Surgical Management of Occipital Neuralgia: A Systematic Review of the Literature

Neural Interconnections of Extracranial Nerves in Headache Surgery: Anatomical Landmarks and Clinical Implications: A Review of the Literature

SUMMARY

Headache disorders (HDs) remain a nationwide challenge for the US health care system, affecting nearly 60% of the US population. Surgical deactivation of the peripheral trigger site, also referred to as headache surgery, represents an effective treatment for patients with refractory HD pain or nonresponse to pharmacologic regimens. Research stemming from other surgical specialties has underlined the clinical relevance of neural interconnections in refining diagnostic algorithms, adapting surgical techniques, and improving overall patient outcomes. Different HD trigger points have been identified, but there is a paucity of studies discussing the mostly sensory neural interconnections between these trigger points in a comprehensive fashion. The authors provide an overview of the specific nerves involved in HD and synthesize the literature on HD nerve interconnections to deduce clinical implications. Overall, this line of research may help refine the perioperative workflow and enhance HD patient care.

Step-by-Step Description of Percutaneous Full-Endoscopic C2 Ganglionectomy: An Anatomic Feasibility Study in Human Cadavers

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

The percutaneous full-endoscopic C2 ganglionectomy (PEC2G), an innovative procedure developed for the surgical treatment of intractable occipital neuralgia, was firstly reported by us in 2021. However, a universally accepted and well-articulated protocol modality remains elusive. The primary objective of this anatomic investigation was to meticulously elucidate the standard procedural steps of PEC2G and assess the anatomic features supporting the safe implementation of PEC2G.

METHODS

Eighteen fresh adult cadavers were incorporated into this study. From this sample, 3 cadavers were subjected to bilateral PEC2G. Each procedure was documented and assessed, leading to the formulation of standard procedure criteria for PEC2G. Subsequently, 10 sets of anatomic parameters pertinent to this procedure were identified, quantified, and analyzed in 15 cadavers after complete bilateral endoscopic exposure of the C2 ganglion. An assessment of the technical feasibility and potential constraints associated with PEC2G was conducted, providing invaluable insights into the procedure's anatomic considerations.

RESULTS

All 3 cadavers successfully underwent the PEC2G without any observed complications, such as dura tears or vertebral artery injuries. The C2 inferior articular process emerged as the optimal bony target for puncture, with the C2 pedicle serving as the standard guiding landmark en route to the C2 ganglion. In the 15 cadavers subjected to the planned procedure, 10 sets of anatomic parameters were quantified, establishing a foundational understanding of the anatomy in the context of PEC2G procedure. The results demonstrated that the characteristic of anatomic data pertinent to surgical site supported the safe implementation of PEC2G.

CONCLUSION

This study contributes the standard surgical steps and crucial anatomic parameters relevant to PEC2G. The characteristic of anatomic data bolsters the safety credentials of this technique, which offers a reliable approach to achieve C2 ganglionectomy. These insights undeniably establish a robust foundation for the ongoing refinement and broader adoption of PEC2G.

Aetiologies of iatrogenic occipital nerve injury and outcomes following treatment with nerve decompression surgery

INTRODUCTION

This study analyzed the etiologies and treatment of iatrogenic occipital nerve injuries.

METHODS

Patients with occipital neuralgia (ON) who were screened for occipital nerve decompression surgery were prospectively enrolled. Patients with iatrogenic occipital nerve injuries who underwent nerve decompression surgery were identified. Data included surgical history, pain characteristics, and surgical technique. Outcomes included pain frequency (days/month), duration (h/day), intensity (0-10), migraine headache index (MHI), and patient-reported percent-resolution of pain.

RESULTS

Among the 416 patients with ON, who were screened for occipital nerve decompression surgery, 12 (2.9%) cases of iatrogenic occipital nerve injury were identified and underwent surgical treatment. Preoperative headache frequency was 30 (±0.0) days/month, duration was 19.4 (±6.9) h, and intensity was 9.2 (±0.9). Neuroma excision was performed in 5 cases followed by targeted muscle reinnervation in 3, nerve cap in 1, and muscle burial in 1. In patients without neuromas, greater occipital nerve decompression and/or lesser occipital nerve neurectomy were performed. At the median follow-up of 12 months (IQR 12-12 months), mean pain frequency was 4.0 (±6.6) pain days/month (p < 0.0001), duration was 6.3 (±8.9) h (p < 0.01), and intensity was 4.4 (±2.8) (p < 0.001). Median patient-reported resolution of pain was 85% (56.3%-97.5%) and success rate was (≥50% MHI improvement) 91.7%.

CONCLUSIONS

Iatrogenic occipital nerve injuries can be caused by various surgical interventions, including craniotomies, cervical spine interventions, and scalp tumor resections. The associated pain can be severe and chronic. Iatrogenic ON should be considered in the differential diagnosis of post-operative headaches and can be treated with nerve decompression surgery or neuroma excision with reconstruction of the free nerve end.

Treatment delay from onset of occipital neuralgia symptoms to treatment with nerve decompression surgery: a prospective cohort study

BACKGROUND

The aims of this study were to (1) evaluate the time between onset of occipital neuralgia symptoms and nerve decompression surgery, (2) perform a cost comparison analysis between surgical and nonsurgical treatment of occipital neuralgia, and (3) report postoperative results of nerve decompression for occipital neuralgia.

METHODS

Subjects (n = 1112) who underwent screening for nerve decompression surgery were evaluated for occipital neuralgia. Of those, 367 patients (33%) met the inclusion criteria. Timing of occipital neuralgia symptom onset and pain characteristics were prospectively collected. Cost associated with the nonsurgical treatment of occipital neuralgia was calculated for the period between onset of symptoms and surgery.

RESULTS

A total of 226 patients (73%) underwent occipital nerve decompression. The average time between onset of occipital neuralgia and surgery was 19 years (7.1-32). Postoperatively, the median number of pain days per month decreased by 17 (0-26, 57%) (P < .001), the median pain intensity decreased by 4 (2-8, 44%) (P < .001), and median pain duration in hours was reduced by 12 (2-23, 50%) (P < .001). The annual mean cost of nonsurgical occipital neuralgia treatment was $28 728.82 ($16 419.42-$41 198.41) per patient. The mean cost during the 19-year time frame before surgery was $545 847.75($311 968.90-$782 769.82).

CONCLUSION

This study demonstrates that patients suffer from occipital neuralgia for an average of 19 years before undergoing surgery. Nerve decompression reduces symptom severity significantly and should be considered earlier in the treatment course of occipital neuralgia that is refractory to conservative treatment to prevent patient morbidity and decrease direct and indirect health care costs.

Compressive lesions of the head and neck: Common and uncommon must-know entities

There are many lesions that cause compression of nerves and vessels in the head and neck, and they can often be overlooked in the absence of adequate history or if not suspected by the radiologist. Many of these lesions require a high index of suspicion and optimal positioning for imaging. While a multimodality approach is critical in the evaluation of compressive lesions, an MRI utilizing high-resolution (heavily weighted) T2-weighted sequence is extremely useful as a starting point. In this review, we aim to discuss the radiological features of the common and uncommon compressive lesions of the head and neck which are broadly categorized into vascular, osseous, and miscellaneous etiologies.

Correspondence: Morphological features of the greater occipital nerve and its possible importance for interventional procedures

This response applauds Saglam et al.'s (2023) recent study on the greater occipital nerve's anatomy while urging readers to consider earlier pivotal studies overlooked. It emphasizes how prior research has significantly shaped headache treatments and provides valuable insights for future practices and discussions.

Functional outcomes between headache surgery and targeted botox injections: A prospective multicenter pilot study

Introduction

Chronic migraine headaches (MH) are a principal cause of disability worldwide. This study evaluated and compared functional outcomes after peripheral trigger point deactivation surgery or botulinum neurotoxin A (BTA) treatment in patients with MH.

Methods

A long-term, multicenter, and prospective study was performed. Patients with chronic migraine were recruited at the Ohio State University and Massachusetts General Hospital and included in each treatment group according to their preference (BTA or surgery). Assessment tools including the Migraine Headache Index (MHI), Migraine Disability Assessment Questionnaire (MIDAS) total, MIDAS A, MIDAS B, Migraine Work and Productivity Loss Questionnaire-question 7 (MWPLQ7), and Migraine-Specific Quality of Life Questionnaire (MSQ) version 2.1 were used to evaluate functional outcomes. Patients were evaluated prior to treatment and at 1, 2, and 2.5 years after treatment.

Results

A total of 44 patients were included in the study (surgery=33, BTA=11). Patients treated surgically showed statistically significant improvement in headache intensity as measured on MIDAS B (p = 0.0464) and reduced disability as measured on MWPLQ7 (p = 0.0120) compared to those treated with BTA injection. No statistical difference between groups was found for the remaining functional outcomes. Mean scores significantly improved over time independently of treatment for MHI, MIDAS total, MIDAS A, MIDAS B, and MWPLQ 7 (p<0.05). However, no difference in mean scores over time was observed for MSQ.

Conclusions

Headache surgery and targeted BTA injections are both effective means of addressing peripheral trigger sites causing headache pain. However, lower pain intensity and work-related disabilities were found in the surgical group.

Treatment Delay in Patients Undergoing Headache Surgery (Nerve Decompression Surgery)

Background

Although headache surgery has been shown to be an effective treatment option for refractory headache disorders, it has not been included as part of the headache disorder management algorithm by non-surgical providers. This study aims to evaluate the delay in surgical management of patients with headache disorders. In addition, a cost comparison analysis between conservative and operative treatment of headache disorders was performed, and the surgical outcomes of headache surgery were reported.

Methods

Among 1112 patients who were screened, 271 (56%) patients underwent headache surgery. Data regarding the onset of headache disorder and pre- and postoperative pain characteristics were prospectively collected. To perform a cost comparison analysis, direct and indirect costs associated with the conservative treatment of headache disorders were calculated.

Results

The median duration between onset of headache disorder symptoms and headache surgery was 20 (8.2-32) years. The annual mean cost of conservative treatment of headache disorders was $49,463.78 ($30,933.87-$66,553.70) per patient. Over the 20-year time period before surgery, the mean cost was $989,275.65 ($618,677.31-$1,331,073.99). In comparison, the mean cost of headache surgery was $11,000. The median pain days per month decreased by 16 (0-25) (p<0.001), the median pain intensity reduced by 4 (2-7) (p<0.001), and the median pain duration decreased by 11 hours (0-22) (p<0.001).

Conclusion

This study shows that patients experience symptoms of headache disorders for an average of 20 years prior to undergoing headache surgery. Surgical treatment not only significantly improves headache pain but also reduces healthcare costs and should be implemented in the management algorithm of headache disorders.

Migraine Surgery and Determination of Success over Time by Trigger Site: A Systematic Review of the Literature

BACKGROUND

Migraine headache is a debilitating disorder that produces high costs and compromises patient quality of life. This study aimed to evaluate surgery success and the longevity of the surgical benefit by trigger site.

METHODS

A systematic literature review was performed by querying the PubMed, Embase, Scopus, and Web of Science databases. The keywords "surgery," "migraine," "outcomes," "headache index," and synonyms in titles and abstracts were used to perform the search.

RESULTS

A total of 17 articles published between 2009 and 2019 met the inclusion criteria. Six studies were prospective and 11 were retrospective. Most of the studies (77.8%, 77.8%, and 80%, respectively) reported success of migraine surgery at 12-month follow-up for trigger sites I, II, and III, respectively. For trigger site IV, the greatest Migraine Headache Index reduction (93.4%) was observed at 12-month follow-up, and the earliest Migraine Headache Index reductions (80.3% and 74.6%) were observed at 6-month follow-up. All studies that evaluated trigger sites V and VI identified surgery success at 12-month follow-up. Migraine surgery was found to remain beneficial at 22 months for trigger sites I, II, III, and IV.

CONCLUSIONS

The symptomatic improvement may initially be evident at 6 months for trigger site IV and at 12 months for trigger sites I, II, III, V, and VI. Surgical benefit in trigger sites I, II, III, and IV can persist after 22 months. Further studies are required to evaluate results at longer follow-up.