Q|R: quantum-based refinement

Quantum refinement in real and reciprocal space using the Phenix and ORCA software

X-ray and neutron crystallography, as well as cryogenic electron microscopy (cryo-EM), are the most common methods to obtain atomic structures of biological macromolecules. A feature they all have in common is that, at typical resolutions, the experimental data need to be supplemented by empirical restraints, ensuring that the final structure is chemically reasonable. The restraints are accurate for amino acids and nucleic acids, but often less accurate for substrates, inhibitors, small-molecule ligands and metal sites, for which experimental data are scarce or empirical potentials are harder to formulate. This can be solved using quantum mechanical calculations for a small but interesting part of the structure. Such an approach, called quantum refinement, has been shown to improve structures locally, allow the determination of the protonation and oxidation states of ligands and metals, and discriminate between different interpretations of the structure. Here, we present a new implementation of quantum refinement interfacing the widely used structure-refinement software Phenix and the freely available quantum mechanical software ORCA. Through application to manganese superoxide dismutase and V- and Fe-nitrogenase, we show that the approach works effectively for X-ray and neutron crystal structures, that old results can be reproduced and structural discrimination can be performed. We discuss how the weight factor between the experimental data and the empirical restraints should be selected and how quantum mechanical quality measures such as strain energies should be calculated. We also present an application of quantum refinement to cryo-EM data for particulate methane monooxygenase and show that this may be the method of choice for metal sites in such structures because no accurate empirical restraints are currently available for metals.

AQuaRef: Machine learning accelerated quantum refinement of protein structures

Cryo-EM and X-ray crystallography provide crucial experimental data for obtaining atomic-detail models of biomacromolecules. Refining these models relies on library-based stereochemical restraints, which, in addition to being limited to known chemical entities, do not include meaningful noncovalent interactions relying solely on nonbonded repulsions. Quantum mechanical (QM) calculations could alleviate these issues but are too expensive for large molecules. We present a novel AI-enabled Quantum Refinement (AQuaRef) based on AIMNet2 neural network potential mimicking QM at substantially lower computational costs. By refining 41 cryo-EM and 30 X-ray structures, we show that this approach yields atomic models with superior geometric quality compared to standard techniques, while maintaining an equal or better fit to experimental data.

A radical approach to radicals

Nitroxide radicals are characterized by a long-lived spin-unpaired electronic ground state and are strongly sensitive to their chemical surroundings. Combined with electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy, these electronic features have led to the widespread application of nitroxide derivatives as spin labels for use in studying protein structure and dynamics. Site-directed spin labelling requires the incorporation of nitroxides into the protein structure, leading to a new protein-ligand molecular model. However, in protein crystallographic refinement nitroxides are highly unusual molecules with an atypical chemical composition. Because macromolecular crystallography is almost entirely agnostic to chemical radicals, their structural information is generally less accurate or even erroneous. In this work, proteins that contain an example of a radical compound (Chemical Component Dictionary ID MTN) from the nitroxide family were re-refined by defining its ideal structural parameters based on quantum-chemical calculations. The refinement results show that this procedure improves the MTN ligand geometries, while at the same time retaining higher agreement with experimental data.

Combining crystallography with quantum mechanics

In standard crystallographic refinement of biomacromolecules, the crystallographic raw data are supplemented by empirical restraints that ensure that the structure makes chemical sense. These restraints are typically accurate for amino acids and nucleic acids, but less so for cofactors, substrates, inhibitors, ligands and metal sites. In quantum refinement, this potential is replaced by more accurate quantum mechanical (QM) calculations. Several implementations have been presented, differing in the level of QM and whether it is used for the entire structure or only for a site of particular interest. It has been shown that the method can improve and correct errors in crystal structures and that it can be used to determine protonation and tautomeric states of various ligands and to decide what is really seen in the structure by refining different interpretations and using standard crystallographic and QM quality measures to decide which fits the structure best.

Multiscale Quantum Refinement Approaches for Metalloproteins

Biomolecules with metal ion(s) (e.g., metalloproteins) play many important biological roles. However, accurate structural determination of metalloproteins, particularly those containing transition metal ion(s), is challenging due to their complicated electronic structure, complex bonding of metal ions, and high number of conformations in biomolecules. Quantum refinement, which was proposed to combine crystallographic data with computational chemistry methods by several groups, can improve the local structures of some proteins. In this study, a quantum refinement method combining several multiscale computational schemes with experimental (X-ray diffraction) information was developed for metalloproteins. Various quantum refinement approaches using different ONIOM (our own N-layered integrated molecular orbital and molecular mechanics) combinations of quantum mechanics (QM), semiempirical (SE), and molecular mechanics (MM) methods were conducted to assess the performance and reliability on the refined local structure in two metalloproteins. The structures for two (Cu- or Zn-containing) metalloproteins were refined by combining two-layer ONIOM2(QM1/QM2) and ONIOM2(QM/MM) and three-layer ONIOM3(QM1/QM2/MM) schemes with experimental data. The accuracy of the quantum-refined metal binding sites was also examined and compared in these multiscale quantum refinement calculations. ONIOM3(QM/SE/MM) schemes were found to give good results with lower computational costs and were proposed to be a good choice for the multiscale computational scheme for quantum refinement calculations of metal binding site(s) in metalloproteins with high efficiency. Additionally, a two-center ONIOM approach was employed to speed up the quantum refinement calculations for the Zn metalloprotein with two remote active sites/ligands. Moreover, a recent quantum-embedding wavefunction-in-density functional theory (WF-in-DFT) method was also adopted as the high-level method in unprecedented ONIOM2(CCSD-in-B3LYP/MM) and ONIOM3(CCSD-in-B3LYP/SE/MM) calculations, which can be regarded as novel pseudo-three- and pseudo-four-layer ONIOM methods, respectively, to refine the key Zn binding site at the coupled-cluster singles and doubles (CCSD) level. These refined results indicate that multiscale quantum refinement schemes can be used to improve the structural accuracy obtained for local metal binding site(s) in metalloproteins with high efficiency.

The critical role of QM/MM X-ray refinement and accurate tautomer/protomer determination in structure-based drug design

Conventional protein:ligand crystallographic refinement uses stereochemistry restraints coupled with a rudimentary energy functional to ensure the correct geometry of the model of the macromolecule-along with any bound ligand(s)-within the context of the experimental, X-ray density. These methods generally lack explicit terms for electrostatics, polarization, dispersion, hydrogen bonds, and other key interactions, and instead they use pre-determined parameters (e.g. bond lengths, angles, and torsions) to drive structural refinement. In order to address this deficiency and obtain a more complete and ultimately more accurate structure, we have developed an automated approach for macromolecular refinement based on a two layer, QM/MM (ONIOM) scheme as implemented within our DivCon Discovery Suite and "plugged in" to two mainstream crystallographic packages: PHENIX and BUSTER. This implementation is able to use one or more region layer(s), which is(are) characterized using linear-scaling, semi-empirical quantum mechanics, followed by a system layer which includes the balance of the model and which is described using a molecular mechanics functional. In this work, we applied our Phenix/DivCon refinement method-coupled with our XModeScore method for experimental tautomer/protomer state determination-to the characterization of structure sets relevant to structure-based drug design (SBDD). We then use these newly refined structures to show the impact of QM/MM X-ray refined structure on our understanding of function by exploring the influence of these improved structures on protein:ligand binding affinity prediction (and we likewise show how we use post-refinement scoring outliers to inform subsequent X-ray crystallographic efforts). Through this endeavor, we demonstrate a computational chemistry ↔ structural biology (X-ray crystallography) "feedback loop" which has utility in industrial and academic pharmaceutical research as well as other allied fields.

Quantum-refinement studies of the bidentate ligand of V‑nitrogenase and the protonation state of CO-inhibited Mo‑nitrogenase

Nitrogenase is the only enzyme that can cleave the triple bond in N₂, making nitrogen available to plants (although the enzyme itself is strictly microbial). It has been studied extensively with both experimental and computational methods, but many details of the reaction mechanism are still unclear. X-ray crystallography is the main source of structural information for biomacromolecules, but it has problems to discern hydrogen atoms or to distinguish between elements with the same number of electrons. These problems can sometimes be alleviated by introducing quantum chemical calculations in the refinement, providing information about the ideal structure (in the same way as the empirical restraints used in standard crystallographic refinement) and comparing different interpretations of the structure with normal crystallographic and quantum mechanical quality measures. We have performed such quantum-refinement calculations to address two important issues for nitrogenase. First, we show that the bidentate ligand of the active-site FeV cluster in V‑nitrogenase is carbonate, rather than bicarbonate or nitrate. Second, we study the CO-inhibited structure of Mo‑nitrogenase. CO binds to a reduced and protonated state of the enzyme by replacing one of the sulfide ions (S2B) in the active-site FeMo cluster. We examined if it is possible to deduce from the crystal structure the location of the protons. Our results indicates that the crystal structure is best modelled as fully deprotonated.

Current and Future Challenges in Modern Drug Discovery

Drug discovery is an expensive, time-consuming, and risky business. To avoid late-stage failure, learnings from past projects and the development of new approaches are crucial. New modalities and emerging new target spaces allow the exploration of unprecedented indications or to address so far undrugable targets. Late-stage attrition is usually attributed to the lack of efficacy or to compound-related safety issues. Efficacy has been shown to be related to a strong genetic link to human disease, a better understanding of the target biology, and the availability of biomarkers to bridge from animals to humans. Compound safety can be improved by ligand optimization, which is becoming increasingly demanding for difficult targets. Therefore, new strategies include the design of allosteric ligands, covalent binders, and other modalities. Design methods currently heavily rely on artificial intelligence and advanced computational methods such as free energy calculations and quantum chemistry. Especially for quantum chemical methods, a more detailed overview is given in this chapter.

Real-space quantum-based refinement for cryo-EM: Q|R#3

Electron cryo-microscopy (cryo-EM) is rapidly becoming a major competitor to X-ray crystallography, especially for large structures that are difficult or impossible to crystallize. While recent spectacular technological improvements have led to significantly higher resolution three-dimensional reconstructions, the average quality of cryo-EM maps is still at the low-resolution end of the range compared with crystallography. A long-standing challenge for atomic model refinement has been the production of stereochemically meaningful models for this resolution regime. Here, it is demonstrated that including accurate model geometry restraints derived from ab initio quantum-chemical calculations (HF-D3/6-31G) can improve the refinement of an example structure (chain A of PDB entry 3j63). The robustness of the procedure is tested for additional structures with up to 7000 atoms (PDB entry 3a5x and chain C of PDB entry 5fn5) using the less expensive semi-empirical (GFN1-xTB) model. The necessary algorithms enabling real-space quantum refinement have been implemented in the latest version of qr.refine and are described here.

Quantum refinement with multiple conformations: application to the P-cluster in nitrogenase

X-ray crystallography is the main source of atomistic information on the structure of proteins. Normal crystal structures are obtained as a compromise between the X-ray scattering data and a set of empirical restraints that ensure chemically reasonable bond lengths and angles. However, such restraints are not always available or accurate for nonstandard parts of the structure, for example substrates, inhibitors and metal sites. The method of quantum refinement, in which these empirical restraints are replaced by quantum-mechanical (QM) calculations, has previously been suggested for small but interesting parts of the protein. Here, this approach is extended to allow for multiple conformations in the QM region by performing separate QM calculations for each conformation. This approach is shown to work properly and leads to improved structures in terms of electron-density maps and real-space difference density Z-scores. It is also shown that the quality of the structures can be gauged using QM strain energies. The approach, called ComQumX-2QM, is applied to the P-cluster in two different crystal structures of the enzyme nitrogenase, i.e. an Fe8S7Cys6 cluster, used for electron transfer. One structure is at a very high resolution (1.0 Å) and shows a mixture of two different oxidation states, the fully reduced PN state (Fe82+, 20%) and the doubly oxidized P2+ state (80%). In the original crystal structure the coordinates differed for only two iron ions, but here it is shown that the two states also show differences in other atoms of up to 0.7 Å. The second structure is at a more modest resolution, 2.1 Å, and was originally suggested to show only the one-electron oxidized state, P1+. Here, it is shown that it is rather a 50/50% mixture of the P1+ and P2+ states and that many of the Fe-Fe and Fe-S distances in the original structure were quite inaccurate (by up to 0.8 Å). This shows that the new ComQumX-2QM approach can be used to sort out what is actually seen in crystal structures with dual conformations and to give locally improved coordinates.

fragHAR: towards ab initio quantum-crystallographic X-ray structure refinement for polypeptides and proteins

The first ab initio aspherical structure refinement against experimental X-ray structure factors for polypeptides and proteins using a fragmentation approach to break up the protein into residues and solvent, thereby speeding up quantum-crystallographic Hirshfeld atom refinement (HAR) calculations, is described. It it found that the geometric and atomic displacement parameters from the new fragHAR method are essentially unchanged from a HAR on the complete unfragmented system when tested on dipeptides, tripeptides and hexapeptides. The largest changes are for the parameters describing H atoms involved in hydrogen-bond interactions, but it is shown that these discrepancies can be removed by including the interacting fragments as a single larger fragment in the fragmentation scheme. Significant speed-ups are observed for the larger systems. Using this approach, it is possible to perform a highly parallelized HAR in reasonable times for large systems. The method has been implemented in the TONTO software.

Including crystallographic symmetry in quantum-based refinement: Q|R#2

Three-dimensional structure models refined using low-resolution data from crystallographic or electron cryo-microscopy experiments can benefit from high-quality restraints derived from quantum-chemical methods. However, nonperiodic atom-centered quantum-chemistry codes do not inherently account for nearest-neighbor interactions of crystallographic symmetry-related copies in a satisfactory way. Here, these nearest-neighbor effects have been included in the model by expanding to a super-cell and then truncating the super-cell to only include residues from neighboring cells that are interacting with the asymmetric unit. In this way, the fragmentation approach can adequately and efficiently include nearest-neighbor effects. It has previously been shown that a moderately sized X-ray structure can be treated using quantum methods if a fragmentation approach is applied. In this study, a target protein (PDB entry 4gif) was partitioned into a number of large fragments. The use of large fragments (typically hundreds of atoms) is tractable when a GPU-based package such as TeraChem is employed or cheaper (semi-empirical) methods are used. The QM calculations were run at the HF-D3/6-31G level. The models refined using a recently developed semi-empirical method (GFN2-xTB) were compared and contrasted. To validate the refinement procedure for a non-P1 structure, a standard set of crystallographic metrics were used. The robustness of the implementation is shown by refining 13 additional protein models across multiple space groups and a summary of the refinement metrics is presented.

Fast and Accurate Quantum Crystallography: From Small to Large, from Light to Heavy

The coupling of the crystallographic refinement technique Hirshfeld atom refinement (HAR) with the recently constructed libraries of extremely localized molecular orbitals (ELMOs) gives rise to the new quantum-crystallographic method HAR-ELMO. This method is significantly faster than HAR but as accurate and precise, especially concerning the free refinement of hydrogen atoms from X-ray diffraction data, so that the first fully quantum-crystallographic refinement of a protein is presented here. However, the promise of HAR-ELMO exceeds large molecules and protein crystallography. In fact, it also renders possible electron-density investigations of heavy elements in small molecules and facilitates the detection and isolation of systematic errors from physical effects.

Macromolecular structure determination using X-rays, neutrons and electrons: recent developments in Phenix

Diffraction (X-ray, neutron and electron) and electron cryo-microscopy are powerful methods to determine three-dimensional macromolecular structures, which are required to understand biological processes and to develop new therapeutics against diseases. The overall structure-solution workflow is similar for these techniques, but nuances exist because the properties of the reduced experimental data are different. Software tools for structure determination should therefore be tailored for each method. Phenix is a comprehensive software package for macromolecular structure determination that handles data from any of these techniques. Tasks performed with Phenix include data-quality assessment, map improvement, model building, the validation/rebuilding/refinement cycle and deposition. Each tool caters to the type of experimental data. The design of Phenix emphasizes the automation of procedures, where possible, to minimize repetitive and time-consuming manual tasks, while default parameters are chosen to encourage best practice. A graphical user interface provides access to many command-line features of Phenix and streamlines the transition between programs, project tracking and re-running of previous tasks.

Refinement of protein structures using a combination of quantum-mechanical calculations with neutron and X-ray crystallographic data

Neutron crystallography is a powerful method to determine the positions of H atoms in macromolecular structures. However, it is sometimes hard to judge what would constitute a chemically reasonable model, and the geometry of H atoms depends more on the surroundings (for example the formation of hydrogen bonds) than heavy atoms, so that the empirical geometry information for the H atoms used to supplement the experimental data is often less accurate. These problems may be reduced by using quantum-mechanical calculations. A method has therefore been developed to combine quantum-mechanical calculations with joint crystallographic refinement against X-ray and neutron data. A first validation of this method is provided by re-refining the structure of the galectin-3 carbohydrate-recognition domain in complex with lactose. The geometry is improved, in particular for water molecules, for which the method leads to better-resolved hydrogen-bonding interactions. The method has also been applied to the active copper site of lytic polysaccharide monooxygenase and shows that the protonation state of the amino-terminal histidine residue can be determined.

Predicting protein-ligand binding affinity and correcting crystal structures with quantum mechanical calculations: lactate dehydrogenase A

Accurately computing the geometry and energy of host-guest and protein-ligand interactions requires a physically accurate description of the forces in action. Quantum mechanics can provide this accuracy but the calculations can require a prohibitive quantity of computational resources. The size of the calculations can be reduced by including only the atoms of the receptor that are in close proximity to the ligand. We show that when combined with log P values for the ligand (which can be computed easily) this approach can significantly improve the agreement between computed and measured binding energies. When the approach is applied to lactate dehydrogenase A, it can make quantitative predictions about conformational, tautomeric and protonation state preferences as well as stereoselectivity and even identifies potential errors in structures deposited in the Protein Data Bank for this enzyme. By broadening the evidence base for these structures from only the diffraction data, more chemically realistic structures can be proposed.

Quantum Crystallography: Current Developments and Future Perspectives

Crystallography and quantum mechanics have always been tightly connected because reliable quantum mechanical models are needed to determine crystal structures. Due to this natural synergy, nowadays accurate distributions of electrons in space can be obtained from diffraction and scattering experiments. In the original definition of quantum crystallography (QCr) given by Massa, Karle and Huang, direct extraction of wavefunctions or density matrices from measured intensities of reflections or, conversely, ad hoc quantum mechanical calculations to enhance the accuracy of the crystallographic refinement are implicated. Nevertheless, many other active and emerging research areas involving quantum mechanics and scattering experiments are not covered by the original definition although they enable to observe and explain quantum phenomena as accurately and successfully as the original strategies. Therefore, we give an overview over current research that is related to a broader notion of QCr, and discuss options how QCr can evolve to become a complete and independent domain of natural sciences. The goal of this paper is to initiate discussions around QCr, but not to find a final definition of the field.

Solving the scalability issue in quantum-based refinement: Q|R#1

Accurately refining biomacromolecules using a quantum-chemical method is challenging because the cost of a quantum-chemical calculation scales approximately as nm, where n is the number of atoms and m (≥3) is based on the quantum method of choice. This fundamental problem means that quantum-chemical calculations become intractable when the size of the system requires more computational resources than are available. In the development of the software package called Q|R, this issue is referred to as Q|R#1. A divide-and-conquer approach has been developed that fragments the atomic model into small manageable pieces in order to solve Q|R#1. Firstly, the atomic model of a crystal structure is analyzed to detect noncovalent interactions between residues, and the results of the analysis are represented as an interaction graph. Secondly, a graph-clustering algorithm is used to partition the interaction graph into a set of clusters in such a way as to minimize disruption to the noncovalent interaction network. Thirdly, the environment surrounding each individual cluster is analyzed and any residue that is interacting with a particular cluster is assigned to the buffer region of that particular cluster. A fragment is defined as a cluster plus its buffer region. The gradients for all atoms from each of the fragments are computed, and only the gradients from each cluster are combined to create the total gradients. A quantum-based refinement is carried out using the total gradients as chemical restraints. In order to validate this interaction graph-based fragmentation approach in Q|R, the entire atomic model of an amyloid cross-β spine crystal structure (PDB entry 2oNA) was refined.