Spontaneous Repositioning of Isolated Blow-In Orbital Roof Fracture: Could Wait and See Be a Strategy in Asymptomatic Cases?

Clinical characteristics and associated features of pure orbital roof fractures: A ten-year retrospective review

PURPOSE

To present the demographics and clinical characteristics of pure (rim-sparing) orbital roof fractures.

METHODS

This retrospective observational study used 10 years of data from a single institution. Patient age, sex, laterality, field of binocular single vision, associated injuries, and radiologic features were analyzed. Orbital roof fractures were categorized into four groups: comminuted/open, hinged, trapdoor, and linear. These were further subdivided into blow-in (-down) and blow-out (-up) fractures. Injury etiology was classified into fall, traffic accidents, sports injuries, assault, work-related, and others.

RESULTS

Data documented a low incidence rate of 2.5% (27 patients) in 1074 patients. Most patients were male (81%). The most common cause of injury was fall (48%), followed by traffic accidents (22%). Comminuted/open fractures constituted the bulk of fracture types (54%), followed by hinged, and linear fractures. Blow-in and blow-out fractures had an incidence rate of 50% each. Concomitant fractures of the medial and inferior orbital walls were predominant. Low surgical intervention was noted owing to acceptable field of binocular single vision outcomes, and the field of binocular single vision included the primary position of gaze in 88% of patients.

CONCLUSION

Pure orbital roof fractures occurred in 2.5% of patients with pure orbital fractures. Patients were predominantly male with trauma caused by high energy forces, which regularly caused comminution of the roof and fractures of the medial and inferior orbital walls. Most patients were managed conservatively.

Pure Orbital Floor Blow-In Fracture: An Extremely Rare Case

A 57-year-old man presented with left diplopia on an upward gaze and ophthalmalgia after hitting the left side of his head. CT revealed a fracture on the left side of the orbital floor without orbital rim fractures and the protrusion of a small bone fragment into the orbit. Hess charts indicated markedly limited vertical movement of the left eye. Based on these findings, the patient was diagnosed with a pure orbital floor blow-in fracture (BIF). Symptoms persisted after a two-week monitoring period; therefore, the bone fragment was removed by a transcutaneous surgical approach with the assistance of a navigation system and an endoscope. Symptoms resolved after surgery, and CT and Hess examinations six months after surgery showed a good outcome. A pure BIF is rare, particularly on the orbital floor. Only a few similar case reports have been published to date, and we herein describe the surgical procedures performed and the treatment outcome of our case.

Globe Compression by Bone Fragments in Orbital Blow-in Fractures: A Case Series and Systematic Review

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to describe the clinical characteristics, management, and outcomes of orbital blow-in fractures involving compression of the globe by bone fragments.

METHODS

A retrospective case series and systematic literature review were performed.

RESULTS

Three male patients (mean age 29 years) with orbital blow-in fractures causing globe indentation presented with extraocular movement restriction, choroidal folds, and B-scan ultrasonography demonstrating deformation of the globe contour by a hyperechoic bone fragment. All underwent surgical repair within 1 day of presentation resulting in improved visual outcomes. An additional 10 cases were identified in the literature review. The majority of patients were male (80%) with a mean age of 29 years. Fractures originated primarily from the lateral orbital wall (50%) or the orbital roof (40%). Globe compression was evident on CT of the orbit (100%) and ultrasonography (30%). Common presenting signs included decreased visual acuity (70%), restriction of supraduction (40%) or abduction (40%), choroidal folds (30%), brow laceration (40%), periorbital edema (40%), and hypoglobus (40%). Most patients underwent surgical intervention (80%) involving fracture reduction (50%) or fragment removal (38%). Reported postsurgical outcomes were excellent with resolution of diplopia, motility, and visual acuity.

CONCLUSION

Globe indentation from blow-in fractures are rare. Clinicians should be suspicious in cases of high-velocity trauma to the superolateral orbit with hypoglobus, motility limitation, and indentation of the globe upon dilated exam. Prompt diagnosis and early surgical removal of the compressive orbital bone fragments in a multidisciplinary fashion can lead to good visual, functional, and cosmetic outcomes.

Post-traumatic intra-orbital meningoencephalocele in adults: technical note on a rare entity and review of the literature

Post-traumatic orbital meningoencephaloceles related to orbital roof fractures are a challenging clinical entity because of their rarity and difficult differential diagnosis. We report a case of post-traumatic intra-orbital meningoencephalocele in a 69-year-old man, secondary to a likely trapdoor mechanism, treated with a modified one-piece orbitozygomatic craniotomy. We also performed an extensive literature review of traumatic Intra-Orbital Encephalocele related to Orbital Roof Fracture focused on adult patients on electronic databases including Scopus, MEDLINE/PubMed, and Google Scholar. Patient well recovered after surgery with immediate exophthalmos resolution and discharged without visual or neurological deficits. The literature review included 22 papers with a total of 28 patients: 22 males (78.6%) and 6 females (21.4%), with a median age of 34.7 years. Twenty-six patients (92.9%) reported ocular injuries, with associated intracranial complications in 16 cases (61.5%). Twenty-seven patients (96.4%) were surgically treated, 18 of those underwent unilateral or bilateral frontal approach. Most orbital roof fractures can be managed nanoperatively if asymptomatic. Indeed, when the intra-orbital volume decreases, for example due to an encephalocele, the intra-orbital pressure could increase and determine an orbital compartment syndrome. In our case, we performed a one-piece modified orbitozygomatic approach, which has several advantages in comparison to the frequent unilateral or bilateral frontal craniotomy like the better exposure of the brain and orbit and a minimum brain retraction.

Literature Review to create Evidence Based Care Pathway for Isolated Adult Orbital Blowout Fractures

This review aims to develop an evidence-based pathway for isolated adult orbital blowout fractures. Evaluation of assessment methods, outcome measures, imaging modalities, and crucially, the optimal timing of surgical intervention was critically examined to develop a clinically applicable care pathway. A literature search was carried out using Scopus, PubMed and Web of Knowledge. The literature favors the use of HAR% ratio, Field of Binocular Single Vision (FOBSV) and Exophthalmometer as the core tests that should form part of the standardized assessment for blow-out fractures (BOFs). CT imaging remains gold standard, particularly to identify 'red-flags' warranting early intervention. There was some disagreement in relation to timing of intervention in adult fractures who continue to be symptomatic without initial extraocular muscle (EOM) entrapment and enophthalmos >3 mm, where early intervention within two weeks is not indicated. The limited literature available agreed that successful functional and radiological outcomes can be achieved with conservative or late surgical management following an extended observational period of four weeks, opposed to the conventional two weeks. An evidence-based care pathway has been created, confidently including the initial assessment methods, imaging modality, and the criteria for observation. A four-week observational period has been advocated due to evidence suggesting that there is no significant difference in outcomes from two-week observation, plus with careful functional evaluation, surgery may be avoided in some cases.

Management of Pediatric Orbital Fractures

INTRODUCTION

Although uncommon in children, orbital fractures can be devastating to both vision and appearance. Due to the scarce information in the literature, the authors here present our experience and management with all pediatric orbital fracture patients.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A 6-years retrospective study was conducted on pediatric patients presented with orbital wall fracture (OFx). All patients (n = 43) were grouped for comparison based on the treatment method. The cohorts were analyzed for demographics data, location of fracture, type of material used for reconstruction, complication rate and follow up length. Data was analyzed utilizing SPSS for χ2 test.

RESULTS

The majority of patients were male (86%) and the mean age of patients was 12.09 ± 4 years. Mean follow-up time was 237 ± 72 days. Most of Patients 31 (72%) underwent surgical intervention. A higher rate of complications was observed in the surgically treated group (32%) compared to the conservative group (8%) regardless to the defect size. Subgroup analysis of the surgery treated group revealed that large size defect had inferior outcome compared to small size defect.

CONCLUSION

The consequences of treatment on long-term growth and development must be a cornerstone when choosing the optimal therapeutic method. Conservative management should be considered first in the absence of significant clinical pathologies. In addition, when surgery is indicated the least invasive procedure should be applied. The use of autogenous bone graft is preferable over alloplastic materials, however, when there is insufficient bone quantity the use of alloplastic materials is not contraindicated for reconstruction.