What Role Should Cytology Play in Cervical Cancer Screening?

Changes over time in papanicolaou cytology test and HPV test in a large women's academic center laboratory

INTRODUCTION

In the past 2 decades, cervical cancer screening guidelines in the United States have undergone numerous revisions with recent greater emphasis on primary high-risk human papillomavirus (hrHPV) testing.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We examine the trends of Papanicolaou test and hrHPV testing at our large academic center across 4 years (2006, 2011, 2016, and 2021) over a 15-year period. The number of ThinPrep Papanicolaou and hrHPV tests, as well as the triggers for HPV testing, were retrospectively analyzed.

RESULTS

A total of 308,355 Papanicolaou tests and 117,477 hrHPV tests were reported across the 4 years. The number of Papanicolaou tests performed decreased nearly 3-fold over the study period, with only 43,230 Papanicolaou tests performed in 2021. The HPV test to Papanicolaou test ratio increased: 17% of Papanicolaou tests had an associated HPV test in 2006, whereas 72% of Papanicolaou tests ordered in 2021 had a companion hrHPV. The use of co-testing also increased. Overall, 73% were co-tests and 27% were reflexively ordered in the 4 one-year time periods. Co-tests constituted only 46% of HPV tests in 2006, but this increased to 93% in 2021. The percentage of positive hrHPV results decreased; in 2006, 18.3% of cases were positive, dropping to 8.6% in 2021 due to the marked increase in co-testing. Stratifying by diagnostic category, hrHPV results have remained relatively constant.

CONCLUSION

With the numerous recent revisions of cervical screening guidelines, screening strategies at our institution reflected these changes in clinical practice. Papanicolaou and HPV co-testing became the most common screening method for women 30 to 65 years of age in our cohort.

HPV detection rates and histopathologic follow-up of patients with HSIL cytology in a large academic women's hospital laboratory

INTRODUCTION

High risk (hr) human papillomavirus (HPV) testing has been proposed as a possible replacement for Papanicolaou (Pap) cytology for cervical screening. The aim of the present study was to assess the hrHPV detection rates using 3 available Food and Drug Administration-approved HPV assays in patients with high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesion (HSIL) cytology results and to correlate the cervical screening test results with the immediate histopathologic findings.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Cases with positive HSIL ThinPrep cytology findings, concurrent hrHPV testing results, and histopathologic follow-up results obtained within 6 months of the Pap/HPV co-testing were identified from July 2010 to April 2018.

RESULTS

A total of 943 HSIL Pap tests were identified with adjunctive hrHPV co-testing, and hrHPV was detected in 883 (93.6%) of these 943 cases. Cervical intraepithelial neoplasia ≥2 (CIN2+) lesions were diagnosed in 71.5% of patients, including 3.2% with invasive squamous cell carcinoma (SCC). In all hrHPV testing platforms, the detection rate for CIN2+ was significantly greater for the patients with positive HPV testing (72.7%) than for those with negative HPV testing (53.4%). However, CIN2+ lesions, including 3 cases of SCC, were found in 24 of 45 women (53.4%) with HSIL Pap and negative HPV testing results.

CONCLUSIONS

The risk of CIN2+ histopathologic findings was significantly greater for patients with hrHPV-positive HSIL results. However, a subset of patients with HPV-negative HSIL results were found to have CIN2+ lesions, including SCC. The long-term effects of primary HPV screening on cervical cancer incidence, stage, and prognosis remain uncertain.