Racial variations in interfacial behavior of lipids extracted from worn soft contact lenses

Biophysical properties of tear film lipid layer II. Polymorphism of FAHFA

Fatty acid esters of hydroxy fatty acids (FAHFAs) are a newly discovered class of endogenous lipids that consist of two acyl chains connected through a single ester bond. Being a unique species of FAHFAs, (O-acyl)-ω-hydroxy fatty acids (OAHFAs) differ from other FAHFAs in that their hydroxy fatty acid backbones are ultralong and their hydroxy esterification is believed to be solely at the terminal (ω-) position. Only in recent years with technological advances in lipidomics have OAHFAs been identified as an important component of the tear film lipid layer (TFLL). It was found that OAHFAs account for approximately 4 mol% of the total lipids and 20 mol% of the polar lipids in the TFLL. However, their biophysical function and contribution to the TFLL is still poorly understood. Here we studied the molecular biophysical mechanisms of OAHFAs using palmitic-acid-9-hydroxy-stearic-acid (PAHSA) as a model. PAHSA and OAHFAs share key structural similarities that could result in comparable biophysical properties and molecular mechanisms. With combined biophysical experiments, atomic force microscopy observations, and all-atom molecular dynamics simulations, we found that the biophysical properties of a dynamic PAHSA monolayer under physiologically relevant conditions depend on a balance between kinetics and thermal relaxation. PAHSA molecules at the air-water surface demonstrate unique polymorphic behaviors, which can be explained by configurational transitions of the molecules under various lateral pressures. These findings could have novel implications in understanding biophysical functions that FAHFAs, in general, or OAHFAs, specifically, play in the TFLL.

Biophysical properties of tear film lipid layer I. Surface tension and surface rheology

Tear film lipid layer (TFLL) is the outmost layer of the tear film. It plays a crucial role in stabilizing the tear film by reducing surface tension and retarding evaporation of the aqueous layer. Dysfunction of the TFLL leads to dysfunctional tear syndrome, with dry eye disease (DED) being the most prevalent eye disease, affecting 10%-30% of the world population. To date, except for treatments alleviating dry eye symptoms, effective therapeutic interventions in treating DED are still lacking. Therefore, there is an urgent need to understand the biophysical properties of the TFLL with the long-term goal to develop translational solutions in effectively managing DED. Here, we studied the composition-function correlations of an artificial TFLL, under physiologically relevant conditions, using a novel experimental methodology called constrained drop surfactometry. This artificial TFLL was composed of 40% behenyl oleate and 40% cholesteryl oleate, representing the most abundant wax ester and cholesteryl ester in the natural TFLL, respectively, and 15% phosphatidylcholine and 5% palmitic-acid-9-hydroxy-stearic-acid (PAHSA), which represent the two predominant polar lipid classes in the natural TFLL. Our study suggests that the major biophysical function of phospholipids in the TFLL is to reduce the surface tension, whereas the primary function of PAHSA is to optimize the rheological properties of the TFLL. These findings have novel implications in better understanding the physiological and biophysical functions of the TFLL and may offer new translational insight to the treatment of DED.

Profiling of non-polar lipids in tears of contact lens wearers during the day

PURPOSE

This study explored whether the non-polar lipids in the human tear fluid lipidome show diurnal variation with and without contact lens wear. It also addressed the relationship between changes in ocular comfort during the day with the level of non-polar lipids.

METHODS

Tear samples were collected in the morning and evening with and without contact lenses using fine glass capillary tubes and were analysed by chip-based nano-electrospray ionization tandem mass spectrometric techniques. Tear levels of cholesteryl esters (CE), wax esters (WE) and triacylglycerides (TAG) were quantified.

RESULTS

TAG 48:0, 52:0 and WE 26:0/16:0, and 27:0/17:0 increased from morning to evening. TAG 52:2, WE 21:0/16:0, 21:0/18:1 and 28:0/18:1 decreased during the day when no lenses were worn. CE 21:0 was the only non-polar lipid that increased from morning to evening in contact lens wear. WE 21:0/16:0 and 27:0/17:0 were lower in the morning in contact lens wear compared to no lens wear (p ≤ 0.05). The level of non-polar lipids did not correlate with ocular comfort at the end of the day.

CONCLUSION

Even though the level of some of non-polar lipid species changed from morning to evening the total level of major tear non-polar lipids remained unchanged during the day with and without contact lens wear. The effect of change in the quantity and structure of lipid species on tear stability and ocular comfort warrants more investigation.

The role of ethnicity versus environment in tear film stability: A pilot study

PURPOSE

Existing literatures suggest a difference in tear film stability between Caucasian and Asian ethnic groups. However, such a finding was compounded by the fact that the comparison was done on subjects living in different environments. Therefore, it is not clear whether such difference is due to ethnicity, environment, or both. The aim of this study is to clarify the roles of these two factors.

METHODS

A total of 88 asymptomatic subjects participated in this present study. For each subject, the tear film break-up time (TBUT), non-invasive TBUT (NITBUT) and tear meniscus height (TMH) were measured. To isolate the effect of ethnicity, the results of 12 American Asian young adults were compared against the results of 23 Caucasian adults. Both groups were recruited from Nova Southeastern University. To elucidate the effect of environment, the results from the same 12 American Asians were compared to that of the 53 Asian young adults recruited from the Tianjin Vocational Institute, China (Tianjin Asian).

RESULTS

The tear film stability did not show significant difference among American Asian subjects and Caucasian subjects in TBUT (10.49 ± 2.86 s vs. 11.06 ± 2.79 s,p =  0.57), NITBUT (11.19 ± 4.89 s vs. 11.14 ± 6.20 s, p =  0.98), and TMH (0.21 ± 0.08 mm vs. 0.22 ± 0.05 mm, p =0.59). However, the tear film stability was significantly better in the American Asian group than the Tianjin Asian group in TBUT (10.49 ± 2.86 s vs. 7.60 ± 3.26 s, p =  0.01), NITBUT (11.19 ± 4.89 s vs. 8.03 ± 3.56 s, p = 0.01), and TMH (0.21 ± 0.08 mm vs. 0.14 ± 0.03 mm, p <  0.01).

CONCLUSIONS

The previously reported difference in Caucasian and Asian populations might be due to the fact that the studied subjects have different living environments.

Structure-function relationship of tear film lipid layer: A contemporary perspective

Tear film lipid layer (TFLL) stabilizes the air/tear surface of the human eye. Meibomian gland dysfunction (MGD) resulting in quantitative and qualitative modifications of TFLL major (>93%) component, the oily secretion of meibomian lipids (MGS), is the world leading cause of dry eye syndrome (DES) with up to 86% of all DES patients showing signs of MGD. Caused by intrinsic factors (aging, ocular and general diseases) and by extrinsic everyday influences like contact lens wear and extended periods in front of a computer screen, DES (resulting in TF instability, visual disturbances and chronic ocular discomfort) is the major ophthalmic public health disease of the present time affecting the quality of life of 10-30% of the human population worldwide. Therefore there is a pressing need to summarize the present knowledge, contradictions and open questions to be resolved in the field of TFLL composition/structure/functions relationship. The following major aspects are covered by the review: (i) Do we have a reliable mimic for TFLL: MGS vs contact lens lipid extracts (CLLE) vs lipid extracts from whole tears. Does TFLL truly consist of lipids only or it is important to keep in mind the TF proteins as well?; (ii) Structural properties of TFLL and of its mimics in health and disease in vitro and in vivo. How the TFLL uniformity and thickness ensures the functionality of the lipid layer (barrier to evaporation, surface properties, TF stability etc.); (iii) What are the main functions of the TFLL? In this aspect an effort is done to emphasize that there is no single main function of TFLL but instead it simultaneously fulfills plethora of functions: suppresses the evaporation (alone or probably in cooperation with other TF constituents) of the aqueous tears; stabilizes (due to its surface properties) the air/tear surface at eye opening and during the interblink interval; and even acts as a first line of defense against bacterial invasion due to its detergency action on the bacterial membranes. An effort is done to highlight how the concept on the importance of TFLL and TF viscoelasticity transpires from old and new studies and what are its clinical implications. An attempt is made to outline the future hot directions of research into the field ranging from quest for molecules that can significantly alter TFLL properties to addressing open questions on the contribution of TFLL to the overall performance of the TF.

TFOS DEWS II Tear Film Report

The members of the Tear Film Subcommittee reviewed the role of the tear film in dry eye disease (DED). The Subcommittee reviewed biophysical and biochemical aspects of tears and how these change in DED. Clinically, DED is characterized by loss of tear volume, more rapid breakup of the tear film and increased evaporation of tears from the ocular surface. The tear film is composed of many substances including lipids, proteins, mucins and electrolytes. All of these contribute to the integrity of the tear film but exactly how they interact is still an area of active research. Tear film osmolarity increases in DED. Changes to other components such as proteins and mucins can be used as biomarkers for DED. The Subcommittee recommended areas for future research to advance our understanding of the tear film and how this changes with DED. The final report was written after review by all Subcommittee members and the entire TFOS DEWS II membership.

Surface Chemistry Interactions of Cationorm with Films by Human Meibum and Tear Film Compounds

Cationorm® (CN) cationic nanoemulsion was demonstrated to enhance tear film (TF) stability in vivo possibly via effects on tear film lipid layer (TFLL). Therefore the interactions of CN with human meibum (MGS) and TFLL in vitro and in vivo deserve special study. MGS and CN were spread at the air/water interface of a Langmuir surface balance to ensure a range of MGS/CN oil phase ratios: 20/1, 10/1, 5/1, 3/1, 2/1 and 1/1. The films capability to reorganize during dynamic area changes was evaluated via the surface pressure-area compression isotherms and step/relaxation dilatational rheology studies. Films structure was monitored with Brewster angle microscopy. CN/TFLL interactions at the ocular surface were monitored with non-contact specular microscopy. The in vitro studies of MGS/CN layers showed that (i) CN inclusion (at fixed MGS content) increased film elasticity and thickness and that (ii) CN can compensate for moderate meibum deficiency in MGS/CN films. In vivo CN mixed with TFLL in a manner similar to CN/MGS interactions in vitro, and resulted in enhanced thickness of TFLL. In vitro and in vivo data complement each other and facilitated the study of the composition-structure-function relationship that determines the impact of cationic nanoemulsions on TF.

Accounting for Ethnicity-Related Differences in Ocular Surface Integrity as a Step Toward Understanding Contact Lens Discomfort

Contact lens discomfort is a common problem that can lead to unsuccessful or limited contact lens wear. Although many factors may contribute to contact lens discomfort, limited research has explored the influence of ethnicity-related differences in the anatomy and physiology of the ocular surface. Therefore, we performed a search of the literature in PubMed using key words related to "ocular surface" paired with the terms "race" and "ethnicity." The goal of this review was to determine potential areas of research regarding ethnicity differences, particularly between Asian and non-Asian eyes, in ocular surface integrity to advance our understanding of contact lens discomfort.

Dynamic interfacial properties of human tear-lipid films and their interactions with model-tear proteins in vitro

This review summarizes the current state of knowledge regarding interfacial properties of very complex biological colloids, specifically, human meibum and tear lipids, and their interactions with proteins similar to the proteins found in aqueous part of human tears. Tear lipids spread as thin films over the surface of tear-film aqueous and play crucial roles in tear-film stability and overall ocular-surface health. The vast majority of papers published to date report interfacial properties of meibum-lipid monolayers spread on various aqueous sub-phases, often containing model proteins, in Langmuir trough. However, it is well established that natural human ocular tear lipids exist as multilayered films with a thickness between 30 and 100nm, that is very much disparate from 1 to 2nm thick meibum monolayers. We employed sessile-bubble tensiometry to study the dynamic interfacial and rheological properties of reconstituted multilayered human tear-lipid films. Small amounts (0.5-1μg) of human tear lipids were deposited on an air-bubble surface to produce tear-lipid films in thickness range 30-100nm corresponding to ocular lipid films. Thus, we were able to overcome major Langmuir-trough method limitations because ocular tear lipids can be safely harvested only in minute, sub-milligram quantities, insufficient for Langmuir through studies. Sessile-bubble method is demonstrated to be a versatile tool for assessing conventional synthetic surfactants adsorption/desorption dynamics at an air-aqueous solution interface. (Svitova T., Weatherbee M., Radke C.J. Dynamics of surfactant sorption at the air/water interface: continuous-flow tensiometry. J. Colloid Interf. Sci. 2003;261:1170-179). The augmented flow-sessile-bubble setup, with step-strain relaxation module for dynamic interfacial rheological properties and high-precision syringe pump to generate larger and slow interfacial area expansions-contractions, was developed and employed in our studies. We established that this method is uniquely suitable for examination of multilayered lipid-film interfacial properties. Recently it was compellingly proven that chemical composition of human tear lipids extracted from whole tears is substantially different from that of meibum lipids. To be exact, healthy human tear lipids contain 8-16% of polar lipids, similar to lung lipids, and they are mostly double-tailed phospholipids, with C16 and longer alkyl chains. Rationally, one would assume that the results obtained for meibum lipids, devoid of surface-active components such as phospholipids, and, above all, in a form of monolayers, are not pertinent or useful for elucidating behavior and stability of an averaged 60-nm thick ocular tear-lipid films in vivo. The advantage of sessile-bubble technique, specifically, using a small amount of lipids required to attain multilayered films, unlocks the prospect of evaluating and comparing the interfacial properties of human tear lipids collected from a single individual, typically 100-150μg. This is in sharp contrast with several milligrams of lipids that would be required to build equally thick films for Langmuir-trough experiments. The results of our studies provided in-depth understanding of the mechanisms responsible for properties and stability of human tear-lipid films in vivo. Here we summarize recent publications and our latest findings regarding human tear-lipid interfacial properties, their chemical composition, and their interaction with model proteins mimicking the proteins found in human tear-aqueous phase.

Understanding Ocular Discomfort and Dryness Using the Pain Sensitivity Questionnaire

PURPOSE

To utilize the Pain Sensitivity Questionnaire (PSQ) to assess the influence of pain sensitivity on perceptions of ocular discomfort and dryness.

METHODS

Subjects completed a battery of questionnaires, including history of ocular and general health, contact lens wear history, the Ocular Surface Disease Index (OSDI) questionnaire, visual analog scale (VAS) 100-point rating scales to assess severity and frequency of average and end of day (EOD) discomfort and dryness, and the PSQ to assess pain sensitivity level. Masked subjects were then instructed to wear one inverted and one normally oriented soft contact lens contralaterally for 30 minutes to induce an inter-eye difference in comfort and dryness sensations. Subjects rated comfort and dryness in each eye on VAS every 5 minutes during contact lens wear. A slit lamp examination was performed to evaluate ocular surface health and to assess contact lens fit.

RESULTS

One hundred and fifty-three subjects (111 females, 42 males) completed the study. In separate models, a higher PSQ score was significantly associated with higher OSDI score (p = 0.002), lower average and EOD comfort (p = 0.005 and 0.001, respectively), and greater EOD dryness (p = 0.04). The minimum (0.14) and maximum (7.14) PSQ scores observed in our subject cohort (i.e., from the subjects who were the least and most sensitive to pain, respectively) corresponded to an estimated difference of 11 points on the OSDI, 20 points on the VAS scale for average comfort, 31 points for EOD comfort and 17 points for EOD dryness. In a mixed effects model, a higher PSQ score was significantly associated with a greater inter-eye difference in comfort (p = 0.013) and dryness (p = 0.010) during CL wear.

CONCLUSIONS

Pain sensitivity influences perceptions of ocular discomfort and dryness, and should be taken into account when evaluating subjective assessments of these symptoms.