High coverage fluid-phase floating lipid bilayers supported by ω-thiolipid self-assembled monolayers

Distance tuneable integral membrane protein containing floating bilayers via in situ directed self-assembly

Model membranes allow for structural and biophysical studies on membrane biochemistry at the molecular level, albeit on systems of reduced complexity which can limit biological accuracy. Floating supported bilayers offer a means of producing planar lipid membrane models not adhered to a surface, which allows for improved accuracy compared to other model membranes. Here we communicate the incorporation of an integral membrane protein complex, the multidomain β-barrel assembly machinery (Bam), into our recently developed in situ self-assembled floating supported bilayers. Using neutron reflectometry and quartz crystal microbalance measurements we show this sample system can be fabricated using a two-step self-assembly process. We then demonstrate the complexity of the model membrane and tuneability of the membrane-to-surface distance using changes in the salt concentration of the bulk solution. Results demonstrate an easily fabricated, biologically accurate and tuneable membrane assay system which can be utilized for studies on integral membrane proteins within their native lipid matrix.

Advances in sample environments for neutron scattering for colloid and interface science

This review describes recent advances in sample environments across the full complement of applicable neutron scattering techniques to colloid and interface science. Temperature, pressure, flow, tensile testing, ultrasound, chemical reactions, IR/visible/UV light, confinement, humidity and electric and magnetic field application, as well as tandem X-ray methods, are all addressed. Consideration for material choices in sample environments and data acquisition methods are also covered as well as discussion of current and potential future use of machine learning and artificial intelligence.

Suspended phospholipid bilayers: A new biological membrane mimetic

HYPOTHESIS

The attractive interaction between a cationic surfactant monolayer at the air-water interface and vesicles, incorporating anionic lipids, is sufficient to drive the adsorption and deformation of the vesicles. Osmotic rupture of the vesicles produces a continuous lipid bilayer beneath the monolayer.

EXPERIMENTAL

Specular neutron reflectivity has been measured from the surface of a purpose-built laminar flow trough, which allows for rapid adsorption of vesicles, the changes in salt concentration required for osmotic rupture of the adsorbed vesicles into a bilayer, and for neutron contrast variation of the sub-phase without disturbing the monolayer.

FINDINGS

The neutron reflectivity profiles measured after vesicle addition are consistent with the adsorption and flattening of the vesicles beneath the monolayer. An increase in the buffer salt concentration results in further flattening and fusion of the adsorbed vesicles, which are ruptured by a subsequent decrease in the salt concentration. This process results in a continuous, high coverage, bilayer suspended 11 Åbeneath the monolayer. As the bilayer is not constrained by a solid substrate, this new mimetic is well-suited to studying the structure of lipid bilayers that include transmembrane proteins.

Exploiting neutron scattering contrast variation in biological membrane studies

Biological membranes composed of lipids and proteins are central for the function of all cells and individual components, such as proteins, that are readily studied by a range of structural approaches, including x-ray crystallography and cryo-electron microscopy. However, the study of complex molecular mixtures within the biological membrane structure and dynamics requires techniques that can study nanometer thick molecular bilayers in an aqueous environment at ambient temperature and pressure. Neutron methods, including scattering and spectroscopic approaches, are useful since they can measure structure and dynamics while also being able to penetrate sample holders and cuvettes. The structural approaches, such as small angle neutron scattering and neutron reflectometry, detect scattering caused by the difference in neutron contrast (scattering length) between different molecular components such as lipids or proteins. Usually, the bigger the contrast, the clearer the structural data, and this review uses examples from our research to illustrate how contrast can be increased to allow the structures of individual membrane components to be resolved. Most often this relies upon the use of deuterium in place of hydrogen, but we also discuss the use of magnetic contrast and other elements with useful scattering length values.

Surface-tethered planar membranes containing the β-barrel assembly machinery: a platform for investigating bacterial outer membrane protein folding

The outer membrane of Gram-negative bacteria presents a robust physicochemical barrier protecting the cell from both the natural environment and acting as the first line of defense against antimicrobial materials. The proteins situated within the outer membrane are responsible for a range of biological functions including controlling influx and efflux. These outer membrane proteins (OMPs) are ultimately inserted and folded within the membrane by the β-barrel assembly machine (Bam) complex. The precise mechanism by which the Bam complex folds and inserts OMPs remains unclear. Here, we have developed a platform for investigating Bam-mediated OMP insertion. By derivatizing a gold surface with a copper-chelating self-assembled monolayer, we were able to assemble a planar system containing the complete Bam complex reconstituted within a phospholipid bilayer. Structural characterization of this interfacial protein-tethered bilayer by polarized neutron reflectometry revealed distinct regions consistent with known high-resolution models of the Bam complex. Additionally, by monitoring changes of mass associated with OMP insertion by quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation monitoring, we were able to demonstrate the functionality of this system by inserting two diverse OMPs within the membrane, pertactin, and OmpT. This platform has promising application in investigating the mechanism of Bam-mediated OMP insertion, in addition to OMP function and activity within a phospholipid bilayer environment.

Large scale model lipid membrane movement induced by a cation switch

A biomembrane sample system where millimolar changes of cations induce reversible large scale (≥ 200 Å) changes in the membrane-to-surface distance is described. The system composes of a free-floating bilayer, formed adjacent to a self-assembled monolayer (SAM). To examine the membrane movements, differently charged floating bilayers in the presence and absence of Ca2+ and Na+, respectively, were examined using neutron reflectivity and quartz crystal microbalance measurements, alongside molecular dynamics simulations. In neutron reflectivity the variation of Ca2+ and Na+ concentration enabled precision manipulation of the membrane-to-surface distance. Simulations suggest that Ca2+ ions bridge between SAM and bilayer whereas the more diffuse binding of Na+, especially to bilayers, is unable to fully overcome the repulsion between anionic floating bilayer and anionic SAM. Reproduced neutron reflectivity results with quartz crystal microbalance demonstrate the potential of this easily producible sample system to become a standard analysis tool for e.g. investigating membrane binding effects, endocytosis and cell signaling.

Studying the surfaces of bacteria using neutron scattering: finding new openings for antibiotics

The use of neutrons as a scattering probe to investigate biological membranes has steadily grown in the past three decades, shedding light on the structure and behaviour of this ubiquitous and fundamental biological barrier. Meanwhile, the rise of antibiotic resistance has catalysed a renewed interest in understanding the mechanisms underlying the dynamics of antibiotics interaction with the bacterial cell envelope. It is widely recognised that the key reason behind the remarkable success of Gram-negative pathogens in developing antibiotic resistance lies in the effectiveness of their outer membrane (OM) in defending the cell from antibacterial compounds. Critical to its function, the highly asymmetric lipid distribution between the inner and outer bilayer leaflets of the OM, adds an extra level of complexity to the study of this crucial defence barrier. Here we review the opportunities offered by neutron scattering techniques, in particular reflectometry, to provide structural information on the interactions of antimicrobials with in vitro models of the OM. The differential sensitivity of neutrons towards hydrogen and deuterium makes them a unique probe to study the structure and behaviour of asymmetric membranes. Molecular-level understanding of the interactions between antimicrobials and the Gram-negative OM provides valuable insights that can aid drug development and broaden our knowledge of this critically important biological barrier.

Understanding the Structure and Dynamics of Complex Biomembrane Interactions by Neutron Scattering Techniques

The membrane is one of the key structural materials of biology at the cellular level. Composed predominantly of a bilayer of lipids with embedded and bound proteins, it defines the boundaries of the cell and many organelles essential to life and therefore is involved in almost all biological processes. Membrane-specific interactions, such as drug binding to a membrane receptor or the interactions of an antimicrobial compound with the lipid matrix of a pathogen membrane, are of interest across the scientific disciplines. Herein we present a review, aimed at nonexperts, of the major neutron scattering techniques used in membrane studies: small-angle neutron scattering, neutron membrane diffraction, neutron reflectometry, quasielastic neutron scattering, and neutron spin echo. Neutron scattering techniques are well suited to studying biological membranes. The nondestructive nature of cold neutrons means that samples can be measured for long periods without fear of beam damage from ultraviolet, electron, or X-ray radiation, and neutron beams are highly penetrating, thus offering flexibility in samples and sample environments. Most important is the strong difference in neutron scattering lengths between the two most abundant forms of hydrogen, protium and deuterium. Changing the relative amounts of protium/deuterium in a sample allows the production of a series of neutron scattering data sets, enabling the observation of differing components within complex membrane architectures. This approach can be as simple as using the naturally occurring neutron contrast between different biomolecules to study components in a complex by changing the solution H₂O/D₂O ratio or as complex as selectively labeling individual components with hydrogen isotopes. This review presents an overview of each experimental technique with the neutron instrument configuration, related sample preparation and sample environment, and data analysis, highlighted by a special emphasis on using prominent neutron contrast to understand structure and dynamics. This review gives researchers a practical introduction to the often enigmatic suite of neutron beamlines, thereby lowering the barrier to taking advantage of these large-facility techniques to achieve new understandings of membranes and their interactions with other molecules.

Design and use of model membranes to study biomolecular interactions using complementary surface-sensitive techniques

Cellular membranes are complex structures and simplified analogues in the form of model membranes or biomembranes are used as platforms to understand fundamental properties of the membrane itself as well as interactions with various biomolecules such as drugs, peptides and proteins. Model membranes at the air-liquid and solid-liquid interfaces can be studied using a range of complementary surface-sensitive techniques to give a detailed picture of both the structure and physicochemical properties of the membrane and its resulting interactions. In this review, we will present the main planar model membranes used in the field to date with a focus on monolayers at the air-liquid interface, supported lipid bilayers at the solid-liquid interface and advanced membrane models such as tethered and floating membranes. We will then briefly present the principles as well as the main type of information on molecular interactions at model membranes accessible using a Langmuir trough, quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation monitoring, ellipsometry, atomic force microscopy, Brewster angle microscopy, Infrared spectroscopy, and neutron and X-ray reflectometry. A consistent example for following biomolecular interactions at model membranes is used across many of the techniques in terms of the well-studied antimicrobial peptide Melittin. The overall objective is to establish an understanding of the information accessible from each technique, their respective advantages and limitations, and their complementarity.

Self-Assembled Fluid Phase Floating Membranes with Tunable Water Interlayers

We present a reliable method for the fabrication of fluid phase, unsaturated lipid bilayers by self-assembly onto charged Self-Assembled Monolayer (SAM) surfaces with tunable membrane to surface aqueous interlayers. Initially, the formation of water interlayers between membranes and charged surfaces was characterized using a comparative series of bilayers deposited onto charged, self-assembled monolayers by sequential layer deposition. Using neutron reflectometry, a bilayer to surface water interlayer of ∼8 Å was found between the zwitterionic phospholipid 1,2-dipalmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DPPC) membrane and an anionic carboxyl terminated grafted SAM with the formation of this layer attributed to bilayer repulsion by hydration water on the SAM surface. Furthermore, we found we could significantly reduce the technical complexity of sample fabrication through self-assembly of planar membranes onto the SAM coated surfaces. Vesicle fusion onto carboxyl-terminated monolayers yielded high coverage (>95%) bilayers of 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC) which floated on a 7-11 Å solution interlayer between the membrane and the surface. The surface to membrane distance was then tuned via the addition of 200 mM NaCl to the bulk solution immersing a POPC floating membrane, which caused the water interlayer to swell reversibly to ∼33 Å. This study reveals that biomimetic membrane models can be readily self-assembled from solution onto functionalized surfaces without the use of polymer supports or tethers. Once assembled, surface to membrane distance can be tailored to the experimental requirements using physiological concentrations of electrolytes. These planar bilayers only very weakly interact with the substrate and are ideally suited for use as biomimetic models for accurate in vitro biochemical and biophysical studies, as well as for technological applications, such as biosensors.

Antibiotic resistance and host immune evasion in Staphylococcus aureus mediated by a metabolic adaptation

Staphylococcus aureus is a notorious human bacterial pathogen with considerable capacity to develop antibiotic resistance. We have observed that human infections caused by highly drug-resistant S. aureus are more prolonged, complicated, and difficult to eradicate. Here we describe a metabolic adaptation strategy used by clinical S. aureus strains that leads to resistance to the last-line antibiotic, daptomycin, and simultaneously affects host innate immunity. This response was characterized by a change in anionic membrane phospholipid composition induced by point mutations in the phospholipid biosynthesis gene, cls2, encoding cardiolipin synthase. Single cls2 point mutations were sufficient for daptomycin resistance, antibiotic treatment failure, and persistent infection. These phenotypes were mediated by enhanced cardiolipin biosynthesis, leading to increased bacterial membrane cardiolipin and reduced phosphatidylglycerol. The changes in membrane phospholipid profile led to modifications in membrane structure that impaired daptomycin penetration and membrane disruption. The cls2 point mutations also allowed S. aureus to evade neutrophil chemotaxis, mediated by the reduction in bacterial membrane phosphatidylglycerol, a previously undescribed bacterial-driven chemoattractant. Together, these data illustrate a metabolic strategy used by S. aureus to circumvent antibiotic and immune attack and provide crucial insights into membrane-based therapeutic targeting of this troublesome pathogen.

Physical Properties of Bacterial Outer Membrane Models: Neutron Reflectometry & Molecular Simulation

The outer membrane (OM) of Gram-negative bacteria is an asymmetric bilayer having phospholipids in the inner leaflet and lipopolysaccharides in the outer leaflet. This unique asymmetry and the complex carbohydrates in lipopolysaccharides make it a daunting task to study the asymmetrical OM structure and dynamics, its interactions with OM proteins, and its roles in translocation of substrates, including antibiotics. In this study, we combine neutron reflectometry and molecular simulation to explore the physical properties of OM mimetics. There is excellent agreement between experiment and simulation, allowing experimental testing of the conclusions from simulations studies and also atomistic interpretation of the behavior of experimental model systems, such as the degree of lipid asymmetry, the lipid component (tail, head, and sugar) profiles along the bilayer normal, and lateral packing (i.e., average surface area per lipid). Therefore, the combination of both approaches provides a powerful new means to explore the biological and biophysical behavior of the bacterial OM.

Supramolecular electrode assemblies for bioelectrochemistry

For more than three decades, the field of bioelectrochemistry has provided novel insights into the catalytic mechanisms of enzymes, the principles that govern biological electron transfer, and has elucidated the basic principles for bioelectrocatalytic systems. Progress in biochemistry, bionanotechnology, and our ever increasing ability to control the chemistry and structure of electrode surfaces has enabled the study of ever more complex systems with bioelectrochemistry. This feature article highlights developments over the last decade, where supramolecular approaches have been employed to develop electrode assemblies that increase enzyme loading on the electrode or create more biocompatible environments for membrane enzymes. Two approaches are particularly highlighted: the use of layer-by-layer assembly, and the modification of electrodes with planar lipid membranes.

Lipid phase behavior studied with a quartz crystal microbalance: A technique for biophysical studies with applications in screening

Quartz crystal microbalance (QCM) is emerging as a versatile tool for studying lipid phase behavior. The technique is attractive for fundamental biophysical studies as well applications because of its simplicity, flexibility, and ability to work with very small amounts of material crucial for biomedical studies. Further progress hinges on the understanding of the mechanism, by which a surface-acoustic technique such as QCM, senses lipid phase changes. Here, we use a custom-built instrument with improved sensitivity to investigate phase behavior in solid-supported lipid systems of different geometries (adsorbed liposomes and bilayers). We show that we can detect a model anesthetic (ethanol) through its effect on the lipid phase behavior. Further, through the analysis of the overtone dependence of the phase transition parameters, we show that hydrodynamic effects are important in the case of adsorbed liposomes, and viscoelasticity is significant in supported bilayers, while layer thickness changes make up the strongest contribution in both systems.

On the interpretation of reflectivity data from lipid bilayers in terms of molecular-dynamics models

Neutron and X-ray reflectivity of model membranes is increasingly used as a tool for the study of membrane structures and dynamics. As the systems under study become more complex, and as long, all-atom molecular-dynamics (MD) simulations of membranes become more available, there is increasing interest in the use of MD simulations in the analysis of reflectometry data from membranes. In order to perform this, it is necessary to produce a model of the complete interface, including not only the MD-derived structure of the membrane, but also the supporting substrate and any other interfacial layers that may be present. Here, it is shown that this is best performed by first producing a model of the occupied volume across the entire interface, and then converting this into a scattering length density (SLD) profile, rather than by splicing together the separate SLD profiles from the substrate layers and the membrane, since the latter approach can lead to discontinuities in the SLD profile and subsequent artefacts in the reflectivity calculation. It is also shown how the MD-derived membrane structure should be corrected to account for lower than optimal coverage and out-of-plane membrane fluctuations. Finally, the method of including the entire membrane structure in the reflectivity calculation is compared with an alternative approach in which the membrane components are approximated by functional forms, with only the component volumes being extracted from the simulation. It is shown that using only the fragment volumes is insufficient for a typical neutron data set of a single deuteration measured at several water contrasts, and that either weighting the model by including more structural information from the fit, or a larger data set involving a range of deuterations, are required to satisfactorily define the problem.

An accurate in vitro model of the E. coli envelope

Gram-negative bacteria are an increasingly serious source of antibiotic-resistant infections, partly owing to their characteristic protective envelope. This complex, 20 nm thick barrier includes a highly impermeable, asymmetric bilayer outer membrane (OM), which plays a pivotal role in resisting antibacterial chemotherapy. Nevertheless, the OM molecular structure and its dynamics are poorly understood because the structure is difficult to recreate or study in vitro. The successful formation and characterization of a fully asymmetric model envelope using Langmuir-Blodgett and Langmuir-Schaefer methods is now reported. Neutron reflectivity and isotopic labeling confirmed the expected structure and asymmetry and showed that experiments with antibacterial proteins reproduced published in vivo behavior. By closely recreating natural OM behavior, this model provides a much needed robust system for antibiotic development.

An Accurate In Vitro Model of the E. coli Envelope

Gram‐negative bacteria are an increasingly serious source of antibiotic‐resistant infections, partly owing to their characteristic protective envelope. This complex, 20 nm thick barrier includes a highly impermeable, asymmetric bilayer outer membrane (OM), which plays a pivotal role in resisting antibacterial chemotherapy. Nevertheless, the OM molecular structure and its dynamics are poorly understood because the structure is difficult to recreate or study in vitro. The successful formation and characterization of a fully asymmetric model envelope using Langmuir–Blodgett and Langmuir–Schaefer methods is now reported. Neutron reflectivity and isotopic labeling confirmed the expected structure and asymmetry and showed that experiments with antibacterial proteins reproduced published in vivo behavior. By closely recreating natural OM behavior, this model provides a much needed robust system for antibiotic development.

Effect of divalent cation removal on the structure of gram-negative bacterial outer membrane models

The Gram-negative bacterial outer membrane (GNB-OM) is asymmetric in its lipid composition with a phospholipid-rich inner leaflet and an outer leaflet predominantly composed of lipopolysaccharides (LPS). LPS are polyanionic molecules, with numerous phosphate groups present in the lipid A and core oligosaccharide regions. The repulsive forces due to accumulation of the negative charges are screened and bridged by the divalent cations (Mg(2+) and Ca(2+)) that are known to be crucial for the integrity of the bacterial OM. Indeed, chelation of divalent cations is a well-established method to permeabilize Gram-negative bacteria such as Escherichia coli. Here, we use X-ray and neutron reflectivity (XRR and NR, respectively) techniques to examine the role of calcium ions in the stability of a model GNB-OM. Using XRR we show that Ca(2+) binds to the core region of the rough mutant LPS (RaLPS) films, producing more ordered structures in comparison to divalent cation free monolayers. Using recently developed solid-supported models of the GNB-OM, we study the effect of calcium removal on the asymmetry of DPPC:RaLPS bilayers. We show that without the charge screening effect of divalent cations, the LPS is forced to overcome the thermodynamically unfavorable energy barrier and flip across the hydrophobic bilayer to minimize the repulsive electrostatic forces, resulting in about 20% mixing of LPS and DPPC between the inner and outer bilayer leaflets. These results reveal for the first time the molecular details behind the well-known mechanism of outer membrane stabilization by divalent cations. This confirms the relevance of the asymmetric models for future studies of outer membrane stability and antibiotic penetration.