Heart Failure Phenotypes Require Sex-Specific Criteria Which Are Based on Ventricular Dimensions

Sex-specific Evaluation of Ventricular Ejection Fraction and End-Systolic Volume Applied to Cardiac Resynchronization Therapy

Cardiac resynchronization therapy (CRT) can decrease the risk of heart failure (HF) events in relatively asymptomatic patients with a reduced ejection fraction (EF) and wide QRS complex. However, individual response to this type of therapy varies widely. Often based on either EF increase or end-systolic volume (ESV) decrease as criterion, a subgroup of super-responders has been described. Therefore, it is important to determine factors that can predict a favorable response and identify those patients who may benefit from CRT. With this goal in mind we explored the possible role of ESV.To improve insight in ventricular pump function we previously introduced the volume regulation graph (VRG), relating ESV to end-diastolic volume (EDV). An individual patient is uniquely defined by the prevailing working point in the volume domain. The traditional metric EF can be graphically derived for each working point. The nonlinear association between EF and ESV is given by EF = 1 + γ {ESV / (δ - ESV)}, with empirical constants γ and δ. The impact of CRT super-responders on EF can be evaluated, taking into account sex-specific ESV values. Based on available regression equations we modeled the impact on EF (as percent points) resulting from CRT-induced fractional ESV changes expressed as % of baseline ESV. Our analysis confirms clinical findings, indicating that CRT super-responders are likely to be women, and clarify why a specific reduction of ESV cannot be directly translated into EF improvement. We propose that the EF as CRT criterion should be abandoned and replaced by sex-specific ESV evaluations.Clinical Relevance- Response to CRT should be evaluated in a sex-specific manner. The smaller heart size in women has implications for the interpretation of percentwise reductions of ESV and their translation into an associated increase of EF.

Ventricular and Atrial Ejection Fractions are Associated with Mean Compartmental Cavity Volume in Cardiac Disease

Ejection fraction (EF) is considered to provide clinically useful information. Despite its enormous popularity, with more than 75,000 citations in PubMed, only few studies have traced the origin(s) of its foundation. This fact is surprising, as there are perhaps more papers published that criticize EF, than the number of publications that actually provide a solid (mathematical) basis for its alleged applicability. EF depends on two volume determinations, namely end-systolic volume (ESV) and end-diastolic volume (EDV). EF is defined as 1-ESV/EDV, yielding a metric without physical units. Previously we formulated a robust analytical expression for the nonlinear connection between EF and ESV. Here we extend that approach by providing a formula to illustrate that EF is strongly associated with half the sum (HS) of ESV and EDV. HS is not new, but forms a major component in the recently introduced Global Function Index. For 420 heart failure (HF) patients we found for left ventricular angio data: R(ESV, eDv) = 0.92, R(EF, ESV) = -0.90, and R(EF, HS) = -0.65. For echo (33 HF patients stages A, B, C and D): R(EF, HS) = -0.82. For the right atrium (CMRI in 21 acute myocardial infarction patients): R(EF, HS)=-0.65. For the left atrium (N=86) R (EF, hS)=-0.46. ESV indicates the level to which the ventricle is able to squeeze blood out of the cavity via pressure build-up. In contrast, EF refers to relative volume changes, not to the mechanism of pumping action. We conclude that for each cardiac compartment EF borrows its acclaimed attractiveness from the fact that for a wide patient spectrum the ESVand EDV correlate in a fairly linear manner. Attractiveness of EF features a straightforward mathematical derivation, rather than reflecting underlying physiology. Clinical Relevance - Ejection fraction (EF) is found to reflect (mean) ventricular / atrial size, and is primarily associated with end-systolic volume, which variable in turn highly correlates with diastolic volume. As a mathematical construct, EF has little affinity with "function", which is a central concept in physiology.