Sudden cardiac death in a 20-year-old male swimmer

Hypothesized mechanisms of death in swimming: a systematic review

BACKGROUND

The study aims to update the specific classification of mechanisms of death in swimming and to demonstrate these categories are reasonable, by analyzing more characteristics of death cases, evaluating the available evidence and determining their quality.

METHODS

Original articles were queried from PubMed, Web of Science, Embase databases, Cochrane Library, and Scopus. Included studies, which were evaluated as level 4 evidence or higher according to the Oxford Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine, discussed hypothesized mechanisms of death in swimming. Parameters analyzed in this study included decedents' characteristics, outcome measures, findings, methodological index for non-randomized studies (MINORS), and critical evaluation of each study classified by death mechanism.

RESULTS

A total of twenty-five studies were included for further analysis: fourteen were associated with cardiovascular diseases, two were about cerebrovascular diseases, two contained respiratory diseases, seven were about hazardous conditions and three contained other drownings, which provided evidence for mechanisms of death.

CONCLUSIONS

It is found that cardiovascular disease is the main cause or contributing factor of death in swimming. Respiratory diseases and cerebrovascular diseases are difficult to be definitive mechanism categories due to insufficient evidence. Hazardous conditions appear to be one of the possible risk factors because there are more cases of deaths from unsafe environments in swimming, but further statistics and research are still needed to support this view. Our study may have important implications for developing potential prevention strategies for sports and exercise medicine.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

PROSPERO ID (CRD42021267330). Registered Aug 13th 2021.

What is Sudden Cardiac Death?

Sudden cardiac death (SCD) is a rapid, unexpected death due to cardiac causes. The differential diagnosis includes diseases from all four structural divisions of the heart: the blood vessels, myocardium, valves, and conduction system. Although ischemic heart disease is a common cause of SCD, acute myocardial infarcts and/or coronary thromboses are not always detected and are not required to make the diagnosis of death due to atherosclerotic coronary disease. Some people die suddenly from heart disease with a grossly and microscopically normal heart. Molecular analysis of some of these autopsy-negative, sudden unexplained deaths (SUD) may detect putative cardiac channel mutations.

There are three SCD scenarios that are of particular interest to forensic pathologists: sudden cardiac deaths in young athletes, during criminal altercations (homicide by heart attack), and in other hostile environments. In young athletes, most sudden deaths involve cardiac disease and include cardiomyopathies, congenital coronary artery anomalies, myocarditis, and channelopathies. One must, however, consider other causes in these deaths (e.g., commotio cordis, hyperthermia, sickle cell trait). Homicide-by-heart-attack deaths are those in which the cause of death is an acute exacerbation of underlying cardiac disease, however, the manner is homicide because a criminal act triggered the lethal pathologic cascade. A sudden cardiac arrest may occur in hostile locations with resultant trauma (e.g., while driving a motor vehicle). When the event occurs in the bathtub or other body of water, the question of whether the person died naturally from heart disease or unnaturally from trauma (e.g., drowning) often arises. One should not be mislead by the initial physical surroundings of the death (i.e., in a motor vehicle collision, or swimming pool) and fail to distinguish a natural sudden death from an accidental one.