No Evidence for Association Between the Renin-Angiotensin-Aldosterone System and Otosclerosis in a Large Belgian-Dutch Population

Genetic Association of rs1021188 and DNA Methylation Signatures of TNFSF11 in the Risk of Conductive Hearing Loss

Otosclerosis (OTSC) is a complex bone disorder of the otic capsule, which causes conductive hearing impairment in human adults. The dysregulation of the signaling axis mediated by the receptor activator of nuclear factor-kappa-B (RANK), RANK ligand (RANKL), and osteoprotegerin has been widely attributed to the context of metabolic bone disorders. While genetic associations and epigenetic alterations in the TNFSF11 gene (RANKL) have been well-linked to metabolic bone diseases of the skeleton, particularly osteoporosis, they have never been addressed in OTSC. This study aimed to assess whether the genetic association of rs1021188 polymorphism in the upstream of TNFSF11 and the DNA methylation changes in its promoter CpG-region reveal the susceptibility of OTSC. Peripheral blood DNA samples were collected from unrelated Tunisian-North African subjects for genotyping (109 cases and 120 controls) and for DNA methylation analysis (40 cases and 40 controls). The gender-stratified analysis showed that the TNFSF11 rs1021188 C/T was associated with OTSC in men (p = 0.023), but not in women (p = 0.458). Individuals with CC genotype were more susceptible to OTSC, suggesting an increased risk to disease development. Using publicly available data, the rs1021188 was within a cluster grouping the subpopulations with African ethnicity. Moreover, 26 loci in the TNFSF11 gene were in linkage disequilibrium with rs1021188, revealing relative similarities between different populations. Significant differences in both DNA methylation and unmethylation status were detected with 4.53- and 4.83-fold decreases in the global DNA methylation levels in female and male OTSC groups, respectively. These changes could contribute to an increased risk of OTSC development. Bioinformatic analyses indicated that each of the rs1021188 variations and the DNA methylation changes in the promoter CpG-sites within TNFSF11 may play an important role in its transcription regulation. To our knowledge, this is the first study that investigates an independent effect of the rs1021188 polymorphism and DNA hypomethylation of TNFSF11 promoter in OTSC. Genetic and epigenetic changes in the regulatory regions of TNFSF11 could offer new molecular insights into the understanding of the complexity of OTSC.

Genetics of otosclerosis: finally catching up with other complex traits?

Otosclerosis is a relatively common cause of hearing impairment, characterized by abnormal bone remodeling of the middle and inner ear. In about 50-60% of the patients, the disease is present in a familial form. In most of these families, otosclerosis seems to be caused by a small number of genetic factors (oligogenic) while only in a small number of families the disease seems to be truly monogenic. In the remaining patients a complex genetic form of otosclerosis is present. Several studies have aimed to identify the genetic factors underlying otosclerosis, which has led to the identification of eight published loci for monogenic otosclerosis, as well as several genes and one chromosomal region (11q13.1) with a clear association with otosclerosis. Implementation of next-generation sequencing (NGS) in otosclerosis research has led to the identification of pathogenic variants in MEPE, ACAN and SERPINF1, although the pathogenic role of the latter is under debate. In addition, a recent GWAS can be considered a breakthrough for otosclerosis as it identified several strong associations with otosclerosis and suggested new potential candidate genes. These recent findings are important for unraveling the genetic architecture of otosclerosis. More future studies will help to understand the complete pathogenesis of the disease.

Evidence of distinct RELN and TGFB1 genetic associations in familial and non-familial otosclerosis in a British population

Otosclerosis is a common form of hearing loss which typically presents in young adults. The disease has a familial, monogenic form and a non-familial form with a more complex aetiology. A previous genome wide association study identified evidence that variants within RELN are associated with the condition. Other genes in which an association has been reported include BMP2, COL1A1, FGF2, PPP2R5B and TGFB1. However, follow up studies have often failed to replicate initial positive results. The aim of this study was to establish if an association exists between eight single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in these six previously implicated genes and otosclerosis in a British case–control cohort (n = 748). Evidence of an association between rs1800472 in TGFB1 and otosclerosis was found (p = 0.034), this association was strongest amongst non-familial cases (p = 0.011). No evidence of an association was detected with variants in COL1A1, FGF2, BMP2, and PPP2R5B. No association between variation in RELN and otosclerosis was observed in the whole cohort. However, a significant association (p = 0.0057) was detected between one RELN SNP (rs39399) and otosclerosis in familial patients. Additionally, we identify expression of one RELN transcript in 51 of 81 human stapes tested, clarifying previous conflicting data as to whether RELN is expressed in the affected tissue. Our findings strengthen the association of TGFB1 (rs1800472) with otosclerosis and support a relationship between RELN and familial otosclerosis only, which may explain previous variable replications.

Genetic association analysis in a clinically and histologically confirmed otosclerosis population confirms association with the TGFB1 gene but suggests an association of the RELN gene with a clinically indistinguishable otosclerosis-like phenotype

BACKGROUND/HYPOTHESIS

Otosclerosis is a frequent cause of hearing impairment characterized by abnormal resorption and deposition of bone in the human otic capsule. It is a disease of complex etiopathogenesis that is caused by both environmental and genetic factors. The goal of this study is to replicate association for genes that were previously reported to be associated with otosclerosis. However, in this study, patients were used in which the presence of otosclerotic foci was confirmed by histologic investigation, in contrast to previous studies, that did not use histologic confirmation.

METHODS

Case-control association study using 153 cases and 300 controls. Thirteen single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in 6 genes (COL1A1, TGFB1, BMP2, BMP4, AGT, and RELN) were genotyped.

RESULTS

An association between TGFB1 (rs1800472) and otosclerosis was detected, confirming several previous reports. It is surprising that no association was found between RELN and otosclerosis because the current analysis had very reasonable power and the RELN association has been published before in different articles using several independent populations.

CONCLUSION

Our findings strengthen the association of TGFB1 (rs1800472) with otosclerosis. The fact that other genes did not replicate could be due to different reasons like lack of power (BMP2 and BMP4) and possible false-positive initial association (COL1A1 and AGT). A plausible explanation for the lack of association for RELN is that RELN could be associated with a specific otosclerosis-like phenotype that is different from the histologically confirmed phenotype of the patients in this study, and that is clinically not distinguishable.

Rare variants in BMP2 and BMP4 found in otosclerosis patients reduce Smad signaling

HYPOTHESIS

Genetic variation in BMP2 and BMP4 found in otosclerosis patients result in altered Smad signaling.

BACKGROUND

Otosclerosis is a common form of adult-onset conductive hearing loss resulting from abnormal bone remodeling of the bony labyrinth that surrounds the inner ear. Both genetic and environmental factors are implicated in the disease, yet very little is known about its pathogenesis. The evidence for a genetic component has been established through family-based linkage and population-based association studies. Previously, members of the TGF-β superfamily of genes have been associated with otosclerosis.

METHODS

Sequencing of BMP2 and BMP4 coding regions was performed to identify common and rare variation in German otosclerosis patients compared with controls. Functional analyses of rare variation in the patient cohort were conducted by exposing an osteosarcoma cell line to conditioned media containing either wild type or variant forms of BMP2 or BMP4 and analyzing Smad1/5/8 phosphorylation.

RESULTS

Although no significant association with common variation in these 2 genes was detected, there were 8 singleton variants identified in the German population. Of the 4 coding variants found solely in otosclerosis patients, two--BMP4(N150K) and BMP2(K357-R396del)--were found to decrease Smad1/5/8 signaling.

CONCLUSION

Rare variants in BMP2 and BMP4 are not a major genetic component in the otosclerosis population. However, those with functional affect showed decreased Smad signaling. Further analysis of Smad signaling molecules should be performed to determine if these pathways in combination are a major contributor to otosclerosis, which could lead to additional treatment options for otosclerosis patients.

No evidence for the expression of renin-angiotensin-aldosterone system in otosclerotic stapes footplates

INTRODUCTION

Recent studies have reported genetic associations between with single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) of the several genes of the renin-angiotensin-aldosterone (RAA) system in otosclerosis without the confirmation of RAA system expression in human stapes footplates. There are conflicting results. These results are conflicting because RAA system expression has been attributed exclusively to neural, vascular, and renal tissues, exclusively.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Ankylotic stapes footplates (n = 20), cortical bone fragments (n = 10), and human kidney tissue specimens (n = 10) were processed to hematoxylin-eosin (HE) staining and RAA system-specific immunofluorescent assay (IFA), respectively.

RESULTS

Histologic diagnosis of otosclerosis was established in all ankylotic stapes footplates. Histologically active- (n = 13) and inactive (n = 7) foci of otosclerosis were consequently characterized by negative immunoreactions for renin, angiotensin converting enzyme (ACE), angiotensin-II (AT-II), and angiotensin-II receptor (AT-IIR), consequently. In cortical bones, a considerable RAA system expression was observed confirmed in the perivascular bone marrow progenitor cells. Kidney specimens, applied as positive controls, showed intense RAA system-specific immunoreactions.

CONCLUSION

Concerning current observations, the 4 studied members of RAA system that did not display active expression were not expressed at protein level in otosclerotic stapes footplates. This phenomenon was independent from the histologic activity of otosclerosis. Between these conditions, the etiologic role of RAA system is questionable in the pathogenesis of otosclerosis.

COL1A1 association and otosclerosis: a meta-analysis

Otosclerosis is a disease of abnormal bone remodeling in the human otic capsule that can lead to progressive hearing loss. Little of the underlying disease etiology has been elucidated thus far, although several studies have suggested that COL1A1 may play a role based on its importance in bone metabolism and other diseases like osteoporosis and osteogenesis imperfecta. Genetic association studies between COL1A1 and otosclerosis, however, have been contradictory. To resolve this issue, we studied a large Belgian-Dutch and a Swiss population for a genetic association between COL1A1 and otosclerosis and additionally performed a meta-analysis to investigate the overall genetic effect of COL1A1 on all otosclerosis populations studied to date. We found a significant association both in the Belgian-Dutch population and in the meta-analysis. In aggregate, our analysis supports evidence for an association between COL1A1 and otosclerosis although effect sizes of the variants reported in the initial studies are likely to be an overestimate of true effect sizes.

The etiology of otosclerosis: a combination of genes and environment

Otosclerosis is a common form of hearing loss characterized by abnormal bone remodeling in the otic capsule. It is a complex genetic disease, caused by a combination of genetic and environmental factors. During the past decade, several attempts have been made to identify factors for otosclerosis. This review provides an overview of the current understanding of the etiology of otosclerosis and describes the genetic and environmental factors that have been implicated in the disease. Environmental factors include fluoride and viral factors, particularly measles. Genetic association studies for otosclerosis have reported several associations of genetic variants that influence the risk of disease, mainly involving bone remodeling pathways, although their individual risk contributions are small. Rare monogenic forms of otosclerosis also exist, which are caused by a mutation in a single gene leading to a clear familial segregation of the disease. Linkage analysis of large otosclerosis families has led to the identification of seven loci, and recently evidence was found that T cell receptor beta is a gene responsible for familial otosclerosis, suggesting an underlying immunological pathway. However, this might also represent an autoimmune process, a hypothesis that is supported by other data as well. In conclusion, a variety of pathways have been identified to be involved in the development of otosclerosis, showing that distinct mechanisms involving both genetic and environmental risk factors can influence and contribute to a similar disease outcome.

Involvement of T-cell receptor-beta alterations in the development of otosclerosis linked to OTSC2

Otosclerosis is a common form of hearing loss, characterized by disordered bone remodeling in the otic capsule. Within the otosclerotic foci, several immunocompetent cells and immune-modulating factors can be found. Different etiological theories involving the immune system have been suggested. However, a genetic component is clearly present. In large otosclerosis families, seven autosomal-dominant loci have been found, but none of the disease-causing genes has been identified. This study focused on the exploration of the second otosclerosis locus on chromosome 7q34-36 (OTSC2), holding the T-cell receptor beta locus (TRB locus). A significantly lower T-cell receptor-beta (TCR-beta) mRNA expression and percentage of blood circulating TCR-alphabeta(+) T cells was detected in OTSC2 patients compared with controls and patients with the complex form of the disease. Further analysis illustrated more significant disturbances in specific T-cell subsets, including an increased CD28(null) cell population, suggesting a disturbed T-cell development and ageing in OTSC2 patients. These disturbances could be associated with otosclerotic bone remodeling, given the known effects of immunocompetent cells on bone physiology. These data implicate the TRB locus as the causative gene in the OTSC2 region and represent an important finding in the elucidation of the disease pathology.