Injectable calcium sulfate vs mixed bone graft of autologous iliac bone and allogeneic bone: Which is the better bone graft material for unicameral bone cyst in humerus?

Percutaneous calcium sulfate injection versus localized scrape bone grafting: clinical effect comparison in titanium elastic nail treatment of pathological fracture of proximal humerus caused by unicameral bone cysts in children

Objective

A retrospective study was conducted to compare the mid-term clinical efficacy between percutaneous calcium sulfate injection (PCSI) and localized scrape bone grafting (LSBG) in using titanium elastic nails treat humerus pathologic fractures caused by unicameral bone cysts in children.

Methods

Humerus pathologic fracture patients with unicameral bone cysts in our pediatric orthopedic department from January 2015 to January 2020 were retrospectively analyzed. Patients were divided into two groups, namely the PCSI group and the LSBG group, based on the type of bone grafting material they received. Preoperative assessments were made in both groups using the Cyst Index and Cyst activity. During the perioperative phase, assessments were made regarding operative time, bleeding, postoperative VAS scores, and the frequency of reoperation within 2 years. Clinical outcomes were evaluated using the Capanna scale at the last follow-up, and the occurrence of re-fractures during the follow-up period.

Results

A total of 22 patients were included, with a mean follow-up duration of 33.5 ± 5.8 months. No significant differences were found between the two groups in terms of Cyst Index and Cyst activity before the operation. The operative time, bleeding, and postoperative VAS scores in the PCSI group were found to be lower than those in the LSBG group (P < 0.05). The PCSI group also showed a higher frequency of reoperation within 2 years compared to the LSBG group (P < 0.05). However, no significant differences were observed between the two groups in terms of Capanna scale scores at the last follow-up and the incidence of re-fractures during follow-up.

Conclusions

Both titanium elastic nails (TEN) combined with PCSI or LSBG were found to be safe and effective treatments for humerus pathologic fractures caused by unicameral bone cysts in children. PCSI is considered as a less invasive option with shorter operative times, less bleeding, and reduced postoperative pain, although it comes with the risk of multiple injections. On the other hand, LSBG is considered as a more invasive option for the treatment of active bone cysts but is associated with a lower recurrence rate.

Treatment and Outcomes of 4,973 Unicameral Bone Cysts: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

» Unicameral bone cysts (UBCs) can increase the risk of pathologic fractures of both long and short bones. Although multiple treatments exist, data are conflicting regarding optimal management.

» We sought to analyze treatment strategies for UBCs and their rates of successful treatment.

» Success rates were analyzed according to treatment modality, with emphasis on filling techniques and/or decompression associated with curettage, and injection compounds.

» Curettage with bone substitute and cyst decompression was identified as a highly successful technique for UBC treatment.

» Decompressing the cyst wall after injection, regardless of the specific compound used, had a greater potential to enhance healing rates.

» The management decision should be individually guided within the patient's context.

Management of juvenile and aneurysmal bone cysts: a systematic literature review with meta-analysis

PURPOSE

Numerous approaches to the management of juvenile and aneurysmal bone cysts (ABC) are described in the specialist literature together with discussion of the associated healing and recurrence rates. Since there is currently no evidence-based treatment standard for these conditions, the aim of this systematic literature review with meta-analysis was to examine the different management approaches, evaluate the corresponding clinical outcomes and, as appropriate, to formulate a valid treatment recommendation.

METHODS

A systematic search on OVID Medline^® based on a pre-existing search strategy returned 1333 publications. Having defined inclusion and exclusion criteria and analysis of the relevant full texts, 167 publications were included in the descriptive analysis and 163 in the meta-analysis. For this purpose, different subgroups were created, based on the type of cyst and the therapeutic procedure. Those subgroups were then analysed in relation to their healing rates, the number of recurrences and complication rates.

RESULTS

For aneurysmal bone cysts, both surgical removal and Doxycycline injection lead to excellent outcomes (98% healing) and low recurrence rates (6% and 11% resp.). Curettage (91% healing), including its combination with autologous cancellous bone graft (96% healing), showed very good healing rates but higher recurrence rates (22% and 15%, resp.), which were however improved by preoperative selective arterial embolization. A critical view must be taken of radiotherapy (90% healing) and the injection of alcohol (92% healing) because of their high complication rates (0.43/cyst and 0.42/cyst, resp.). In the management of juvenile bone cysts, surgical interventions like curettage and cancellous bone graft (87% healing) are far superior to non-surgical approaches (51% healing), furthermore, the application of autologous cancellous bone graft reduced the recurrence rate (3% recurrence) compared to curettage alone (20% recurrence). In subgroup analysis, treatment by ESIN was found to produce excellent outcomes (100% healing), though the patient collectives were small.

CONCLUSION

Surgical procedures to treat aneurysmal bone cysts appear to be the method of choice whereby Doxycycline injection may be an alternative. A surgical approach should be preferred in the treatment of juvenile bone cysts.

Stabilisation of Pathologic Proximal Femoral Fracture near the Growth Plate with Use of a Locking Plate and Transphyseal Screws

Aneurysmal bone cyst (ABC) is a benign osseus lesion with a high pathologic fracture risk. The described treatment options are varied and inconsistent. For successful treatment results, it is essential to prevent recurrence and sufficiently stabilise the weakened bone. Lesions close to the growth plates, especially in the femoral neck region, are challenging to stabilise in children. In this study, 27 clinics, including 11 sarcoma centres, 15 paediatric orthopaedic clinics, and one sarcoma/paediatric orthopaedic centre, were surveyed and asked about their treatment approaches for an exemplary case of ABC in the femoral neck causing a pathological fracture in a 20-month-old infant, with a response rate of 81%. The heterogeneity of treatment options described in the literature is consistent with the survey results. The most favoured approach was curettage, defect filling of any kind, and surgical stabilisation. However, the lesion stabilisation option introduced in this paper, which involves the use of transphyseal screws, was not mentioned in the survey and has not been reported in the literature. Contrary to the existing concepts, our technique offers high stability without significant growth restriction. Transphyseal screws are also suitable for the treatment of femoral neck fractures of other aetiologies in children.

Is elastic stable intramedullary nail a good choice for pathological fractures of the proximal femur due to simple bone cyst in pediatric population?

Pathological fracture of the proximal femur represents a challenging situation for orthopedic surgeons because of the high risk of non-union, varus union, and avascular necrosis (AVN) of the femoral head. This study aims to investigate the efficacy of ESINs for the treatment of proximal femoral fractures caused by simple bone cysts (SBCs).All the patients with a diagnosis of proximal femoral fracture secondary to SBC treated with ESINs combined with bone grafting between January 2008 and January 2018, were analyzed retrospectively.In all, 11 patients were included in the Double ESINs group (5.1 ± 0.8 years, 5 male, 6 female) and 27 patients were included in the Triple ESINs group (9.1 ± 2.1 years, 11 male, 16 female). There was no significant difference between the 2 groups concerning the patients demographic parameters, including sex and affected side. However, the age in the Double group was significantly younger than those in the Triple group (P < .001). All patients in both groups displayed excellent outcomes according to the Musculoskeletal Tumor Society Score (MSTS), and there was no significant difference between the 2 groups at a 12-month follow-up evaluation (P = .10). As for the Capanna classification (1 + 2), there was no significant difference between these 2 groups (P = .24). In the Triple ESINs group, 24 (88.9%) patients were categorized in Capanna 1 and 2, whereas all patients in Double ESINs were Capanna 1 and 2. Overall, the success rate was 92%.ESINs combined with bone grafting is a successful strategy for proximal femoral fractures caused by SBCs in the pediatric population.