Biliverdin reductase-induced phytochrome chromophore deficiency in transgenic tobacco

Bilirubin Distribution in Plants at the Subcellular and Tissue Levels

In heterotrophs, heme degradation produces bilirubin, a tetrapyrrole compound that has antioxidant activity. In plants, heme is degraded in plastids and is believed to be converted to phytochromobilin rather than bilirubin. Recently, we used the bilirubin-inducible fluorescent protein UnaG to reveal that plants produce bilirubin via a non-enzymatic reaction with NADPH. In the present study, we used an UnaG-based live imaging system to visualize bilirubin accumulation in Arabidopsis thaliana and Nicotiana benthamiana at the organelle and tissue levels. In chloroplasts, bilirubin preferentially accumulated in the stroma, and the stromal bilirubin level increased upon dark treatment. Investigation of intracellular bilirubin distribution in leaves and roots showed that it accumulated mostly in plastids, with low levels detected in the cytosol and other organelles, such as peroxisomes, mitochondria and the endoplasmic reticulum. A treatment that increased bilirubin production in chloroplasts decreased the bilirubin level in peroxisomes, implying that a bilirubin precursor is transported between the two organelles. At the cell and tissue levels, bilirubin showed substantial accumulation in the root elongation region but little or none in the root cap and guard cells. Intermediate bilirubin accumulation was observed in other shoot and root tissues, with lower levels in shoot tissues. Our data revealed the distribution of bilirubin in plants, which has implications for the transport and physiological function of tetrapyrroles.

Loss of Biliverdin Reductase Increases Oxidative Stress in the Cyanobacterium Synechococcus sp. PCC 7002

Oxygenic photosynthesis requires metal-rich cofactors and electron-transfer components that can produce reactive oxygen species (ROS) that are highly toxic to cyanobacterial cells. Biliverdin reductase (BvdR) reduces biliverdin IXα to bilirubin, which is a potent scavenger of radicals and ROS. The enzyme is widespread in mammals but is also found in many cyanobacteria. We show that a previously described bvdR mutant of Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 contained a secondary deletion mutation in the cpcB gene. The bvdR gene from Synechococcus sp. PCC 7002 was expressed in Escherichia coli, and recombinant BvdR was purified and shown to reduce biliverdin to bilirubin. The bvdR gene was successfully inactivated in Synechococcus sp. PCC 7002, a strain that is naturally much more tolerant of high light and ROS than Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803. The bvdR mutant strain, BR2, had lower total phycobiliprotein and chlorophyll levels than wild-type cells. As determined using whole-cell fluorescence at 77 K, the photosystem I levels were also lower than those in wild-type cells. The BR2 mutant had significantly higher ROS levels compared to wild-type cells after exposure to high light for 30 min. Together, these results suggest that bilirubin plays an important role as a scavenger for ROS in Synechococcus sp. PCC 7002. The oxidation of bilirubin by ROS could convert bilirubin to biliverdin IXα, and thus BvdR might be important for regenerating bilirubin. These results further suggest that BvdR is a key component of a scavenging cycle by which cyanobacteria protect themselves from the toxic ROS byproducts generated during oxygenic photosynthesis.

Bilirubin is produced nonenzymatically in plants to maintain chloroplast redox status

Bilirubin, a potent antioxidant, is a product of heme catabolism in heterotrophs. Heterotrophs mitigate oxidative stress resulting from free heme by catabolism into bilirubin via biliverdin. Although plants also convert heme to biliverdin, they are generally thought to be incapable of producing bilirubin because they lack biliverdin reductase, the enzyme responsible for bilirubin biosynthesis in heterotrophs. Here, we demonstrate that bilirubin is produced in plant chloroplasts. Live-cell imaging using the bilirubin-dependent fluorescent protein UnaG revealed that bilirubin accumulated in chloroplasts. In vitro, bilirubin was produced nonenzymatically through a reaction between biliverdin and reduced form of nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate at concentrations comparable to those in chloroplasts. In addition, increased bilirubin production led to lower reactive oxygen species levels in chloroplasts. Our data refute the generally accepted pathway of heme degradation in plants and suggest that bilirubin contributes to the maintenance of redox status in chloroplasts.

Photomedicine based on heme-derived compounds

Photoimaging and phototherapy have become major platforms for the diagnosis and treatment of various health complications. These applications require a photosensitizer (PS) that is capable of absorbing light from a source and converting it into other energy forms for detection and therapy. While synthetic inorganic materials such as quantum dots and gold nanorods have been widely explored for their medical diagnosis and photodynamic (PDT) and photothermal (PTT) therapy capabilities, translation of these technologies has lagged, primarily owing to potential cytotoxicity and immunogenicity issues. Of the various photoreactive molecules, the naturally occurring endogenous compound heme, a constituent of red blood cells, and its derivatives, porphyrin, biliverdin and bilirubin, have shown immense potential as noteworthy candidates for clinically translatable photoreactive agents, as evidenced by previous reports. While porphyrin-based photomedicines have attracted significant attention and are well documented, research on photomedicines based on two other heme-derived compounds, biliverdin and bilirubin, has been relatively lacking. In this review, we summarize the unique photoproperties of heme-derived compounds and outline recent efforts to use them in biomedical imaging and phototherapy applications.

Guard-cell phytochromes impact seedling photomorphogenesis and rosette leaf morphology

Using a previously established transgenic approach to inactivate phytochrome chromophore synthesis in specific organs or tissues, we used a guard cell-specific promoter to induce phytochrome deficiencies in guard cells of Arabidopsis thaliana. Analyses of multiple homozygous lines depleted of phytochromes in stomatal guard cells indicated elongated hypocotyls specifically in red and far-red growth conditions. Furthermore, rosette leaves of adult plants with guard cell-specific phytochrome deficiencies showed enhanced serration compared to the wild-type Col-0 parent. Thus, we demonstrate that guard cell-localized phytochromes impact the inhibition of hypocotyl elongation, as well as leaf margin morphology of adult rosette leaves in A. thaliana.

Mesophyll-specific phytochromes impact chlorophyll light-harvesting complexes (LHCs) and non-photochemical quenching

Phytochromes regulate light-dependent plastid development and plant growth and development. Prior analyses demonstrated that phytochromes regulate expression of Sigma factor 2 (SIG2), which is involved in plastid transcription and coordinates expression of plastid- and nuclear-encoded genes involved in plastid development, as well as plant growth and development. Mutation of SIG2 impacts distinct aspects of photosynthesis, resulting in elevated levels of cyclic electron flow and nonphotochemical quenching (NPQ). As we initially identified SIG2 expression as misregulated in a line lacking phytochromes in mesophyll tissues (i.e., CAB3::pBVR lines), here we report on an investigation of whether photosynthetic parameters such as NPQ are also disrupted in CAB3::pBVR lines. We determined that a specific parameter of NPQ, i.e., energy-dependent quenching (qE) which is a rapidly induced photoprotective mechanism that dissipates stressful absorption of excess light energy during photosynthesis, is disrupted when mesophyll phytochromes are significantly depleted. The observed reduction in NPQ levels in strong CAB3::pBVR lines is associated with a reduction in the accumulation of Lhcb1 proteins and assembly or stability of light-harvesting complexes (LHCs), especially trimeric LHC. These results implicate mesophyll-localized phytochromes in a specific aspect of phytochrome-mediated NPQ, likely through regulation of chlorophyll synthesis and accumulation and the associated impacts on chlorophyll-protein complexes. This role is distinct from the impact of mesophyll phytochrome-dependent control of SIG2 and associated NPQ regulation.

Spatiotemporal Phytochrome Signaling during Photomorphogenesis: From Physiology to Molecular Mechanisms and Back

Light exposure results in distinct responses in specific seedling tissues during photomorphogenesis. Light promotes growth of cotyledons and leaves, as well as development and elongation of roots, whereas light inhibits elongation of hypocotyls. For distinct plant responses such as shade avoidance, far-red light or shifts in spectral light quality similarly have disparate impacts on distinct plant tissues, resulting in elongation of stems or petioles and a reduction in growth of leaf blades for many species. The physiological bases of such tissue- and organ-specific light responses were initially studied using localized irradiation of specific tissues and organs, or irradiation of dissected plant parts. These historical approaches were used to identify spatial-specific pools of photoreceptors responsible for regulating local, i.e., tissue- or organ-specific, or distal, i.e., interorgan, plant responses. The red/far-red responsive phytochromes have been the most widely studied among photoreceptors in this regard. Whereas, the spatial localization of photoreceptors regulating many tissue- or organ-specific light responses were identified, the underlying signaling networks responsible for mediating the observed responses have not been well defined. Recent approaches used to investigate the molecular bases of spatiotemporal light responses include selective irradiation of plants harboring mutations in specific photoreceptors, tissue-specific expression of photoreceptors, primarily in photoreceptor mutant backgrounds, or tissue-specific biochemical ablation of photoreceptor accumulation. Progressive integration of such approaches for regulating the availability of localized pools of phytochromes with the use of transcriptomic or proteomic analyses for assessing the genes or proteins which these spatially discrete pools of phytochrome regulate is yielding emergent insight into the molecular bases of spatiotemporal phytochrome signaling pathways responsible for regulating spatiotemporal light responses of which we have been aware of at the physiological level for decades. Here, I discuss historical and emerging approaches to elucidating spatiotemporal signaling mediated by phytochromes during photomorphogenesis.

Downstream effectors of light- and phytochrome-dependent regulation of hypocotyl elongation in Arabidopsis thaliana

Arabidopsis, like most plants, exhibits tissue-specific, light-dependent growth responses. Cotyledon and leaf growth and the accumulation of photosynthetic pigments are promoted by light, whereas hypocotyl growth is inhibited. The identification and characterization of distinct phytochrome-dependent molecular effectors that are associated with these divergent tissue-specific, light-dependent growth responses are limited. To identify phytochrome-dependent factors that impact the photoregulation of hypocotyl length, we conducted comparative gene expression studies using Arabidopsis lines exhibiting distinct patterns of phytochrome chromophore inactivation and associated disparate hypocotyl elongation responses under far-red (FR) light. A large number of genes was misregulated in plants lacking mesophyll-specific phytochromes relative to constitutively-deficient phytochrome lines. We identified and characterized genes whose expression is impacted by light and by phyA and phyB that have roles in the photoregulation of hypocotyl length. We characterized the functions of several identified target genes by phenotyping of T-DNA mutants. Among these genes is a previously uncharacterized LHE (LIGHT-INDUCED HYPOCOTYL ELONGATION) gene, which we show impacts light- and phytochrome-mediated regulation of hypocotyl elongation under red (R) and FR illumination. We describe a new approach for identifying genes involved in light- and phytochrome-dependent, tissue-specific growth regulation and confirmed the roles of three such genes in the phytochrome-dependent photoregulation of hypocotyl length.

Retrograde bilin signaling enables Chlamydomonas greening and phototrophic survival

The maintenance of functional chloroplasts in photosynthetic eukaryotes requires real-time coordination of the nuclear and plastid genomes. Tetrapyrroles play a significant role in plastid-to-nucleus retrograde signaling in plants to ensure that nuclear gene expression is attuned to the needs of the chloroplast. Well-known sites of synthesis of chlorophyll for photosynthesis, plant chloroplasts also export heme and heme-derived linear tetrapyrroles (bilins), two critical metabolites respectively required for essential cellular activities and for light sensing by phytochromes. Here we establish that Chlamydomonas reinhardtii, one of many chlorophyte species that lack phytochromes, can synthesize bilins in both plastid and cytosol compartments. Genetic analyses show that both pathways contribute to iron acquisition from extracellular heme, whereas the plastid-localized pathway is essential for light-dependent greening and phototrophic growth. Our discovery of a bilin-dependent nuclear gene network implicates a widespread use of bilins as retrograde signals in oxygenic photosynthetic species. Our studies also suggest that bilins trigger critical metabolic pathways to detoxify molecular oxygen produced by photosynthesis, thereby permitting survival and phototrophic growth during the light period.

Detection of spatial-specific phytochrome responses using targeted expression of biliverdin reductase in Arabidopsis

To regulate levels of holophytochrome in a spatial-specific manner and investigate the major sites of action of phytochromes during seedling development, we constructed transgenic Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) plant lines expressing plastid-targeted mammalian biliverdin IXalpha reductase (pBVR) under regulatory control of CAB3 and MERI5 promoters. Comparative photobiological and phenotypic analyses indicated that spatial-specific expression of pBVR led to the disruption of distinct subsets of phytochrome-regulated responses for different promoters. pBVR expression in photosynthetic tissues (CAB3::pBVR lines) had intermediate effects on chlorophyll accumulation, carotenoid production, anthocyanin synthesis, and leaf development responses in white-light conditions. CAB3::pBVR expression, however, resulted in distinctive phenotypes in far-red (FR) conditions. A number of FR high irradiance responses were disrupted in CAB::pBVR lines, including FR-dependent inhibition of hypocotyl elongation and stimulation of anthocyanin accumulation. By contrast, preferential expression of pBVR in the shoot apical meristem in MERI5::pBVR lines resulted in a phytochrome-deficient, leaf development phenotype under short-day growth conditions. These results implicate leaf-localized phytochrome A as having a unique role in regulating FR-mediated hypocotyl elongation and meristem- and/or leaf primordia-localized phytochromes as having a novel role in phytochrome-dependent responses. Taken together, these studies demonstrate the efficacy of selectively inactivating distinct phytochrome-mediated responses by regulated expression of BVR in transgenic plants, a novel means to investigate the sites of phytochrome photoperception and to regulate specifically light-mediated plant growth and development.

Spatial-specific phytochrome responses during de-etiolation in Arabidopsis thaliana

Photoreceptors exhibit complex regulation of many aspects of growth and development, including developmental-, spatial- and temporal-specific photoregulatory responses. Such diverse regulation has been noted for all major classes of photoreceptors in plants, including red/far-red (R/FR) absorbing phytochromes and blue/UV-A (B/UV-A) light-absorbing cryptochromes and phototropins. However, the most insight into spatiotemporal responses has been reported for phytochromes both at the physiological and, more recently, at the molecular levels. Through tissue-specific degradation of the phytochrome chromophore, my laboratory recently demonstrated that phytochromes exhibit light-dependent, spatiotemporal control over de-etiolation responses in Arabidopsis thaliana. Mesophyll-localized phytochrome A (phyA) controls numerous far-red high irradiance responses (FR-HIR) in Arabidopsis. Meristem- and/or leaf primordia-localized phytochromes are involved in the regulation of leaf development. In this addendum, I provide additional novel evidence for spatial-specific, blue-light-dependent signaling roles of phytochromes.

Light-independent phytochrome signaling mediated by dominant GAF domain tyrosine mutants of Arabidopsis phytochromes in transgenic plants

The photoreversibility of plant phytochromes enables continuous surveillance of the ambient light environment. Through expression of profluorescent, photoinsensitive Tyr-to-His mutant alleles of Arabidopsis thaliana phytochrome B (PHYB(Y276H)) and Arabidopsis phytochrome A (PHYA(Y242H)) in transgenic Arabidopsis plants, we demonstrate that photoconversion is not a prerequisite for phytochrome signaling. PHYB(Y276H)-expressing plants exhibit chromophore-dependent constitutive photomorphogenesis, light-independent phyB(Y276H) nuclear localization, constitutive activation of genes normally repressed in darkness, and light-insensitive seed germination. Fluence rate analyses of transgenic plants expressing PHYB(Y276H), PHYA(Y242H), and other Y(GAF) mutant alleles of PHYB demonstrate that a range of altered light-signaling activities are associated with mutation of this residue. We conclude that the universally conserved GAF domain Tyr residue, with which the bilin chromophore is intimately associated, performs a critical role in coupling light perception to signal transduction by plant phytochromes.

Modulation of flowering responses in different Nicotiana varieties

We have identified and characterized a FLOWERING PROMOTING FACTOR 1 ( FPF1 ) gene from tobacco ( NtFPF1 ). Over-expression of NtFPF1 leads to early flowering in the day-neutral tobacco Nicotiana tabacum cv. Hicks, and under inductive photoperiods also in the short-day Nicotiana tabacum cv. Hicks Maryland Mammoth ( MM ) tobacco and the long-day plant Nicotiana sylvestris . N. sylvestris wild-type plants remained in the rosette stage and never flowered under non-inductive short-days, whereas 35S:: NtFPF1 transgenic plants bolted but did not flower. However, if treated with gibberellins, transgenic N. sylvestris plants flowered much faster under non-inductive short days than corresponding wild type plants, indicating an additive effect of gibberellins and the NtFPF1 protein in flowering time control. The day-neutral wild type cv. Hicks and the short-day cv. Hicks MM plants exhibit an initial rosette stage, both under short- and long-days. In the transgenic lines, this rosette stage was completely abolished. Wild-type plants of cv. Hicks MM never flowered under long days; however, all transgenic lines over-expressing NtFPF1 flowered under this otherwise non-inductive photoperiod.

Misregulation of tetrapyrrole biosynthesis in transgenic tobacco seedlings expressing mammalian biliverdin reductase

Previous studies have established that the expression of mammalian biliverdin IXalpha reductase (BVR) in transgenic tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum cv. Maryland Mammoth) resulted in the loss of photoregulatory activity of all phytochromes together with a pronounced chlorophyll deficiency. This study was undertaken to assess the contribution of BVR-mediated alteration of tetrapyrrole metabolism to the observed phenotypes of BVR transgenic plants. BVR expression in dark-grown plants led to the reduced accumulation of protochlorophyllide and transcripts for the two committed enzymes for 5-aminolevulinic acid (ALA) synthesis despite the marked increased capacity for synthesis of ALA. Together with the observation that Mg-porphyrin accumulation in dark-grown seedlings treated with an iron chelator was unaffected by BVR expression, these results indicate that BVR diverts tetrapyrrole metabolism toward heme synthesis while also reducing heme levels to de-repress ALA synthesis. By contrast with dark-grown seedlings, light-grown BVR plants showed a marked inhibition of ALA synthesis compared with wild-type plants - a result that was correlated with the disappearance of the CHL I subunit of Mg-chelatase and an increase in heme oxygenase protein levels. As transcript levels of all tetrapyrrole biosynthetic genes tested were not strongly affected by BVR expression, these results implicate misregulated tetrapyrrole metabolism to be a major mechanism for BVR-dependent inhibition of chlorophyll biosynthesis in light-grown plants.

Photochromic chromopeptides derived from phycoerythrocyanin: biophysical and biochemical characterization

Truncated chromopeptides have been prepared from the small photo- and redox-switchable biliprotein alpha-phycoerythrocyanin (alpha-PEC). The native chromoprotein consists of a C-terminal globin domain containing the chromophore and the regulatory cysteins 98 and 99, and a two-helix (X,Y) N-terminal domain responsible for aggregation. Digestion with chymotrypsin-free trypsin leads to three chromopeptides, (N-30, N-33 and N-35), basically lacking the two N-terminal helices X and Y. The photo- and redox chemistry of the major product (N-33) is identical, qualitatively and quantitatively, to that of native alpha-PEC. A series of N- and C-terminally truncated polypeptides were expressed in E. coli and subjected to autocatalytic and enzymatic reconstitution with phycocyanobilin. Enzymatic reconstitution was possible with N-terminally truncated polypeptides up to 45 aa, while neither a more extensively shortened (N-63) peptide, nor two C-terminally shortened polypeptides could be reconstituted. All chromopeptides recovered from enzymatic reconstitution contained the native phycoviolobilin chromophore and showed the photochemical and redox reactivity of alpha-PEC, albeit quantitatively reduced in the N-45 chromopeptide.