Efficient solutions of self-consistent mean field equations for dewetting and electrostatics in nonuniform liquids

A formula and numerical study on Ewald 1D summation

Ewald summation is famous for its successful applications in molecular simulations for systems under 2 dimensional periodic boundary condition (2D PBC, e.g., planar interfaces) and systems under 3D PBC (e.g., bulk). However, the extension to systems under 1D PBC (like porous structures and tubes) is largely hindered by the special functions in the formula. In this work, a simple approximation of Ewald 1D sum is introduced with its error rigorously controlled. To investigate the impacts on the efficiency and accuracy by different parts, a pairwise potential is calculated for a series of screening parameters ( α ) and radial distances ( ρ ) between two point charges. A mapping between the sum of trigonometric functions in Ewald 1D method and the sum of specific vectors further reveals the different converging speeds of different Fourier parts. When choosing α = 0.2 Å^-1 , it is appropriate to ignore the insignificant parts in the sum to accelerate the method.

Dielectric response with short-ranged electrostatics

The dielectric nature of polar liquids underpins much of their ability to act as useful solvents, but its description is complicated by the long-ranged nature of dipolar interactions. This is particularly pronounced under the periodic boundary conditions commonly used in molecular simulations. In this article, the dielectric properties of a water model whose intermolecular electrostatic interactions are entirely short-ranged are investigated. This is done within the framework of local molecular-field theory (LMFT), which provides a well-controlled mean-field treatment of long-ranged electrostatics. This short-ranged model gives a remarkably good performance on a number of counts, and its apparent shortcomings are readily accounted for. These results not only lend support to LMFT as an approach for understanding solvation behavior, but also are relevant to those developing interaction potentials based on local descriptions of liquid structure.

Local Molecular Field Theory for Nonequilibrium Systems

We provide a framework for extending equilibrium local molecular field (LMF) theory to a statistical ensemble evolving under a time-dependent applied field. In this context, the self-consistency of the original LMF equation is achieved dynamically, which provides an efficient method for computing the equilibrium LMF potential, in addition to providing the nonequilibrium generalization. As a concrete example, we investigate water confined between hydrophobic or charged walls, systems that are very sensitive to the treatment of long-ranged electrostatics. We then analyze confined water in the presence of a time-dependent applied electric field, generated by a sinusoidal or abrupt variation of the magnitudes of uniform charge densities on each wall. Very accurate results are found from the time-dependent LMF formalism even for strong static fields and for time-dependent systems that are driven far from equilibrium where linear response methods fail.

Analytic theory of finite-size effects in supercell modeling of charged interfaces

The Ewald3D sum with the tinfoil boundary condition (e3dtf) evaluates the electrostatic energy of a finite unit cell inside an infinitely periodic supercell. Although it has been used as a de facto standard treatment of electrostatics for simulations of extended polar or charged interfaces, the finite-size effect on simulated properties has yet to be fully understood. There is, however, an intuitive way to quantify the average effect arising from the difference between the e3dtf and Coulomb potentials on the response of mobile charges to contact surfaces with fixed charges and/or to an applied external electric field. Although any charged interface formed by mobile countercharges that compensate the fixed charges fluctuates upon a change in the acting electric field, the distance between a pair of oppositely charged interfaces is found to be nearly stationary, which allows an analytic finite-size correction to the amount of countercharges. Application of the theory to solvated electric double layers (insulator/electrolyte interfaces) predicts that the state of complete charge compensation is invariant with respect to solvent permittivities, which is confirmed by a proper analysis of simulation data in the literature.

Alchemical free energy calculations and umbrella sampling with local molecular field theory

Understanding the thermodynamic driving forces underlying any chemical process requires a description of the underlying free energy surface. However, computation of free energies is difficult, often requiring advanced sampling techniques. Moreover, these computations can be further complicated by the evaluation of any long-ranged interactions in the system of interest, such as Coulomb interactions in charged and polar media. Local molecular field theory is a promising approach to avoid many of the conceptual and computational difficulties associated with long-ranged interactions. We present frameworks for performing alchemical free energy calculations and non-Boltzmann sampling with local molecular field theory. We demonstrate that local molecular field theory can be used to perform these free energy calculations with accuracy comparable to traditional methodologies while eliminating the need for explicit treatment of long-ranged interactions in simulations.

On the connections and differences among three mean-field approximations: a stringent test

This letter attempts to clarify the meaning of three closely related mean-field approximations: random phase approximation (RPA), local molecular field (LMF) approximation, and symmetry-preserving mean-field (SPMF) approximation, and their use of reliability and validity in the field of theory and simulation of liquids when the long-ranged component of the intermolecular interaction plays an important role in determining density fluctuations and correlations. The RPA in the framework of classical density functional theory (DFT) neglects the higher order correlations in the bulk and directly applies the long-ranged part of the potential to correct the pair direct correlation function of the short-ranged system while the LMF approach introduces a nonuniform mimic system under a reconstructed static external potential that accounts for the average effect arising from the long-ranged component of the interaction. Furthermore, the SPMF approximation takes the viewpoint of LMF but instead instantaneously averages the long-ranged component of the potential over the degrees of freedom in the direction with preserved symmetry. The formal connections and the particular differences of the viewpoint among the three approximations are explained and their performances in producing structural properties of liquids are stringently tested using an exactly solvable model. We demonstrate that the RPA treatment often yields uncontrolled poor results for pair distribution functions of the bulk system. On the other hand, the LMF theory produces quite reasonably structural correlations when the pair distribution in the bulk is converted to the singlet particle distribution in the nonuniform system. It turns out that the SPMF approach outperforms the other two at all densities and under extreme conditions where the long-ranged component significantly contributes to the structural correlations.

Long-ranged contributions to solvation free energies from theory and short-ranged models

Long-standing problems associated with long-ranged electrostatic interactions have plagued theory and simulation alike. Traditional lattice sum (Ewald-like) treatments of Coulomb interactions add significant overhead to computer simulations and can produce artifacts from spurious interactions between simulation cell images. These subtle issues become particularly apparent when estimating thermodynamic quantities, such as free energies of solvation in charged and polar systems, to which long-ranged Coulomb interactions typically make a large contribution. In this paper, we develop a framework for determining very accurate solvation free energies of systems with long-ranged interactions from models that interact with purely short-ranged potentials. Our approach is generally applicable and can be combined with existing computational and theoretical techniques for estimating solvation thermodynamics. We demonstrate the utility of our approach by examining the hydration thermodynamics of hydrophobic and ionic solutes and the solvation of a large, highly charged colloid that exhibits overcharging, a complex nonlinear electrostatic phenomenon whereby counterions from the solvent effectively overscreen and locally invert the integrated charge of the solvated object.

Molecular insight into the dynamical adsorption behavior of nanoscale water droplets on a heterogeneous surface

A heterogeneous surface is constructed by adding one hydrophilic patch at the center of a hydrophobic surface, and the dynamical adsorption process of nanoscale water droplets is investigated adopting molecular dynamics simulations.

Symmetry-preserving mean field theory for electrostatics at interfaces

A novel method is developed for complex nonuniform electrostatics in computer simulations of molecular liquids at interfaces.

Relationship between local molecular field theory and density functional theory for non-uniform liquids

The local molecular field theory (LMF) developed by Weeks and co-workers has proved successful for treating the structure and thermodynamics of a variety of non-uniform liquids. By reformulating LMF in terms of one-body direct correlation functions we recast the theory in the framework of classical density functional theory (DFT). We show that the general LMF equation for the effective reference potential φ(R)(r) follows directly from the standard mean-field DFT treatment of attractive interatomic forces. Using an accurate (fundamental measures) DFT for the non-uniform hard-sphere reference fluid we determine φ(R)(r) for a hard-core Yukawa liquid adsorbed at a planar hard wall. In the approach to bulk liquid-gas coexistence we find the effective potentials exhibit rich structure that can include damped oscillations at large distances from the wall as well as the repulsive hump near the wall required to generate the low density "gas" layer characteristic of complete drying. We argue that it would be difficult to obtain the same level of detail from other (non-DFT based) implementations of LMF. LMF emphasizes the importance of making an intelligent division of the interatomic pair potential of the full system into a reference part and a remainder that can be treated in mean-field approximation. We investigate different divisions for an exactly solvable one-dimensional model where the pair potential has a hard-core plus a linear attractive tail. Results for the structure factor and the equation of state of the uniform fluid show that including a significant portion of the attraction in the reference system can be much more accurate than treating the full attractive tail in mean-field approximation. We discuss further aspects of the relationship between LMF and DFT.

A local entropic signature of specific ion hydration

Monovalent ion hydration entropies are analyzed via energetic partitioning of the potential distribution theorem free energy. Extensive molecular dynamics simulations and free energy calculations are performed over a range of temperatures to determine the electrostatic and van der Waals components of the entropy. The far-field electrostatic contribution is negative and small in magnitude, and it does not vary significantly as a function of ion size, consistent with dielectric models. The local electrostatic contribution, however, varies widely as a function of ion size; the sign yields a direct indication of the kosmotropic (strongly hydrated) or chaotropic (weakly hydrated) nature of the ion hydration. The results provide a thermodynamic signature for specific ion effects in hydration and are consistent with experiments that suggest minimal perturbations of water structure outside the first hydration shell. The hydration entropies are also examined in relation to the corresponding entropies for the isoelectronic rare gas pairs; an inverse correlation is observed, as expected from thermodynamic hydration data.