Cell-type-specific expression of plant cytochrome c mRNA in developing flowers and roots

Coordination of plant mitochondrial biogenesis: keeping pace with cellular requirements

Plant mitochondria are complex organelles that carry out numerous metabolic processes related with the generation of energy for cellular functions and the synthesis and degradation of several compounds. Mitochondria are semiautonomous and dynamic organelles changing in shape, number, and composition depending on tissue or developmental stage. The biogenesis of functional mitochondria requires the coordination of genes present both in the nucleus and the organelle. In addition, due to their central role, all processes held inside mitochondria must be finely coordinated with those in other organelles according to cellular demands. Coordination is achieved by transcriptional control of nuclear genes encoding mitochondrial proteins by specific transcription factors that recognize conserved elements in their promoter regions. In turn, the expression of most of these transcription factors is linked to developmental and environmental cues, according to the availability of nutrients, light-dark cycles, and warning signals generated in response to stress conditions. Among the signals impacting in the expression of nuclear genes, retrograde signals that originate inside mitochondria help to adjust mitochondrial biogenesis to organelle demands. Adding more complexity, several nuclear encoded proteins are dual localized to mitochondria and either chloroplasts or the nucleus. Dual targeting might establish a crosstalk between the nucleus and cell organelles to ensure a fine coordination of cellular activities. In this article, we discuss how the different levels of coordination of mitochondrial biogenesis interconnect to optimize the function of the organelle according to both internal and external demands.

Mitoribosomal regulation of OXPHOS biogenesis in plants

The ribosome filter hypothesis posits that ribosomes are not simple non-selective translation machines but may also function as regulatory elements in protein synthesis. Recent data supporting ribosomal filtering come from plant mitochondria where it has been shown that translation of mitochondrial transcripts encoding components of oxidative phosphorylation complexes (OXPHOS) and of mitoribosomes can be differentially affected by alterations in mitoribosomes. The biogenesis of mitoribosome was perturbed by silencing of a gene encoding a small-subunit protein of the mitoribosome in Arabidopsis thaliana. As a consequence, the mitochondrial OXPHOS and ribosomal transcripts were both upregulated, but only the ribosomal proteins were oversynthesized, while the OXPHOS subunits were actually depleted. This finding implies that the heterogeneity of plant mitoribosomes found in vivo could contribute to the functional selectivity of translation under distinct conditions. Furthermore, global analysis indicates that biogenesis of OXPHOS complexes in plants can be regulated at different levels of mitochondrial and nuclear gene expression, however, the ultimate coordination of genome expression occurs at the complex assembly level.

Silencing of the nuclear RPS10 gene encoding mitochondrial ribosomal protein alters translation in arabidopsis mitochondria

Hardly anything is known about translational control of plant mitochondrial gene expression. Here, we provide evidence for differential translation of mitochondrial transcripts in Arabidopsis thaliana. We found that silencing of the nuclear RPS10 gene encoding mitochondrial ribosomal protein S10 disturbs the ratio between the small and large subunits of mitoribosomes, with an excess of the latter. Moreover, a portion of the small subunits are incomplete, lacking at least the S10 protein. rps10 cells also have an increased mitochondrial DNA copy number per cell, causing an upregulation of all mitochondrial transcripts. Mitochondrial translation is also altered so that it largely overrides the hyperaccumulation of transcripts, and as a consequence, only ribosomal proteins are oversynthesized, whereas oxidative phosphorylation subunits are downregulated. Expression of nuclear-encoded components of mitoribosomes and oxidative phosphorylation system (OXPHOS) complexes seems to be less affected. The ultimate coordination of expression of the nuclear and mitochondrial genomes occurs at the complex assembly level. These findings indicate that mitoribosomes can regulate gene expression by varying the efficiency of translation of mRNAs for OXPHOS and ribosomal proteins.

Mitochondrial proteome heterogeneity between tissues from the vegetative and reproductive stages of Arabidopsis thaliana development

Specialization of the mitochondrial proteome in Arabidopsis has the potential to underlie the roles of these organelles at different developmental time points and in specific organs; however, most research to date has been limited to studies of mitochondrial composition from a few vegetative tissue types. To provide further insight into the extent of mitochondrial heterogeneity in Arabidopsis, mitochondria isolated from six organ/cell types, leaf, root, cell culture, flower, bolt stem, and silique, were analyzed. Of the 286 protein spots on a 2-D gel of the mitochondrial proteome, the abundance of 237 spots was significantly varied between different samples. Identification of these spots revealed a nonredundant set of 83 proteins which were differentially expressed between organ/cell types, and the protein identification information can be analyzed in an integrated manner in an interactive fashion online. A number of mitochondrial protein spots were identified as being derived from the same genes in Arabidopsis but differed in their pI, indicating organ-specific variation in the post-translational modifications, or in their MW, suggesting differences in truncated mitochondrial products accumulating in different tissues. Comparisons of the proteomic data for the major isoforms with microarray analysis showed a positive correlation between mRNA and mitochondrial protein abundance and 60-90% concordance between changes in protein and transcript abundance. These analyses demonstrate that, while mitochondrial proteins are controlled transcriptionally by the nucleus, post-transcriptional regulation and/or post-translational modifications play a vital role in modulating the state or regulation of proteins in key biochemical pathways in plant mitochondria for specific functions. The integration of protein abundance and protein modification data with respiratory measurements, enzyme assays, and transcript data sets has allowed the identification of organ-enhanced differences in central carbon and amino acid metabolism pathways and provides ranked lists of mitochondrial proteins that are strongly transcriptionally regulated vs those whose abundance or activity is strongly influenced by a variety of post-transcriptional processes.

Combining proteomics of root and shoot mitochondria and transcript analysis to define constitutive and variable components in plant mitochondria

Mitochondria undertake respiration in plant cells, but through metabolic plasticity utilize differ proportions of substrates and deliver different proportions of products to cellular metabolic and biosynthetic pathways. In Arabidopsis the mitochondrial proteome from shoots and cell culture have been reported, but there has been little information on mitochondria in roots. We compare the root mitochondrial proteome with mitochondria isolated from photosynthetic shoots to define the role of protein abundance in these differences. The major differences observed were in the abundance and/or activities of enzymes in the TCA cycle and the mitochondrial enzymes involved in photorespiration. Metabolic pathways linked to TCA cycle and photorespiration were also altered, namely cysteine, formate and one-carbon metabolism, as well as amino acid metabolism focused on 2-oxoglutarate generation. Comparisons to microarray analysis of these same tissues showed a positive correlation between mRNA and mitochondrial protein abundance, but still ample evidence for the role of post-transcriptional processes in defining mitochondrial composition. Broader comparisons of transcript abundances for mitochondrial components across Arabidopsis tissues provided additional evidence for specialization of plant mitochondria, and clustering of these data in functional groups showed the constitutive vs variably expressed components of plant mitochondria.

Transcriptional coordination of the biogenesis of the oxidative phosphorylation machinery in plants

Publicly available microarray experiments were used to analyze Arabidopsis thaliana genes whose expression is correlated with that of nuclear genes encoding components of the oxidative phosphorylation machinery (OxPhos genes). This analysis indicated the existence of coordination in the expression of genes encoding components of the five respiratory complexes. For these genes, preferential expression was observed in anthers and roots, especially in the elongation zone, while reduced or very low relative expression was evident in leaves and mature pollen grains. A global induction of OxPhos genes by carbohydrates, photo-destruction of chloroplasts, inhibition of cellulose synthesis, release from dormancy and germination, among other conditions, was also observed. Cluster analysis of the response of Arabidopsis genes to a set of 15 treatments allowed the identification of DNA motifs, known as site II, that are frequently present in the upstream regions of genes with responses like those of OxPhos genes. Mutagenic analysis of site II motifs in several genes encoding respiratory chain components showed that they actively participate in transcription of these genes. We conclude that an important number of nuclear genes encoding components of the five respiratory complexes show coordinated expression under various circumstances, and that site II elements and the putative proteins that interact with them are, together with as yet unidentified factors, important actors in this coordinated response.

Development- and tissue-specific expression of the RpoT gene family of Arabidopsis encoding mitochondrial and plastid RNA polymerases

Arabidopsis thaliana possesses three RpoT genes which encode three different phage-type RNA polymerases with yet unknown function in organelle transcription: RpoTm and RpoTp, imported into mitochondria and plastids, respectively, and RpoTmp, co-targeted into both organelles. Expression of the RpoT genes was analyzed by quantitative RT-PCR, histochemical beta-glucuronidase (GUS) assays and in situ hybridization. Transcripts of all three RpoT genes accumulated to very low amounts in all organs. Surprisingly, RT-PCR revealed their highest levels in flower tissues. RpoTm transcripts were the most abundant in all organs, except mature leaves, in which RpoTp transcripts showed the highest accumulation. In the developing seedling, RpoTm::GUS and RpoTmp::GUS expression precedes that of RpoTp::GUS, the latter showing up only 7 days after germination. The RpoTm and RpoTmp promoters expressed GUS mainly in meristematic and mitochondria-rich cells such as the distal part of the root and companion cells flanking the phloem, whereas RpoTp::GUS activity was found in green tissues as the parenchyme cells of young leaves, the primary cortex of the stem, and sepals of buds and young flowers. Sites of GUS expression coincided spatially with those of in situ hybridization. Our data demonstrate an overlapping expression pattern of RpoTm and RpoTmp, and a completely differing pattern of RpoTp expression. The results suggest that RpoTm and RpoTmp recognize different types of mitochondrial promoters. The plastid polymerase RpoTp might play a major role in green tissue, i.e. in chloroplast transcription, whilst the dual-targeted RpoTmp in plastids should function mainly in the transcription of genes in non-green types.

Differential expression of the Arabidopsis cytochrome c genes Cytc-1 and Cytc-2. Evidence for the involvement of TCP-domain protein-binding elements in anther- and meristem-specific expression of the Cytc-1 gene

The promoters of the Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) cytochrome c genes, Cytc-1 and Cytc-2, were analyzed using plants transformed with fusions to the beta-glucuronidase coding sequence. Histochemical staining of plants indicated that the Cytc-1 promoter directs preferential expression in root and shoot meristems and in anthers. In turn, plants transformed with the Cytc-2 promoter fusions showed preferential expression in vascular tissues of cotyledons, leaves, roots, and hypocotyls, and also in anthers. Quantitative measurements in extracts prepared from different organs suggested that expression of Cytc-1 is higher in flowers, while that of Cytc-2 is higher in leaves. The analysis of a set of deletions and site-directed mutants of the Cytc-1 promoter indicated that a segment located between -147 and -156 from the translation start site is required for expression and that site II elements (TGGGCC/T) located in this region, coupled with a downstream internal telomeric repeat (AAACCCTAA), are responsible for the expression pattern of this gene. Proteins present in cauliflower nuclear extracts, as well as a recombinant protein from the TCP-domain family, were able to specifically bind to the region required for expression. We propose that expression of the Cytc-1 gene is linked to cell proliferation through the elements described above. The fact that closely located site II motifs are present in similar locations in several genes encoding proteins involved in cytochrome c-dependent respiration suggests that these elements may be the target of factors that coordinate the expression of nuclear genes encoding components of this part of the mitochondrial respiratory chain.

The leader intron of Arabidopsis thaliana genes encoding cytochrome c oxidase subunit 5c promotes high-level expression by increasing transcript abundance and translation efficiency

The involvement of regions located upstream of the translation start site in the expression of two Arabidopsis thaliana nuclear COX5c genes encoding subunit 5c of mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase has been analysed. It was observed that these regions, which include a leader intron, direct the tissue-specific expression of the gus reporter gene, mainly in root and shoot meristems, actively growing tissues and vascular strands. Expression was also observed in flowers, specifically localized in anthers, stigma, and the receptacle, and in developing seeds. GUS activity measurements in protein extracts from transformed plants indicated that expression levels are higher than those observed with the constitutive CaMV 35S promoter. Removal of the leader intron produced a significant decrease in expression to values only slightly higher than those observed with a promoterless gus gene. Histochemical staining of plants transformed with the intronless construct revealed expression only in pollen, suggesting that regulatory elements capable of directing pollen-specific expression are present upstream of the intron. The COX5c-2 intron also increased GUS expression levels when fused in the correct orientation with the promoter of the unrelated COX5b-1 gene. Comparison of GUS activity values with the transcript levels suggests that the intron also increases translation efficiency of the corresponding mRNA. The results obtained point to an essential role of the intron present in the 5'-non-coding region of all known COX5c genes in directing the expression of these genes in plants.

Cell-specific regulation of a Brassica napus CMS-associated gene by a nuclear restorer with related effects on a floral homeotic gene promoter

Cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS) is a maternally inherited defect in pollen production specified by novel mitochondrial genes. It can be suppressed by nuclear restorer (Rf) genes which normally downregulate expression of a CMS-associated novel mitochondrial gene. Two forms of Brassica napus CMS, nap and pol, are associated with related chimeric genes, orf222 and orf224, respectively. We show that in pol and nap CMS, anther locule development is asynchronous and asymmetric, that one or more locules within each anther may fail to develop entirely and that CMS anthers display polarity in locule development. We show, by in situ hybridization, that orf222 transcripts accumulate in sterile anthers prior to development of morphological differences between CMS and restored stamens, and remain preferentially localized to microsporangia. In fertility-restored anthers, however, orf222 transcript levels remain low throughout development. Some sporogenous and meiotic cells differentiate within CMS anthers and form functional pollen despite retaining high orf222 transcript levels, suggesting that the effect of orf222 expression in blocking pollen development is limited to an early and specific stage. Transcripts of other mitochondrial genes, exemplified by atp6 and cob, and of the nuclear-encoded ATP synthase gamma subunit, accumulate preferentially in the microsporangia of both sterile and fertile anthers. Thus nuclear fertility restoration reduces orf222 transcript levels in a gene and tissue-specific manner. We observe differences between CMS and fertile plants in the timing and patterning of APETALA3 promoter activity that suggest a possible basis for the developmental abnormalities of CMS flowers.

Nuclear SDH2-1 and SDH2-2 genes, encoding the iron-sulfur subunit of mitochondrial complex II in Arabidopsis, have distinct cell-specific expression patterns and promoter activities

Three different nuclear genes encode the essential iron-sulfur subunit of mitochondrial complex II (succinate dehydrogenase) in Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana), raising interesting questions about their origin and function. To find clues about their role, we have undertaken a detailed analysis of their expression. Two genes (SDH2-1 and SDH2-2) that likely arose via a relatively recent duplication event are expressed in all organs from adult plants, whereas transcripts from the third gene (SDH2-3) were not detected. The tissue- and cell-specific expression of SDH2-1 and SDH2-2 was investigated by in situ hybridization. In flowers, both genes are regulated in a similar way. Enhanced expression was observed in floral meristems and sex organ primordia at early stages of development. As flowers develop, SDH2-1 and SDH2-2 transcripts accumulate in anthers, particularly in the tapetum, pollen mother cells, and microspores, in agreement with an essential role of mitochondria during anther development. Interestingly, in contrast to the situation in flowers, only SDH2-2 appears to be expressed at a significant level in root tips. Strong labeling was observed in all cell layers of the root meristematic zone, and a cell-specific pattern of expression was found with increasing distance from the root tip, as cells attain their differentiated state. Analysis of transgenic Arabidopsis plants carrying SDH2-1 and SDH2-2 promoters fused to the beta-glucuronidase reporter gene indicate that both promoters have similar activities in flowers, driving enhanced expression in anthers and/or pollen, and that only the SDH2-2 promoter is active in root tips. These beta-glucuronidase staining patterns parallel those obtained by in situ hybridization, suggesting transcriptional regulation of these genes. Progressive deletions of the promoters identified regions important for SDH2-1 expression in anthers and/or pollen and for SDH2-2 expression in anthers and/or pollen and root tips. Interestingly, regions driving enhanced expression in anthers are differently located in the two promoters.

The advantages of cDNA microarray as an effective tool for identification of reproductive organ-specific genes in a model legume, Lotus japonicus

To understand the molecular mechanisms intrinsic to reproductive organ development a cDNA microarray, fabricated from flower bud cDNA clones, was used to isolate genes, which are specifically expressed during the development of the anther and pistil in Lotus japonicus. Cluster analysis of the microarray data revealed 21 and 111 independent cDNA groups, which were specifically expressed in immature and mature anthers, respectively. RT-PCR was performed to provide a direct assessment of the accuracy and reproducibility of our approach. Confirmation of our results suggests that cDNA microarray technology is an effective tool for identification of novel reproductive organ-specific genes.