The phylogenetic position of enteromonads: a challenge for the present models of diplomonad evolution

Expanded gene and taxon sampling of diplomonads shows multiple switches to parasitic and free-living lifestyle

BACKGROUND

Diplomonads are anaerobic flagellates classified within Metamonada. They contain both host-associated commensals and parasites that reside in the intestinal tracts of animals, including humans (e.g., Giardia intestinalis), as well as free-living representatives that inhabit freshwater and marine anoxic sediments (e.g., Hexamita inflata). The evolutionary trajectories within this group are particularly unusual as the free-living taxa appear to be nested within a clade of host-associated species, suggesting a reversal from host-dependence to a secondarily free-living lifestyle. This is thought to be an exceedingly rare event as parasites often lose genes for metabolic pathways that are essential to a free-living life strategy, as they become increasingly reliant on their host for nutrients and metabolites. To revert to a free-living lifestyle would require the reconstruction of numerous metabolic pathways. All previous studies of diplomonad evolution suffered from either low taxon sampling, low gene sampling, or both, especially among free-living diplomonads, which has weakened the phylogenetic resolution and hindered evolutionary insights into this fascinating transition.

RESULTS

We sequenced transcriptomes from 1 host-associated and 13 free-living diplomonad isolates; expanding the genome scale data sampling for diplomonads by roughly threefold. Phylogenomic analyses clearly show that free-living diplomonads form several branches nested within endobiotic species. Moreover, the phylogenetic distribution of genes related to an endobiotic lifestyle suggest their acquisition at the root of diplomonads, while traces of these genes have been identified in free-living diplomonads as well. Based on these results, we propose an evolutionary scenario of ancestral and derived lifestyle transitions across diplomonads.

CONCLUSIONS

Free-living taxa form several clades nested within endobiotic taxa in our phylogenomic analyses, implying multiple transitions between free-living and endobiotic lifestyles. The evolutionary history of numerous virulence factors corroborates the inference of an endobiotic ancestry of diplomonads, suggesting that there have been several reversals to a free-living lifestyle. Regaining host independence may have been facilitated by a subset of laterally transferred genes. We conclude that the extant diversity of diplomonads has evolved from a non-specialized endobiont, with some taxa becoming highly specialized parasites, others becoming free-living, and some becoming capable of both free-living and endobiotic lifestyles.

Phylogenetic and morphological diversity of free-living diplomonads

Diplomonadida is a lineage of anaerobic protists belonging to Fornicata, Metamonada. Most diplomonads are endobiotic or parasitic, such as Giardia intestinalis, which is a famous human pathogen, but several free-living species exist as well. Although it has been proposed that the free-living diplomonads are descendants of endobiotic organisms and thus interesting from the evolutionary point of view, they have been largely neglected. We obtained 58 cultures of free-living diplomonads belonging to four genera (Hexamita, Trepomonas, Gyromonas, and Trimitus) and six strains of endobiotic diplomonads and analyzed their SSU rRNA gene sequences. We also studied light-microscopic morphology of selected strains and the ultrastructure of Trepomonas rotans for the first time. Our phylogenetic analysis showed that the genus Hexamita, and, possibly, also the genus Trepomonas, are polyphyletic. Trepomonas rotans, which may represent a novel genus, is unique among Diplomonadida by having the cell covered in scales. Our results suggest that the evolution of the endobiotic life style and cell organization in diplomonads is more complicated than previously thought.

Three monophyletic clusters in Retortamonas species isolated from vertebrates

Retortamonas spp. has been reported as an intestinal parasite among various host organisms, including humans; however, its intra-genus molecular diversity has not yet been elucidated. Haplotypes of the 18S small subunit ribosomal RNA locus (1836-1899 bp) of Retortamonas spp. from humans (n = 8), pigs (n = 6), dogs (n = 1), goats (n = 16), water buffalos (n = 23), cattle (n = 7), rats (n = 3), and chickens (n = 5) were analyzed with references isolated from non-human mammals, amphibians, and insects. Phylogenetic and network analyses revealed a statistically supported three cluster formation among the vertebrate-isolated haplotypes, while insect-isolated haplotypes were independently clustered with Chilomastix. In the clade of vertebrate isolates, assemblage A (amphibian genotype), which included the amphibian references, was addressed as an out-group of the other clusters. Assemblage B (mammalian and chicken genotype) included most haplotypes from various mammals including humans with the haplotypes isolated from a chicken. Human isolates were all classified into this assemblage, thus assemblage B might correspond to R. intestinalis. Assemblage C (bovine genotype), which included specific haplotypes from water buffalos and cattle, was addressed as a sister lineage of assemblage B. Among the diversified haplotypes of assemblage B, a specific haplotype, which was identified from multiple host mammals (humans, dogs, pigs, cattle, water buffalos, elks, goats, and rats), indicates the potential zoonotic transmission of the Retortamonas among them. The genotyping classification of retortamonads could contribute to a better understanding of its molecular epidemiology, especially among humans and related host organisms.

Ultrastructure and Molecular Phylogeny of Iotanema spirale gen. nov. et sp. nov., a New Lineage of Endobiotic Fornicata with Strikingly Simplified Ultrastructure

Fornicata (Metamonada) is a group of Excavata living in low-oxygen environments and lacking conventional mitochondria. It includes free-living Carpediemonas-like organisms from marine habitats and predominantly parasitic/commensal retortamonads and diplomonads. Current modest knowledge of biodiversity of Fornicata limits our ability to draw a complete picture of the evolutionary history in this group. Here, we report the discovery of a novel fornicate, Iotanema spirale gen. nov. et sp. nov., obtained from fresh feces of the gecko Phelsuma madagascariensis. Our phylogenetic analyses of the small subunit ribosomal RNA gene demonstrate that I. spirale is closely related to the free-living, marine strain PCS and the Carpediemonas-like organism Hicanonectes teleskopos within Fornicata. Iotanema spirale exhibits several features uncommon to fornicates, such as a single flagellum, a highly reduced cytoskeletal system, and the lack of the excavate ventral groove, but shares these characters with the poorly known genus Caviomonas. Therefore, I. spirale is accommodated within the family Caviomonadidae, which represents the third known endobiotic lineage of Fornicata. This study improves our understanding of character evolution within Fornicata when placed within the molecular phylogenetic context.

Large genomic differences between the morphologically indistinguishable diplomonads Spironucleus barkhanus and Spironucleus salmonicida

BACKGROUND

Microbial eukaryotes show large variations in genome structure and content between lineages, indicating extensive flexibility over evolutionary timescales. Here we address the tempo and mode of such changes within diplomonads, flagellated protists with two nuclei found in oxygen-poor environments. Approximately 5,000 expressed sequence tag (EST) sequences were generated from the fish commensal Spironucleus barkhanus and compared to sequences from the morphologically indistinguishable fish parasite Spironucleus salmonicida, and other diplomonads. The ESTs were complemented with sequence variation studies in selected genes and genome size determinations.

RESULTS

Many genes detected in S. barkhanus and S. salmonicida are absent in the human parasite Giardia intestinalis, the most intensively studied diplomonad. For example, these fish diplomonads show an extended metabolic repertoire and are able to incorporate selenocysteine into proteins. The codon usage is altered in S. barkhanus compared to S. salmonicida. Sequence variations were found between individual S. barkhanus ESTs for many, but not all, protein coding genes. Conversely, no allelic variation was found in a previous genome survey of S. salmonicida. This difference was confirmed by sequencing of genomic DNA. Up to five alleles were identified for the cloned S. barkhanus genes, and at least nineteen highly expressed S. barkhanus genes are represented by more than four alleles in the EST dataset. This could be explained by the presence of a non-clonal S. barkhanus population in the culture, by a ploidy above four, or by duplications of parts of the genome. Indeed, genome size estimations using flow cytometry indicated similar haploid genome sizes in S. salmonicida and G. intestinalis (approximately 12 Mb), whereas the S. barkhanus genome is larger (approximately 18 Mb).

CONCLUSIONS

This study indicates extensive divergent genome evolution within diplomonads. Genomic traits such as codon usage, frequency of allelic sequence variation, and genome size have changed considerably between S. barkhanus and S. salmonicida. These observations suggest that large genomic differences may accumulate in morphologically indistinguishable eukaryotic microbes.

Molecular phylogeny of diplomonads and enteromonads based on SSU rRNA, alpha-tubulin and HSP90 genes: implications for the evolutionary history of the double karyomastigont of diplomonads

BACKGROUND

Fornicata is a relatively recently established group of protists that includes the diplokaryotic diplomonads (which have two similar nuclei per cell), and the monokaryotic enteromonads, retortamonads and Carpediemonas, with the more typical one nucleus per cell. The monophyly of the group was confirmed by molecular phylogenetic studies, but neither the internal phylogeny nor its position on the eukaryotic tree has been clearly resolved.

RESULTS

Here we have introduced data for three genes (SSU rRNA, alpha-tubulin and HSP90) with a wide taxonomic sampling of Fornicata, including ten isolates of enteromonads, representing the genera Trimitus and Enteromonas, and a new undescribed enteromonad genus. The diplomonad sequences formed two main clades in individual gene and combined gene analyses, with Giardia (and Octomitus) on one side of the basal divergence and Spironucleus, Hexamita and Trepomonas on the other. Contrary to earlier evolutionary scenarios, none of the studied enteromonads appeared basal to diplokaryotic diplomonads. Instead, the enteromonad isolates were all robustly situated within the second of the two diplomonad clades. Furthermore, our analyses suggested that enteromonads do not constitute a monophyletic group, and enteromonad monophyly was statistically rejected in 'approximately unbiased' tests of the combined gene data.

CONCLUSION

We suggest that all higher taxa intended to unite multiple enteromonad genera be abandoned, that Trimitus and Enteromonas be considered as part of Hexamitinae, and that the term 'enteromonads' be used in a strictly utilitarian sense. Our result suggests either that the diplokaryotic condition characteristic of diplomonads arose several times independently, or that the monokaryotic cell of enteromonads originated several times independently by secondary reduction from the diplokaryotic state. Both scenarios are evolutionarily complex. More comparative data on the similarity of the genomes of the two nuclei of diplomonads will be necessary to resolve which evolutionary scenario is more probable.

Stable transformation of an episomal protein-tagging shuttle vector in the piscine diplomonad Spironucleus vortens

Background

Diplomonads are common free-living inhabitants of anoxic aquatic environments and are also found as intestinal commensals or parasites of a wide variety of animals. Spironucleus vortens is a putatively commensal diplomonad of angelfish that grows to high cell densities in axenic culture. Genomic sequencing of S. vortens is in progress, yet little information is available regarding molecular and cellular aspects of S. vortens biology beyond descriptive ultrastructural studies. To facilitate the development of S. vortens as an additional diplomonad experimental model, we have constructed and stably transformed an episomal plasmid containing an enhanced green fluorescent protein (GFP) tag, an AU1 epitope tag, and a tandem affinity purification (TAP) tag. This construct also contains selectable antibiotic resistance markers for both S. vortens and E. coli.

Results

Stable transformants of S. vortens grew relatively rapidly (within 7 days) after electroporation and were maintained under puromycin selection for over 6 months. We expressed the enhanced GFP variant, eGFP, under transcriptional control of the S. vortens histone H3 promoter, and visually confirmed diffuse GFP expression in over 50% of transformants. Next, we generated a histone H3::GFP fusion using the S. vortens conventional histone H3 gene and its native promoter. This construct was also highly expressed in the majority of S. vortens transformants, in which the H3::GFP fusion localized to the chromatin in both nuclei. Finally, we used fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) of the episomal plasmid to show that the transformed plasmid localized to only one nucleus/cell and was present at roughly 10–20 copies per nucleus. Because S. vortens grows to high densities in laboratory culture, it is a feasible diplomonad from which to purify native protein complexes. Thus, we also included a TAP tag in the plasmid constructs to permit future tagging and subsequent purification of protein complexes by affinity chromatography via a two-step purification procedure.

Conclusion

Currently, progress in protistan functional and comparative genomics is hampered by the lack of free-living or commensal protists in axenic culture, as well as a lack of molecular genetic tools with which to study protein function in these organisms. This stable transformation protocol combined with the forthcoming genome sequence allows Spironucleus vortens to serve as a new experimental model for cell biological studies and for comparatively assessing protein functions in related diplomonads such as the human intestinal parasite, Giardia intestinalis.

A genomic survey of the fish parasite Spironucleus salmonicida indicates genomic plasticity among diplomonads and significant lateral gene transfer in eukaryote genome evolution

BACKGROUND

Comparative genomic studies of the mitochondrion-lacking protist group Diplomonadida (diplomonads) has been lacking, although Giardia lamblia has been intensively studied. We have performed a sequence survey project resulting in 2341 expressed sequence tags (EST) corresponding to 853 unique clones, 5275 genome survey sequences (GSS), and eleven finished contigs from the diplomonad fish parasite Spironucleus salmonicida (previously described as S. barkhanus).

RESULTS

The analyses revealed a compact genome with few, if any, introns and very short 3' untranslated regions. Strikingly different patterns of codon usage were observed in genes corresponding to frequently sampled ESTs versus genes poorly sampled, indicating that translational selection is influencing the codon usage of highly expressed genes. Rigorous phylogenomic analyses identified 84 genes--mostly encoding metabolic proteins--that have been acquired by diplomonads or their relatively close ancestors via lateral gene transfer (LGT). Although most acquisitions were from prokaryotes, more than a dozen represent likely transfers of genes between eukaryotic lineages. Many genes that provide novel insights into the genetic basis of the biology and pathogenicity of this parasitic protist were identified including 149 that putatively encode variant-surface cysteine-rich proteins which are candidate virulence factors. A number of genomic properties that distinguish S. salmonicida from its human parasitic relative G. lamblia were identified such as nineteen putative lineage-specific gene acquisitions, distinct mutational biases and codon usage and distinct polyadenylation signals.

CONCLUSION

Our results highlight the power of comparative genomic studies to yield insights into the biology of parasitic protists and the evolution of their genomes, and suggest that genetic exchange between distantly-related protist lineages may be occurring at an appreciable rate in eukaryote genome evolution.

Cytogenetic evidence for diversity of two nuclei within a single diplomonad cell of Giardia

Giardia intestinalis is an ancient protist that causes the most commonly reported human diarrheal disease of parasitic origin worldwide. An intriguing feature of the Giardia cell is the presence of two morphologically similar nuclei, generally considered equivalent, in spite of the fact that their karyotypes are unknown. We found that within a single cell, the two nuclei differ both in the number and the size of chromosomes and that representatives of two major genetic groups of G. intestinalis possess different karyotypes. Odd chromosome numbers indicate aneuploidy of Giardia nuclei, and their stable occurrence is suggestive of a long-term asexuality. A semi-open type of Giardia mitosis excludes a chromosome interfusion between the nuclei. Differences in karyotype and DNA content, and cell cycle-dependent asynchrony are indicative of diversity of the two Giardia nuclei.

The Marine Pathogenic Genotype of Spironucleus barkhanus from Farmed Salmonids Redescribed as Spironucleus salmonicida n. sp

There are two genotypes of the diplomonad Spironucleus barkhanus. Based on sequence data from the small subunit ribosomal RNA gene the conspecificity of these two genotypes has been questioned. Therefore, we have sampled Spironucleus from 27 fish, representing 14 populations, five species, and four genera. Partial nucleotide sequences from the three genes; small subunit ribosomal DNA, glutamate dehydrogenase 1 and alpha-tubulin were compared. The pathogenic isolates of S. barkhanus, which causes systemic spironucleosis in Atlantic salmon, Chinook salmon, and Arctic charr, all farmed in sea water, were genetically very different from the commensal isolate found in wild freshwater populations of Arctic charr and grayling. The genetic distances between the genotypes were of the same magnitude as those separating species of Giardia. Based on these genetic and ecological data, the pathogenic genotype from farmed salmonids is described as a new species, Spironucleus salmonicida n. sp. Scanning and transmission electron microscopy showed no specific morphological or ultrastructural features distinguishing S. salmonicida n. sp. from S. barkhanus. The present study clearly demonstrates the value of applying genetics in identification of Spironucleus species. Phylogenetic analyses that included the isolates of S. salmonicida n. sp. did not change the phylogenetic relationship within the genus Spironucleus.

Evidence from SSU rRNA Phylogeny that Octomitus is a Sister Lineage to Giardia

Octomitus intestinalis is a diplomonad flagellate inhabiting the digestive tract of rodents and amphibians. Octomitus is of evolutionary interest because, based on ultrastructural characteristics, it is thought to be closely related to the morphologically derived genus Giardia, and together they have been proposed to make up the Giardiinae. In molecular trees of diplomonads, Giardia is the deepest branching lineage, so identifying a sister group to Giardia that is less derived would be informative. Octomitus is a logical candidate for this position, but unfortunately there are no molecular data from it, and it is not available in culture. To determine the position of Octomitus, and specifically test whether it is more closely related to Giardia than other diplomonads, we have isolated it directly from the caecum of wild mice and characterized its small subunit ribosomal RNA (SSU rRNA) gene. Phylogenetic analysis showed Octomitus to be the sister to Giardia with strong support, together occupying one side of the deepest split in the diplomonad tree.