The Natural History of Hearing Loss in Pendred Syndrome and Non-Syndromic Enlarged Vestibular Aqueduct

Clinical Phenotypic Characterization of the SLC26A4 Mutation in Pendred Syndrome/Nonsyndromic Enlarged Vestibular Aqueduct

OBJECTIVE

To summarize the Solute Carrier Family 26 Member 4 (SLC26A4) mutations and clinical phenotypic characteristics of patients with Pendred syndrome/nonsyndromic enlarged vestibular aqueduct (PS/NSEVA).

DESIGN

A retrospective cohort study for the Chinese population was performed to analyze the hearing test results of 406 patients with PS/NSEVA who had a SLC26A4 mutation and the relationship between inner ear imaging and audiology.

RESULTS

There was a significant difference in the mean hearing threshold in patients with biallelic mutations (M2), monoallelic mutations (M1), and nonallelic mutations (M0) and between patients with isolated vestibular aqueduct enlargement (IEVA) and patients with IEVA combined with Mondini malformation. There was no significant difference between patients with different gene mutation types or different sexes, or between the width of the vestibular aqueduct (VA) and the mean hearing threshold. The degree of hearing loss was linearly correlated with age.

CONCLUSIONS

We propose that the presence and absence of SLC26A4 mutation, whether combined with Mondini malformation and patient age, are essential factors affecting the degree of hearing loss in the Chinese population. However, the number and type of mutations, degree of VA expansion, and sex of the patients did not affect the clinical audiological phenotype.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

3 Laryngoscope, 135:848-856, 2025.

Variability in Inner Ear Morphology Among a Family With Pendred Syndrome Due to a SLC26A4 Gene Variant

OBJECTIVES

Pendred syndrome, an autosomal recessive disorder, is often associated with pathogenic variants of the SLC26A4 gene that encodes the pendrin protein. Given its autosomal recessive inheritance, tracing the family history and screening siblings become crucial once a diagnosis of Pendred syndrome is confirmed. This case report aims to underscore the variability in inner ear morphology within a family diagnosed with Pendred syndrome, all carrying the same SLC26A4 gene mutation.

METHODS

A chart review and a review of the literature.

RESULTS

We present a family of 4, all of whom possess sensorineural hearing loss due to the same homozygous SLC26A4 variant c.919-2A>G. Intriguingly, clinical manifestations, especially inner ear deformities, displayed variability among family members. Notably, 1 family member exhibited a normal cochleovestibular structure morphology, which was rarely reported in the literature.

CONCLUSIONS

This report highlights the significance of genetic testing and familial consultation when a proband exhibits typical Pendred syndrome symptoms. It also underscores that the inner ear morphology can exhibit variability among family members, even with the same homozygous SLC26A4 variant.

The Genetic Background of Hearing Loss in Patients with EVA and Cochlear Malformation

The most frequently observed congenital inner ear malformation is enlarged vestibular aqueduct (EVA). It is often accompanied with incomplete partition type 2 (IP2) of the cochlea and a dilated vestibule, which together constitute Mondini malformation. Pathogenic SLC26A4 variants are considered the major cause of inner ear malformation but the genetics still needs clarification. The aim of this study was to identify the cause of EVA in patients with hearing loss (HL). Genomic DNA was isolated from HL patients with radiologically confirmed bilateral EVA (n = 23) and analyzed by next generation sequencing using a custom HL gene panel encompassing 237 HL-related genes or a clinical exome. The presence and segregation of selected variants and the CEVA haplotype (in the 5' region of SLC26A4) was verified by Sanger sequencing. Minigene assay was used to evaluate the impact of novel synonymous variant on splicing. Genetic testing identified the cause of EVA in 17/23 individuals (74%). Two pathogenic variants in the SLC26A4 gene were identified as the cause of EVA in 8 of them (35%), and a CEVA haplotype was regarded as the cause of EVA in 6 of 7 patients (86%) who carried only one SLC26A4 genetic variant. In two individuals with a phenotype matching branchio-oto-renal (BOR) spectrum disorder, cochlear hypoplasia resulted from EYA1 pathogenic variants. In one patient, a novel variant in CHD7 was detected. Our study shows that SLC26A4, together with the CEVA haplotype, accounts for more than half of EVA cases. Syndromic forms of HL should also be considered in patients with EVA. We conclude that to better understand inner ear development and the pathogenesis of its malformations, there is a need to look for pathogenic variants in noncoding regions of known HL genes or to link them with novel candidate HL genes.

SLC26A4 Phenotypic Variability Influences Intra- and Inter-Familial Diagnosis and Management

SLC26A4 is one of the most common genes causing autosomal recessive non-syndromic sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL). It has been reported to cause Pendred Syndrome (PDS) and DFNB4 which is deafness with enlarged vestibular aqueduct (EVA). However, mutated SLC26A4 is not conclusive for having either DFNB4 or PDS. Three unrelated Jordanian families consisting of eight affected individuals with congenital bilateral hearing loss (HL) participated in this study. Whole-exome and Sanger sequencing were performed to investigate the underlying molecular etiology of HL. Further clinical investigations, including laboratory blood workup for the thyroid gland, CT scan for the temporal bone, and thyroid ultrasound were performed. Three disease-causing variants were identified in SLC26A4 in the three families, two of which were novel. Two families had a novel pathogenic homozygous splice-site accepter variant (c.165-1G>C), while the third family had compound heterozygous pathogenic variants (c.1446G>A; p.Trp482* and c.304G>A; p.Gly102Arg). Our approach helped in redirecting the diagnosis of several affected members of three different families from non-syndromic HL to syndromic HL. Two of the affected individuals had typical PDS, one had DFNB4, while the rest had atypical PDS. Our work emphasized the intra- and inter-familial variability of SLC26A4-related phenotypes. In addition, we highlighted the variable phenotypic impact of SLC26A4 on tailoring a personalized healthcare management.

Cochlear Implantation in Children with Enlarged Vestibular Aqueduct: A Systematic Review of Surgical Implications and Outcomes

OBJECTIVES

This study investigated age at implantation, improvement in hearing and speech perception outcomes, as well as surgical complications in pediatric cochlear implant recipients with Pendred Syndrome (PS) or non-syndromic enlarged vestibular aqueduct (NSEVA).

DESIGN

A systematic review of the literature between 1984 and 2021 was performed. Two independent reviewers performed abstract and full-text screening using the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis guidelines. The inclusion criteria were: English language, cochlear implant, age at implantation available, age <18 years, PS, Mondini malformation, and enlarged vestibular aqueduct. Full-text analysis was completed using the National Institute of Health assessment tool for case series and case-control studies. Studies were also graded according to the Oxford Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine grading system.

RESULTS

In total, 198 studies were identified and screened, and 55 studies were included for analysis. Audiological outcomes were available in 46 studies, and the four-frequency pure-tone audiogram average improved by 60 to 78 dB HL due to cochlear implantation. Auditory performance and speech intelligibility scores increased by 44%. The overall average implantation age was 60 months. The implantation age was 21 months lower in the studies where individuals were implanted after the year 2000 compared with those implanted before the year 2000. Perilymph gusher/oozing was the most common surgical incident reported, occurring in 187 of 1572 implantations.

CONCLUSIONS

In children with PS/NSEVA, cochlear implantation improves pure-tone average by 60 to 78 dB HL and capacity of auditory performance/speech intelligibility by 44%. The implantation age for these children has decreased during the last two decades but is still somewhat higher than reported for unselected pediatric cochlear implantation. Perilymph gusher/oozing is the most common surgical complication.

Enlarged Vestibular Aqueduct: Disease Characterization and Exploration of Potential Prognostic Factors for Cochlear Implantation

OBJECTIVES

There is an unmet need to match the anticipated natural history of hearing loss (HL) in enlarged vestibular aqueduct (EVA) with clinical management strategies. The objectives of this study are therefore to provide a detailed case characterization of an EVA cohort and explore the relationship between candidate prognostic factors and timing of cochlear implant (CI) surgery.

STUDY DESIGN

A multicenter retrospective review of patients diagnosed with EVA.

SETTING

Patient data recruitment across three CI centers in the UK.

PATIENTS

One hundred fifty patients with a radiological diagnosis of EVA from January 1995 to January 2021.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Age at audiological candidacy for CI and age at first implant surgery.

RESULTS

EVA was predominately a bilateral condition (144/ 150) with increased prevalence in women (M:F, 64:86). 51.7% of patients failed new-born hearing screening, with 65.7% having HL diagnosed by 1 year. Initial moderate to severe and severe to profound HL were reported most frequently. In 123 patients, median age that audiological candidacy for CI was met for at least one ear was 2.75 years. Median age at first CI was 5 years (140/150).Pendred syndrome (confirmed in 73 patients) and ethnicity, were not significantly associated with earlier CI surgery. Multivariate linear regression demonstrated that male patients have first CI surgery significantly earlier than females (coefficient -0.43, 95% CI [-0.82, -0.05), p-value = 0.028).

CONCLUSIONS

This large UK EVA cohort provides evidence that patients should be closely monitored for CI candidacy within the first 3 years of life. Significantly, male gender is emerging as an independent prognostic factor for earlier assessment and first CI surgery.

A case of Landau-Kleffner syndrome with SLC26A4-related hearing impairment

Background

Landau-Kleffner syndrome (LKS) is an acquired aphasia and electroencephalogram (EEG) abnormalities mainly in temporoparietal areas. SLC26A4 mutations can cause hearing loss associated with enlarged vestibular aqueduct (EVA).

Case presentations

We report a case of LKS in a 5-year-old boy with non-syndromic EVA due to homozygous mutations of c.919-2A>G (IVS7-2A>G) in SLC26A4. He had normal language development before 2 years old. At the age of 2.5 years, he was admitted to the hospital due to remarkable language delay, and diagnosed with hearing loss with EVA. The seizures started at 4.4 years of age and EEG recording showed electrical status epilepticus during sleep (ESES) with a posterior-temporal predominance. He received cochlear implantation in the right ear at 4.7 years of age, which improved his hearing and language skills. The nocturnal focal motor seizures recurred at 4.9 years of age. Then a remarkable inability to respond to calls and reduction in spontaneous speech were noticed. He was treated with methylprednisolone at 5 years old, which controlled the seizures, suppressed ESES, and remarkably improved the language ability. The absence of seizures maintained until the last follow-up at 5.3 years of age, with further improvements in EEG recording and language ability.

Conclusions

The co-existence of LKS and hearing loss caused by SLC26A4 mutations increases the difficulty of LKS diagnosis, especially in the presence of hearing loss and impaired language skills. EEG discharges predominantly in temporoparietal areas, the occurrence of ESES, and language improvement after antiepileptic medications are potential indicators for LKS diagnosis.

Vestibular Function in Pendred Syndrome: Intact High Frequency VOR and Saccular Hypersensitivity

OBJECTIVE

Although Pendred syndrome involves anatomical abnormalities in the vestibular system and patient-perceived dizziness, the literature on vestibular function is scarce. The objective was to evaluate objective vestibular function in patients with PS using the video head impulse test (VHIT) and the cervical vestibular evoked myogenic potential (cVEMP) test, assessing the high frequency vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR) and the saccular function, respectively.

METHODS

Twenty-six subjects (52 ears) with Pendred Syndrome and severe-to-profound hearing loss (cochlear implant candidacy) were studied retrospectively. Main outcome measures were VHIT VOR gain, refixation saccades, cVEMP stimulus thresholds and amplitudes.

RESULTS

In total, 4 of 52 ears (8%) had pathological VHIT outcomes (2 ears with low VHIT gain and 2 ears with saccades). The mean VHIT gain value was 0.96 (range 0.63-2.02). No patients had complete VOR loss. CVEMP responses were present in 76% of tested ears and absent in 24%. The mean cVEMP amplitude value was 192 μV. Absence of cVEMP response was associated with the presence of VHIT saccades (p = 0.038) and advanced age (rs = -0.34; p < 0.05). cVEMP amplitude was correlated with VHIT gain (rs = 0.46; p < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

Despite dysmorphic vestibular anatomy and severe loss of hearing, the VHIT VOR function is normal in patients with Pendred Syndrome. However, saccular function appears to be abnormally sensitive, as documented by low cVEMP thresholds and high amplitudes, which agrees with a "third window" effect secondary to the large vestibular aqueduct.

Genetic architecture and phenotypic landscape of SLC26A4-related hearing loss

Mutations of coding regions and splice sites of SLC26A4 cause Pendred syndrome and nonsyndromic recessive hearing loss DFNB4. SLC26A4 encodes pendrin, a transmembrane exchanger of anions and bases. The mutant SLC26A4 phenotype is characterized by inner ear malformations, including an enlarged vestibular aqueduct (EVA), incomplete cochlear partition type II and modiolar hypoplasia, progressive and fluctuating hearing loss, and vestibular dysfunction. A thyroid iodine organification defect can lead to multinodular goiter and distinguishes Pendred syndrome from DFNB4. Pendred syndrome and DFNB4 are each inherited as an autosomal recessive trait caused by biallelic mutations of SLC26A4 (M2). However, there are some EVA patients with only one detectable mutant allele (M1) of SLC26A4. In most European-Caucasian M1 patients, there is a haplotype that consists of 12 variants upstream of SLC26A4, called CEVA (Caucasian EVA), which acts as a pathogenic recessive allele in trans to mutations affecting the coding regions or splice sites of SLC26A4. This combination of an M1 genotype with the CEVA haplotype is associated with a less severe phenotype than the M2 genotype. The phenotype in EVA patients with no mutant alleles of SLC26A4 (M0) has a very low recurrence probability and is likely to be caused by other factors.

[Molecular and functional testing in case of hereditary hearing loss associated with the SLC26A4 gene]

Due to development of molecular techniques at hand, the number of genomic sequence variants detected in patient investigations is rising constantly. The number of potentially involved genes in hereditary hearing loss is rising simultaneously.In this overview, current methods for diagnostic workup on a molecular and functional level for variants of the SLC26A4 gene are described. Based on the description of the physiological function of the resulting protein Pendrin, molecular investigations for interpretation of the function are explained. Based on these investigations, the potential clinical consequences of a variant may be predicted more precisely and simplify routine reporting of a proven genotype and a phenotype, at hand. Finally, subsequent clinical investigations necessary, such as perchlorate discharge test, as well as therapeutic options are discussed.

Enlarged vestibular aqueduct and Mondini Malformation: audiological, clinical, radiologic and genetic features

PURPOSE

When referring to enlarged vestibular aqueduct (EVA) we should differentiate between nonsyndromic enlarged vestibular aqueduct (NSEVA) and Pendred Syndrome (PDS), a disease continuum associated with pathogenic sequence variants of Pendrin's Gene (SLC26A4) in about half of the cases. The study was aimed to analyse the clinical and audiological features of a monocentric cohort of Caucasian patients with NSEVA/PDS, their genetic assessment and morphological inner ear features.

METHODS

We retrospectively reviewed the audiologic, genetic and anamnestic data of 66 patients with NSEVA/PDS followed by our audiology service.

RESULTS

SLC26A4 mutations was significantly correlated with the presence of PDS rather than NSEVA (p < 0.019), with the expression of inner ear malformations (p < 0.001) and with different severity of hearing loss (p = 0.001). Furthermore, patients with PDS showed significantly worse pure tone audiometry (PTA) than patients with NSEVA (p = 0.001). Anatomically normal ears presented significantly better PTA than ears associated with Mondini Malformation or isolated EVA (p < 0.001), but no statistically significative differences have been observed in PTA between patients with Mondini Malformation and isolated EVA.

CONCLUSION

NSEVA/PDS must be investigated in all the congenital hearing loss, but also in progressive, late onset, stepwise forms. Even mixed or fluctuating hearing loss may constitute a sign of a NSEVA/PDS pathology. Our findings can confirm the important role of SLC26A4 mutations in determining the phenotype of isolated EVA/PDS, both for the type/degree of the malformation, the hearing impairment and the association with thyroid dysfunction.

Congenital chloride diarrhea and Pendred syndrome: case report of siblings with two rare recessive disorders of SLC26 family genes

BACKGROUND

Congenital chloride diarrhea (CLD; OMIM 214700) is a rare autosomal recessive disorder caused by pathogenic variations in the solute carrier family 26 member A3 (SLC26A3) gene. Without salt substitution, this chronic diarrheal disorder causes severe dehydration and electrolyte disturbances. Homozygous variants in the nearby gene SLC26A4 disrupt anion exchange in the inner ear and the thyroid, causing Pendred syndrome (PDS; OMIM 274600), which is the most frequent form of syndromic deafness.

CASE PRESENTATION

We report an unusual co-occurrence of two rare homozygous mutations in both the SLC26A3 and SLC26A4 genes, causing a rare combination of both CLD and PDS in two siblings. Although the clinical pictures were typical, the combined loss of these anion transporters might modulate the risk of renal injury associated with CLD.

CONCLUSIONS

Familial presentation of two rare autosomal recessive disorders with loss of function of different SLC26 anion transporters is described. Independent homozygous variants in the SLC26A3 and SLC26A4 genes cause CLD and PDS in siblings, shedding light on co-occurrence of rare recessive traits in the progeny of consanguineous couples.

Receptive language acquisition in a pediatric population with Pendred syndrome and non-syndromic enlarged vestibular aqueduct

Background: Children with Pendred syndrome (PS) and non-syndromic enlarged vestibular aqueduct (NSEVA) represent a group of pre-lingual hearing-impaired individuals with rehabilitation challenges.Objective: To evaluate receptive language capabilities in a pediatric cohort with PS and NSEVA.Materials and methods: Twenty-four (24) children diagnosed with either PS or NSEVA, were examined using the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test (PPVT) and compared to a cohort of 55 Danish children with normal hearing, as well as to a mixed group of 29 children with hearing impairment of congenital and hereditary non-syndromal type. In addition, test results were compared to normative data (PPVT-4 US standard scores).Results: PS/NSEVA children's PPVT-4 test scores fall within the normative data for the PPVT-4 (US) but proved to be significantly lower statistically, when compared to Danish children with normal hearing (p<.0001) or to children with mixed non-syndromic hereditary hearing impairment (p=.006). Implantation age was significantly later for the PS/NSEVA group (median = 43 months), compared to the mixed non-syndromic hereditary congenial hearing impairment group (median = 11 months).Conclusions and significance: Children with PS/NSEVA perform below age equivalent for receptive vocabulary outcome when compared to both children with normal hearing, and children with non-syndromic mixed hereditary congenital hearing impairment who receive cochlear implants earlier.