Comparison of bone SPECT/CT and MRI in detection of pain generator in ankle and foot pain: a retrospective diagnostic study

Emerging role of bone scintigraphy single-photon emission computed tomography/computed tomography in foot pain management

Foot and ankle joints being weight-bearing joints are commonly subjected to wear and tear and are prone to traumatic and other pathologies. Most of these foot and ankle pathologies present with pain. The diagnosis of pathology and localization of pain generators is difficult owing to the complex anatomy of the foot and similar clinical presentation. This makes the management of foot pain clinically challenging. Conventional anatomical imaging modalities are commonly employed for evaluation of any anatomical defect; however, these modalities often fail to describe the functional significance of the anatomical lesions, especially in presence of multiple lesions which is common in ankle and foot; however, hybrid single-photon emission computed tomography/computed tomography (SPECT/CT) by virtue of its dual modalities, that is, highly sensitive functional imaging and highly specific anatomical imaging can serve as a problem-solving tool in patient management. This review attempts to describe the role of hybrid SPECT/CT in overcoming the limitation of conventional imaging and describes its potential application in the management of foot and ankle pain.

[Radiological-nuclear medicine hybrid diagnostics with SPECT/CT for chronic foot and ankle diseases : A new and important diagnostic tool]

BACKGROUND AND AIM

In contrast to standard methods (sonography, X‑ray, CT (computed tomography), MRI (magnetic resonance imaging), numerous diseases of the foot or ankle can be diagnosed using SPECT/CT (single photon emission computed tomography/computed tomography) with regard to their clinical relevance with high accuracy (up to > 90%). The aim of this review is to provide an up-to-date overview of the importance of SPECT/CT in selected diseases of the foot and ankle.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A literature search was carried out in the Pubmed database using the following terms: SPECT/CT, SPECT, skeletal scintigraphy, CT, computed tomography, foot and ankle disease, OSG, tarsal root, foot pain. The publications were selected with regard to questions and diagnoses that frequently occur in foot and ankle diagnostics. Furthermore, papers that describe a more precise diagnosis, a change in therapy management or a reduction in symptoms due to the use of SPECT/CT were selected.

RESULTS

Several studies have shown that a focally increased bone metabolism in osteoarthritis and osteochondral lesions correlates significantly with the development of pain. The presence of symptomatic ossicles such as the os naviculare accessorium type II and os trigonum can be clearly demonstrated with the help of SPECT/CT and cannot be assigned as the source of the symptoms as accurately with any other imaging method. Bony reactions in the area of coalitions, arthrodesis, osteosynthesis, occult fractures, prostheses and diabetic foot cannot be detected with comparable accuracy using any other imaging method, so that therapy concepts in unclear cases, based only on standard imaging are changed in up to 2/3 of cases by SPECT/CT information.

DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION

SPECT/CT is useful when there are clinical uncertainties despite standard imaging.

Review of the role of bone-SPECT/CT in tarsal coalitions

Tarsal coalition (TC) is a congenital abnormal connection (fibrous, cartilaginous, or osseous) between two or more bones in the hind and midfoot, mostly consisting of calcaneonavicular or talocalcaneal coalition, and is often asymptomatic. However, TCs may result in foot motion limitation and pain with or without flatfoot (pes planus), arising in adolescents and young adults. Appropriate imaging is needed to pinpoint foot pain in the (suspected) TC, starting with plain radiographs. Still, normal radiographs do not exclude TCs. Computed tomography (CT) and MRI are frequently used advanced imaging techniques. CT alone has known limited sensitivity in cartilaginous and fibrous TCs and correlation between CT abnormalities and pain may be challenging, as solely anatomical changes in TCs are often asymptomatic. MRI can depict soft tissue abnormalities in TC with high accuracy. Nonetheless, after the implantation of metallic osteosynthesis material, MRI is often limited due to image distortion, signal loss, and misregistration. Bone scintigraphy with [99mTc]Tc-diphosphonate single photon emission computed tomography/CT (bone-SPECT/CT) is a known sensitive tool to detect osteoblastic bone pathology. However, the literature concerning bone-SPECT/CT in TC patients is limited. This article reviews bone-SPECT/CT patterns in TCs, how it complements other imaging techniques and their relation to clinical complaints. Bone-SPECT/CT excels in accurate bone pathology characterization in TC, confidently excluding synchronous lesions elsewhere, and offering optimal insight into osseous structures and 3D-localization of bone metabolism for surgery planning. Furthermore, even with implanted osteosynthesis material, bone-SPECT/CT can pinpoint the culprit pain generator, where MRI is either contra-indicated or considerably hampered.