Design and Outcomes of a Novel Keratoprosthesis: Addressing Unmet Needs in End-Stage Cicatricial Corneal Blindness

Replace or Regenerate? Diverse Approaches to Biomaterials for Treating Corneal Lesions

The inner structures of the eye are protected by the cornea, which is a transparent membrane exposed to the external environment and subjected to the risk of lesions and diseases, sometimes resulting in impaired vision and blindness. Several eye pathologies can be treated with a keratoplasty, a surgical procedure aimed at replacing the cornea with tissues from human donors. Even though the success rate is high (up to 90% for the first graft in low-risk patients at 5-year follow-up), this approach is limited by the insufficient number of donors and several clinically relevant drawbacks. Alternatively, keratoprosthesis can be applied in an attempt to restore minimal functions of the cornea: For this reason, it is used only for high-risk patients. Recently, many biomaterials of both natural and synthetic origin have been developed as corneal substitutes to restore and replace diseased or injured corneas in low-risk patients. After illustrating the traditional clinical approaches, the present paper aims to review the most innovative solutions that have been recently proposed to regenerate the cornea, avoiding the use of donor tissues. Finally, innovative approaches to biological tissue 3D printing and xenotransplantation will be mentioned.

Transmucosal Boston Keratoprosthesis Type II in a Case of Severe Bilateral Chemical Burn

PURPOSE

The purpose of this report was to describe a new alternative surgical technique combining oral mucosa and the Boston Keratoprosthesis type II (BKPro II) in a patient with severe chemical burn.

METHODS

We present a case of a 37-year-old man who suffered a severe bilateral chemical burn. Visual acuity was light perception and projection in both eyes. After many surgeries, including eyelid reconstruction, eyelashes electrolysis, and amniotic membrane transplants, he presented a corneal thinning in his right eye that was managed with an autologous oral mucosa graft. Considering the limited function of the eyelids, mild symblepharon, and dry ocular surface, we proposed the implantation of a BKPro II. The patient voiced his desire of avoiding complete tarsorrhaphy for better cosmesis. Osteo-odonto-keratoprosthesis or tibial bone keratoprothesis was also discarded at the patient's express wish. A year and a half later, the oral mucosa was transplanted, and once the ocular surface was stabilized, we lift the mucosa 270 degrees and performed the implantation of the BKPro II covering this device with the mucosa trephined avoiding the complete tarsorrhaphy and theraby modifying the standard procedure.

RESULTS

After 34 months of follow-up, the patient did not develop any complications, his visual acuity is stable (0.3 decimal), and funduscopic examination showed a pale optic disk, vascular tortuosity, and an epiretinal membrane that remains stable up to this period.

CONCLUSIONS

Transmucosal BKPro II may be considered as an alternative surgical technique for implant support in BKPro II carriers who want to improve their cosmesis avoiding, avoid complete tarsorrhaphy, and do not want to be exposed to dental or bone surgeries.

Keratoprosthesis in dry eye disease

Bilateral corneal blindness with severe dry eye disease (DED), total limbal stem cell deficiency with underlying corneal stromal scarring and vascularization, combined with adnexal complications secondary to chronic cicatrizing conjunctivitis is a highly complex situation to treat. In such eyes, procedures such as penetrating keratoplasty alone or combined with limbal stem cell transplantation are doomed to fail. In these eyes, keratoprosthesis (Kpro) or an artificial cornea is the most viable option, eliminating corneal blindness even in eyes with autoimmune disorders such as Stevens-Johnson syndrome, ocular mucous membrane pemphigoid, Sjogren's syndrome, and nonautoimmune disorders such as chemical/thermal ocular burns, all of which are complex pathologies. Performing a Kpro in these eyes also eliminates the need for systemic immunosuppression and may provide relatively early visual recovery. In such eyes, the donor cornea around the central cylinder of the Kpro needs to be covered with a second layer of protection to avoid desiccation and progressive stromal melt of the underlying cornea, which is a common complication in eyes with severe DED. In this review, we will focus on Kpro designs that have been developed to survive in eyes with the hostile environment of severe DED. Their outcomes in such eyes will be discussed.

The Boston Keratoprosthesis-The First 50 Years: Some Reminiscences

Millions of people worldwide are bilaterally blind due to corneal diseases including infectious etiologies, trauma, and chemical injuries. While corneal transplantation can successfully restore sight in many, corneal graft survival decreases in eyes with chronic inflammation and corneal vascularization. Additionally, the availability of donor cornea material can be limited, especially in underdeveloped countries where corneal blindness may also be highly prevalent. Development of methods to create and implant an artificial cornea (keratoprosthesis)may be the only option for patients whose eye disease is not suitable for corneal transplantation or who live in regions where corneal transplantation is not possible. The Boston keratoprosthesis (B-KPro) is the most commonly implanted keratoprosthesis worldwide, having restored vision in thousands of patients. This article describes the initial design of the B-KPro and the modifications that have been made over many years. Additionally, some of the complications of surgical implantation and long-term care challenges, particularly complicating inflammation and glaucoma, are discussed. Expected final online publication date for the Annual Review of Vision Science, Volume 8 is September 2022. Please see http://www.annualreviews.org/page/journal/pubdates for revised estimates.

Effects of Calf Blood-Deproteinized Extract Ophthalmic Gel Combined with Sodium Hyaluronate Eye Drops on Conjunctival Hyperemia Score and Tear Film Stability in Patients with Dry Eye

Objective

The aim of this paper is to research the impact of calf blood-deproteinized extract ophthalmic gel combined with sodium hyaluronate eye drops on conjunctival hyperemia score and tear film stability in patients having dry eye.

Methods

144 patients having dry eye disease who were hospitalized from July 2018 to July 2021 were chosen as the research targets, which were composed of the control group and research group on the basis of the sequences of hospitalization, and each has 72 cases. The sodium hyaluronate eye drops were gained in the control one. In accordance with the control one, the study ones were given the combined treatment with eye drops of sodium hyaluronate. Treatment of calf blood-deproteinized extract ophthalmic gel, the scores of conjunctival hyperemia, tear film stability, visual function, curative effect, and their adverse reactions were observed and made comparisons among the two groups.

Results

After the treatments of 2 weeks and later 1 month, the numerical values of the conjunctival hyperemia were fewer in the categories which had been mentioned above, and in contrast with the control one (P < 0.05), the numerical values of the conjunctival hyperemia in the study one were distinctly fewer. The data of SIt, BUT, and the heights of the central tear river of the lower eyelid were higher than those before cure. In comparison with the control one, the FL of the study one was distinctly lower, and the heights of SIt, BUT, and the central tear river of the lower eyelid were obviously better than the control one (P < 0.05). After therapy, the visual contrast sensitivity of the patients in two categories at 6.4 c/d and 12c/d increased in comparison with those before treatment, and the visual contrast sensitivity of the study group at 6.4 c/d and 12c/d was apparently higher than the data of control one (P < 0.05); the effective rate of treatment in the study one was 97.22%, which had a higher situation than the control one, 88.89% (P < 0.05); the probability of occurrence of the negative events in the study one after treatment was 4.17%, which was distinctly below the control one, 15.28% (P < 0.05).

Conclusion

In order for the treatments of patients having dry eye disease, the use of calf blood-deproteinized extract ophthalmic gel having the combinations with eye drops of sodium hyaluronate can enhance the extent of visual impairment and conjunctival hyperemia with effect and improve the stability of tear film, with significant safety and high efficiency.

A Review of the Diagnosis and Treatment of Limbal Stem Cell Deficiency

Limbal stem cell deficiency (LSCD) can cause significant corneal vascularization and scarring and often results in serious visual morbidity. An early and accurate diagnosis can help prevent the same with a timely and appropriate intervention. This review aims to provide an understanding of the different diagnostic tools and presents an algorithmic approach to the management based on a comprehensive clinical examination. Although the diagnosis of LSCD usually relies on the clinical findings, they can be subjective and non-specific. In such cases, using an investigative modality offers an objective method of confirming the diagnosis. Several diagnostic tools have been described in literature, each having its own advantages and limitations. Impression cytology and in vivo confocal microscopy (IVCM) aid in the diagnosis of LSCD by detecting the presence of goblet cells. With immunohistochemistry, impression cytology can help in confirming the corneal or conjunctival source of epithelium. Both IVCM and anterior segment optical coherence tomography can help supplement the diagnosis of LSCD by characterizing the corneal and limbal epithelial changes. Once the diagnosis is established, one of various surgical techniques can be adopted for the treatment of LSCD. These surgeries aim to provide a new source of corneal epithelial stem cells and help in restoring the stability of the ocular surface. The choice of procedure depends on several factors including the involvement of the ocular adnexa, presence of systemic co-morbidities, status of the fellow eye and the comfort level of the surgeon. In LSCD with wet ocular surfaces, autologous and allogeneic limbal stem cell transplantation is preferred in unilateral and bilateral cases, respectively. Another approach in bilateral LSCD with wet ocular surfaces is the use of an autologous stem cell source of a different epithelial lineage, like oral or nasal mucosa. In eyes with bilateral LSCD with significant adnexal issues, a keratoprosthesis is the only viable option. This review provides an overview on the diagnosis and treatment of LSCD, which will help the clinician choose the best option amongst all the therapeutic modalities currently available and gives a clinical perspective on customizing the treatment for each individual case.

Critical media attributes in E-beam sterilization of corneal tissue

When ionizing irradiation interacts with a media, it can form reactive species that can react with the constituents of the system, leading to eradication of bioburden and sterilization of the tissue. Understanding the media's properties such as polarity is important to control and direct those reactive species to perform desired reactions. Using ethanol as a polarity modifier of water, we herein generated a series of media with varying relative polarities for electron beam (E-beam) irradiation of cornea at 25 kGy and studied how the irradiation media's polarity impacts properties of the cornea. After irradiation of corneal tissues, mechanical (tensile strength and modulus, elongation at break, and compression modulus), chemical, optical, structural, degradation, and biological properties of the corneal tissues were evaluated. Our study showed that irradiation in lower relative polarity media improved structural properties of the tissues yet reduced optical transmission; higher relative polarity reduced structural and optical properties of the cornea; and intermediate relative polarity (ethanol concentrations = 20-30% (v/v)) improved the structural properties, without compromising optical characteristics. Regardless of media polarity, irradiation did not negatively impact the biocompatibility of the corneal tissue. Our data shows that the absorbed ethanol can be flushed from the irradiated cornea to levels that are nontoxic to corneal and retinal cells. These findings suggest that the relative polarity of the irradiation media can be tuned to generate sterilized tissues, including corneal grafts, with engineered properties that are required for specific biomedical applications. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Extending the shelf-life of corneal tissue can improve general accessibility of cornea grafts for transplantation. Irradiation of donor corneas with E-beam is an emerging technology to sterilize the corneal tissues and enable their long-term storage at room temperature. Despite recent applications in clinical medicine, little is known about the effect of irradiation and preservation media's characteristics, such as polarity on the properties of irradiated corneas. Here, we have showed that the polarity of the media can be a valuable tool to change and control the properties of the irradiated tissue for transplantation.

Artificial Cornea: Past, Current, and Future Directions

Corneal diseases are a leading cause of blindness with an estimated 10 million patients diagnosed with bilateral corneal blindness worldwide. Corneal transplantation is highly successful in low-risk patients with corneal blindness but often fails those with high-risk indications such as recurrent or chronic inflammatory disorders, history of glaucoma and herpetic infections, and those with neovascularisation of the host bed. Moreover, the need for donor corneas greatly exceeds the supply, especially in disadvantaged countries. Therefore, artificial and bio-mimetic corneas have been investigated for patients with indications that result in keratoplasty failure. Two long-lasting keratoprostheses with different indications, the Boston type-1 keratoprostheses and osteo-odonto-keratoprostheses have been adapted to minimise complications that have arisen over time. However, both utilise either autologous tissue or an allograft cornea to increase biointegration. To step away from the need for donor material, synthetic keratoprostheses with soft skirts have been introduced to increase biointegration between the device and native tissue. The AlphaCor™, a synthetic polymer (PHEMA) hydrogel, addressed certain complications of the previous versions of keratoprostheses but resulted in stromal melting and optic deposition. Efforts are being made towards creating synthetic keratoprostheses that emulate native corneas by the inclusion of biomolecules that support enhanced biointegration of the implant while reducing stromal melting and optic deposition. The field continues to shift towards more advanced bioengineering approaches to form replacement corneas. Certain biomolecules such as collagen are being investigated to create corneal substitutes, which can be used as the basis for bio-inks in 3D corneal bioprinting. Alternatively, decellularised corneas from mammalian sources have shown potential in replicating both the corneal composition and fibril architecture. This review will discuss the limitations of keratoplasty, milestones in the history of artificial corneal development, advancements in current artificial corneas, and future possibilities in this field.

Clinical Aspects of Stevens-Johnson Syndrome/Toxic Epidermal Necrolysis With Severe Ocular Complications in India

Stevens-Johnson syndrome/toxic epidermal necrolysis (SJS/TEN) is a spectrum of rare, severe immunological blistering skin reactions which are triggered by medication intake or infections. The acute phase is characterized by necrolysis of the skin and desquamation of mucosa, primarily oral and ocular, with significant mortality rates. The chronic phase is characterized by multi-organ sequelae with increased rates of morbidity and reduced quality of life for patients who have survived the acute phase. Since the primary goal in the acute phase is saving the life of the patient, ocular involvement is often missed and a significant proportion of patients present to an ophthalmologist with the chronic ocular sequelae. In India, chronic ocular sequelae and low vision are observed in two-thirds of patients who present in the chronic phase of SJS/TEN. In the chronic phase of ocular involvement, there are definite windows of opportunity which if targeted with specific interventions such as scleral lenses and mucous membrane grafts can help reduce the incidence of corneal blindness and improve the quality of life for patients with SJS/TEN. Over the last decade, several studies from India have advanced the understanding of the natural course of ocular involvement in SJS/TEN and the outcomes of timely interventions in the chronic phase of the disease. We present an overview of the epidemiology of ocular complications of SJS/TEN in India, the specific challenges faced in the management of ocular complications in the acute stage and recent advances in management of the chronic ocular complications of the disease.

Surgical Management of Limbal Stem Cell Deficiency

Treatment of limbal stem cell deficiency is challenging. Multiple options can be adopted according to the underlying cause and the patient and physician preferences. Stem cell transplant is a common treatment modality and several techniques have been described with outcomes varying by the laterality of the condition. Keratoprosthesis is a preferred option for bilateral conditions. Indications for type 1 and type 2 keratoprosthesis differ and the past 2 decades have seen a revolution in the field of keratoprosthesis with encouraging and improved outcomes. Management also includes preventive measures and measures to optimize/stabilize the ocular surface that would go a long way in reducing the deterioration of the ocular surface. The aim of this review is to provide an overview of the currently available techniques and to present a comprehensive algorithm to assist in decision making for unilateral and bilateral limbal stem cell deficiency.

Intrinsic Optical Properties of Boston Keratoprosthesis

Purpose

To benchmark the optical performance of Boston Keratoprosthesis (B-KPro).

Methods

Back focal lengths (BFL) of B-KPros for various eye axial lengths were measured using an optical bench, International Organization for Standardization–certified for intraocular lens characterization, and compared against manufacturer's specification. The modulation transfer function (MTF) and the resolution efficiencies were measured. The theoretical geometry-dependent higher-order aberrations (HOA) were calculated. The devices were characterized with optical profilometry for estimating the surface scattering. Aberration correction and subsequent image quality improvement were simulated in CODE-V. Natural scene-imaging was performed in a mock ocular environment. Retrospective analysis of 15 B-KPro recipient eyes were presented to evaluate the possibility of achieving 20/20 best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA).

Results

BFL measurements were in excellent agreement with the manufacturer-reported values (r = 0.999). The MTF specification exceeded what is required for achieving 20/20 visual acuity. Astigmatism and field curvature, correctable in simulations, were the primary aberrations limiting imaging performance. Profilometry of the anterior surface revealed nanoscale roughness (root-mean-square amplitude, 30–50 nm), contributing negligibly to optical scattering. Images of natural scenes obtained with a simulated B-KPro eye demonstrated good central vision, with 10/10 visual acuity (equivalent to 20/20). Full restoration of 20/20 BCVA was obtainable for over 9 years in some patients.

Conclusions

Theoretical and experimental considerations demonstrate that B-KPro has the optical capacity to restore 20/20 BCVA in patients. Further image quality improvement can be anticipated through correction of HOAs.

Translational Relevance

We establish an objective benchmark to characterize the optics of the B-KPro and other keratoprosthesis and propose design changes to allow improved vision in B-KPro patients.

Treatment of Oculoplastic and Ocular Surface Disease in Eyes Implanted with a Type I Boston Keratoprosthesis in Southern China: A Retrospective Study

INTRODUCTION

This study aimed to describe the clinical features, surgical management of the eyelid and ocular surface, and outcomes of 16 patients implanted with a Boston type I keratoprosthesis (KPro).

METHODS

A retrospective, single-center, consecutive case series of 16 patients with Stevens-Johnson syndrome (1), ocular chemical burns (12), and ocular thermal burns (3) implanted with KPro was studied. All subjects were men aged 27-51 years. Surgical treatment and outcomes for eyelid malposition, symblepharon, and glaucoma were assessed.

RESULTS

From September 2010 to February 2019, 29 patients were admitted to Zhongshan Ophthalmic Center for KPro implantation, of whom 16 (55%) required eyelid or ocular surface surgeries to maintain hydration and protect the corneal tissue, which is vulnerable to epithelial defects. Forty-one adnexal surgical procedures were performed. The most common indication for surgery was symblepharon, and the most frequent procedures were symblepharon lysis with ocular mucous membrane grafts and amniotic membranes (7) and full-thickness skin grafts to the eyelids (7). Preoperative conjunctival injection and corneal staining were documented in 9 (56%) and 8 (50%) eyes, respectively, and at up to 4 months postoperative follow-up (the last adnexal surgery before KPro) were recorded in 3 (19%, p = 0.03) and 2 (12%, p = 0.02) eyes, respectively. Glaucoma drainage devices were inserted in six patients. One patient with Stevens-Johnson syndrome underwent FP7 Ahmed glaucoma valve (AGV) implantation inferotemporally and developed plate exposure 2 months postoperatively. Five patients underwent FP8 AGV implantation with tube insertion into the vitreous cavity due to the scarred conjunctiva and limited subconjunctival space. In the study period, intraocular pressure (IOP) was in the normal range, and no tube or plate exposure was observed.

CONCLUSION

The ocular environment is critical for successful KPro surgery. A multidisciplinary approach for any lid and ocular surface abnormality in ocular burns or Stevens-Johnson syndrome is important to improve the quality of the ocular surface and accommodate KPro and AGV, which is vital for maintaining vision after KPro surgery. FP8 AGV may be feasible for IOP control in adult KPro cases with restricted subconjunctival space.

Boston Type 1 Keratoprosthesis: Updated Perspectives

The use of Boston type 1 keratoprosthesis (BKPro) has significantly increased worldwide. It is no longer considered a procedure of last resort but a reasonable option for patients with otherwise poor prognosis for a traditional penetrating keratoplasty. BKPro was approved by the Food and Drug Administration in 1992 for bilateral severe corneal blindness due to multiple corneal transplant failure. Over the years, indications have extended beyond recurrent immunologic rejection to include other conditions such as chemical injury and other causes of bilateral limbal stem cell deficiency, extensive corneal neovascularization, neurotrophic corneas and hypotony, among others. Numerous advances in the design of the BKPro, improvement of preoperative, intraoperative and postoperative management have resulted in favorable outcomes and a reduction in postoperative complications. Accordingly, many studies have shown that implantation of this device is highly effective in restoring vision with very good short-term outcomes. However, due to the lifetime risk of sight-threatening complications after BKPro implantation, a longer follow-up period should provide outcomes that are more realistic. In this review, the authors examined only the results of publications with an average of at least 2 years of follow-up. The overall intermediate to long-term visual outcomes and retention rate in BKPro seem to be favorable. However, autoimmune diseases and cicatrizing conditions continue to show a higher incidence of postoperative complications that require further management.