 6) or heparinized NS (n = 6). Flow, resistance, and pH were measured continuously. At the end of the 24-h period, tissue was collected for histological analysis of edema and apoptosis.

Results

KPS-1 perfused limbs showed significantly less edema than the NS group, as evidenced by lower limb weight gain (P < 0.001) and less interfascicular space (P < 0.001). KPS-perfused muscle had significantly less cell death than NS-perfused muscle based on terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase dUTP nick-end labeling (P < 0.001) and cleaved caspase-3 staining (P = 0.045). During hypothermic machine perfusion, a significant decrease in pH over time was detected in both groups, with a significantly greater decline in pH in the KPS-1 group than in the NS group. There were no significant differences overall and over time in flow rate or vascular resistance between the KPS and NS groups.

Conclusions

Perfusion with KPS-1 can successfully extend vascularized composite allograft perfusion cold storage for 24 h in a rat hindlimb model without significant edema or cell death.

First-in-Human Whole-Eye Transplantation: Ensuring an Ethical Approach to Surgical Innovation

As innovations in the field of vascular composite allotransplantation (VCA) progress, whole-eye transplantation (WET) is poised to transition from non-human mammalian models to living human recipients. Present treatment options for vision loss are generally considered suboptimal, and attendant concerns ranging from aesthetics and prosthesis maintenance to social stigma may be mitigated by WET. Potential benefits to WET recipients may also include partial vision restoration, psychosocial benefits related to identity and social integration, improvements in physical comfort and function, and reduced surgical risk associated with a biologic eye compared to a prosthesis. Perioperative and postoperative risks of WET are expected to be comparable to those of facial transplantation (FT), and may be similarly mitigated by immunosuppressive protocols, adequate psychosocial support, and a thorough selection process for both the recipient and donor. To minimize the risks associated with immunosuppressive medications, the first attempts in human recipients will likely be performed in conjunction with a FT. If first-in-human attempts at combined FT-WET prove successful and the biologic eye survives, this opens the door for further advancement in the field of vision restoration by means of a viable surgical option. This analysis integrates recent innovations in WET research with the existing discourse on the ethics of surgical innovation and offers preliminary guidance to VCA programs considering undertaking WET in human recipients.

Combined Face and Whole Eye Transplantation: Cadaveric Rehearsals and Feasibility Assessment

Background

In properly selected patients, combined face and whole eye transplantation (FWET) may offer a more optimal aesthetic and potentially functional outcome while avoiding the complications and stigma of enucleation and prosthetics. This study presents the most comprehensive cadaveric assessment for FWET to date, including rehearsal allograft procurement on a brain-dead donor.

Methods

Over a 2-year period, 15 rehearsal dissections were performed on 21 cadavers and one brain-dead donor. After identification of a potential recipient, rehearsals assessed clinical feasibility and enabled operative planning, technical practice, refinement of personalized equipment, and improved communication among team members. Operative techniques are described.

Results

Facial allograft procurement closely followed previously described face transplant techniques. Ophthalmic to superficial temporal (O-ST) vessel anastomosis for globe survival was assessed. Craniectomy allowed for maximal optic nerve and ophthalmic vessel pedicle length. Appropriate pedicle length and vessel caliber for O-ST anastomosis was seen. Research procurement demonstrated collateral blood flow to the orbit and surrounding structures from the external carotid system as well as confirmed the feasibility of timely O-ST anastomosis. Personalized cutting guides enabled highly accurate bony inset.

Conclusions

This study formalizes an approach to FWET, which is feasible for clinical translation in judiciously selected patients. O-ST anastomosis seems to minimize retinal ischemia time and allow perfusion of the combined allograft on a single external carotid pedicle. Although restoration of vision likely remains out of reach, globe survival is possible.