Beware the Alar Base Optical Illusion in Assessment of Unilateral Cleft Lip Nasal Deformity

State of the art: The Unilateral Cleft lip and Nose Deformity and Anatomic Subunit Approximation

The anatomic subunit approximation approach to unilateral cleft lip repair was developed over 20 years ago. While the underlying principles of the repair are unchanged, its description has been simplified, additional landmarks and creases have been added, and objective analysis of perioperative changes have provided better clarity regarding goals and desired alterations. We review recent insights regarding the deformity; describe the repair in a simplified manner; and link a stepwise approach to foundation-based primary rhinoplasty as a part of the avenue to creating nasolabial balance and harmony.

Balancing the Anteroposterior Diameters of the Nostril Lengths in Cleft Rhinoplasty

BACKGROUND

Osteocartilaginous deformities in cleft rhinoplasties may be restored with numerous techniques. However, the anteroposterior (AP) diameter lengths of the nostrils may still be unequal and should also be addressed. A technique was designed to balance nostril AP diameter lengths and apical shapes.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Balance between AP nostril diameters was accomplished by reduction of the AP diameter of the nostril at the non-cleft side by medial crural reduction and augmentation of the AP diameter of the nostril at the cleft side by three-parted mini-flap reconstruction at the soft triangle. The cleft-side AP diameter length was divided by the non-cleft-side AP diameter length of the same preoperative, per-operative and 1-year postoperative base view photographs of each patient, and "nostril balancing ratio" was obtained. The more this ratio was near to "one," the more the AP nostril diameters were equal.

RESULTS

Seventy-eight unilateral-cleft rhinoplasty were performed between January/2019 and May/2022. Forty-two of them required nostril AP diameter equalization. Twenty-nine patients were female, thirteen were male. Thirty-three of them were operated for a primary cleft rhinoplasty. Nine of them for secondary cleft rhinoplasty. Mean age was 28 years (22-39 years). Mean follow-up was 25 months (6-40 months). The preoperative, per-operative and postoperative mean "nostril balancing ratios" were 0.714 (0.621-0.813), 0.743 (0.721-0.752) and 0.971 (0.943-0.976), respectively.

CONCLUSION

Balancing AP diameter symmetry with MCO at the non-cleft side and three-parted mini skin flap reconstruction at the cleft side may provide the satisfactory results. Three mini-flaps at the soft triangle may remold the nostril apex in an oval shape, which may result in a better shape symmetry.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE IV

This journal requires that authors assign a level of evidence to each article. For a full description of these Evidence-Based Medicine ratings, please refer to the Table of Contents or the online Instructions to Authors www.springer.com/00266 .

Primary cheilorhinoseptoplasty using the Talmant protocol in unilateral complete cleft lip: functional and aesthetic results on nasal correction and comparison with the Tennison-Malek protocol

Many surgical procedures used to treat patients with unilateral complete cleft lip do not include a complete primary rhinoseptoplasty, which is delayed until the end of growth as part of secondary surgery. Primary cheilorhinoseptoplasty using the Talmant technique has been performed at Lapeyronie University Hospital, Montpellier for 15 years. This retrospective study evaluated and compared the functional and aesthetic results obtained in such patients at 4-6 years after surgery with those obtained without primary rhinoseptoplasty in patients undergoing the Tennison-Malek technique. This study included a cohort of 60 children who presented a unilateral complete cleft lip: 29 were operated on with the Tennison-Malek technique and 31 with the Talmant technique. Three functional and 14 aesthetic criteria were evaluated. All functional criteria showed better results in the Talmant group: nocturnal nasal breathing (P < 0.001), incidence of closed rhinolalia (P = 0.0019), and presence of asymmetric nasal breathing (P < 0.001). Concerning the aesthetic results, all criteria evaluated on the frontal and basal photographs of each patient showed significantly better results in the Talmant technique group. The rate of satisfactory results was> 75% for 12 of the 14 criteria in the Talmant group, compared with none of the 14 criteria in the Tennison-Malek group.

Three-Dimensional Anthropometry for Evaluating Reliability of Worm's Eye View Photographs of Unilateral Cleft Lip Nasal Deformity

BACKGROUND

Worm's eye view photograph has been widely used for anthropometric analysis. However, it is difficult to secure objectivity because it cannot be captured at a constant head-up degree. This study aimed to analyze whether anthropometric nasal measurements in worm's eye view differ from the actual values.

METHODS

A total of 40 patients with unilateral cleft lip nasal deformities were included. The 30° and 60° head-tilted two-dimensional (2D) photographs were captured from the three-dimensional (3D) images. The real measurements were obtained from 3D images and 2D measurements were obtained from the captured images. The cleft/non-cleft side ratios of the nostril height, width, and alar base width were compared between 3D and 2D images.

RESULTS

There was a significant difference in the nostril height between the 3D and 30° values (3D = 0.82, 30° = 0.92, P < 0.001) but no meaningful difference was noted between the 3D and 60° values (3D = 0.82, 60° = 0.84, P = 0.31). There was no significant difference in the nostril width among the 30°, 60°, and 3D values. A significant difference was found in the alar base width between the 3D values and both the 30° (3D = 0.998, 30° = 1.04, P = 0.026) and 60° (3D = 0.998, 30° = 1.03, P = 0.029) values.

CONCLUSIONS

This study demonstrates that 2D photographs do not accurately reflect actual values. The nostril height and alar width ratio can be changed depending on the head-up position. The 3D systems are more accurate and less affected by the subject's head position. Therefore, the 3D imaging system is advocated for the anthropometric analysis of unilateral cleft lip nasal deformity.

How Deviation of Nasal Septum Affects Nasal Appearance in Unilateral Cleft Patients: A Study Using Cone-Beam Computed Tomography

AIM

To quantitatively evaluate the relationship between nasal appearance and nasal septum deviation in unilateral complete cleft patients using cone-beam computed tomography.Method: Cone-beam computed tomography images of 180 patients with unilateral cleft lip/palate from June 2014 to June 2017 were used in the study. None of the subjects had undergone septoplasty. The data were compared between the 2 groups to elucidate the relationship between nasal appearance and deviated nasal septum in unilateral complete cleft patients.

RESULTS

The mean age of a total of 180 patients (126 males and 54 females) was 14.58 years, with a standard deviation of 7.10 years, ranged from 6 years old to 49 years old. Columella nasi symmetry parameters show slight positive significant association with angle of nasal septal deviation on transerve plan (r = 0.250, P < 0.001), TRSD (r = 0.323, P < 0.001) and coronal range of nasal septal deviation (r = 0.294, P < 0.001), and moderate positive significant association with coronal angle about septal deviation (r = 0.404, P < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Columella nasi symmetry affected by septal deviation, whereas there is lack of evidence to say symmetry of nasal tip and base affected by septal deviation. The symmetry of nasal tip and alar base are not just determined by nasal septum deviation. The nasal septum deviation show difference in different cleft type.

Beware of Optical Illusion of the Alar Base in Unilateral Cleft Lip Nasal Deformity

Background:

It is generally accepted that the alar base on the cleft side in the cleft lip nose is displaced outward and downward; therefore, it is rotated inward and upward in almost all procedures for cleft lip closure. However, nostril narrowing and collapse of the lower lateral cartilage on the cleft side are sometimes experienced. In this retrospective study, we investigated whether the preoperative alar base on the cleft side is displaced outward and downward.

Methods:

This was a retrospective evaluation using preoperative frontal images obtained from patients with unilateral cleft lip (n = 245). The midcolumellar and subalare points were placed, and each ratio was analyzed and compared to those of age-matched controls (n = 40).

Results:

The subalare on the noncleft side and subnasale were displaced upward and outward. In contrast, the subalare on the cleft side was displaced downward and inward. The displacement of the subalare was greater on the noncleft than on the cleft side. There were no significant differences between male and female patients and between the left and right sides. Among the complete cleft lip and palate, incomplete cleft lip and palate, complete cleft lip and alveolus, incomplete cleft lip and alveolus, and microform cleft lip groups, the complete cleft lip and palate group showed the greatest displacement.

Conclusion:

The cleft alar base appeared to shift outward and downward because of an optical illusion, but in fact, both alar bases shifted; the alar base on the cleft side was displaced inward and downward, and the alar base on the noncleft side was displaced outward and upward.

Revisiting the unrepaired unilateral cleft lip and nasal deformity using 3D surface image analysis: A data-driven model and its implications

BACKGROUND

Current descriptions of the unilateral cleft lip and nasal deformity (uCLND) are based upon limited sample sets and subjective observations. While those descriptions are inconsistent and contradictory, theoretical models, including Hogan's "tilted tripod" and Fisher's "nasal arch forms", have never been tested. Given that favorable outcomes of treatment remain elusive, detailed study of the deformity is critical in devising better treatments. The purpose of this study was to develop a data-driven three-dimensional (3D) model of uCLND that spans the spectrum of presentation and involves a pervasive underlying mechanism.

METHODS

We studied 3D images of 100 infants with unrepaired cleft lip at 6 months of age. Objective assessment included the landmark positions, anthropometric dimensions, and shape-based measures. Cleft severity was stratified by the lateral displacement of subnasale, so that a model could be developed using linear regression.

RESULTS

With progressive deviation of subnasale, the non-cleft alar base moved lateral, the cleft alar base was left posterior, and the nasal dorsum followed the caudal septum (deviating towards the non-cleft side). The "twist" resulted in opposing cleft alar dome collapse, non-cleft alar ring constriction (the non-cleft nasal sill narrowed, lateral genu rose, and alar-cheek junction became more acute), and displacement of the philtrum from midline.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study not only supports theoretical models of uCLND but also clarifies vectors of change and reveals significant non-cleft side alterations. On the basis of our findings, the objectives of treatment should involve centralization of the columella and philtrum and rebalancing the nose by untwisting the orthogonal displacement of the alar bases.