Transfer of C(4) Photosynthetic Characters through Hybridization of Flaveria Species

On the hybrid origin of the C2 Salsola divaricata agg. (Amaranthaceae) from C3 and C4 parental lineages

C₂ photosynthesis is characterised using recapturing photorespiratory CO₂ by RuBisCo in Kranz-like cells and is therefore physiologically intermediate between C₃ and C₄ photosynthesis. C₂ can be interpreted as an evolutionary precursor of C₄ and/or as the result of hybridisation between a C₃ and C₄ lineage. We compared the expression of photosynthetic traits among populations of the Salsola divaricata agg. (C₂ ) from humid subtropical to arid habitats on the coasts of the Canary Islands and Morocco and subjected them to salt and drought treatments. We screened for enhanced C₄ -like expression of traits related to habitat or treatment. We estimated species trees with a transcriptome dataset of Salsoleae and explored patterns of gene tree discordance. With phylogenetic networks and hybridisation analyses we tested for the hybrid origin of the Salsola divaricata agg. We observed distinct independent variation of photosynthetic traits within and among populations and no clear evidence for selection towards C₄ -like trait expression in more stressful habitats or treatments. We found reticulation and gene tree incongruence in Salsoleae supporting a putative hybrid origin of the Salsola divaricata agg. C₂ photosynthesis in the Salsola divaricata agg. combines traits inherited from its C₃ and C₄ parental lineages and seems evolutionarily stable, possibly well adapted to a wide climatic amplitude.

Using breeding and quantitative genetics to understand the C4 pathway

Reducing photorespiration in C3 crops could significantly increase rates of photosynthesis and yield. One method to achieve this would be to integrate C4 photosynthesis into C3 species. This objective is challenging as it involves engineering incompletely understood traits into C3 leaves, including complex changes to their biochemistry, cell biology, and anatomy. Quantitative genetics and selective breeding offer underexplored routes to identify regulators of these processes. We first review examples of natural intraspecific variation in C4 photosynthesis as well as the potential for hybridization between C3 and C4 species. We then discuss how quantitative genetic approaches including artificial selection and genome-wide association could be used to better understand the C4 syndrome and in so doing guide the engineering of the C4 pathway into C3 crops.

C3 -C4 intermediates may be of hybrid origin - a reminder

The currently favoured model of the evolution of C₄ photosynthesis relies heavily on the interpretation of the broad phenotypic range of naturally growing C₃ -C₄ intermediates as proxies for evolutionary intermediate steps. On the other hand, C₃ -C₄ intermediates had earlier been interpreted as hybrids or hybrid derivates. By first comparing experimentally generated with naturally growing C₃ -C₄ intermediates, and second summarising either direct or circumstantial evidence for hybridisation in lineages comprising C₃ , C₄ and C₃ -C₄ intermediates, we conclude that a possible hybrid origin of C₃ -C₄ intermediates deserves careful examination. While we acknowledge that the current model of C₄ photosynthesis evolution is clearly the best available, C₃ -C₄ intermediates of hybrid origin, if existing, should not be used for further analysis of this model. However, experimental C₃  × C₄ hybrids potentially are excellent systems to analyse the genetic differences between C₃ and C₄ species and, also using segregating progeny, to study the relationship between individual photosynthetic traits and environmental factors.

Getting the most out of natural variation in C4 photosynthesis

C4 photosynthesis is a complex trait that has a high degree of natural variation, involving anatomical and biochemical changes relative to the ancestral C3 state. It has evolved at least 66 times across a variety of lineages and the evolutionary route from C3 to C4 is likely conserved but not necessarily genetically identical. As such, a variety of C4 species are needed to identify what is fundamental to the C4 evolutionary process in a global context. In order to identify the genetic components of C4 form and function, a number of species are used as genetic models. These include Zea mays (maize), Sorghum bicolor (sorghum), Setaria viridis (Setaria), Flaveria bidentis, and Cleome gynandra. Each of these species has different benefits and challenges associated with its use as a model organism. Here, we propose that RNA profiling of a large sampling of C4, C3-C4, and C3 species, from as many lineages as possible, will allow identification of candidate genes necessary and sufficient to confer C4 anatomy and/or biochemistry. Furthermore, C4 model species will play a critical role in the functional characterization of these candidate genes and identification of their regulatory elements, by providing a platform for transformation and through the use of gene expression profiles in mesophyll and bundle sheath cells and along the leaf developmental gradient. Efforts should be made to sequence the genomes of F. bidentis and C. gynandra and to develop congeneric C3 species as genetic models for comparative studies. In combination, such resources would facilitate discovery of common and unique C4 regulatory mechanisms across genera.

Evolution of C4 photosynthesis in the genus flaveria: establishment of a photorespiratory CO2 pump

C4 photosynthesis is nature's most efficient answer to the dual activity of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase and the resulting loss of CO(2) by photorespiration. Gly decarboxylase (GDC) is the key component of photorespiratory CO(2) release in plants and is active in all photosynthetic tissues of C(3) plants, but only in the bundle sheath cells of C(4) plants. The restriction of GDC to the bundle sheath is assumed to be an essential and early step in the evolution of C(4) photosynthesis, leading to a photorespiratory CO(2) concentrating mechanism. In this study, we analyzed how the P-protein of GDC (GLDP) became restricted to the bundle sheath during the transition from C(3) to C(4) photosynthesis in the genus Flaveria. We found that C(3) Flaveria species already contain a bundle sheath-expressed GLDP gene in addition to a ubiquitously expressed second gene, which became a pseudogene in C(4) Flaveria species. Analyses of C(3)-C(4) intermediate Flaveria species revealed that the photorespiratory CO(2) pump was not established in one single step, but gradually. The knowledge gained by this study sheds light on the early steps in C(4) evolution.

C4 cycles: past, present, and future research on C4 photosynthesis

In the late 1960s, a vibrant new research field was ignited by the discovery that instead of fixing CO(2) into a C(3) compound, some plants initially fix CO(2) into a four-carbon (C(4)) compound. The term C(4) photosynthesis was born. In the 20 years that followed, physiologists, biochemists, and molecular and developmental biologists grappled to understand how the C(4) photosynthetic pathway was partitioned between two morphologically distinct cell types in the leaf. By the early 1990s, much was known about C(4) biochemistry, the types of leaf anatomy that facilitated the pathway, and the patterns of gene expression that underpinned the biochemistry. However, virtually nothing was known about how the pathway was regulated. It should have been an exciting time, but many of the original researchers were approaching retirement, C(4) plants were proving recalcitrant to genetic manipulation, and whole-genome sequences were not even a dream. In combination, these factors led to reduced funding and the failure to attract young people into the field; the endgame seemed to be underway. But over the last 5 years, there has been a resurgence of interest and funding, not least because of ambitious multinational projects that aim to increase crop yields by introducing C(4) traits into C(3) plants. Combined with new technologies, this renewed interest has resulted in the development of more sophisticated approaches toward understanding how the C(4) pathway evolved, how it is regulated, and how it might be manipulated. The extent of this resurgence is manifest by the publication in 2011 of more than 650 pages of reviews on different aspects of C(4). Here, I provide an overview of our current understanding, the questions that are being addressed, and the issues that lie ahead.

Evolution of C4 photosynthesis in flaveria species. Isoforms Of nadp-malic enzyme

NADP-malic enzyme (NADP-ME, EC 1.1.1.40), a key enzyme in C4 photosynthesis, provides CO2 to the bundle-sheath chloroplasts, where it is fixed by ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase. We characterized the isoform pattern of NADP-ME in different photosynthetic species of Flaveria (C3, C3-C4 intermediate, C4-like, C4) based on sucrose density gradient centrifugation and isoelectric focusing of the native protein, western-blot analysis of the denatured protein, and in situ immunolocalization with antibody against the 62-kD C4 isoform of maize. A 72-kD isoform, present to varying degrees in all species examined, is predominant in leaves of C3 Flaveria spp. and is also present in stem and root tissue. By immunolabeling, NADP-ME was found to be mostly localized in the upper palisade mesophyll chloroplasts of C3 photosynthetic tissue. Two other isoforms of the enzyme, with molecular masses of 62 and 64 kD, occur in leaves of certain intermediates having C4 cycle activity. The 62-kD isoform, which is the predominant highly active form in the C4 species, is localized in bundle-sheath chloroplasts. Among Flaveria spp. there is a 72-kD constitutive form, a 64-kD form that may have appeared during evolution of C4 metabolism, and a 62-kD form that is necessary for the complete functioning of C4 photosynthesis.

Photosynthetic Characteristics of Segregates from Hybrids between Flaveria brownii (C4 Like) and Flaveria linearis (C3-C4)

Characteristics related to C4 photosynthesis were studied in reciprocal F1 hybrids and F2 plants from Flaveria brownii (C4 like) and Flaveria linearis (C3-C4). The reciprocal F1 plants differed in 13C/12C ratios of leaves and the percentage of 14C initially incorporated into C4 acids, being more like the pollen parents in these traits. They did not differ in apparent photosynthesis or in O2 inhibition of apparent photosynthesis and differed only slightly in CO2 compensation concentration at 175 [mu]mol quanta m-2 s-1 and 400 mL L-1 O2. The 13C/12C ratios of 78 F2 progeny from the two F1 plants exhibited a normal distribution centered between those of the parents, with a few values slightly higher and lower than the parents. Apparent photosynthesis at 130 [mu]L L-1 CO2 and inhibition of photosynthesis by O2 was nearly normally distributed in the F2 population, but no values for F2 plants approached those for F. brownii (15.4 [mu]mol m-2 s-1 and 7.8%, respectively). Distribution of the CO2 compensation concentration measured at 1000 [mu]mol quanta m-2 s-1 and 400 mL L-1 of O2 in the F2 population was skewed toward F. brownii with 72% of the progeny having values <9 [mu]L of CO2 L-1 compared to 1.5 and 27.2 [mu]L L-1 for F. brownii and F. linearis, respectively. Correlations among traits of F2 plants were low (coefficients of 0.30 to -0.49), indicating that the C4- related traits are not closely linked in segregating populations. Plants in the F2 population selected for high or low apparent photosynthesis at 130 [mu]L of CO2 L-1 (six each) did not rank consistently high or low for 13C/12C ratios, O2 inhibition of apparent photosynthesis, CO2 compensation concentration, or activities of phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase or NADP-malic enzyme. This study confirms results of earlier work that indicates independent segregation of C4 traits and also shows that the C4-like parental type can be recovered, at least for some characteristics (13C/12C ratio), in segregating populations. Recovery of fully functional C4 plants awaits further experimentation with C4 x C3 or C4 x C3-C4 hybrid plants that produce fertile progeny.

Degree of C(4) Photosynthesis in C(4) and C(3)-C(4)Flaveria Species and Their Hybrids : I. CO(2) Assimilation and Metabolism and Activities of Phosphoenolpyruvate Carboxylase and NADP-Malic Enzyme

The degree of C(4) photosynthesis was assessed in four hybrids among C(4), C(4)-like, and C(3)-C(4) species in the genus Flaveria using (14)C labeling, CO(2) exchange, (13)C discrimination, and C(4) enzyme activities. The hybrids incorporated from 57 to 88% of the (14)C assimilated in a 10-s exposure into C(4) acids compared with 26% for the C(3)-C(4) species Flaveria linearis, 91% for the C(4) species Flaveria trinervia, and 87% for the C(4)-like Flaveria brownii. Those plants with high percentages of (14)C initially fixed into C(4) acids also metabolized the C(4) acids quickly, and the percentage of (14)C in 3-phosphoglyceric acid plus sugar phosphates increased for at least a 30-s exposure to (12)CO(2). This indicated a high degree of coordination between the carbon accumulation and reduction phases of the C(4) and C(3) cycles. Synthesis and metabolism of C(4) acids by the species and their hybrids were highly and linearly correlated with discrimination against (13)C. The relationship of (13)C discrimination or (14)C metabolism to O(2) inhibition of photosynthesis was curvilinear, changing more rapidly at C(4)-like values of (14)C metabolism and (13)C discrimination. Incorporation of initial (14)C into C(4) acids showed a biphasic increase with increased activities of phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase and NADP-malic enzyme (steep at low activities), but turnover of C(4) acids was linearly related to NADP-malic enzyme activity. Several other traits were closely related to the in vitro activity of NADP-malic enzyme but not phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase. The data indicate that the hybrids have variable degrees of C(4) photosynthesis but that the carbon accumulation and reduction portions of the C(4) and C(3) cycles are well coordinated.

Degree of C(4) Photosynthesis in C(4) and C(3)-C(4)Flaveria Species and Their Hybrids : II. Inhibition of Apparent Photosynthesis by a Phosphoenolpyruvate Carboxylase Inhibitor

Hybrids have been made between species of Flaveria exhibiting varying levels of C(4) photosynthesis. The degree of C(4) photosynthesis expressed in four interspecific hybrids (Flaveria trinervia [C(4)] x F. linearis [C(3)-C(4)], F. brownii [C(4)-like] x F. linearis, and two three-species hybrids from F. trinervia x [F. brownii x F. linearis]) was estimated by inhibiting phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase in vivo with 3,3-dichloro-2-dihydroxyphosphinoylmethyl-2-propenoate (DCDP). The inhibitor was fed to detached leaves at a concentration of 4 mm, and apparent photosynthesis was measured at atmospheric levels of CO(2) and at 20 and 210 mL L(-1) of O(2). Photosynthesis at 210 mL L(-1) of O(2) was inhibited 32% by DCDP in F. linearis, by 60% in F. brownii, and by 87% in F. trinervia. Inhibition in the hybrids ranged from 38 to 52%. The inhibition of photosynthesis by 210 mL L(-1) of O(2) was increased when DCDP was used, except in the C(4) species, F. trinervia, in which photosynthesis was insensitive to O(2). Except for F. trinervia, control plants with less O(2) sensitivity (more C(4)-like) exhibited a progressively greater change in O(2) inhibition of photosynthesis when treated with DCDP. This increased O(2) inhibition probably resulted from decreased CO(2) concentrations in bundle sheath cells due to inhibition of phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase. The inhibition of photosynthesis by DCDP is concluded to underestimate the degree of C(4) photosynthesis in the interspecific hybrids because increased direct assimilation of atmospheric CO(2) by ribulose bisphosphate carboxylase may compensate for inhibition of phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase.

Comparative effects of growth irradiance on photosynthesis and leaf anatomy of Flaveria brownii (C4-like), Flaveria linearis (C 3-C 4) and their F 1 hybrid

Photosynthetic rates and related anatomical characteristics of leaves developed at three levels of irradiance (1200, 300 and 80 umol · m(-2) · s(-1)) were determined in the C4-like species Flaveria brownii A.M. Powell, the C3-C4-intermediate species F. linearis Lag., and the F1 hybrid between them (F. brownii × F. linearis). In the C3-C4 and F1 plants, increases in photosynthetic capacity per unit leaf area were strongly correlated with changes in mesophyll area per unit leaf area. The C4-like plant F. brownii, however, showed a much lower correlation between photosynthetic capacity and mesophyll area per unit leaf area. Plants of F. brownii developed at high irradiance showed photosynthetic rates per unit of mesophyll cell area 50% higher than those plants developed at medium irradiance. These results along with an increase in water-use efficiency are consistent with an increase of C4 photosynthesis in high-irradiance-grown F. brownii plants, whereas in the other two genotypes such plasticity seems to be absent. Photosynthetic discrimination against (13)C in the three genotypes was less at high than at low irradiance, with the greatest change occurring in F. brownii. Discrimination against (13)C expressed as δ (13)C was linearly correlated (r (2) = 0.81; P<0.001) with the ratio of bundle-sheath volume to mesophyll cell area when all samples from the three genotypes were combined. This tissue ratio increased for F. brownii and the F1 hybrid as growth irradiance increased, indicating a greater tendency towards Kranz anatomy. The results indicated that F. brownii had plasticity in its C4-related anatomical and physiological characteristics as a function of growth irradiance, whereas plasticity was less evident in the F1 hybrid and absent in F. linearis.

Leaf anatomical characteristics in Flaveria trinervia (C4), Flaveria brownii (C 4-like) and their F 1 hybrid

Several leaf anatomical and ultrastructural characteristics usually related with photosynthetic capacity were examined in two Flaveria species with strong differences in anatomy and their F1 hybrid. Flaveria trinervia (Spreng.) Mohr (C4) was the female parent and F. brownii A.M. Powell (C4-like) was the male parent. Quantitative anatomical analysis was made on transverse sections of leaves at both the light and electron microscope level. Four kinds of photosynthetic tissues were considered: bundle sheath (BS), mesophyll adjacent to the BS, mesophyll not adjacent to the BS, and larger spongy mesophyll cells. Flaveria trinvervia partitioned a larger proportion of its photosynthetic cells to BS and the mesophyll layer adjacent to BS and also possessed larger chloroplasts, especially in BS, than did F. brownii. These results suggest that although F. brownii is very C4-like, its anatomy is not as completely C4 as is the case for F. trinervia. In the F1 hybrid the relative contribution of the different tissues to the total photosynthetic tissue volume and area per unit leaf area was quite similar to that of F. trinervia. On the other hand, the chloroplast density and size of the F1 hybrid were fairly similar to those of F. brownii, especially in BS. Thus, there was no evidence of maternal inheritance in the chloroplast characteristics studied. A negative correlation (P<0.05) between chloroplast size and density was observed among species and relicates within each kind of tissue. This correlation was highest (r=-0.94, P<0.001) for the BS and when values were plotted on a logarithmic scale. Thus, higher chloroplast numbers for F. brownii and the F1 hybrid were offset by larger chloroplasts in F. trinervia. Less complete C4 photosynthesis in F. brownii may be partially due to incomplete development of Kranz anatomy usually associated with C4 photosynthesis.