Variable ability of rapid tests to detect Mycobacterium tuberculosis rpoB mutations conferring phenotypically occult rifampicin resistance

We compared the ability of commercial and non-commercial, phenotypic and genotypic rapid drug susceptibility tests (DSTs) to detect rifampicin resistance (RR)-conferring ‘disputed’ mutations frequently missed by Mycobacterium Growth Indicator Tube (MGIT), namely L430P, D435Y, L452P, and I491F. Strains with mutation S450L served as positive control while wild-types were used as negative control. Of the 38 mutant strains, 5.7% were classified as RR by MGIT, 16.2% by Trek Sensititre MYCOTB MIC plate, 19.4% by resazurin microtiter plate assay (REMA), 50.0% by nitrate reductase assay (NRA), and 62.2% by microscopic observation direct susceptibility testing (MODS). Reducing MGIT rifampicin concentration to 0.5 µg/ml, and/or increasing incubation time, enhanced detection of disputed mutations from 5.7% to at least 65.7%, particularly for mutation I491F (from 0.0 to 75.0%). Compared with MGIT at standard pre-set time with 0.25 µg/ml ECOFF as breakpoint, we found a statistically significant increase in the ability of MGIT to resolve disputed mutants and WT strains at extended incubation period of 15 and 21 days, with 0.5 µg/ml and 1 µg/ml ECOFF respectively. MODS detected 75.0% of the I491F strains and NRA 62.5%, while it was predictably missed by all molecular assays. Xpert MTB/RIF, Xpert Ultra, and GenoscholarTB-NTM + MDRTB detected all mutations within the 81 bp RR determining region. Only GenoType MTBDRplus version 2 missed mutation L430P in 2 of 11 strains. Phenotypic and genotypic DSTs varied greatly in detecting occult rifampicin resistance. None of these methods detected all disputed mutations without misclassifying wild-type strains.

Detection of a streptomycin-resistant Mycobacterium bovis strain through antitubercular drug susceptibility testing of Tunisian Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex isolates from cattle

Background

A rising isolation trend of drug-resistant M. bovis from human clinical cases is documented in the literature. Here we assessed Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex isolates from cattle for drug susceptibility by the gold standard agar proportion method and a simplified resazurin microtitre assay (d-REMA). A total of 38 M. tuberculosis complex strains, including M. bovis (n = 36) and M. caprae (n = 2) isolates, from cattle in Tunisia were tested against isoniazid, rifampin, streptomycin, ethambutol, kanamycin and pyrazinamide.

Results

M. caprae isolates were found to be susceptible to all test drugs. All M. bovis strains were resistant to pyrazinamide, as expected. In addition, one M. bovis isolate showed high-level resistance to streptomycin (MIC > 500.0 μg/ml). Concordant results with the two methods were found. The most common target genes associated with streptomycin resistance, namely the rrs, rpsL and gidB genes, were DNA sequenced. A non-synonymous mutation at codon 43 (K43R) was found in the rpsL gene. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first report describing the isolation of a streptomycin-resistant M. bovis isolate from animal origin.

Conclusions

Antitubercular drug susceptibility testing of M. bovis isolates from animals should be performed in settings where bTB is endemic in order to estimate the magnitude of the risk of drug-resistant tuberculosis transmission to humans.

A comparative study of phenotypic and genotypic first- and second-line drug resistance testing of Mycobacterium tuberculosis

This study aimed to evaluate the frequency of resistance to first- and second-line drugs using phenotypic and genotypic methods and its correlation with resistance-linked mutations in Mycobacterium tuberculosis (M. tb) isolated in Iran. Three different methods, including the indirect proportion method(PM), direct and indirect nitrate reductase assay(NRA), and direct sequencing were used to assess drug resistance. In this study, sensitivity, specificity, agreement, costs, and turnaround time of these methods were compared in 395 smear positive isolates. Compared to the PM, the NRA and the direct sequencing methods demonstrated higher specificity, sensitivity, and agreement for detection of all anti-tuberculosis drugs. The NRA had a short turnaround time and was more cost-effective than the other methods. Mutations in codon 531 in rpoB, 315 in katG, 18 in rpsL, and 306 in embB were associated with high-level resistance to the first-line drugs, and mutations in codon 94 in gyrA, and A1401G in rrs were correlated with resistance to the second-line drugs. We found that the NRA is a highly sensitive, specific, inexpensive, and rapid test with strong potential to be a useful and interesting alternative tool, particularly in low-income countries. In addition, these molecular data will be helpful for developing new molecular methods for detecting first- and second-line drug-resistant M. tb.

A systematic review of rapid drug susceptibility tests for multidrug-resistant tuberculosis using rifampin resistance as a surrogate

BACKGROUND

The emergence of multidrug-resistant tuberculosis (MDR-TB) has prompted the development of rapid drug susceptibility assays with a focus on rifampin in recent years. Systematic reviews with evaluation of predictive values for different assays are scarce.

METHOD

MEDLINE was searched on 6 September 2008 for English articles that contain concurrent original data for generating summary measures of sensitivity, specificity and likelihood ratios of rapid rifampin susceptibility assays.

RESULTS/CONCLUSIONS

Significant heterogeneity was found in likelihood ratios across studies of all assays except nitrate reductase assay and colorimetric assays. Although rapid assays are fairly reliable for ruling out MDR-TB, careful consideration of clinical risk factors is required before using these assays to rule in MDR-TB under different epidemiological settings.

Surrogate markers of infection: interrogation of the immune system

Infectious diseases remain the greatest causes of morbidity and mortality in global terms. As much of the burden occurs in the developing world, limited access to diagnostic testing has hampered the diagnosis and treatment of these conditions, while, in the developed world, the cost of managing infectious diseases remains considerable. Despite the size of the problem there remains an ongoing need for tests that improve diagnostic sensitivity and specificity, provide more rapid diagnoses, are available for point-of-care testing in remote regions, and can help inform therapeutic decision-making by identifying resistance patterns or patient outcomes. This article discusses the background to biomarker development for infectious diseases, some current assays that are providing useful information regarding the host's response to infection (using examples such as Cytomegalovirus and Mycobacterium tuberculosis), as well as likely future technologies and their limitations.

New and improved diagnostics for detection of drug-resistant pulmonary tuberculosis

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Tuberculosis (TB) remains a global emergency and continues to kill 1.7 million people globally each year. Drug-resistant TB is now well established throughout the world and most TB patients are not being screened for drug resistance due to lack of laboratory resources and rapid accurate point-of-care tests. Accurate and rapid diagnosis of TB and drug-resistant TB is of paramount importance in establishing appropriate clinical management and infection control measures. During the past decade, there have been significant advances in diagnostic technologies for TB and drug-resistant TB. The purpose of this article is to review the current data, recommendations and evidence base for these tests.

RECENT FINDINGS

Second-line drug susceptibility testing (DST) is complex and expensive. Automated liquid culture systems and molecular line probe assays are recommended by the WHO as the current 'gold standard' for first-line DST. Liquid culture DST for aminoglycosides, polypeptides and fluoroquinolones has been shown to have relatively good reliability and reproducibility for diagnosis of extensively drug-resistant TB; however, DST for other second-line drugs (ethionamide, prothionamide, cycloserine, terizidone, para-aminosalicylic acid, clofazimine, amoxicillin-clavulanate, clarithromycin, linezolid) is not recommended. Automated liquid culture systems are currently recommended by the WHO as the 'gold standard' for second-line DST.

SUMMARY

In this review, we describe the phenotypic and genotypic methods currently available for the diagnosis of TB and drug-resistant forms of Mycobacterium tuberculosis and discuss future prospects for TB diagnostics. Current technologies for the detection of drug resistant M. tuberculosis vary greatly in terms of turnaround time, cost and complexity. Ultimately, the 'holy grail' diagnostic for TB must fulfil all technical specifications for a good point-of-care test, screen for drug resistance concurrently and be adaptable to the various health system levels and to countries with diverse economic status and TB burden.