Cosmetic thyroid surgery: defining the essential principles

Evaluation of public's perception of scar cosmesis after thyroidectomy: results of a survey of Turkish versus South Korean individuals

Purpose

Visible scars on the neck caused by thyroid surgery give rise to significant aesthetic, functional, and psychosocial problems. The objective of this study is to comparatively investigate the public perception of neck scar cosmesis in Turkish and South Korean populations.

Methods

This survey was prepared to collect participants' demographic and socioeconomic data and determine their perception of scar cosmesis on the neck and consisted of 15 questions. One thousand thirty-nine individuals who did not undergo thyroid surgery completed the survey. The P-values of <0.05 were deemed to indicate statistical significance.

Results

There were 1,039 respondents, of whom 525 (50.5%) were Turkish and 514 (49.5%) were South Korean. South Korean respondents stated that they would be significantly more uncomfortable with the thought of having a scar due to thyroid surgery, compared to the Turkish respondents (P < 0.001). The South Korean respondents stated that they would be significantly more concerned about the scar's length, thickness, and darkening color, compared to the Turkish respondents (P < 0.001 for all cases).

Conclusion

Patients' expectations, which are affected by various sociodemographic factors and cultural characteristics, are as important as the medical condition when deciding on the type of thyroid surgery. The study findings clearly indicated that the South Korean population would be significantly more uncomfortable with having a scar on the neck, compared to the Turkish population. Therefore, in selected cases, a scarless thyroidectomy approach, such as transoral endoscopic thyroidectomy, vestibular approach may be preferable for societies like South Korea.

Minimally invasive thyroid and parathyroid surgery: modifications for low-resource environments

Minimally invasive thyroidectomy (MIT) and parathyroidectomy (MIP) are gaining popularity in the current surgical practice. The need for specific equipment and technology is an obstacle in the low-resource environment. This article provides simple and practical guidance for surgeons practicing in low-resource environments to help them attain quality surgical practice, maintain patient safety, preserve available resources, and achieve the best outcomes.

[Minimally invasive carotid artery surgery]

OBJECTIVE

To determine the criteria for choosing a surgical approach and compare an effectiveness of carotid endarterectomy (CEAE) via 3 approaches.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

The study included 120 patients who underwent CEAE via 3 different approaches. Intraoperative skin marking included lower jaw angle, skin fold closest to common carotid artery bifurcation. Carotid artery bifurcation and borders of atherosclerotic plaque were visualized using ultrasound. An effectiveness of each access was evaluated in accordance with the following criteria: neurological complications, cosmetic effect and quality of life after 1 and 12 months. The patients were divided into 2 groups. Group I - 80 patients with CEAE with access through the natural skin fold (NSF); group II - 40 patients with CEAE using the classical longitudinal access. The 1st group was divided into 2 subgroups. Subgroup I A - 39 patients with CEAE using mini-access via NSF; subgroup I B - 41 patients with CEAE using extended access via NSF.

RESULTS

There were no strokes and transient ischemic attacks in a month after surgery in both groups. After 12 months, stroke occurred in 2 (%) patients of group II, cranial neuropathy - 8 (21%) patients in the same group. The best cosmic effect was achieved in subgroup I A after 1 and 12 months (37.1±6.7 scores). Mean score of physical health was 51.59±5.9 scores in subgroup I A, 46.03±7.53 scores - in subgroup I B, 38.84±5.28 scores - in group II. Index of mental health was 49.63±6.69, 45.68±5.6, and 48.59±7.29 scores, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Considering these data, we developed a personalized computer program ensuring fast choice of optimal surgical approach.

Cervical scar satisfaction post conventional thyroidectomy

Background

Thyroidectomy is a commonly performed procedure with large centres performing thousands of thyroid surgeries per year. The traditional Kocher mid-cervical incision has been the standard approach to thyroidectomy since the late 1870s with predictable results. The introduction of minimally invasive and remote access techniques seeks to reduce the morbidity of a mid-cervical scar incision.

Methods

Ninety-five [95] patients who underwent this approach over the thirty [30] months period from January 2015 to July 2017 were administered the validated Patient Scar Assessment Questionnaire and the collected data analysed.

Results

Forty-eight [48] patients, (50.5%) met inclusion criteria and provided responses with a mean time since surgery of 18.9 months. There is a high level of satisfaction with 91.7% of patients in the study having scores consistent with scar satisfaction after conventional thyroidectomy. While patients were satisfied with the appearance of their scars, a majority of patients (n=28, 58.3%) were at least slightly conscious of their incisions, with more than 10% of patients (n=5) reporting significant levels of self-consciousness. Patients of Mixed race were found to have slightly elevated scores on PSAQ compared with IndoTrinidadian and AfroTrinidadian races (P=0.002 and P=0.006).

Conclusions

Most patients were satisfied with their scar results in the years after thyroidectomy. Despite the high level of satisfaction, a majority of patients are self-conscious about the presence of a mid-cervical incision. Further research is needed to elucidate causes and the effects of this finding.

Aesthetics in Thyroid Surgery: The Patient Perspective

Objectives

To define characteristics that influence patient perceptions of thyroidectomy scar cosmesis.

Study Design

Prospective cohort study.

Setting

Tertiary endocrine surgery practice in an academic medical center.

Subjects and Methods

Institutional review board–approved trial in which 136 subjects were recruited from a population of patients being seen for either thyroid or sinus surgery and evaluated standardized photographs, superimposed with computer-generated thyroidectomy scars of varying lengths (2, 4, and 6 cm) and widths (1 and 2 mm), and graded their perception of the scars using the observer scar assessment scale (OSAS) domains of the patient and observer scar assessment scale.

Results

There were 69 subjects in the thyroid group and 67 in the nonthyroid group. Controlling for width, longer scars were perceived as worse than shorter scars; controlling for length, thicker scars were perceived as worse than thinner scars ( P < .01). Beyond 2 cm, thick scars were judged to be worse than thin scars, even when they were shorter. There was no difference in the mean overall OSAS scores between surgery, sex, or age groups. Nonwhites tended to judge scars as being worse than whites did ( P < .01).

Conclusion

As expected, patients of all demographics prefer shorter scars compared with longer scars and thinner scars over thick scars. Ethnic differences in scar perception were identified and deserve additional study. Surgeons should endeavor to perform thyroid surgery through the smallest incision that allows the operation to be performed safely to minimize the cosmetic impact of the operation.

Midcervical scar satisfaction in thyroidectomy patients

OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS

Assess long-term patient satisfaction with conventional thyroidectomy scars and the impact of thyroidectomy scars on patient quality of life.

STUDY DESIGN

Validated survey administration and retrospective review of clinical and demographic data.

METHODS

Patients who underwent conventional thyroidectomy through years 2000 to 2010 were identified and administered the validated Patient Scar Assessment Questionnaire. Mean satisfaction, appearance and scar-consciousness scores were determined. Thirty-seven patients also measured the length of their current scar. Patient demographic and operative data were collected retrospectively from the medical record. Data were analyzed with one-way analysis of variance and independent samples t testing.

RESULTS

Sixty of 69 patients perceived the appearance of their scar to be "good" or "excellent." Sixty-three patients (91.3%) were satisfied with all scar outcomes; 67 (97.1%) were satisfied with the overall appearance of their scar. Mean total satisfaction score was 17.3 (<26 indicates a high level of satisfaction). Fifty-six (81.2%) were "not at all" self-conscious of their scar; 65 (94.2%) reported no attempt to hide their scar. Seven patients (10.1%) indicated any likelihood of pursuing scar revision. Females had significantly higher total satisfaction scores, consciousness scores, and satisfaction with appearance scores. The effect of perceived scar length was significant for scar-consciousness, not patient satisfaction.

CONCLUSIONS

The majority of patients were satisfied with their thyroidectomy scar appearance. Few patients reported a desire to hide the scar or pursue revision. Women were more likely to be dissatisfied than men. Length may play a role in scar consciousness.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

4 Laryngoscope, 127:1247-1252, 2017.

What Can Determine the Length of an Open Nonendoscopic Thyroidectomy Incision?

Objectives  Surgeons are now utilizing small incisions when performing thyroidectomy. This study evaluated the association between patient weight, nodule size, and maximum thyroid diameter and the length of an open thyroidectomy incision. Study Design  Retrospective analysis of 32 consecutive patients. Subjects and Methods  Patient demographics, clinical exam, ultrasound findings, operative findings, and pathology were recorded. Results  Of the 32 patients (81% women), 27 underwent a hemithyroidectomy. The mean patient weight was 194 lbs. The mean clinical nodule diameter was 3.46 cm, and the mean maximum thyroid diameter was 5.91 cm. The mean incision size was 5.13 cm. Independently, patient weight, maximum thyroid diameter, and maximum nodule diameter were shown in regression models to be statistically significant predictors of incision size. In stepwise regression analysis that included all three listed variables, maximum thyroid diameter was the most significant predictor of incision size ( p  < 0.0001). Conclusions  Surgeons may determine the length of the incision using clinical and radiologic parameters, but most probably use their subconscious clinical judgment and the challenge of utilizing a very small incision for this operation. This study has shown that maximum thyroid diameter is the most significant determinant for the incision but that nodule size and patient weight are also significant factors. This study is evidence-based medicine level III.

Six-Year Experience With Endoscopic Thyroidectomy: Outcomes and Safety Profile

BACKGROUND

Though minimally invasive video-assisted thyroidectomy (MIVAT) offers many advantages over traditional thyroid surgery, its adoption in North America has been limited. This study analyzes the largest series of MIVAT in North America to explore its safety.

METHODS

A prospectively maintained database of all patients undergoing thyroid surgery by a single surgeon from 2003 to 2011 at an academic tertiary care medical center was evaluated. Demographic information, surgical and pathologic data, and postoperative outcomes were analyzed.

RESULTS

Beginning in 2005, a total of 260 MIVATs were performed during the study period. Outpatient surgery was accomplished in 234 MIVATs (90%). MIVAT patients were predominantly young (46.8±14.8 years vs 52.4±14.6 years for conventional thyroidectomy) and female (88.5% vs 75.5% for conventional thyroidectomy). There were no cases of permanent hypoparathyroidism or permanent recurrent laryngeal nerve dysfunction. Observed complications included transient recurrent laryngeal nerve dysfunction (n=10; 3.8%), cellulitis (n=1; 0.4%), and temporary hypocalcemia (n=6; 2.3%). The overall complication rate for MIVAT (6.5%) was lower than the overall complication rate in conventional thyroidectomy (18.5%, P<.0001).

CONCLUSION

MIVAT can be performed safely with a low complication profile in a high-volume practice. The safety of MIVAT represented by this experience supports broader adoption across surgical practices.

Incision Planning in Thyroid Compartment Surgery: Getting it Perfect

OBJECTIVE

This study evaluated changes in thyroid compartment incision site locations with patient positioning to define a reliable method for placing the scar in the optimal vertical location.

METHODS

The optimal incision location was marked with the patient sitting upright before surgery. The distance from the sternal notch to this mark was measured with the patient in the upright, supine, and final surgical positions.

RESULTS

Complete data were available for 104 procedures. The mean distances from the sternal notch to the incision site were 4.8, 21.5, and 31.9 mm in the sitting, supine, and surgical positions, respectively. Each of these distances were significantly different from one another (P<.0001) and were independent of patient age, sex, body mass index (BMI), or height.

CONCLUSIONS

Cutaneous cervical landmarks migrate significantly during patient positioning. Marking the thyroid compartment incision site while the patient is in an upright position results in a more predictable final scar location.

Stretch of the Minimally Invasive Incision during Thyroid and Parathyroid Surgery

Objective

Identify and quantify changes in length of the skin incision following minimally invasive thyroid and parathyroid surgery and determine whether these changes persist postoperatively.

Study Design

Cohort study.

Setting

Tertiary care teaching hospital.

Subjects and Methods

Between July 2012 and June 2013, a prospective, nonrandomized study was performed on 44 consecutive patients undergoing open cervical minimally invasive thyroidectomy (incision approximately 6 cm or less) or minimally invasive parathyroidectomy (incision approximately 3 cm or less). Incision length was measured following initial incision, immediately after wound closure, and on postoperative follow-up at 2-week and 14-week visits.

Results

Thirty-one patients underwent minimally invasive thyroidectomy or parathyroidectomy with initial incision lengths ranging from 20 mm to 60 mm. Seven patients (21%) underwent total thyroidectomy with a mean length of 45 ± 8 mm, 15 patients (44%) underwent unilateral thyroid lobectomy with a mean length of 37 ± 5 mm, and 9 patients (26%) underwent parathyroidectomy with a mean length of 28 ± 2 mm. On average, the skin incision lengthened by 3.0 ± 0.9 mm during surgery representing an intraoperative stretch of 8.0% ( P < .0001). Incision lengths decreased by an average of 0.3 mm at 2-week postoperative follow-up ( ns) and 6.3 mm at 14-week postoperative follow-up ( P < .0001).

Conclusion

Significant intraoperative incision stretch is likely to occur during minimally invasive thyroid and parathyroid surgery. Postoperative follow-up data suggest that the increase in incision length is not permanent and resolves upon postoperative follow-up.

Contemporary surgical techniques

Recent technologic advances have engendered alternative and innovative approaches to thyroid surgery aimed at reducing cosmetic sequelae. Minimally invasive techniques via small anterior cervical incisions hidden in natural skin creases and remote access approaches that eliminate anterior neck incisions entirely have emerged as viable options for patients who regard cosmesis as a priority. The safe application of these techniques to both benign and malignant thyroid disease has been evaluated.

Alternative approaches to the thyroid gland

Advances in surgical technology and patient-driven demands have fueled exploration into methods to improve cosmetic outcomes in thyroid surgery. This exploration has produced 2 fundamentally different pathways for reducing the visible thyroidectomy scar. Minimally invasive anterior cervical approaches use small incisions hidden in natural skin creases and reduce the overall extent of dissection required to remove the thyroid. Remote access approaches remove the incision from the anterior neck completely but require more extensive dissection to access the thyroid compartment.

Comparative study of a gasless transaxillary approach versus a bilateral axillo-breast approach for endoscopic thyroidectomy in a single institute

BACKGROUND

Gasless transaxillary approach (TA) and the bilateral axillo-breast approach (BABA) are 2 distinctive approaches for endoscopic thyroidectomy. The purpose of this study was to evaluate and compare these 2 procedures.

METHODS

From May 2008 to July 2011, we performed endoscopic hemithyroidectomy via gasless TA (83 cases) and BABA (45 cases). The following variables were evaluated: operation time, postoperative pain score, drainage amount, drainage day, postoperative complications, and cosmetic satisfaction score.

RESULTS

There were no significant differences between the 2 approaches in terms of clinicopathologic characteristics and surgical outcomes, except for postoperative pain and cosmetic satisfaction. As for postoperative pain and cosmetic satisfaction, the gasless TA group complained of less pain and the BABA group had a better cosmetic outcome.

CONCLUSION

These findings will contribute to providing guidelines for the choice of surgeons between gasless TA and BABA techniques for endoscopic thyroidectomy.

Single-port endoscopic thyroidectomy via a submental approach: report of an initial experience

BACKGROUND

Based on our experience of trans-areola single-site endoscopic thyroidectomy and a preclinical study in the porcine model, we attempted to develop a new approach called trans-submental single-port endoscopic thyroidectomy (TSSPET).

METHODS

Two female patients (43 and 27 years old, respectively) were selected for TSSPET. Both were preoperatively diagnosed with benign thyroid nodule by ultrasonography and fine-needle aspiration cytology (FNAC). Two mini-incisions were made in the submental area. The isthmectomy was performed for 1 patient and a right lobectomy for the other.

RESULTS

This procedure was successfully accomplished in 2 cases. The operative time was 108 minutes and 150 minutes, respectively. No complications occurred. Postoperative hospital stay was 2 days. After 3 months, cosmetic result was satisfactory.

CONCLUSION

Our initial experience demonstrates that the TSSPET is feasible and safe for selected patients. Nevertheless, large series and comparative studies could be necessary to further confirm its effectiveness.

New endoscopic thyroidectomy via a unilateral axillo-breast approach with gas insufflation: Preliminary report

BACKGROUND

Invasiveness of endoscopic thyroidectomy has been in debate. The purpose of this study was to introduce new endoscopic thyroidectomy via a unilateral axillo-breast approach (UABA) with gas insufflation to lessen invasiveness.

METHODS

We performed 68 cases of hemithyroidectomy via a UABA with gas insufflation from January to July 2011. The following variables were studied: operation time, pain score, drainage amount, drainage day, perioperative complications, pathological outcomes, and cosmetic satisfaction.

RESULTS

Mean postoperative pain visual analogue scale (VAS) scores were 2.75 ± 0.93 and 2.07 ± 0.79 at 1 and 3 days after surgery. The mean amount of drainage over the first 3 postoperative days was 144.35 ± 51.64 mL, and the mean time to drain removal was 3.75 ± 0.81 days. Two cases (2.9%) of transient vocal cord palsy and 2 cases (2.9%) of seroma were identified. All patients were satisfied with the cosmetic results.

CONCLUSION

Endoscopic thyroidectomy via a UABA with gas insufflation is a feasible and less invasive option for selected patients.

Modifications of Miccoli minimally invasive thyroidectomy for the low-volume surgeon

OBJECTIVE

The objective of the study was to describe our experience with modifications of the Miccoli minimally invasive thyroidectomy.

DESIGN

Planned analysis of a prospectively maintained database was undertaken after Institutional Review Board approval.

METHODS

Demographic and surgical data were obtained and analyzed with attention to age, sex, pathology, incision lengths, and complications.

RESULTS

From a single-surgeon series of 785 consecutive thyroidectomies, 178 patients were identified who underwent an endoscopic minimally invasive thyroidectomy. A series of modifications of the classic Miccoli technique evolved over a period of 4 years and include presurgical factors (patient marking in holding area, intubation with laryngeal EMG tube using videolaryngoscope, rotation of operating table away from anesthesia), intraoperative principles (use of operative loupes, slave monitor, laryngeal nerve monitoring, and novel instrumentation; identification of the medial cleft and ligation of superior pedicle bundle using ultrasonic technology; avoidance of clips), and postoperative techniques (deep extubation, laryngeal endoscopy, outpatient management, and oral calcium supplementation).

CONCLUSIONS

A minimally invasive endoscopic thyroidectomy is possible even in a practice with moderate surgical volumes by using several techniques that facilitate the performance of this procedure. A high success rate and low complication rate can be achieved, resulting in improved patient satisfaction.

The minimally-invasive thyroidectomy incision: a histological analysis

BACKGROUND

Minimally invasive thyroidectomy (MIT) has gained popularity in the surgical management of benign and malignant pathology of the thyroid. One of the main benefits of utilizing this technique is the use of smaller incisions resulting in increased cosmetic satisfaction. Unfortunately, the retraction required for adequate exposure during MIT may lead to skin damage, impaired wound healing and poor cosmetic outcomes. Some have proposed that excising incision edges prior to closure may improve cosmesis. A review of the literature does not reveal any histologic evidence to support this technique.

MATERIAL/METHODS

In this prospective observational study, nine subjects undergoing MIT were identified. Both the superior and inferior skin edges were excised and labeled for orientation. Specimens were sent for hematoxylin and eosin staining and histologic analysis by a staff pathologist.

RESULTS

All specimens showed no significant findings such as damage to the architecture of the dermis, acute inflammation, edema or evidence of hemorrhage. Focal blood vessel ectasia within the dermis was identified in three of nine subjects.

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings do not yield a histological basis supporting the routine trimming of incisions during MIT. Although no significant findings were noted histologically, further studies are warranted to investigate the long-term cosmetic outcome of MIT incisions.

Minimal access surgery - thyroid and parathyroid

The concept of surgical invasiveness cannot be limited to the length or to the site of the skin incision. It must be extended to all structures dissected during the procedure. Therefore, MIT or MIP should properly be defined as operations through a short and discrete incision that permits direct access to the thyroid or parathyroid gland, resulting in a focused dissection.Parathyroid glands are particularly suitable for minimally invasive surgery as most parathyroid tumors are small and benign. MIP are performed through a limited or discrete incision when compared to classic open transverse cervical incision and are targeted on one specific parathyroid gland. The concept of these limited explorations is based on the fact that 85% of patients will have single-gland disease. MIP must be proposed only for patients with sporadic hyperparathyroidism in whom a single adenoma has been clearly localized by preoperative imaging studies.The minimal access approaches to the thyroid gland may be broadly classified into three groups: the mini-open lateral approach via a small incision, minimally invasive video-assisted thyroidectomy via the midline and various endoscopic techniques. Endoscopic extracervical approaches have the main advantage of leaving no scar in the neck but cannot reasonably be described as minimally invasive as they require more dissection than conventional open surgery.Initially the indications for MIT were a solitary thyroid nodule of less than 3 cm in diameter in an otherwise normal gland. Today, MIT are also proposed in patients with small nodular goiters, Graves's diseases and low risk papillary thyroid cancers. Some concern remains about the radicality of MIT in this latter group but preliminary results are comparable to those of conventional surgery both in terms of I-131 uptake and serum thyroglobuline levels.Demonstrating the advantages of MIT and MIP over conventional surgery is not easy. Main complications, such as nerve injury, hypoparathyroidism, or hemorrhage, are the same as in conventional surgery. Several studies comparing conventional surgery with minimally invasive techniques using a cervical access have shown a diminution of postoperative pain, and better cosmetic results with minimally invasive techniques. MIP and MIT seem overall to be an advance but only randomized studies will demonstrate the real benefit.

Flapless conventional thyroidectomy: a prospective, randomized study

PURPOSE

Conventional thyroid surgery is one of the most common operations performed worldwide. The conventional technique involves placement of small or large cutaneous flaps. However, the published data regarding flap use for thyroidectomy are contradictory. This study presents the results using a flapless conventional thyroidectomy and the efficacy of this approach in a thyroidectomy. In addition, the study determined whether there are any advantages associated with the use of this approach in comparison to conventional thyroid surgery.

METHODS

One hundred and forty-two patients underwent a thyroidectomy. The patients were randomly assigned to surgical procedures. Patients in Group 1 (n = 70) underwent a conventional thyroidectomy, and patients in Group 2 (n = 70) underwent a conventional thyroidectomy without a cutaneous flap.

RESULTS

There was no significant difference between the two groups in terms of age, sex, body mass index, length of incision, gland volume, and length of hospital stay. Postoperative pain was significantly less in Group 2 than in Group 1 (P = 0.006). Patients in Group 2 showed significantly lower requirement for postoperative intravenous analgesic (P = 0.001), and postoperative peroral analgesic (P = 0.023) in comparison to those in Group 1. Incidences of transient vocal cord paralysis and hypocalcemia were 1.4% and 1.4%, respectively. Of 140 patients, 5 (3.6%) developed postoperative wound complications.

CONCLUSIONS

These results indicate that a flapless thyroidectomy is safe and technically feasible, and therefore could be an alternative to a conventional thyroidectomy.

Extracervical approaches to endoscopic thyroid surgery

There is increasing demand for surgical procedures which avoid visible scars while maintaining optimal functional and ideal cosmetic results, without compromising the safety or effectiveness of the procedure. Endoscopic techniques have been adapted to abdominal and pelvic surgery and increasingly employed over the past three decades. Although hampered by the absence of a natural cavity, endoscopic techniques have been adapted to surgery in the neck for the past 15 years, particularly for the thyroid gland. While earlier attempts at endoscopic thyroid surgery were performed through incisions in or near the midline of the neck, recent techniques have been developed to place the incisions and endoscopic ports extracervically, or at least away from the midline region of the neck, rendering the cosmetic result more acceptable. Most of these approaches are through the axilla, breast, chest wall or a combination of approaches. Visualization of the thyroid and rate of complications with these approaches are equal to those attained with older endoscopic approaches. Careful patient selection is important for endoscopic surgery. Complications unique to the endoscopic approach are mostly related to insufflation of cervical tissues with pressurized CO(2).

Randomized trial of tissue adhesive vs staples in thyroidectomy integrating patient satisfaction and Manchester score

Objective: Closure of skin incision of minimally invasive thyroidectomy with tissue adhesive is compared with surgical staples for 1) cosmetic appearance, 2) patient pain score, and 3) patient satisfaction score.

Study Design: Prospective single-blinded randomized study.

Subjects and Methods: Seventy-two patients undergoing minimally invasive thyroid surgery using video-assisted thyroidectomy (VAT) and minimal incision thyroidectomy (MIT) techniques were randomized for skin closure into two groups, one using staples and the other using tissue adhesive. Patients evaluated their pain on the first and tenth postoperative days. Scars were assessed using the Manchester scar assessment tool, and patients completed a satisfaction assessment form.

Results: Sixty out of the 72 patients were followed up for three months postoperatively. Assessment of wound cosmesis revealed no statistical difference; however, there was a statistical difference in ability to shower and overall satisfaction in the tissue adhesive group ( P = 0.017).

Conclusion: Tissue adhesive is an excellent alternative for skin incision closure, having the added advantage of ability to shower on the same day, avoidance of the anxiety associated with staple removal, and no General Practitioner (GP) visit required for wound care. The use of tissue adhesive achieves higher patient satisfaction levels and enhances the perception of minimally invasive thyroid surgery (MITS) techniques among patients and surgeons alike.

Minimally invasive thyroid surgery for single nodules: an evidence-based review of the lateral mini-incision technique

BACKGROUND

Minimally invasive thyroidectomy techniques are being developed in an effort to minimize pain, shorten the length of hospital stay, and improve cosmesis. Various minimally invasive thyroid surgery (MITS) techniques have been shown to be safe and feasible with some benefits in terms of cosmesis and pain outcomes; however, no single technique has been broadly accepted. This study was designed to review the evidence in relation to MITS and our experience with the direct lateral mini-incision technique.

METHODS

A review of literature published until December 2007 on minimally invasive thyroidectomy techniques was undertaken. Three issues were addressed: 1) Does MITS provide any benefit compared with conventional open thyroidectomy? 2) Is there any advantage to the use of endoscopic or video-assisted techniques compared with the direct mini-incision technique? 3) Is the lateral mini-incision technique safe and efficacious? Additional data in relation to the above issues was derived from a retrospective cohort study of patients undergoing mini-incision thyroid surgery within our unit.

RESULTS

Issue 1: Five prospective randomized studies and eight studies at a lower level of evidence have demonstrated consistent advantages of MITS compared with open thyroid surgery in terms of reduced pain and improved cosmesis with equivalent operative safety. Issue 2: In compiling four level III and IV studies that compared open and video-assisted minimally invasive surgery, there do not seem to be significant differences in patient satisfaction with the incision. The video-assisted approaches require significantly longer operative times but also seem to be less painful. Issue 3: Three cohort studies (level IV) have demonstrated that the lateral mini-incision technique is both safe and efficacious compared with open surgery for hemi-thyroidectomy. Data from our cohort study of 1281 patients (open hemi-thyroidectomy 1054 vs. MITS 227) confirmed MITS to be a safe and effective procedure. The rate of postoperative hematoma formation and wound infection was equivalent between groups. The rate of permanent recurrent laryngeal nerve injury was 0.4% for MITS and 0.3% for CHT and not significantly different (p = 0.7).

CONCLUSIONS

MITS has demonstrated advantages over conventional open approaches for both hemi- and total thyroidectomy and the benefits do not depend on the open or video-assisted approach. For thyroid lobectomies, the lateral mini-incision approach can be performed with an operative time and postoperative complication profile equivalent to conventional hemi-thyroidectomy while providing excellent cosmesis with a 2-3 cm scar.

Minimally invasive video-assisted thyroidectomy for benign thyroid disease: an evidence-based review

BACKGROUND

A decade after nearly all surgical disciplines developed minimally invasive techniques, the first report of a single case of minimally invasive thyroidectomy was published. Minimally invasive video-assisted thyroidectomy (MIVAT) is now considered the most widely practiced and most easily reproducible minimally invasive procedure for thyroidectomy. The aim of this review was to analyze the treatment of benign thyroid diseases by MIVAT.

METHODS

A systematic evidence-based literature review focusing on three questions was carried out. Additional data were obtained on the basis of our personal experience. (1) Are minimally invasive procedures indicated in the treatment of thyroid diseases? (2) Is MIVAT a safe technique and what are the demonstrated advantages? (3) Since different thyroid diseases may be treated by MIVAT, is it of any value in the treatment of benign thyroid diseases?

RESULTS

MIVAT can be considered an appropriate treatment of some thyroid diseases; it represents a safe procedure with the same incidence of complications as traditional surgery, and also has advantages in terms of both cosmetic result and postoperative distress.

CONCLUSIONS

In spite of an increasing trend toward performing more extensive procedures other than thyroidectomy alone during videoscopic procedures, the current literature seems to reaffirm that the main and safest indication for MIVAT is benign disease.