Effect of High-Risk Human Papillomavirus but Normal Cytology at Test of Cure on Achieving Colposcopy Standards

Reporting and Assessing the Quality of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies for Cervical Cancer Screening and Management

Supplemental digital content is available in the text.

Objective

We adapted the Quality Assessment of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies 2 (QUADAS-2) tool for studies of cervical cancer screening and management and used the adapted tool to evaluate the quality of studies included in a systematic review supporting the 2019 Risk-Based Management Consensus Guidelines.

Methods

We evaluated the quality of all studies included in our systematic review for postcolposcopy (n = 5) and posttreatment (n = 23) surveillance using QUADAS-2 criteria. Subsequently, we adapted signaling questions to indications of cervical cancer screening and management. An iterative process was carried out to evaluate interrater agreement between 2 study authors (M.A.C. and N.W.). Discrepant ratings were discussed, and criteria were adapted accordingly. We also evaluated the influence of study quality on risk estimates and between study variation using stratified subgroup meta-analyses.

Results

Twelve signaling questions for bias assessment that were adapted to or newly developed for cervical cancer screening and management are described here. Interrater agreement on bias assessment increased from 70% to 83% during the adaptation process. Detailed assessment of bias and applicability showed that all studies on postcolposcopy management and 90% of studies on posttreatment management had high risk of bias in at least 1 domain. Most commonly, high risk of bias was observed for the patient selection domain, indicating the heterogeneity of study designs and clinical practice in reported studies.

Conclusions

The adapted QUADAS-2 will have broad application for researchers, evidence evaluators, and journals who are interested in designing, conducting, evaluating, and publishing studies for cervical cancer screening and management.

A Systematic Review of Tests for Postcolposcopy and Posttreatment Surveillance

OBJECTIVE

For the 2019 ASCCP Risk-Based Management Consensus Guidelines, we conducted a systematic review of diagnostic assays for postcolposcopy and posttreatment management.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A literature search was conducted to identify articles reporting on tests/assays for cervical cancer screening, triage, postcolposcopy surveillance, and posttreatment surveillance published between 2012 and 2019 in PubMed and Embase. Titles and abstracts were evaluated by co-authors for inclusion. Included articles underwent full-text review, data abstraction, and quality assessment. Pooled absolute pretest and posttest risk estimates were calculated for studies evaluating management of patients after treatment.

RESULTS

A total of 2,862 articles were identified through the search. Of 50 articles on postcolposcopy, 5 were included for data abstraction. Of 66 articles on posttreatment, 23 were included for data abstraction and were summarized in the meta-analysis. The pooled posttreatment risk of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) 2+ in all studies was 4.8% (95% CI = 3.4%-6.8%), ranging from 0.4%-19.5% (τ = 0.57) in individual studies. Among individuals testing negative for human papillomavirus (HPV) posttreatment, the risk of CIN 2+ was 0.69% (95% CI = 0.3%-1.5%); among individuals testing positive for HPV posttreatment, the risk of CIN 2+ was 18.3% (95% CI = 12.1%-26.6%) in all studies. All risk estimates were substantially higher for liquid-based cytology. The HPV-cytology co-testing provided slightly better reassurance compared with HPV alone at the cost of much higher positivity.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite a large number of published studies on postcolposcopy and posttreatment surveillance, only few met criteria for abstraction and were included in the meta-analysis. More high-quality studies are needed to evaluate assays and approaches that can improve management of patients with abnormal screening.

Using technology to harmonise treatment approaches in colposcopy in the face of a changing environment

The overall numbers of precancerous lesions are expected to fall as human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccinated women enter the cervical screening programme. Juxtaposed against an increase in referrals from the introduction of primary high-risk HPV screening, colposcopists expect to see a decreasing incidence of high-grade cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN). Correct identification of lesions will become more challenging, as the prevalence of high-grade lesions becomes minimal and conventional colposcopy is subject to a lower sensitivity. In this review, we explore the scenarios where adjunct technologies could support colposcopists to manage referrals and diagnose treatable lesions with more confidence.

Definitive chemoradiotherapy for cervical cancer: A 11-year population-based study

PURPOSE

To assess the recurrence pattern and survival in women treated with definitive chemoradiotherapy for cervical cancer.

METHODS

A retrospective cohort study of women FIGO (2012) stage IB2 to IVA from the Grampian region of Scotland between February 2000 and March 2011. These women were followed up until April 2018.

RESULTS

A total of 121 eligible women allocated with mean age at treatment 50.59 years (SD = 13.98, range 22-82). Tumours staged: IB2: n = 24 (19.8%), II: n = 45 (37.2%), III: n = 43 (35.5%) and IVA: n = 7 (5.8%). Two (1.7%) women had no available data. Fifty-five (45.5%) women had recurrence after treatment, and 51 (42.15%) women died from the disease. The sites of recurrence were as follows: central pelvic only (n = 4, 7.27%), pelvic and distant (n = 39, 70.91%) and distant only (n = 12, 21.82%) with median time from end of treatment to first recurrence 44 months (range 2-98), 26 months (range 1-146) and 22 months (range 3-66) respectively. 5-and 8-year overall survival was 76.0% (95% CI: 68.8%-84.0%) and 64.4% (95% CI: 56.4%-73.5%) respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Though overall survival is better than with radiotherapy alone, recurrence occurs up to 10 years after treatment. This raises the issues of how to reduce late recurrence and the appropriateness of current follow-up protocols.

An update on the use of immunohistochemistry and molecular pathology in the diagnosis of pre-invasive and malignant lesions in gynecological oncology

OBJECTIVE

One of the most common challenges in everyday clinical practice of gynecological oncology is to identify the type and the primary origin of a tumor. This is a crucial step in the management, treatment, prognosis, and survival of patients suffering from a gynecological malignancy. Immunohistochemistry has been widely adopted over the last three decades in pathology laboratories all over the world. Recent advances in our understanding of the differentiation of gynecological tumors based on immunohistochemical expression have resulted in use of immunohistochemistry as a major diagnostic tool in gynecology, for precise tumor classification. More recently, advances in molecular pathology, have taken this disease sub-classification further resulting in more effective personalised treatment regimens. The aim of this review is to provide clinicians with up to date information on the various immunohistochemical and molecular tests used in the diagnosis of gynecological malignancies of the female genital tract and an understanding of how to interpret them.

METHODS

We performed a review of the current literature including review articles, original research articles, and guidelines on various immunohistochemical markers and molecular techniques which are used for the differential diagnosis of gynecologic malignancies.

CONCLUSIONS

Immunohistochemistry is useful as an objective means for improved diagnostic reproducibility, accuracy, and precise classification in cases where the diagnosis with histochemical stains is inconclusive, providing a more reliable estimate of clinical outcomes. The diagnosis, in some cases, can be further refined by the use of molecular techniques leading to personalised medical treatments.