The Use of Radial Vessel Stump in Free Radial Forearm Flap as Flap Monitor in Head and Neck Reconstruction

Flap Monitoring Techniques: A Review

Postoperative tissue flap vitality monitoring enables early detection of clinical complications, allowing for intervention. Timely re-operation can prevent the need for extensive correction procedures, thus reducing healthcare costs and hospitalization time. Statistics show that monitoring can increase the success rate of flap survival to 95% or higher. However, despite the significant progress in monitoring techniques, major and minor complications, leading to the loss of the flap, still occur. This clinical application review aims to provide a comprehensive overview of the recent advancements and findings in flap surgery reconstructions, transplants, and systems for their postoperative assessment. The literature from the years 1925 to 2024 has been reviewed to capture previous and current solutions for monitoring flap vitality. Clinically acclaimed methods and experimental techniques were classified and reviewed from a technical and clinical standpoint. Physical examination, metabolism change, ultrasound method, and electromagnetic (EM) radiation-based measurement methods were carefully evaluated from the perspective of their considered applications. Guidelines aiding engineers in the future design and development process of monitoring systems were proposed. This paper provides a comprehensive overview of the monitoring techniques used in postoperative flap vitality monitoring. It also gives an overview of each approach and potential ways for future development.

Pedicled thoracoacromial artery compound flaps for circumferential hypopharyngeal reconstruction

BACKGROUND

Total laryngeal and hypopharyngeal resection remained to be the mainly treatment option for advanced hypopharyngeal cancer, which resulted in complicated reconstructive challenge for circumferential hypopharyngeal defect. The pedicled thoracoacromial artery compound flaps included Thoracoacromial artery perforator (TAAP) flap and pectoralis major myocutaneous (PMMC) flap. This study is to evaluate the clinical application of the pedicled thoracoacromial artery compound flaps for circumferential hypopharyngeal reconstruction.

METHODS

From May 2021 to April 2022, four hypopharyngeal cancer patients with circumferential hypopharyngeal defects were reconstructed by the pedicled thoracoacromial artery compound flaps. All patients were males. Patient age ranged from 35 to 62 years (average, 50 years). The Shoulder function were evaluated by SPADI. The average follow-up was 10.25 months (range from 4 to 18 months).

RESULTS

All of the pedicled thoracoacromial artery compound flaps in our study survived. The defect length between tongue base and cervical esophagus ranged from 8 to 10 cm after total laryngeal and hypopharyngeal resection. The TAAP flap size ranged from 6 × 7 cm to 7 × 10 cm, and the PMMC flap size ranged from 6 × 7 cm to 9 × 12 cm. The pedicle length of TAAP and PMMC flaps varied, respectively, from 5 to 8 cm (mean 6.5 cm) and 7 cm to 11 cm (mean 8.75 cm). The mean time of TAAP and PMMC flaps harvest was, respectively, 82 min and 39 min. All patients were able to resume soft diet in the fourth week of postoperation, but one patient was operated by gastrostomy in the second month of postoperation because of pharyngeal cavity stenosis, and the patient successfully resumed oral soft diet by endoscopic balloon dilation after postoperation radiotherapy. All patients have resumed oral feeding at last. There were mild dysfunction for our patients according to SPADI during the mid-long follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

The pedicled thoracoacromial artery compound flaps have stable blood supply and provide adequate muscle coverage for greater protection during radiotherapy, and the microsurgical skills have no requirement. Therefore, the compound flaps provide a good choice for the reconstruction of circumferential hypopharyngeal defect, especially in the aged or patients with comorbidities who are not able to tolerate prolonged surgery.

modified tubed anterolateral free flap for reconstruction of total laryngopharyngectomy

Background: A tubed anterolateral thigh (ALT) flap has become a reliable option for laryngopharyngeal defects; however, successful reconstruction remains challenging. Prevention of fistulae, resurfacing of the neck and flap monitoring are key issues that surgeons have sought to address through various flap modifications. Here we describe a chimeric design of the tubed ALT flap which tackles these and other challenges. Methods: Fourteen cases requiring ALT flaps were harvested for reconstruction of total laryngopharyngectomy defects between 2017 and 2019. Each flap was raised on at least two perforators of the descending branch of the lateral circumflex femoral artery (dbLCFA) or both the dbLCFA and transverse branch of the lateral circumflex femoral artery (tbLCFA) to create a chimeric flap. The primary cutaneous paddle was tubed to reconstruct the oesophagus, and the secondary component was inset to the neck as a skin-monitoring paddle. A strip of vascularised vastus lateralis was harvested in the primary paddle continuing with the flap and sutured along the neopharynx suture line, an additional layer preventing anastomotic leak. Results: Patients averaged 61.1 years of age. An average of 2.4 perforators were included per flap. All flaps survived. Donor sites were closed primarily in all cases. Barium swallow was performed in 71.4 per cent of cases (10/14). Fistula occurred in 7.1 per cent of patients (1/14). Patients were followed up for an average of 13 months. Conclusion: Our chimeric ALT free flap design provides a reliable pharyngeal reconstruction, and allows for flap monitoring and neck resurfacing when required, with a low rate of clinically significant leaks or fistula.

Success of Implantable Doppler Probes for Monitoring Buried Free Flaps

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this study is to describe the operative success of completely buried free flaps and to determine the safety/reliability of using implantable dopplers for postoperative monitoring in completely buried free flaps.

STUDY DESIGN

A retrospective chart review was conducted from 2014 to 2020. Patients were included who had implantable dopplers placed for monitoring a completely buried free flap without a visible skin paddle.

SETTING

Single academic cancer hospital.

METHODS

Patient charts were reviewed to determine flap viability after surgery, need for reoperation, and ability of implanted doppler probes to detected change in free flap status.

RESULTS

A total of 65 patients were included. Locations of flaps were as follows: pharynx, 76.9%; skull base, 7.7%; trachea, 6.2%; esophagus, 4.6%; and facial reanimation, 4.6%. Types of free flaps performed included radial forearm (50.8%), anterolateral thigh (44.6%), and gracilis (4.6%). One patient (1.5%) returned to the operating room for vascular compromise, which was accurately detected by the implantable doppler and salvaged. All free flaps were viable upon hospital discharge based on clinical examination and implantable doppler signals. There were no complications related to implantable doppler use.

CONCLUSIONS

Implantable dopplers are an effective method for evaluating postoperative success of completely buried free flaps. In our series utilizing implantable dopplers, buried free flap survival was higher than traditionally thought. The use of implanted dopplers for monitoring buried free flaps allows for an effective, cosmetically appealing, and simplified reconstructive technique.

Modern postoperative monitoring of free flaps

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Flap failure in microvascular reconstruction is a costly complication with total flap loss being the worst-case scenario. With the aim to rapidly identify a postoperative circulatory problem, some susceptible flaps can be saved by careful clinical monitoring or by various technical monitoring methods. In head and neck surgery, where the flaps are often buried and difficult to monitor clinically, a reliable technical monitoring method would be useful. A broad range of different techniques are in use varying according to practical and personal preferences among clinics and surgeons. However, no evidence for any particular technique being superb has emerged. We review reports of some frequently used and modern free flap monitoring techniques.

RECENT FINDINGS

Clinical monitoring is still the gold standard to which other techniques are compared to. Laser Doppler flowmetry and near-infrared spectroscopy have been reported to identify early circulatory problems, but both techniques are not well suited for buried flaps. Implantable Doppler, flow coupler, partial tissue oxygen pressure and microdialysis are invasive monitoring methods suitable for buried flaps.

SUMMARY

More research with practical and clinically relevant parameters, that is flap salvage rate, false positive rate and cost-efficiency are needed before objective comparisons between different monitoring techniques can be made.

A Novel Application of Double-Paddle Peroneal Chimeric Flap as External Sentinel Monitor in Hypopharyngeal Reconstruction

OBJECTIVES

Monitoring the viability of buried free flaps in hypopharyngeal reconstruction is difficult. Various methods have been proposed to monitor these buried flaps, but limitations remain.

METHOD

We present a method of using double-paddle chimeric peroneal flaps that permanently externalizes a flap skin paddle as a monitoring paddle in hypopharyngeal reconstructions. This study was performed in a medical center in southern Taiwan; between 2013 and 2015, 10 patients underwent double-paddle chimeric peroneal flap reconstruction in advanced stages of hypopharyngeal cancer. We retrospectively reviewed the medical records from these surgeries, searching for either short-term postoperative complications or long-term follow-up morbidity and researched relevant articles for comparisons with other monitoring methods.

RESULTS

None of the 10 flaps underwent total loss. The rate of stenosis and that of fistula formation was 10%. The average postoperative hospital stay was 39 days. Six of 10 patients were able to resume at least a soft diet after reconstruction, and none of the patients experienced significant complications.

CONCLUSIONS

The peroneal flap is a useful flap because it is thin and pliable, has minimal donor site morbidity in patients without peripheral vascular disease, and has the potential of multiple skin paddles so that one skin paddle can be used for monitoring the buried flap. Using this method, direct clinical monitoring is feasible, and early detection of vascular complications is possible. Furthermore, the drawbacks of using a monitoring paddle produced by a deepithelialized bridge can be avoided.

Outcomes Comparison for Microsurgical Breast Reconstruction in Specialty Surgery Hospitals Versus Tertiary Care Facilities

Background:

Postoperative monitoring is crucial in the care of free flap breast reconstruction patients. Tertiary care facilities (TCFs) provide postoperative monitoring in an ICU after surgery. Specialty surgery hospitals (SSHs) do not have ICUs, but these facilities perform free flap breast reconstruction as well. Are outcomes comparable between the 2 facilities in terms of flap reexploration times and overall success?

Methods:

Retrospective study including 163 SSH and 157 TCF patients. Primary predictor was facility in which the procedure was performed. Secondary predictors included operative, demographic, and comorbidity data. Primary outcomes were flap take back rate and flap failures. Secondary outcomes were total time from adverse event noticed in the flap to returning to the operating room (OR) and total time from decision made to return to the OR to returning to the OR (decision made). Tertiary outcomes were length of stay, operative times, and blood loss.

Results:

Patients at the TCF were generally less healthy than SSH patients. Salvage rates and failure rates were similar between the 2 institutions. Adverse event noticed and decision made times did not differ between the 2 facilities. Overall flap success rate was 98.22% at SSH and 98.81% at TCF. No primary or secondary predictors had a significant correlation with increased odds for flap failure.

Conclusion:

SSHs can offer similar outcomes in free flap breast reconstruction with just as effective clinical response times to endangered flaps as found in a TCF. However, surgery at an SSH may best be reserved for healthier patients.

The free inverted omega-shaped flap for circumferential hypopharyngeal reconstruction with simultaneous neck skin defect

BACKGROUND

Circumferential hypopharyngeal defect with simultaneous skin defect can pose complicated reconstructive challenge for reconstructive microsurgeons. Our experience with the versatile inverted-omega flap tubing design is proposed to accommodate such problem.

METHODS

From 2012 to 2015, 13 anterolateral thigh (ALT) flaps and one anteromedial thigh (AMT) flap were harvested for reconstruction of circumferential hypopharyngeal defects with skin defects in 14 patients. All patients were males except one. Patient age ranged from 42 to 67 years (average, 53.1 years). Fifty-seven percent were recurrent cases. All but one patient received preoperative chemoradiotherapy.

RESULTS

The average flap size was 29 × 8 cm (range: 25-31 × 6-10 cm² ). An average of 2.6 perforators was included in each flap (2-4 perforators/flap). All flaps survived. One venous thrombosis was noted and salvaged after thrombolectomy and vein graft. The mean follow-up period was 25 months. The fistula rate was 21.4% (three patients). One fistula never healed because of early recurrence; one fistula healed after surgical intervention; and one fistula need a loco-regional flap for secondary reconstruction. Three postoperative strictures were noted (21.4%).

CONCLUSION

For the circumferential hypopharyngeal defect with simultaneous neck skin defect, this inverted-omega ALT tubing design offers an alternative choice for such complicated reconstruction. © 2016 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Microsurgery, 38:51-59, 2018.

Choice of flap affects fistula rate after salvage laryngopharyngectomy

Due to the significant morbidity and mortality associated with pharyngocutaneous fistula in pharyngoesophageal reconstruction following cancer resection, the purpose of this retrospective study is to examine the selection of tubed skin flaps that impact anastomotic integrity. The flaps evaluated included radial forearm flap versus anterolateral thigh flap, and fasciocutaneous anterolateral thigh flap versus chimeric anterolateral thigh flap. The outcome of interest is the incidence of pharyngocutaneous fistula. The radial forearm group had a significantly higher rate of fistula than the anterolateral thigh group (56.6% vs. 30.2%, p = 0.03). No significant difference in the incidence of fistula was demonstrated between fasciocutaneous and chimeric anterolateral thigh flap (36.8% vs. 25%, p = 0.51). The anastomotic integrity in pharyngoesopharyngeal reconstruction is affected by choice of skin flaps. Anterolateral thigh flap appears to be a viable option for pharyngoesophageal reconstruction. The more technical demand of the anterolateral thigh flap must be weighed against an easily harvested radial forearm flap.

Postoperative care and monitoring of the reconstructed head and neck patient

Reconstruction of head and neck patients using free tissue transfer is perhaps the most challenging of areas in the human body. Although complications are inevitable in a percentage of patients, it is good postoperative care and monitoring that determines the success or failure of the reconstruction and also permits early salvage of a failing free flap. Teamwork and cooperation among members of the reconstructive team are critical. Here we review the significance of clinical care and monitoring of reconstructed head and neck patients in the intraoperative and postoperative periods. We also review different techniques and strategies for flap monitoring and anticoagulation used for free tissue transfers.

Analysis of 13 cases of venous compromise in 178 radial forearm free flaps for intraoral reconstruction

The purpose of this study was to analyse the causes of venous compromise and flap failure in radial forearm free flap (RFFF) surgery for intraoral reconstruction. One hundred seventy-eight RFFF reconstructions were reviewed retrospectively for intraoral defects. Of the 13 flaps with venous obstruction, 9 flaps were salvaged, and 4 were lost, with a salvage rate of 69.2%. Eleven venous occlusions occurred within the first 72h. The main reasons for venous failure were mechanical obstruction or technical errors due to inadequate pedicle length and geometry, inadequate venous drainage, compression and kinking of the vein. The main cause of failure for oropharynx reconstruction was unrecognized vascular events due to the lack of reliable monitoring for buried flap. Oozing of dusky blood from the flap margin may be directly related to venous congestion in the early postoperative period and a late indication of a change in skin colour. In conclusion, a thorough operative plan, including carefully selected drainage vein for the flap and recipient vessels, adequate pedicle length and geometry, precise surgical technique, avoidance of haematoma, and expert monitoring of buried flaps may improve the success rate of RFFF transfer in intraoral reconstruction.

Long term study into surgical re-exploration of the 'free flap in difficulty'

BACKGROUND

Free tissue transfers must survive in order to achieve their surgical goals. There is little consensus about managing the 'failing' free flap, and practice is often guided by anecdote.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

We have prospectively collected data about all free flaps performed within our department between 1985 and 2008 (2569 flaps). We identified 327 flaps which were re-explored a total of 369 times. We analysed these flaps with regard to indication for re-exploration, operative findings and outcome.

RESULTS

Thirteen percent (327) of free flaps were re-explored. Of these, 291 (83%) had a successful outcome. Successful re-explorations took place at a mean 19h post-op and unsuccessful re-explorations at a mean 56h post-op. Clinical diagnosis prior to re-exploration was confirmed operatively in 91% of cases.

CONCLUSION

We have considered the factors that allowed us to achieve the salvage rates described over a prolonged period, and identified two key areas. Firstly, we favour a model for free flap monitoring with clinical judgement at its core. Secondly, we feel the facility to recover patients post-operatively in a specialised, warmed environment, and return them to theatre quickly should the need arise, is essential. These two simple, yet institutionally determined factors are vital for maintaining excellent success rates.

[Application of radial forearm free flap in extraoral soft tissue head and neck reconstruction]

BACKGROUND/AIM

Radial forearm free flap, highly regarded in head and neck reconstructive surgery, is known to be one of the most reliable and versatile flaps. The aim of this study was to illustrate the versatility and reliability of a radial forearm flap in reconstruction of a variety of extraoral head and neck defects.

METHODS

During a period 2001-2007 at the Clinic for Maxillofacial Surgery, Faculty of Dentistry and the Center for Burns, Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery in Belgrade, 19 patients underwent microsurgical reconstructions after extraoral tumor ablation in the head and neck region, using fasciocutaneous radial forearm free flap.

RESULTS

The overall flap survival rate was 89.5%. The complications that appeared were one partial necrosis and one venous thrombosis that in spite of reanastomosis resulted in a complete flap failure. The donor site healed uneventfully in all patients, except one, who had a partial skin graft failure, that ended in a secondary skin grafting.

CONCLUSION

For reconstruction in head and neck surgery, with the need for thin, pliable tissues and a long vascular pedicle, radial forearm flap still remains a primary choice. Because of their multiple advantages, free flaps from the radial forearm is a safe method for reconstruction of a variety of extensive extraoral soft tissue defects in the head and neck region.