Exploring the intrinsic behaviour of multisite phosphorylation systems as part of signalling pathways

In distributive phosphorylation catalytic constants enable non-trivial dynamics

Ordered distributive double phosphorylation is a recurrent motif in intracellular signaling and control. It is either sequential (where the site phosphorylated last is dephosphorylated first) or cyclic (where the site phosphorylated first is dephosphorylated first). Sequential distributive double phosphorylation has been extensively studied and an inequality involving only the catalytic constants of kinase and phosphatase is known to be sufficient for multistationarity. As multistationarity is necessary for bistability it has been argued that these constants enable bistability. Here we show for cyclic distributive double phosphorylation that if its catalytic constants satisfy an analogous inequality, then Hopf bifurcations and hence sustained oscillations can occur. Hence we argue that in distributive double phosphorylation (sequential or distributive) the catalytic constants enable non-trivial dynamics. In fact, if the rate constant values in a network of cyclic distributive double phosphorylation satisfy this inequality, then a network of sequential distributive double phosphorylation with the same rate constant values will show multistationarity-albeit for different values of the total concentrations. For cyclic distributive double phosphorylation we further describe a procedure to generate rate constant values where Hopf bifurcations and hence sustained oscillations can occur. This may, for example, allow for an efficient sampling of oscillatory regions in parameter space. Our analysis is greatly simplified by the fact that it is possible to reduce the network of cyclic distributive double phosphorylation to what we call a network with a single extreme ray. We summarize key properties of these networks.

Cardiac myosin binding protein-C phosphorylation as a function of multiple protein kinase and phosphatase activities

Phosphorylation of cardiac myosin binding protein-C (cMyBP-C) is a determinant of cardiac myofilament function. Although cMyBP-C phosphorylation by various protein kinases has been extensively studied, the influence of protein phosphatases on cMyBP-C's multiple phosphorylation sites has remained largely obscure. Here we provide a detailed biochemical characterization of cMyBP-C dephosphorylation by protein phosphatases 1 and 2 A (PP1 and PP2A), and develop an integrated kinetic model for cMyBP-C phosphorylation using data for both PP1, PP2A and various protein kinases known to phosphorylate cMyBP-C. We find strong site-specificity and a hierarchical mechanism for both phosphatases, proceeding in the opposite direction of sequential phosphorylation by potein kinase A. The model is consistent with published data from human patients and predicts complex non-linear cMyBP-C phosphorylation patterns that are validated experimentally. Our results suggest non-redundant roles for PP1 and PP2A under both physiological and heart failure conditions, and emphasize the importance of phosphatases for cMyBP-C regulation.

Network regulation meets substrate modification chemistry

Biochemical networks are at the heart of cellular information processing. These networks contain distinct facets: (i) processing of information from the environment via cascades/pathways along with network regulation and (ii) modification of substrates in different ways, to confer protein functionality, stability and processing. While many studies focus on these factors individually, how they interact and the consequences for cellular systems behaviour are poorly understood. We develop a systems framework for this purpose by examining the interplay of network regulation (canonical feedback and feed-forward circuits) and multisite modification, as an exemplar of substrate modification. Using computational, analytical and semi-analytical approaches, we reveal distinct and unexpected ways in which the substrate modification and network levels combine and the emergent behaviour arising therefrom. This has important consequences for dissecting the behaviour of specific signalling networks, tracing the origins of systems behaviour, inference of networks from data, robustness/evolvability and multi-level engineering of biomolecular networks. Overall, we repeatedly demonstrate how focusing on only one level (say network regulation) can lead to profoundly misleading conclusions about all these aspects, and reveal a number of important consequences for experimental/theoretical/data-driven interrogations of cellular signalling systems.

A nested bistable module within a negative feedback loop ensures different types of oscillations in signaling systems

In this article, we consider a double phosphorylation cycle, a ubiquitous signaling component, having the ability to display bistability, a behavior strongly related to the existence of positive feedback loops. If this component is connected to other signaling elements, it very likely undergoes some sort of protein-protein interaction. In several cases, these interactions result in a non-explicit negative feedback effect, leading to interlinked positive and negative feedbacks. This combination was studied in the literature as a way to generate relaxation-type oscillations. Here, we show that the two feedbacks together ensure two types of oscillations, the relaxation-type ones and a smoother type of oscillations functioning in a very narrow range of frequencies, in such a way that outside that range, the amplitude of the oscillations is severely compromised. Even more, we show that the two feedbacks are essential for both oscillatory types to emerge, and it is their hierarchy what determines the type of oscillation at work. We used bifurcation analyses and amplitude vs. frequency curves to characterize and classify the oscillations. We also applied the same ideas to another simple model, with the goal of generalizing what we learned from signaling models. The results obtained display the wealth of oscillatory dynamics that exists in a system with a bistable module nested within a negative feedback loop, showing how to transition between different types of oscillations and other dynamical behaviors such as excitability. Our work provides a framework for the study of other oscillatory systems based on bistable modules, from simple two-component models to more complex examples like the MAPK cascade and experimental cases like cell cycle oscillators.

Symmetry breaking meets multisite modification

Multisite modification is a basic way of conferring functionality to proteins and a key component of post-translational modification networks. Additional interest in multisite modification stems from its capability of acting as complex information processors. In this paper, we connect two seemingly disparate themes: symmetry and multisite modification. We examine different classes of random modification networks of substrates involving separate or common enzymes. We demonstrate that under different instances of symmetry of the modification network (invoked explicitly or implicitly and discussed in the literature), the biochemistry of multisite modification can lead to the symmetry being broken. This is shown computationally and consolidated analytically, revealing parameter regions where this can (and in fact does) happen, and characteristics of the symmetry-broken state. We discuss the relevance of these results in situations where exact symmetry is not present. Overall, through our study we show how symmetry breaking (i) can confer new capabilities to protein networks, including concentration robustness of different combinations of species (in conjunction with multiple steady states); (ii) could have been the basis for ordering of multisite modification, which is widely observed in cells; (iii) can significantly impact information processing in multisite modification and in cell signalling networks/pathways where multisite modification is present; and (iv) can be a fruitful new angle for engineering in synthetic biology and chemistry. All in all, the emerging conceptual synthesis provides a new vantage point for the elucidation and the engineering of molecular systems at the junction of chemical and biological systems.

Proteins help our cells perform the chemical reactions necessary for life. Once proteins are made, they can also be modified in different ways. This can simply change their activity, or otherwise make them better suited for their specific jobs within the cell. Biological ‘catalysts’ called enzymes carry out protein modifications by reversibly adding (or removing) chemical groups, such as phosphate groups.

‘Multisite modifications’ occur when a protein has two or more modifications in different areas, which can be added randomly or in a specific sequence. The combination of all the modifications attached to a protein acts like a chemical barcode and confers a specific function to the protein.

Modification networks add levels of complexity above individual proteins. These encompass not only the proteins in a cell or tissue, but also the different enzymes that can modify them, and how they all interact with each other. Although our knowledge of these networks is substantial, basic aspects, such as how the ordering of multisite modification systems emerges, is still not well understood.

Using a simple set of multisite modifications, Ramesh and Krishnan set out to study the potential mechanisms allowing the creation of order in this context. Symmetry is a pervasive theme across the sciences. In biology, symmetry and how it may be broken, is important to understand, for example, how organism develop. Ramesh and Krishnan used the perspective of symmetry in protein networks to uncover the origins of ordering.

First, mathematical models of simple modification networks were created based on their basic descriptions. This system centred on proteins that could have phosphate modifications at two possible sites. The network was ‘symmetric’, meaning that the rate of different sets of chemical reactions was identical, as were the amounts of all the enzymes involved.

Dissecting the simulated network using a variety of mathematical approaches showed that its initial symmetry could break, giving rise to sets of ordered multisite modifications. Breaking symmetry did not require any additional features or factors; the basic chemical ‘ingredients’ of protein modification were all that was needed. The prism of symmetry also revealed other aspects of these multisite modification networks, such as robustness and oscillations.

This study sheds new light on the mechanism behind ordering of protein modifications. In the future, Ramesh and Krishnan hope that this approach can be applied to the study of not just proteins but also a wider range of biochemical networks.

Exploring cyclic networks of multisite modification reveals origins of information processing characteristics

Multisite phosphorylation (and generally multisite modification) is a basic way of encoding substrate function and circuits/networks of post-translational modifications (PTM) are ubiquitous in cell signalling. The information processing characteristics of PTM systems are a focal point of broad interest. The ordering of modifications is a key aspect of multisite modification, and a broad synthesis of the impact of ordering of modifications is still missing. We focus on a basic class of multisite modification circuits: the cyclic mechanism, which corresponds to the same ordering of phosphorylation and dephosphorylation, and examine multiple variants involving common/separate kinases and common/separate phosphatases. This is of interest both because it is encountered in concrete cellular contexts, and because it serves as a bridge between ordered (sequential) mechanisms (representing one type of ordering) and random mechanisms (which have no ordering). We show that bistability and biphasic dose response curves of the maximally modified phosphoform are ruled out for basic structural reasons independent of parameters, while oscillations can result with even just one shared enzyme. We then examine the effect of relaxing some basic assumptions about the ordering of modification. We show computationally and analytically how bistability, biphasic responses and oscillations can be generated by minimal augmentations to the cyclic mechanism even when these augmentations involved reactions operating in the unsaturated limit. All in all, using this approach we demonstrate (1) how the cyclic mechanism (with single augmentations) represents a modification circuit using minimal ingredients (in terms of shared enzymes and sequestration of enzymes) to generate bistability and oscillations, when compared to other mechanisms, (2) new design principles for rationally designing PTM systems for a variety of behaviour, (3) a basis and a necessary step for understanding the origins and robustness of behaviour observed in basic multisite modification systems.

Relevance and proteomics challenge of functional posttranslational modifications in Kinetoplastid parasites

Protozoan parasitic infections are health, social and economic issues impacting both humans and animals, with significant morbidity and mortality worldwide. Protozoan parasites have complicated life cycles with both intracellular and extracellular forms. As a consequence, protozoan adapt to changing environments in part through a dynamic enzyme-catalyzed process leading to reversible posttranslational modifications (PTMs). The characterization by proteomics approaches reveals the critical role of the PTMs of the proteins involved in host-pathogen interaction. The complexity of PTMs characterization is increased by the high diversity, stoichiometry, dynamic and also co-existence of several PTMs in the same moieties which crosstalk between them. Here, we review how to understand the complexity and the essential role of PTMs crosstalk in order to provide a new hallmark for vaccines developments, immunotherapies and personalized medicine. In addition, the importance of these motifs in the biology and biological cycle of kinetoplastid parasites is highlighted with key examples showing the potential to act as targets against protozoan diseases.