A crystallization apparatus for temperature-controlled flow-cell dialysis with real-time visualization

Droplet-Based Evaporative System for the Estimation of Protein Crystallization Kinetics

Crystallization is a potential cost-effective alternative to chromatography for the purification of biotherapeutic proteins. Crystallization kinetics are required for the design and control of such processes, but only a limited quantity of proteins is available during the initial stage of process development. This article describes the design of a droplet-based evaporative system for the evaluation of candidate crystallization conditions and the estimation of kinetics using only a droplet (on the order of μL) of protein solution. The temperature and humidity of air fed to a flow cell containing the droplet are controlled for evaporation and rehydration of the droplet, which are used for manipulating supersaturation. Dual-angle images of the droplet are taken and analyzed on-line to obtain the droplet volume and crystal sizes. Crystallization kinetics are estimated based on a first-principles process model and experimental data. Tight control of temperature and humidity of the air, fast and accurate image analysis, and accurate estimation of crystallization kinetics are experimentally demonstrated for a model protein lysozyme. The estimated kinetics are suitable for the model-based design and control of protein crystallization processes.

Opportunities and challenges in neutron crystallography

Neutron and X-ray crystallography are complementary to each other. While X-ray scattering is directly proportional to the number of electrons of an atom, neutrons interact with the atomic nuclei themselves. Neutron crystallography therefore provides an excellent alternative in determining the positions of hydrogens in a biological molecule. In particular, since highly polarized hydrogen atoms (H+) do not have electrons, they cannot be observed by X-rays. Neutron crystallography has its own limitations, mainly due to inherent low flux of neutrons sources, and as a consequence, the need for much larger crystals and for different data collection and analysis strategies. These technical challenges can however be overcome to yield crucial structural insights about protonation states in enzyme catalysis, ligand recognition, as well as the presence of unusual hydrogen bonds in proteins.

Optimization of crystallization of biological macromolecules using dialysis combined with temperature control

A rational way to find the appropriate conditions to grow crystal samples for bio-crystallography is to determine the crystallization phase diagram, which allows precise control of the parameters affecting the crystal growth process. First, the nucleation is induced at supersaturated conditions close to the solubility boundary between the nucleation and metastable regions. Then, crystal growth is further achieved in the metastable zone - which is the optimal location for slow and ordered crystal expansion - by modulation of specific physical parameters. Recently, a prototype of an integrated apparatus for the rational optimization of crystal growth by mapping and manipulating temperature-precipitant-concentration phase diagrams has been constructed. Here, it is demonstrated that a thorough knowledge of the phase diagram is vital in any crystallization experiment. The relevance of the selection of the starting position and the kinetic pathway undertaken in controlling most of the final properties of the synthesized crystals is shown. The rational crystallization optimization strategies developed and presented here allow tailoring of crystal size and diffraction quality, significantly reducing the time, effort and amount of expensive protein material required for structure determination.

Prospects for membrane protein crystals in NMX

Adding hydrogen atoms and protonation states to structures of membrane proteins requires successful implementation of neutron macromolecular crystallography (NMX). This information would significantly increase our fundamental understanding of the transport processes membrane proteins undertake. To grow the large crystals needed for NMX studies requires significant amounts of stable protein, but once that challenge is overcome there is no intrinsic property of membrane proteins preventing the growth of large crystals per se. The calcium-transporting P-type ATPase (SERCA) has been thoroughly characterized biochemically and structurally over decades. We have extended our crystallization efforts to assess the feasibility of growing SERCA crystals for NMX-exploring microdialysis and capillary counterdiffusion crystallization techniques as alternatives to the traditional vapor diffusion crystallization experiment. Both methods possess crystallization dynamics favorable for maximizing crystal size and we used them to facilitate the growth of large crystals, validating these approaches for membrane protein crystallization for NMX.

A microfluidic device for both on-chip dialysis protein crystallization and in situ X-ray diffraction

This paper reports a versatile microfluidic chip developed for on-chip crystallization of proteins through the dialysis method and in situ X-ray diffraction experiments. A microfabrication process enabling the integration of regenerated cellulose dialysis membranes between two layers of the microchip is thoroughly described. We also describe a rational approach for optimizing on-chip protein crystallization via chemical composition and temperature control, allowing the crystal size, number and quality to be tailored. Combining optically transparent microfluidics and dialysis provides both precise control over the experiment and reversible exploration of the crystallization conditions. In addition, the materials composing the microfluidic chip were tested for their transparency to X-rays in order to assess their compatibility for in situ diffraction data collection. Background scattering was evaluated using a synchrotron X-ray source and the background noise generated by our microfluidic device was compared to that produced by commercial crystallization plates used for diffraction experiments at room temperature. Once crystals of 3 model proteins (lysozyme, IspE, and insulin) were grown on-chip, the microchip was mounted onto the beamline and partial diffraction data sets were collected in situ from several isomorphous crystals and were merged to a complete data set for structure determination. We therefore propose a robust and inexpensive way to fabricate microchips that cover the whole pipeline from crystal growth to the beam and does not require any handling of the protein crystals prior to the diffraction experiment, allowing the collection of crystallographic data at room temperature for solving the three-dimensional structure of the proteins under study. The results presented here allow serial crystallography experiments on synchrotrons and X-ray lasers under dynamically controllable sample conditions to be observed using the developed microchips.

Large crystal growth for neutron protein crystallography

The use of neutron protein crystallography (NPX) is expanding rapidly, with most structures determined in the last decade. This growth is stimulated by a number of developments, spanning from the building of new NPX beamlines to the availability of improved software for structure refinement. The main bottleneck preventing structural biologists from adding NPX to the suite of methods commonly used is the large volume of the individual crystals required for a successful experiment. A survey of deposited NPX structures in the Protein Data Bank shows that about two-thirds came from crystals prepared using vapor diffusion, while batch and dialysis-based methods all-together contribute to most of the remaining one-third. This chapter explains the underlying principles of these protein crystallization methods and provides practical examples that may help others to successfully prepare large crystals for NPX.

Perdeuteration, large crystal growth and neutron data collection of Leishmania mexicana triose-phosphate isomerase E65Q variant

Triose-phosphate isomerase (TIM) catalyses the interconversion of dihydroxyacetone phosphate and glyceraldehyde 3-phosphate. Two catalytic mechanisms have been proposed based on two reaction-intermediate analogues, 2-phosphoglycolate (2PG) and phosphoglycolohydroxamate (PGH), that have been used as mimics of the cis-enediol(ate) intermediate in several studies of TIM. The protonation states that are critical for the mechanistic interpretation of these structures are generally not visible in the X-ray structures. To resolve these questions, it is necessary to determine the hydrogen positions using neutron crystallography. Neutron crystallography requires large crystals and benefits from replacing all hydrogens with deuterium. Leishmania mexicana triose-phosphate isomerase was therefore perdeuterated and large crystals with 2PG and PGH were produced. Neutron diffraction data collected from two crystals with different volumes highlighted the importance of crystal volume, as smaller crystals required longer exposures and resulted in overall worse statistics.

Neutron macromolecular crystallography

Neutron diffraction techniques permit direct determination of the hydrogen (H) and deuterium (D) positions in crystal structures of biological macromolecules at resolutions of ∼1.5 and 2.5 Å, respectively. In addition, neutron diffraction data can be collected from a single crystal at room temperature without radiation damage issues. By locating the positions of H/D-atoms, protonation states and water molecule orientations can be determined, leading to a more complete understanding of many biological processes and drug-binding. In the last ca. 5 years, new beamlines have come online at reactor neutron sources, such as BIODIFF at Heinz Maier-Leibnitz Zentrum and IMAGINE at Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL), and at spallation neutron sources, such as MaNDi at ORNL and iBIX at the Japan Proton Accelerator Research Complex. In addition, significant improvements have been made to existing beamlines, such as LADI-III at the Institut Laue-Langevin. The new and improved instrumentations are allowing sub-mm3 crystals to be regularly used for data collection and permitting the study of larger systems (unit-cell edges >100 Å). Owing to this increase in capacity and capability, many more studies have been performed and for a wider range of macromolecules, including enzymes, signalling proteins, transport proteins, sugar-binding proteins, fluorescent proteins, hormones and oligonucleotides; of the 126 structures deposited in the Protein Data Bank, more than half have been released since 2013 (65/126, 52%). Although the overall number is still relatively small, there are a growing number of examples for which neutron macromolecular crystallography has provided the answers to questions that otherwise remained elusive.

What macromolecular crystallogenesis tells us - what is needed in the future

Crystallogenesis is a longstanding topic that has transformed into a discipline that is mainly focused on the preparation of crystals for practising crystallo-graphers. Although the idiosyncratic features of proteins have to be taken into account, the crystallization of proteins is governed by the same physics as the crystallization of inorganic materials. At present, a diversified panel of crystallization methods adapted to proteins has been validated, and although only a few methods are in current practice, the success rate of crystallization has increased constantly, leading to the determination of ∼105 X-ray structures. These structures reveal a huge repertoire of protein folds, but they only cover a restricted part of macromolecular diversity across the tree of life. In the future, crystals representative of missing structures or that will better document the structural dynamics and functional steps underlying biological processes need to be grown. For the pertinent choice of biologically relevant targets, computer-guided analysis of structural databases is needed. From another perspective, crystallization is a self-assembly process that can occur in the bulk of crowded fluids, with crystals being supramolecular assemblies. Life also uses self-assembly and supramolecular processes leading to transient, or less often stable, complexes. An integrated view of supramolecularity implies that proteins crystallizing either in vitro or in vivo or participating in cellular processes share common attributes, notably determinants and antideterminants that favour or disfavour their correct or incorrect associations. As a result, under in vivo conditions proteins show a balance between features that favour or disfavour association. If this balance is broken, disorders/diseases occur. Understanding crystallization under in vivo conditions is a challenge for the future. In this quest, the analysis of packing contacts and contacts within oligomers will be crucial in order to decipher the rules governing protein self-assembly and will guide the engineering of novel biomaterials. In a wider perspective, understanding such contacts will open the route towards supramolecular biology and generalized crystallogenesis.