Clinical Characteristics and Treatment Outcomes for Patients With External Auditory Canal Cholesteatoma

Risk factors for occurrence and progression of external auditory canal cholesteatoma

OBJECTIVE

External auditory canal cholesteatoma (EACC) is characterized by retained squamous debris within the external canal and variable amounts of localized bone destruction. The etiology of primary EACC remains incompletely understood. This study was conducted to analyze the clinical features and backgrounds of patients with primary EACC and to clarify the risk factors for the occurrence and progression of EACC.

METHODS

Sixty-nine ears of 62 patients diagnosed with primary EACC were included in this study (EACC group). Additionally, 74 ears of 60 patients with chronic otitis media (COM) with perforation who underwent tympanoplasty or myringoplasty were included as controls (COM group). We retrospectively investigated the clinical features, life history, and medical history of the patients in both groups. In addition, to investigate the risk factors for progression of EACC, we compared the clinical features and medical history of patients with stage IV (advanced) disease versus stage I + II (mild) disease.

RESULTS

The inferior wall of the bony canal was the main structure affected in patients with primary EACC of all stages. The following factors were significantly more common in the EACC than COM group: older age, female sex, left-sided disease, osteoporosis, renal dysfunction, anemia, and treatment with bisphosphonates. Among these, the most significant factor associated with EACC was renal dysfunction (odds ratio, 11.4; 95 % confidence interval, 2.32-55.9). The significant factors observed in patients with stage IV disease were younger age, male sex, posterior wall involvement, and otorrhea. Surgical treatment was required for more than half of the patients with stage III and IV EACC.

CONCLUSION

Patients with renal dysfunction are at risk of primary EACC. In particular, younger patients and relatively younger elderly patients with posterior wall involvement have a risk of progression to advanced-stage EACC. Canalplasty should be considered in patients with EACC who have these risk factors to prevent progression to advanced-stage disease.

External Ear Disease: Keratinaceous Lesions of the External Auditory Canal

Keratosis obturans (KO) and external auditory canal cholesteatoma (EACC) are two distinct keratinaceous lesions of the external ear. This article reviews the signs, symptoms, pathophysiology, workup, and treatment of each. Patients with either pathology can often be managed in the clinic with debridement; however, EACC is more likely to involve osteonecrosis and require more extensive operative management if disease is not confined to the canal on account of the bony erosion characteristic of cholesteatoma. If required for extensive disease, surgical approaches to both pathologies are similar.

Coexistence of Primary External Auditory Canal Cholesteatoma and Tympanomastoid Paraganglioma: A Diagnostic Dilemma

Synchronous presentation of cholesteatoma and tympanomastoid paraganglioma is extremely rare. Due to the overlapping clinical features, the clinical diagnosis of coexistence is difficult. Only two cases of tympanomastoid paraganglioma coexisting with middle ear cholesteatoma have been reported in the literature, but simultaneous presentation of primary external auditory canal cholesteatoma and tympanomastoid paraganglioma has not been reported till date. Coexistence of external auditory canal cholesteatoma and paraganglioma is an incidental diagnosis in this current case. The advancement of imaging techniques could help the diagnosis of this very rare clinical coexistence in preoperative assessment.

Primary external auditory canal cholesteatoma of 301 ears: a single-center study

PURPOSE

Limited literature exists on primary external auditory canal (EAC) cholesteatoma (EACC). Here, we focus on the clinical features of this rare disease, especially the invasive patterns of lesion progression, through a large population study and present simple and practical staging.

METHODS

In all, 276 patients (male 99; female 177; mean age 41.3 ± 21 years; ears 301) with primary EACC were retrospectively analyzed. Stage I indicated EACC without bony lesions, stage II indicated invasion confined within EAC, stage III indicated invasion beyond the EAC involving mastoid air cells or tympanic cavity, but within the temporal bone, and stage IV indicated invasion beyond the temporal bone.

RESULTS

In all, 41, 219, 40, and 1 ear with Stage I, II, III, and IV lesions were found, respectively. Common clinical symptoms were hearing loss (237 ears, 78.7%), otalgia (221 ears, 73.4%), and otorrhea (85 ears, 28.2%). The mean air conduction and air-bone gaps were 45.4 ± 17.9 dB HL and 24.6 ± 15 dB HL, respectively. EACCs were found to invade in all directions of the EAC, with the inferior wall (224 ears, 74.4%) > posterior wall (207 ears, 68.8%) > anterior wall (186 ears, 61.8%) > superior wall (86 ears, 28.6%) invasion; multiwall invasions (207 ears) were common; however, inward invasions into the tympanic cavity were rare.

CONCLUSION

Primary EACCs occurred mostly in women and often unilaterally invaded multiple bony walls in the lower half of the EAC. The present staging reflects the patterns and severity of lesion progression and may be beneficial in treatment planning.

Cholesteatoma debridement for primary external auditory canal cholesteatoma with non-extensive bone erosion

Background: External auditory canal (EAC) cholesteatoma (EACC) is rare and its treatment for different lesions has not yet been standardized.Objective: This study aimed to explore the clinical features of EACC with bone erosion, and to assess the curative effect of initial complete cholesteatoma debridement (ICCD).Material and methods: Clinical characteristics and prognosis of 41 ears were analyzed retrospectively.Results: The bone erosion of the EAC was most commonly affected on the posterior wall (37 ears), next by the inferior wall (34 ears), the anterior wall (30 ears) and the superior wall (23 ears). Hearing loss (36 ears) was the most common symptom, followed by otalgia (33 ears), otorrhea (18 ears), tinnitus (11 ears) and pruritus (3 ears). The hearing impairment of mean air conduction and air-bone gaps were improved from 39.2 dB to 22.7 dB, and 23.5 dB to 7.1 dB after the ICCD procedure, respectively. Four ears presented recurrence during the follow-up time and accepted a revision-debridement.Conclusion and significance: The ICCD might be applicable in the treatment of patients in the early stages and with non-extensive bone defect; however, close and long-term surveillance is essential and serial debridement is probable.

Cartilage Fascia Composite Canalplasty for External Auditory Canal Cholesteatoma: Case Analysis and Long-term Surgical Results

OBJECTIVE

To analyze surgical outcomes of cartilage-fascia composite canalplasty (CFCC) for external auditory canal cholesteatoma (EACC).

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective case review study.

SETTING

Tertiary referral center.

PATIENTS

A total of 13 patients with EACC (n = 14 ears due to one patient with bilateral EACC).

INTERVENTION

Surgical method of CFCC using well designed-conchal cartilage and temporalis muscle fascia after complete removal of EACC.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Clinical characteristics and EACC stages were determined by oto-endoscopic examination and computed tomography (CT) findings. The surgical results of CFCC were analyzed.

RESULTS

The median age of patients was 43 years (range, 12-75 yr), with a male to female ratio of 6 to 7. EACC stages were from II to IV. Cortical bone erosion in the inferior part of the bony EAC was the most common finding. All patients had satisfactory results: no more ear symptoms related with cholesteatoma and no need of dressing. Postoperative hearing gain was observed in four patients. No complications or recurrence occurred during the mean follow-up period of 34.4 months.

CONCLUSION

Surgical technique of CFCC was effective for EACC not responding to conservative management.