A Literature Review of Studies Using Qualitative Research to Explore Chronic Neuromuscular Disease

"It doesn't get more normal than that!" - challenges with sexuality experienced by people with neuromuscular diseases and their needs for rehabilitation knowledge and guidance on sexual life

PURPOSE

To investigate challenges with sexuality experienced by people with neuromuscular diseases and their needs for knowledge and guidance on sexual life to target future rehabilitation services.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

11 semi-structured individual interviews with 10 women and one man with neuromuscular diseases. The methodology was Interpretive Description, using the Crip Theory as the theoretical lens to guide the analysis.

RESULTS

The sexual expression of people with neuromuscular diseases was affected by three overall themes. Knowledge and approach in society was characterized by a dichotomous relation of being disabled or nondisabled, causing the nondisabled to consider people with neuromuscular diseases to be asexual even though sexual notions were not affected by the neuromuscular disease. Perceptions and notions represented discovering and unfolding sexuality and how a limited representation of people with disabilities in the public discourse made it difficult to find inspirational role models. Self-confidence and autonomy demonstrated how the personal assistants or partners play significant roles to ensure autonomy of people with neuromuscular diseases.

CONCLUSION

The challenges related to how sexuality of people with neuromuscular diseses was affected by the lack of knowledge and general approach in society which was either silence or misconceived considerations. The healthcare professionals' reluctance toward addressing sexuality should be considered when planning rehabilitation services.

Cross-sectoral collaboration among hospital professionals on rehabilitation for patients with neuromuscular diseases

Introduction: Living with a neuromuscular disease often leads to a need for specialized rehabilitation due to the complexity and progression of the diseases. Aim: To investigate cross-sectoral collaboration on rehabilitation for patients with neuromuscular diseases among hospital professionals to inform future targeted rehabilitation services. Patients & methods: The design was qualitative using the interpretive description methodology and the theoretical lens of symbolic interactionism. Ethnographic fieldwork was conducted, and 50 hospital professionals included, 19 of whom were interviewed. Results & conclusion: The results emphasize the importance of relations when collaborating across sectors. The professionals acted and made choices in relation to dilemmas and influences of diagnosis and progression, professional demarcations in multiprofessional teams, and cross-sectoral collaboration toward a mutual goal.

Singing and Dancing With Neuromuscular Conditions: A Mixed-Methods Study

The purpose of this study was to assess the safety and meaningfulness of a 15-week recreational dance and singing program for people with neuromuscular conditions. Within a transformative mixed-methods design, pulmonary function tests, plethysmography through wearable technology (Hexoskin vests), individualized neuromuscular quality-of-life assessments (version 2.0), and semistructured interviews were used. The interviews were analyzed through inductive, semantic thematic analysis. Although the sample sizes were small (six people with neuromuscular conditions), the authors found no evidence of safety concerns. There was evidence of respiratory improvements and reported improvements in swallowing and speech. The most notable quality-of-life changes included improvements related to weakness, swallowing, relationships, and leisure. The participants shared that the program offered meaningful social connection and embodied skills and safe and pleasurable physical exertion. The authors learned that recreational singing and dancing programs could be a safe and deeply meaningful activity for those with neuromuscular conditions that impact respiration.

Ageing with neuromuscular disease: Implications for a lifeworld-led care through a humanising approach

OBJECTIVES

To understand the care and support needs in ageing with neuromuscular disease from a patient-user perspective.

BACKGROUND

The term neuromuscular disease covers several chronic hereditary or acquired disease subtypes. In the developed countries, advances in symptoms management, technical advancements and rehabilitation initiatives have resulted in increased life expectancy for some subtypes. Life with neuromuscular disease is thus likely to continue into adulthood and old age. However, knowledge of the care and support needs of patients ageing with neuromuscular disease remains sparse.

DESIGN

Adopting a user-participatory approach embedded in a phenomenological hermeneutic tradition, we conducted two user-group discussions focusing on care and support needs in people ageing with neuromuscular disease. Twenty-five users with neuromuscular disease participated in the group discussions. Data were analysed using a three-stepped analysis method inspired by the French Philosopher Paul Ricoeur. In the analysis process, dialectical movements between a surface interpretation and an in-depth understanding occur. The COREQ checklist was used to report the study.

RESULTS

Two themes were identified; 'Changes in the sheltering relationships of life require preparation' and 'Ageing introduces a dichotomy between circumstantial normalcy and minority groupness'. An understanding of care and support needs in life with neuromuscular disease was reached revealing a need for a lifeworld-led approach.

CONCLUSION

Persons ageing with neuromuscular disease crave a fusion of disease- and age-led care and support. This fusion may be achieved through the introduction of a lifeworld-led approach to care and support.

RELEVANCE FOR CLINICAL PRACTICE

Unmet care and support needs in people ageing with neuromuscular disease may result in patients experiencing fear and concern about their life situation. Healthcare professionals may play a crucial role in creating coherent lives for these persons if they understand the approach proposed herein to uncover the care and support needs in people ageing with neuromuscular disease.

Ageing with neuromuscular disease: getting lost in transitions

PURPOSE

To explore the lived experiences of people ageing with neuromuscular disease (NMD).

INTRODUCTION

NMD refers to several chronic types of hereditary and progressive NMDs. Owing to advances in rehabilitation and treatment, life expectancy has increased for some subtypes, resulting in life continuing into adulthood and even old age; however, knowledge of people's lived experiences with NMD is sparse.

METHODS

A qualitative study using a phenomenological-hermeneutic approach inspired by Ricoeur was conducted. Fifteen persons with NMD were interviewed in 2018. The Consolidated Criteria for Reporting Qualitative Research (COREQ) checklist was used.

RESULTS

Four themes were identified: "A time-framed paradox of striving for independent dependency arises as age increases", "Ageing means entering no man's land", "Exercising is caught between shrinking surplus of physical energy and demands of everyday life" and "Ending work life is a jumble of relief, concern and altered self-perception".

CONCLUSION

The pathway to old age with NMD encompasses several transitions, all potentially including the risk of getting lost. Physical changes, changes in legislation, experiences of uncertainty regarding where one socially belongs and how to balance reduced physical strength in everyday life are indicated as key areas that affect ageing life with NMD.Implications for rehabilitationRehabilitation professionals should address ageing with NMD from a life course perspective and not with a singled minded focus on chronological age.A biopsychosocial focus is needed to prevent gaps and pave the pathway to old age with NMD.The experiences of multiple transitions when ageing with NMD should be in focus.

Health Practitioners' Perceptions of Falls and Fall Prevention in Older People: A Metasynthesis

Fall prevention has received a great deal of consideration and funding, however fall rates have not reduced accordingly. Health practitioners are key stakeholders in the process of implementing fall prevention evidence into their clinical assessment and management of older people at risk of falling. Investigating health practitioners' clinical experiences and perceptions has been identified as a means to enhance the translation of knowledge. Four databases were searched for studies exploring health practitioners' perceptions of falls and fall prevention. A metasynthesis of eight qualitative studies was conducted. The findings suggest that health practitioners face substantial barriers in the implementation of fall prevention practices. These include personal, interpersonal, and clinical barriers in addition to limitations of the research evidence. This knowledge hopes to enhance targeted dissemination of knowledge, reducing the research-practice gap and improving clinical outcomes for older people at risk of falls.

It's not just physical: a qualitative study regarding the illness experiences of people with facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy

PURPOSE

Little is known about the illness experiences of people with Facioscapulohumeral Muscular Dystrophy (FSHD). The aim of this study was to provide insight into the illness experiences of people with FSHD in order to tailor rehabilitation programs to individual needs and expectations.

METHODS

Twenty-five semi-structured interviews were conducted with people with FSHD. The interviews were audiotaped, transcribed and member checked. Computerized (MAXqda) and manual techniques were used for thematic data analysis.

RESULTS

Intra- as well as extra-individual aspects play a role in the illness experiences of people with FSHD. Integrating the consequences of the diagnosis and symptoms, coping with heredity and progenity, adjusting to a decreasing independence, and the accompanying changing relationship with one's partner, are mentioned as intra-individual aspects. As extra-individual factors are the responses of the social environment, which was mentioned as well as used assistive devices, and maintaining or giving up work.

CONCLUSIONS

Better understanding of the individual illness experiences, cognitions, and social context of people with FSHD can give health professionals tools to improve their care and give researchers direction for future studies to evaluate healthcare improvements from a holistic, patient-centred perspective. Implications for Rehabilitation FSHD has a major impact on people's lives. Besides the physical consequences, issues such as heredity, progenity, changing (intimate) relationships, social interactions and work should be addressed by rehabilitation professionals. Dependent on the timing of the diagnosis (early or later in life) people with FSHD could, in addition to medical consultation and physical therapy, profit from support by a social worker, occupational therapist and/or genetic Counselor for the above-mentioned themes to be addressed more extensively. It is relevant for rehabilitation professionals to become familiar with the personal characteristics and social circumstances of the patient before communicating the diagnosis and prognosis in order to individually tailor the content of the communication.

Identifying gaps in knowledge: A map of the qualitative literature concerning life with a neurological condition

OBJECTIVES

To describe patterns in the qualitative literature regarding the everyday experience of living with a neurological condition; to identify areas of depth as well as gaps in the existing knowledge base.

METHODS

An extensive search of the literature yielded 474 articles meeting the inclusion criteria. Data extraction, based on scrutiny of both abstract and full text article included country of origin, diagnosis, stated aim, methodological framework/design, participants, and data collection method(s). Studies were categorized into 27 topics within four broad foci.

RESULTS

Four broad foci describe the field: impact and management, daily activities and occupations, impact on family, and the healthcare experience. Overall the research is unevenly distributed by diagnosis; some are well represented while others are the subject of little research. Even diagnoses well represented in quantity can be limited in breadth.

DISCUSSION

Possible explanations for the patterns of emphasis include: a focus on issues and problems, highlighted points of contact between patients and healthcare providers, and ability of participants to voice their views. The literature is also characterized by limited across diagnoses research or that comparing the experience of people with different diagnoses. There is a need for more research in particular diagnoses; more varied data collection methods and acknowledgement of ethnicity, gender, discrimination, and social inequalities.

Dependence on care experienced by people living with Duchenne muscular dystrophy and spinal cord injury

Being dependent on care in a hospital or in a traditional homecare setting may generate an experience of inferiority in patients. In a private home, dependence is easier to bear if the dependent person has the possibility to influence the planning of care. Little is known about the experience of being dependent on care in a private home, where the dependent person employs his or her own helpers. The aim of this study was to describe the meaning of dependence on care in a private home setting among people living with help requirements for all aspects of daily life. The article draws on two interview studies of people with high cervical spinal cord injury and men with Duschenne muscular dystrophy. Transcriptions of the interviews were analyzed according to a phenomenological hermeneutic approach influenced by Paul Ricoeur's philosophy of interpretation. The meaning of all the interview texts is presented as four short stories. Four themes were identified: the helper as liberating, the paramount verbalization of own needs, the creative engagement in life, and accessibility as an issue in everyday life. Dependence on care was identified to be a movement between freedom and restriction, where the helpers played a crucial role, because it was key that they were sensitive to the signals they got and were able to transform words into meticulous actions.