Long-term Symptom-specific Outcomes for Patients With Petrous Apex Cholesterol Granulomas: Surgery Versus Observation

Surgical Approaches to Petrous Apex Cholesterol Granulomas: A Systematic Review and Network Meta-analysis

OBJECTIVE

To compare the outcomes of different surgical approaches to petrous apex cholesterol granulomas (PACG).

DATA SOURCES

PubMed, Embase, Google Scholar, Cochrane, and Web of Science.

REVIEW METHODS

Following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses-Network Meta-analyses guidelines, databases were searched from inception to November 31, 2022. Studies comparing two or more approaches were included. Reviews and population studies were excluded. The main outcome measures were the resolution of symptoms, serviceable hearing, complication, and revision rates.

RESULTS

The search yielded 2132 studies. After applying inclusion and exclusion criteria, 15 studies remained, consisting of 214 patients treated with lateral approaches (n = 182) or anterior endonasal approaches (n = 32). The efficacy of lateral and anterior endonasal approaches in achieving symptom resolution was comparable (73% vs. 68%, p = 0.5). Both exhibited similar rates of complications (33% vs. 37%, p = 0.3), albeit with distinct profiles. Lateral approaches were associated with higher rates of facial palsy and sensorineural hearing loss (44% vs. 18%, p = 0.03). Anterior endonasal approaches demonstrated higher rates of epistaxis and cerebrospinal fluid leak (15% vs. 1%, p = 0.001). Anterior endonasal approaches exhibited lower revision rates (OR: 0.35, 95% CI: 0.14-0.88). The placement of a stent in both approaches was associated with higher symptom resolution (OR: 5.12, 95% CI: 1.05-9.97) and lower revision rates (OR: 0.71, 95% CI: 0.33-0.92).

CONCLUSIONS

Anterior endonasal approaches yield lower revision rates compared to lateral approaches for PACG. Both approaches demonstrate similar effectiveness in symptom resolution and comparable rates of complications, with distinct profiles. Facial nerve and hearing status are important factors that should be addressed when selecting the approach. Stenting is beneficial.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

NA Laryngoscope, 134:1540-1550, 2024.

Quantitative Evaluations of Vestibular Function in Patients With Petrous Apex Cholesterol Granulomas Treated With an Endoscopic Transsphenoidal Approach: A Report of Two Cases

OBJECTIVE

We report two cases of petrous apex cholesterol granuloma (PACG) treated with an endoscopic transsphenoidal approach. Vestibular functions of the two patients were evaluated quantitatively by video Head Impulse Test (vHIT) and/or vestibular evoked myogenic potentials (VEMPs).

PATIENTS

Two patients with PACG who experienced episodes of dizziness are presented.

INTERVENTION

An endoscopic transsphenoidal approach to PACG.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE

The preoperative and postoperative vestibular functions as evaluated by vHIT and VEMP.

RESULTS

Two cases of PACG were treated by a transsphenoidal approach. The internal auditory canal was compressed by the PACG in both cases. The patients both experienced episodes of dizziness before surgery and preoperative vestibular testing including vHIT and VEMP indicated dysfunction of vestibular nerves. After surgery, their symptoms were completely resolved, and the vestibular testing results were improved.

CONCLUSIONS

This article is noteworthy for being the first to publish quantitative vestibular function testing for patients with PACG with vestibular dysfunction. PACG may show various symptoms, with dizziness being one of the most common symptoms. In cases in which the internal auditory canal is compressed by the PACG, vestibular functions should be evaluated by vHIT and VEMP. In the present cases, dizziness was found to be resolved by surgery to release the compression on internal auditory canal. Based on the present cases, the transsphenoidal approach is considered to be both safe and effective.

Typical and Atypical Symptoms of Petrous Apex Cholesterol Granuloma: Association with Radiological Findings

Objective: Petrous apex cholesterol granuloma (PACG) is a lesion that can give rise to different symptoms, and correlations with etiopathology are ambiguous. The aim of this study is to analyze the association between PACG symptoms and radiological findings at presentation, in order to establish a reproduceable pre-operative radiological evaluation and guide the surgical indication. Methods: PACG patients were collected in two tertiary care hospitals. All cases underwent CT/MRI to evaluate the cyst localization and erosion of surrounding structures. Typical and atypical symptoms were then analyzed and compared to radiologic findings established in accordance with the literature. Results: Twenty-nine patients were recruited; the most common symptoms were headache (69%), diplopia (20.7%) and fainting (24.1%), an atypical clinical manifestation related to jugular tubercle involvement. Significant associations between symptoms and radiologic findings were noted in terms of headache and temporal lobe compression (p = 0.04), fainting and jugular tubercle erosion (p < 0.001), vestibular symptoms and internal auditory canal erosion (p = 0.02), facial paresthesia and Meckel’s cave compression (p = 0.03), diplopia and Dorello canal involvement (p = 0.001), and tinnitus and cochlear basal turn erosion (p < 0.001). All patients were treated via an endoscopic−endonasal approach, in which extension was tailored to each case. At a median follow-up of 46 months, 93.1% of patients experienced resolution of symptoms. Conclusions: This clinico-radiological series demonstrates associations between symptoms and anatomical subsites involved with PACG. Hence, it may guide the surgeon at the time of surgical decision, since it asserts that typical and atypical symptoms are actually related to PACG.

Petrous bone lesions: surgical implementation and outcomes of extradural subtemporal approach

BACKGROUND

Petrous bone lesions (PBLs) are rare with few reports in the neurosurgical literature. In this study, the authors describe our current technique of extradural subtemporal approach (ESTA). The objective of this study was to evaluate the role and efficacy of ESTA for treatment of the PBLs. To our knowledge, this is the largest reported clinical series of using an ESTA-treated PBLs in which the clinical outcomes were evaluated.

METHODS

Between 1994 and 2019, 67 patients with PBLs treated by ESTA were retrospectively reviewed. Extent of resection, neurological outcomes, recurrence rate, and surgical complications were evaluated and compared with previous studies. The indications, advantages, limitations, and outcomes of ESTA were analyzed according to pathology.

RESULTS

This series included 7 facial nerve schwannomas (10.4%), 16 cholesterol granulomas (23.9%), 16 chordomas (23.9%), 6 chondrosarcomas (9%), 5 trigeminal schwannomas (7.5%), 9 epidermoids/dermoids (13.4%), and 8 other pathologies (11.9%). The most common location of PBLs operated with ESTA was at the petrous apex and rhomboid areas (68.7%). Gross total resection was achieved in 35 (55.6%). Symptomatic improvement occurred in 56 patients (83.6%). Complications occurred in 7 (10.4%) of cases including one mortality. Nine patients (17%) had recurrence within the mean follow-up 71 months. Compared to previous literature, our results demonstrated comparable outcomes but with higher rates of hearing and facial nerve preservation as well as minimal morbidity. From our results, ESTA is an effective therapeutic option for lesions located at the rhomboid and petrous apex, particularly when patients presented with intact facial and hearing function.

CONCLUSION

Our series demonstrated that ESTA provided satisfactory outcomes with excellent benefits of hearing and facial function preservation for patients with petrous bone lesions. ESTA should be considered as a safe and effective therapeutic option for selected patients with PBLs.

Endoscopic transsphenoidal drainage of a petrous apex cholesterol granuloma using a frontal sinus nasal stent: a case report with long term follow up

BACKGROUND

Cholesterol granulomas of the petrous apex are benign cysts affecting 0.6 patients per 1 million. The pathophysiology involves cholesterol crystals and lipids that are surrounded by giant cells. The cholesterol deposits induce an inflammatory response likely from acute hemorrhage leading to the formation of a fibrous capsule. The capsule expands over time compressing nearby cranial nerves (VI-VIII), which can cause worsening symptoms. Surgical resection has been shown to provide excellent improvement in symptoms. Historically, open approaches such as the infracochlear, infralabyrinthine, and middle fossa have been used. Herein we present a case showing the feasibility and clinical utility of using an endoscopic endonasal transclival approach for treatment of these tumors.

CASE

A 44-year-old female presented with history of intermittent double vision, dizziness, nausea, and headaches for 3 years. She developed a partial left CN6 palsy with significant diplopia and episodes of left facial weakness. The worsening symptoms prompted presentation to the ED where MRI and CT scan revealed a left petrous apex lesion (1.8 × 1.7 cm) with hyperintensity on T1 and T2 imaging, suggestive of cholesterol granuloma. She underwent an endoscopic transclival resection of the lesion: drainage of left petrous apex cholesterol granuloma and stent placement from left petrous apex into sphenoid sinus (novel technique). This was done to allow continued communication and drainage of the tumor bed from the petrous apex into the sphenoid sinus with the intent to minimize the risk of recurrence. At the postop visit both 6th nerve palsy and diplopia had resolved. Imaging is stable 2 years after the surgery.

DISCUSSION

The placement of the stent in this case was done to prevent symptom recurrence. 11% of patients that do not receive a stent will have symptom recurrence within one year. From the historical literature, only 4% of patients who had stent placement developed cyst recurrence or expansion on follow-up imaging. Stent placement has been shown to prevent cyst enlargement within the first few months after surgery. We demonstrate that the endoscopic endonasal transclival approach provided good visualization of the tumor, allowed for an adequate working window for resection, and provided a sufficient approach for stent placement.

Can bone wax cause cholesterol granuloma in the petrous apex? A case report

•

Bone wax, due to its non-resorbable property is known to cause foreign body reaction.

•

Cholesterol granuloma can possibly manifest as a complication of bone wax usage from previous surgeries.

•

Surgical excision of the cholesterol granuloma with removal of its inciting agent is one of the management options.

•

More studies should be conducted with regards to bone wax causing cholesterol granuloma in the petrous apex as this is the first case described in the literature.

•

Surgeons should be aware of this potential complication and use hemostatic agents, in particular bone wax more judiciously.

Background

Cholesterol granuloma (CG) is a rare entity but is the commonest lesion in the petrous apex. They are associated with chronic ear disease and previous temporal bone surgery. While bone wax has been known to cause foreign body reaction due to its non-resorbable property in the mastoid, it has not been documented to cause CG formation.

Case presentation

We described a 43 years old male who presented with a right mastoid swelling, nine years after a right retro-sigmoid craniotomy and excision for a cerebellopontine angle meningioma. He also had multiple cranial neuropathies involving trigeminal, facial and vestibulocochlear nerves. Temporal bone CT and MRI showed features suggestive of cholesterol granuloma with extensive bony erosions. He was treated with surgical excision and drainage where bone wax residues were found intraoperatively. Histopathological analysis of the lesion confirmed the diagnosis of cholesterol granuloma. Post-operatively, the mastoid swelling resolved and his recovery was uneventful.

Conclusion

Our case showed that CG could manifest as a complication of bone wax usage in a neurosurgical procedure. Even though further study is needed to draw a definitive conclusion on this theory, we believe this paper will contribute to the current literature as it is the only reported case of cholesterol granuloma with bone wax as the possible causative agent. This is important so that surgeons are aware of this potential complication and use this haemostatic agent more judiciously.

Indications and endonasal treatment of petrous apex cholesterol granulomas

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Lesions of the petrous apex of the temporal bone can be challenging to access and approaches laterally through the mastoid as well as medially through an endonasal approach are utilized to access this region while preserving function of adjacent structures. Cholesterol granulomas of the petrous apex requiring surgery are marsupialized to prevent expansion of the inflamed cyst and relieve associated clinical symptoms. The endonasal approach to the petrous apex has in the past been limited to lesions medial to the internal carotid artery.

RECENT FINDINGS

Endoscopic approaches have been developed to expand the range of petrous apex lesions that are accessible endonasally. These endonasal corridors include a nasopharyngeal/transclival corridor, lateralization of the internal carotid artery to create an expanded medial window, a pterygopalatine infrapetrosal approach, and a contralateral maxillary approach, which allow improved access to the inferior and lateral petrous apex. Nasoseptal flaps may reduce the risk of postoperative stenosis of the drainage tract.

SUMMARY

Endoscopic endonasal approaches can be used safely to address both medial and lateral/inferior petrous apex lesions. Morbidity of these procedures is low and use of a nasoseptal flap may limit restenosis of the drainage pathway.

Petrous Apex Cholesterol Granulomas: Outcomes, Complications, and Hearing Results From Surgical and Wait-and-Scan Management

OBJECTIVE

1. To analyze the surgical outcomes in the management of petrous apex cholesterol granulomas (PACG) with a brief literature review.2. To evaluate the importance of wait-and-scan management option.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective review.

SETTING

Quaternary referral center for otology and skull base surgery.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

Charts of 55 patients with at least 12 months of follow-up were analyzed for demographic, clinical, audiometric, and radiological features. Patients were divided into surgical group (SG) (n = 31) and wait-and-scan (n = 24) (WS) group. Surgical approach was chosen as per hearing status and PACG extension and relation to nearby neurovascular structures and included either drainage by transmastoid-infralabyrinthine approach (TM-IL)/transcanal-infracochlear approach (TC-IC) or resection by infratemporal fossa type B approach (ITF-B). The combination of ITF-B with trans-otic (TO) approach or TO approach solely was used in unserviceable hearing cases. Postoperative outcomes and complications were evaluated in SG.

RESULTS

Postoperative symptom relief was observed in 24 patients (77.4%). Diplopia and paresthesia recovered in each case and improvement in headache, dizziness, tinnitus, and hearing loss was observed in 87.1% cases. Serviceable hearing was preserved in 24 of 26 cases. Postoperative complication rate was 32.2% including incidences of profound hearing loss, facial nerve paresis, carotid artery injury and intraoperative CSF leaks. Revision surgery was required in 3 (9.6%) cases, after TM-IL approach.

CONCLUSION

Surgical drainage is preferable to more aggressive resection procedures, with the latter reserved for recurrent lesions or lesions with severe hearing loss/involvement of critical neurovascular structures. ITF-B approach provides adequate cyst and neurovascular control for resection, while avoiding brain retraction. An initial wait-and-scan approach can be used in most patients where symptoms and imaging justify so.