How Far Can We Expand Donor Age Criteria for Pancreas Transplantation?

Pancreatic transplant surgery and stem cell therapy: Finding the balance between therapeutic advances and ethical principles

The latest achievements in the field of pancreas transplantation and stem cell therapy require an effort by the scientific community to clarify the ethical implications of pioneering treatments, often characterized by high complexity from a surgical point of view, due to transplantation of multiple organs at the same time or at different times, and from an immunological point of view for stem cell therapy. The fundamental value in the field of organ transplants is, of course, a solidarity principle, namely that of protecting the health and life of people for whom transplantation is a condition of functional recovery, or even of survival. The nature of this value is that of a concept to which the legal discipline of transplants entrusts its own ethical dignity and for which it has ensured a constitutional recognition in different systems. The general principle of respect for human life, both of the donor and of the recipient, evokes the need not to put oneself and one’s neighbor in dangerous conditions. The present ethical reflection aims to find a balance between the latest therapeutic advances and several concepts including the idea of the person, the respect due to the dead, the voluntary nature of the donation and the consent to the same, the gratuitousness of the donation, the scientific progress and the development of surgical techniques, and the policies of health promotion.

Clinical impact of pancreas donor age on outcomes following pancreas transplantation: Analysis of a nationwide registry in Japan

OBJECTIVES

Clinical impact of pancreas donor age on pancreas transplantation (PTx) outcome has not been well investigated. Here we analyzed the nationwide PTx registry in Japan to assess posttransplant outcomes in donor age-stratified groups.

METHODS

This study included 410 cases of PTx performed in Japan between 2000 and 2019. Analyses were performed using clinical data from the Japan Pancreas Transplant Registry of Japan Society for Pancreas and Islet Transplantation.

RESULTS

The 410 PTx cases were classified based on donor age: <10 years (n = 10, 2.4%), 10-19 years (n = 30, 7.3%), 20-29 years (n = 64, 15.6%), 30-39 years (n = 75, 18.3%), 40-49 years (n = 114, 27.8%), 50-59 years (n = 90, 22.0%), and ≥60 years (n = 27, 6.6%). The incidence of early pancreas graft loss (8.9%, 36/410 cases) did not exhibit a significant linear correlation with donor age. Posttransplant pancreas graft survival (1-/3-/5-/10-year rates of 85.9%/80.6%/76.2%/67.4% among all cases) was also not significantly associated with donor age.

CONCLUSION

Pancreas donor age was not significantly associated with posttransplant outcome. This finding supports the use of expanded criteria donors, with regards to pancreas donor age, for PTx in cases of type 1 diabetes mellitus.

Impact of an older donor pancreas on the outcome of pancreas transplantation: single-center experience of the expansion of donor criteria

PURPOSE

The impact of using an older donor pancreas on the clinical outcomes of pancreas transplantation (PTx) is unknown. We investigated this by comparing the outcomes of PTx using older and younger donors in a single Japanese center, to expand the donor criteria.

METHODS

The subjects were 54 patients who received PTx from deceased donors in our institution. Posttransplant outcomes were analyzed based on donor age, with older donors defined as those aged ≥ 60 years.

RESULTS

The donors included six older (11.1%; aged 64 ± 4 years) and 48 younger donors (88.9%; aged 43 ± 12 years). There was no significant difference in the donor age between the recipients with vs. those without postoperative complications or between those with vs. those without early pancreas graft loss. Long-term outcomes, including overall, pancreas graft, and kidney graft survival after PTx, did not differ significantly between the older and younger donor groups. Graft age, defined as the age of the donor at the time of procurement plus the graft survival period, was not associated with graft loss.

CONCLUSION

Our results suggest that post-transplant outcomes of PTx using pancreas from older donors aged ≥ 60 years are comparable to those using pancreas from younger donors, and support expansion of the donor pool for transplantation therapy for type 1 diabetes mellitus.