Testicular-sparing surgery in the pediatric population: multicenter review of practice with review of the literature

Clinical characteristics and long-term management of prepubertal testicular teratomas: a retrospective, multicenter study

Prepubertal testicular teratomas are rare tumors with limited practical guidance for their management. This study aimed to analyze a large multicenter database to establish the optimal management of testicular teratomas. We retrospectively collected data on testicular teratomas in children younger than 12 years who underwent surgery without postoperative chemotherapy in three large professional children's institutions in China between 2007 and 2021. The biological behavior and long-term outcomes of testicular teratomas were analyzed. In total, 487 children (with 393 mature teratomas and 94 immature teratomas) were included. Among mature teratomas, 375 cases were testis-sparing, 18 were orchiectomies, 346 were operated through the scrotal approach, and 47 underwent the inguinal approach. The median follow-up period was 70 months, and no recurrence or testicular atrophy was observed. Among the children with immature teratomas, 54 underwent testis-sparing surgery, 40 underwent orchiectomy, 43 were operated through the scrotal approach, and 51 were operated through the inguinal approach. Two cases of immature teratomas with cryptorchidism had local recurrence or metastasis within 1 year of the operation. The median follow-up duration was 76 months. No other patients had recurrence, metastasis, or testicular atrophy.  Conclusion: Testicular-sparing surgery is the first treatment choice for prepubertal testicular teratomas, with the scrotal approach being a safe and well-tolerated strategy for these diseases. Additionally, patients with immature teratomas and cryptorchidism may have tumor recurrence or metastasis after surgery. Therefore, these patients should be closely followed up in the first year after surgery. What is Known: • There is a fundamental difference between testicular tumours in childhood and those in adulthood - not only in terms of the difference and incidence but also in terms of histology. • For surgical techniques, the inguinal approach is recommended for the treatment of testicular teratomas in children. What is New: • The scrotal approach being a safe and well-tolerated strategy for testicular teratomas in children. • Patients with immature teratomas and cryptorchidism may have tumor recurrence or metastasis after surgery. These patients should be closely followed up in the first year after surgery.

Imaging of Pediatric Testicular and Para-Testicular Tumors: A Pictural Review

Pre- and post-pubertal testicular tumors are two distinct entities in terms of epidemiology, diagnosis and treatment. Most pre-pubertal tumors are benign; the most frequent are teratomas, and the most common malignant tumors are yolk-sac tumors. Post-pubertal tumors are similar to those found in adults and are more likely to be malignant. Imaging plays a pivotal role in the diagnosis, staging and follow-up. The appearance on ultrasonography (US) is especially helpful to differentiate benign lesions that could be candidates for testis-sparing surgery from malignant ones that require radical orchidectomy. Some specific imaging patterns are described for benign lesions: epidermoid cysts, mature cystic teratomas and Leydig-cell tumors. Benign tumors tend to be well-circumscribed, with decreased Doppler flow on US, but malignancy should be suspected when US shows an inhomogeneous, not-well-described lesion with internal blood flow. Imaging features should always be interpreted in combination with clinical and biological data including serum levels of tumor markers and even intra-operative frozen sections in case of conservative surgery to raise any concerns of malignity. This review provides an overview of imaging features of the most frequent testicular and para-testicular tumor types in children and the value of imaging in disease staging and monitoring children with testicular tumors or risk factors for testicular tumors.

Genitourinary Tract Tumors in Children: An Update

BACKGROUND

Genitourinary tract tumors in children are less common than in adults. Most of these tumors have different genetic backgrounds, clinical presentation, and oncologic behavior than their adult counterpart. As a result of low prevalence in children, some of the treatment approaches and recommendations are based on treatment experience in adult patients. However, thanks to scientific and technological development, survival rates have risen considerably.

OBJECTIVE

This paper presents a review of the principal features of the tumors involving the genitourinary tract in children and an update in genetic background, diagnosis, and treatment.

METHODS

A narrative review was performed on published literature about genitourinary tract tumors in pediatric patients. Papers presented in English and Spanish literature were reviewed. PubMed, Science Direct, and SciELO databases were used to collect information and present this article.

RESULTS

Kidney tumors are the most common type of genitourinary tumors in children. Among those, Wilms tumor represents the majority of cases and shows the successful work of clinical trial groups studying this tumor type. Other tumors involving the genitourinary tract in children include Rhabdomyosarcoma, Transitional cell carcinoma, Testicular, and Adrenal tumors.

CONCLUSION

Genitourinary tract tumors in children represent significant morbidity and economic burden, so awareness in early diagnosis represents improvement in treatment, clinical, and oncological outcomes.

EAU-ESPU pediatric urology guidelines on testicular tumors in prepubertal boys

BACKGROUND

Testicular tumors in prepubertal boys account for 1-2% of all solid pediatric tumors. They have a lower incidence, a different histologic distribution and are more often benign compared to testicular tumors in the adolescent and adult group. This fundamental difference should also lead to a different approach and treatment.

OBJECTIVE

To provide a guideline for diagnosis and treatment options in prepubertal boys with a testicular mass.

METHOD

A structured literature search and review for testicular tumors in prepubertal boys was performed. All English abstracts up to the end of 2019 were screened, and relevant papers were obtained to create the guideline.

RESULTS

A painless scrotal mass is the most common clinical presentation. For evaluation, high resolution ultrasound has a detection rate of almost 100%, alpha-fetoprotein is a tumor marker, however, is age dependent. Human chorionic gonadotropin (HCG) was not a tumor marker for testis tumors in prepubertal boys.

CONCLUSION

Based on a summary of the literature on prepubertal testis tumors, the 2021 EAU guidelines on Pediatric Urology recommend a partial orchiectomy as the primary approach in tumors with a favorable preoperative ultrasound diagnosis.

Frozen-section examination in the management of paediatric testicular lesions

PURPOSE

Paediatric testicular and para-testicular lesions have traditionally been managed according to adult protocols. Testis-sparing surgery (TSS) has gained popularity as it has become apparent benign lesions predominate in childhood. Frozen-section examination (FSE) for intra-operative diagnosis has been extensively utilised in adults, though its use in paediatric practice remains limited. We reviewed our experience of FSE in paediatric patients with an aim to identify the utility and efficacy of this tool in the management of testicular and para-testicular pathology.

METHODS

A retrospective, single-centre review of paediatric patients who underwent intra-operative FSE for a range of testicular and para-testicular lesions was performed. FSE results were compared to final pathology. TSS was performed if appropriate, and was utilised in adolescent patients, and in lesions with a diameter greater than 20 mm.

RESULTS

Nine males underwent FSE from 2013 to 2020. Median age at surgery was 9 years (range 1-15). Eight (89%) patients had benign pathology. FSE result correlated with the final pathological examination in 100% of cases. FSE facilitated TSS in 7/9 cases.

CONCLUSION

FSE has 100% diagnostic accuracy for paediatric testicular and para-testicular pathology. We would recommend all lesions be evaluated by FSE to guide intra-operative decision making and facilitate TSS in appropriate cases.

Evaluation of an Algorithm for Testis-Sparing Surgery in Boys with Testicular Tumors: A Retrospective Cohort Study

Aim: This study reports surgical treatment and its outcome for boys with a testicular tumor, in order to analyze the considerations of testis-sparing surgery (TSS) and investigate whether, in retrospect, treatment was according to a recently developed algorithm. Methods: We retrospectively reviewed boys with testicular tumors who underwent surgical treatment between January 2000 and June 2020 at the Wilhelmina’s Children’s Hospital and the Princess Máxima Center for Pediatric Oncology, The Netherlands. Medical records were searched for clinical characteristics and outcome. Results: We identified 31 boys (median age = 5.5 years) with a testicular tumor, 26 germ cell tumors (GCTs), four sex cord-stromal tumors, and one gonadoblastoma. Seventeen boys (median age = 1.5 years) had malignant and 14 (median age = 3.6 years) had benign tumors. Four boys with benign GCTs were treated with TSS, 25 with radical inguinal orchiectomy (RIO), and 2 with scrotal orchiectomy. No recurrence or testicular atrophy was reported. All boys with benign testicular tumors were treated as suggested by the algorithm, except for one boy treated with RIO. Conclusion: Retrospective analysis of surgical treatment of prepubertal boys with benign testicular tumors showed that TSS appears to be safe, and should be considered based on clinicoradiological data, in line with our algorithm.

Testis Sparing Surgery in Pediatric Testicular Tumors

Simple Summary

Testis sparing surgery (TSS) is a safe treatment option in selected cases of testicular tumors in adults, focusing on technical feasibility, oncologic safety, preserving of testicular function, and long-term outcome. This surgical technique is also increasingly being considered in children, as benign tumors are more common in this population. With this systematic review, we aim to evaluate outcome of TSS and to investigate under which circumstances TSS can be considered safe in boys with testicular tumors. Based on the current practice described in this systematic review, combined with the outcome of TSS, we would like to suggest an algorithm to guide clinicians in determining the appropriate surgical treatment in prepubertal patients less than 12 years of age with a testicular tumor. TSS may lead to improved testicular function and quality of life in boys with testicular tumors.

Abstract

Objective: The purpose of this review is to evaluate the outcomes of testis sparing surgery (TSS) and to investigate under which circumstances TSS can be considered a safe treatment option in pediatric patients with testicular tumors. Methods: A database search was performed in Cochrane, Pubmed, and Embase for studies that focused on TSS as treatment for testicular tumors in the pediatric population, excluding reviews and single case reports. Results: Twenty studies, describing the surgical treatment of 777 patients with testicular tumors, were included in the analysis. The majority of pediatric patients with benign germ cell tumors (GCTs) (mean age: 3.7 years) and sex cord-stromal tumors (SCSTs) (mean age: 6.6 years) were treated with TSS, 61.9% and 61.2%, respectively. No cases of testicular atrophy occurred. Four of the benign GCTs, i.e., three teratomas and one epidermoid cyst, recurred. No cases of recurrence were reported in patients with SCSTs. Of the 243 malignant GCTs (mean age: 4.2 years), only one patient had TSS (0.4%). Conclusion: TSS is a safe treatment option for prepubertal patients less than 12 years of age with benign GCTs and low grade SCSTs.