Transthoracic cardiac stimulation thresholds for short pulses

Dosimetry for Ventricular Fibrillation Risk with Short Electrical Pulses: History and Future

Electrical safety limits for unidirectional pulses with short durations are increasingly important due to the proliferation of electric-car and factory energy storage systems with potentially dangerous voltages. Electrocution by a short-duration direct-current pulse is not understood as well as that by alternating current and the data are limited. The primary international guidance comes from IEC 60479-2 section 11.

METHODS

We have analyzed the dosimetry for short pulse safety limits based on a fuller understanding of the scientific principles involved and human data. Implantable defibrillators have been tested by externally delivering short-duration pulses giving us human data which we analyze for this paper.

RESULTS

The present IEC current limit (60479-2:11) for short pulse durations is based on an exponent of -0.68 in the equation I = d^-0.68, (d being pulse width), while the correct exponent should be -1.0 given the constant charge for the VF threshold of short pulses. We also propose a baseline charge value based on the human data.

CONCLUSIONS

Charge-based VF thresholds give the correct dosimetry for short-duration pulses. Results from this paper should be considered in support of revising the IEC 60479-2 standard section 11.

Transthoracic ventricular fibrillation charge thresholds

Standards, including IEC 60479-1 and -2, provide current-based ventricular fibrillation thresholds (VFT) for stimuli durations between 0.1 ms and 10 s. It has been established that the amount of electrical charge, not the current calculated by root-mean-square, is most representative of the effects of cardiac stimulation. There are no unified models that present transthoracic charge VFTs for a wide range of stimuli durations. This work proposes a new unified charge model applicable to transthoracic stimuli durations ranging over 1 μs - 300 s. VFTs were compiled from our previous animal work and from other published reports, including from the studies that provided the raw data for IEC 60479-1 and -2. Our study goal was to cover a wide range of stimuli durations, for which reliable data exists. Consistent data were found for stimuli durations covering the range of 1 μs - 300 s where VFTs were expressed as charge. The model predicted a transthoracic charge VFT of 1 mC at 1 μs duration. The charge VFT increased with stimulus duration and reached 10 C at 300 s. Presenting the first charge-based transthoracic VFT model covering stimuli durations over 1 μs - 300 s, we found 3 behavioral regions of charge VFT vs.

DURATION

For short stimuli durations, 1 μs - 10 ms, VFTs followed a classic Weiss charge strength-duration curve. For long stimuli, longer than 5 s, charge VFTs can be approximated using a 38 mArms constant current model. From 10 ms to 5 s, charge VFTs tracked through a transition zone that could be approximated as a constant charge model Q≈100 mC.

Validity of the small swine model for human electrical safety risks

Small swine are the most common model now used for electrical safety studies. Because of the significant anatomical and electrophysiological differences and the effect of animal size on the ventricular fibrillation (VF) threshold, there are concerns that these differences may exaggerate the risks of electrical devices to humans. We chose, as an illustrative and relevant example, swine studies of the TASER® conducted electrical weapon (CEW) as it has numerous published VF studies. We reviewed the published electrical swine safety studies for CEWs and compared them to finite element modeling studies, electrical safety standards, and epidemiological experience from field usage. We also compared the body weights of the swine to those of law enforcement arrest-related deaths. Studies of small swine exaggerate the risks of CEWs to humans. This conclusion may be extrapolated to suggest that the use of small swine for electrical safety studies should be questioned in general.