Feasibility of Augmenting Ankle Exoskeleton Walking Performance With Step Length Biofeedback in Individuals With Cerebral Palsy

Predicting Steady-State Metabolic Power in Cerebral Palsy, Stroke, and the Elderly During Walking With and Without Assistive Devices

PURPOSE

Individuals with walking impairment, such as those with cerebral palsy, often face challenges in leading physically active lives due to the high energy cost of movement. Assistive devices like powered exoskeletons aim to alleviate this burden and improve mobility. Traditionally, optimizing the effectiveness of such devices has relied on time-consuming laboratory-based measurements of energy expenditure, which may not be feasible for some patient populations. To address this, our study aimed to enhance the state-of-the-art predictive model for estimating steady-state metabolic rate from 2-min walking trials to include individuals with and without walking disabilities and for a variety of terrains and wearable device conditions.

METHODS

Using over 200 walking trials collected from eight prior exoskeleton-related studies, we trained a simple linear machine learning model to predict metabolic power at steady state based on condition-specific factors, such as whether the trial was conducted on a treadmill (level or incline) or outdoors, as well as demographic information, such as the participant's weight or presence of walking impairment, and 2 minutes of metabolic data.

RESULTS

We demonstrated the ability to predict steady-state metabolic rate to within an accuracy of 4.71 ± 2.7% on average across all walking conditions and patient populations, including with assistive devices and on different terrains.

CONCLUSION

This work seeks to unlock the use of in-the-loop optimization of wearable assistive devices in individuals with limited walking capacity. A freely available MATLAB application allows other researchers to easily apply our model.

User experience of lower extremity exoskeletons and its improvement methodologies: A narrative review

In this review, user experience (UX) of recent lower limb exoskeletons (LLEs) and its improvement methodologies are investigated. First, statistics based on standardised and custom UX evaluations are presented. It is indicated that, LLE users have positive UX, especially in the aspects of safety, dimension and effectiveness. Further, overall, UX levels of ankle and hip-knee exoskeletons are higher than those of other exoskeleton types; unilateral LLEs have higher mean UX levels than that of the bilateral ones. Then, design practices for improving UX are studied; the focused points are burden reduction and improvement of device fit. The former is achieved through lightweight design and approaches that reduce device's moment of inertia (MOI) at mechanical joints. Works on the latter refer to the endeavours to enhance static and dynamic fit; they mainly rely on the optimisations of human-robot interface (HRS) and endeavours to rectify misalignment of axes of mechanical and anatomic joints, respectively. The following section is control approaches to enhance wearing comfort level; it is mainly focused on adaptive, interaction and compensation-based controls. Finally, existing problems and future directions are stated and prospected respectively.

Assistance force-line of exosuit affects ankle multidimensional motion: a theoretical and experimental study

BACKGROUND

The talocrural joint and the subtalar joint are the two major joints of the ankle-joint complex. The position and direction of the exosuit force line relative to these two joint axes can influence ankle motion. We aimed to understand the effects of different force-lines on ankle multidimensional motion.

METHODS

In this article, three assistance force line schemes for ankle exosuits were proposed: perpendicular to the talocrural joint axis (PT), intersecting with the subtalar joint axis (IS), and parallel to the triceps surae (PTS). A theoretical model was proposed to calculate the exosuit's assistance moment. Seven participants completed four experimental tests of ankle plantarflexion, including three passive motions assisted by the PT, PTS and IS schemes, and one active motion without exosuit assistance (Active).

RESULTS

The simulation results demonstrated that all three exosuits were able to produce significant moments of ankle plantarflexion. Among these, the PT scheme exhibited the highest moments in all dimensions, followed by the PTS and IS schemes. The experimental findings confirmed the effectiveness of all three exosuit schemes in assisting ankle plantarflexion. Additionally, as the assistive force lines approached the subtalar joint, there was a decrease in ankle motion assisted by the exosuits in non-plantarflexion directions, along with a reduction in the average distance of ankle angle curves relative to active ankle motion. Furthermore, the linear correlation coefficients between inversion and plantarflexion, adduction and plantarflexion, and adduction and inversion gradually converged toward active ankle plantarflexion motion.

CONCLUSIONS

Our research indicates that the position of the exosuit force line to the subtalar joint has a significant impact on ankle inversion and adduction. Among all three schemes, the IS, which has the closest distance to the subtalar joint axes, has the greatest kinematic similarity to active ankle plantarflexion and might be a better choice for ankle assistance and rehabilitation.

Journey to 1 Million Steps: A Retrospective Case Series Analyzing the Implementation of Robotic-Assisted Gait Training Into an Outpatient Pediatric Clinic

PURPOSE

To describe the implementation of an exoskeleton program in a rehabilitation setting using a Design Thinking framework.

METHODS

This is a retrospective case series of 3 randomly selected children who participated in skilled physical therapy using a pediatric exoskeleton that occurred on our journey to walking 1 000 000 steps in the exoskeleton devices. Participants ranged in age from 3 to 5 years, and all had neurologic disorders.

RESULTS

All participants improved toward achieving their therapy goals, tolerated the exoskeleton well, and had an increased number of steps taken over time.

CONCLUSION

The implementation of new technology into pediatric care and an established outpatient therapy clinic is described. The Design Thinking process applies to health care professionals and improves clinical care. Exoskeletons are effective tools for use in pediatric physical therapy.

Evaluation of controllers for augmentative hip exoskeletons and their effects on metabolic cost of walking: explicit versus implicit synchronization

Background: Efficient gait assistance by augmentative exoskeletons depends on reliable control strategies. While numerous control methods and their effects on the metabolic cost of walking have been explored in the literature, the use of different exoskeletons and dissimilar protocols limit direct comparisons. In this article, we present and compare two controllers for hip exoskeletons with different synchronization paradigms. Methods: The implicit-synchronization-based approach, termed the Simple Reflex Controller (SRC), determines the assistance as a function of the relative loading of the feet, resulting in an emerging torque profile continuously assisting extension during stance and flexion during swing. On the other hand, the Hip-Phase-based Torque profile controller (HPT) uses explicit synchronization and estimates the gait cycle percentage based on the hip angle, applying a predefined torque profile consisting of two shorter bursts of assistance during stance and swing. We tested the controllers with 23 naïve healthy participants walking on a treadmill at 4 km ⋅ h-1, without any substantial familiarization. Results: Both controllers significantly reduced the metabolic rate compared to walking with the exoskeleton in passive mode, by 18.0% (SRC, p < 0.001) and 11.6% (HPT, p < 0.001). However, only the SRC led to a significant reduction compared to walking without the exoskeleton (8.8%, p = 0.004). The SRC also provided more mechanical power and led to bigger changes in the hip joint kinematics and walking cadence. Our analysis of mechanical powers based on a whole-body analysis suggested a reduce in ankle push-off under this controller. There was a strong correlation (Pearson's r = 0.778, p < 0.001) between the metabolic savings achieved by each participant with the two controllers. Conclusion: The extended assistance duration provided by the implicitly synchronized SRC enabled greater metabolic reductions compared to the more targeted assistance of the explicitly synchronized HPT. Despite the different assistance profiles and metabolic outcomes, the correlation between the metabolic reductions with the two controllers suggests a difference in individual responsiveness to assistance, prompting more investigations to explore the person-specific factors affecting assistance receptivity.

Effects of ankle exoskeleton assistance and plantar pressure biofeedback on incline walking mechanics and muscle activity in cerebral palsy

Ankle dysfunction affects more than 50 % of people with cerebral palsy, resulting in atypical gait patterns that impede lifelong mobility. Incline walking requires increased lower limb effort and is a promising intervention that targets lower-limb extensor muscles. A concern when prescribing incline walking to people with gait deficits is that this exercise may be too challenging or reinforce unfavorable gait patterns. This study aims to investigate how ankle exoskeleton assistance and plantar pressure biofeedback would affect gait mechanics and muscle activity during incline walking in CP. We recruited twelve children and young adults with CP. Participants walked with ankle assistance alone, biofeedback alone, and the combination while we assessed ankle, knee, and hip mechanics, and plantar flexor and knee extensor activity. Compared to incline walking without assistance or biofeedback, ankle assistance alone reduced the peak biological ankle moment by 12 % (p < 0.001) and peak soleus activity by 8 % (p = 0.013); biofeedback alone increased the biological ankle moment (4 %, p = 0.037) and power (19 %, p = 0.012), and plantar flexor activities by 9 - 27 % (p ≤ 0.026); assistance-plus-biofeedback increased biological ankle and knee power by 34 % and 17 %, respectively (p ≤ 0.05). The results indicate that both ankle exoskeleton assistance and plantar pressure biofeedback can effectively modify lower limb mechanics and muscular effort during incline walking in CP. These techniques may help in establishing personalized gait training interventions by providing the ability to adjust intensity and biomechanical focus over time.

Audiovisual biofeedback amplifies plantarflexor adaptation during walking among children with cerebral palsy

BACKGROUND

Biofeedback is a promising noninvasive strategy to enhance gait training among individuals with cerebral palsy (CP). Commonly, biofeedback systems are designed to guide movement correction using audio, visual, or sensorimotor (i.e., tactile or proprioceptive) cues, each of which has demonstrated measurable success in CP. However, it is currently unclear how the modality of biofeedback may influence user response which has significant implications if systems are to be consistently adopted into clinical care.

METHODS

In this study, we evaluated the extent to which adolescents with CP (7M/1F; 14 [12.5,15.5] years) adapted their gait patterns during treadmill walking (6 min/modality) with audiovisual (AV), sensorimotor (SM), and combined AV + SM biofeedback before and after four acclimation sessions (20 min/session) and at a two-week follow-up. Both biofeedback systems were designed to target plantarflexor activity on the more-affected limb, as these muscles are commonly impaired in CP and impact walking function. SM biofeedback was administered using a resistive ankle exoskeleton and AV biofeedback displayed soleus activity from electromyography recordings during gait. At every visit, we measured the time-course response to each biofeedback modality to understand how the rate and magnitude of gait adaptation differed between modalities and following acclimation.

RESULTS

Participants significantly increased soleus activity from baseline using AV + SM (42.8% [15.1, 59.6]), AV (28.5% [19.2, 58.5]), and SM (10.3% [3.2, 15.2]) biofeedback, but the rate of soleus adaptation was faster using AV + SM biofeedback than either modality alone. Further, SM-only biofeedback produced small initial increases in plantarflexor activity, but these responses were transient within and across sessions (p > 0.11). Following multi-session acclimation and at the two-week follow-up, responses to AV and AV + SM biofeedback were maintained.

CONCLUSIONS

This study demonstrated that AV biofeedback was critical to increase plantarflexor engagement during walking, but that combining AV and SM modalities further amplified the rate of gait adaptation. Beyond improving our understanding of how individuals may differentially prioritize distinct forms of afferent information, outcomes from this study may inform the design and selection of biofeedback systems for use in clinical care.

Precision medicine in neurosurgery: The evolving role of theranostics

Theranostics in neurosurgery is a rapidly advancing field of precision medicine that combines diagnostic and therapeutic modalities to optimize patient outcomes. This approach has the potential to provide real-time feedback during therapy and diagnose a condition while simultaneously providing treatment. One such form of theranostics is focused ultrasound, which has been found to be effective in inducing neuroablation and neuromodulation and improving the efficacy of chemotherapy drugs by disrupting the blood-brain barrier. Targeted radionuclide therapy, which pairs positron emission tomography tracers with therapeutic effects and imaging modalities, is another promising form of theranostics for neurosurgery. Automated pathology analysis is yet another form of theranostics that can provide real-time feedback during the surgical resection of tumors. Electrical stimulation has also shown promise in optimizing therapies for patients with cerebral palsy. Overall, theranostics is a cost-effective way to optimize medical care for patients in neurosurgery. It is a relatively new field, but the advancements made so far show great promise for improving patient outcomes.

Advances on mechanical designs for assistive ankle-foot orthoses

Assistive ankle-foot orthoses (AAFOs) are powerful solutions to assist or rehabilitate gait on humans. Existing AAFO technologies include passive, quasi-passive, and active principles to provide assistance to the users, and their mechanical configuration and control depend on the eventual support they aim for within the gait pattern. In this research we analyze the state-of-the-art of AAFO and classify the different approaches into clusters, describing their basis and working principles. Additionally, we reviewed the purpose and experimental validation of the devices, providing the reader with a better view of the technology readiness level. Finally, the reviewed designs, limitations, and future steps in the field are summarized and discussed.

Recent advances in wearable actuated ankle-foot orthoses: Medical effects, design, and control

This paper presents a survey on recent advances of wearable actuated ankle-foot orthoses (AAFOs). First of all, their medical functions are investigated. From the short-term aspect, they lead to rectification of pathological gaits, reduction of metabolic cost, and improvement of gait performance. After AAFO-based walking training with sufficient time, free walking performance can be enhanced. Then, key design factors are studied. First, primary design parameters are investigated. Second, common actuators are analysed. Third, human-robot interaction (HRI), ergonomics, safety, and application places, are considered. In the following section, control technologies are reviewed from the aspects of rehabilitation stages, gait feature quantities, and controller characteristics. Finally, existing problems are discussed; development trends are prospected.

[Current approaches to the use of robotic devices in rehabilitation complex of children with cerebral palsy]

Cerebral palsy is a neurological disease that is associated with multiple motor impairments and dysfunctions in children. The effective recovery of motor activity in both the upper and lower limbs is an important condition for the patient's social independence throughout his life. Robotic systems are new devices which are becoming increasingly popular as a part of the treatment of cerebral palsy. They have become a good addition to comprehensive rehabilitation therapy, including conducted at the sanatorium-resort stage. Further research is needed to clarify and prove the extent to which these devices help in treatment of children with cerebral palsy.

Under pressure: design and validation of a pressure-sensitive insole for ankle plantar flexion biofeedback during neuromuscular gait training

BACKGROUND

Electromyography (EMG)-based audiovisual biofeedback systems, developed and tested in research settings to train neuromuscular control in patient populations such as cerebral palsy (CP), have inherent implementation obstacles that may limit their translation to clinical practice. The purpose of this study was to design and validate an alternative, plantar pressure-based biofeedback system for improving ankle plantar flexor recruitment during walking in individuals with CP.

METHODS

Eight individuals with CP (11-18 years old) were recruited to test both an EMG-based and a plantar pressure-based biofeedback system while walking. Ankle plantar flexor muscle recruitment, co-contraction at the ankle, and lower limb kinematics were compared between the two systems and relative to baseline walking.

RESULTS

Relative to baseline walking, both biofeedback systems yielded significant increases in mean soleus (43-58%, p < 0.05), and mean (68-70%, p < 0.05) and peak (71-82%, p < 0.05) medial gastrocnemius activation, with no differences between the two systems and strong relationships for all primary outcome variables (R = 0.89-0.94). Ankle co-contraction significantly increased relative to baseline only with the EMG-based system (52%, p = 0.03).

CONCLUSION

These findings support future research on functional training with this simple, low-cost biofeedback modality.

Foot contact forces can be used to personalize a wearable robot during human walking

Individuals with below-knee amputation (BKA) experience increased physical effort when walking, and the use of a robotic ankle-foot prosthesis (AFP) can reduce such effort. The walking effort could be further reduced if the robot is personalized to the wearer using human-in-the-loop (HIL) optimization of wearable robot parameters. The conventional physiological measurement, however, requires a long estimation time, hampering real-time optimization due to the limited experimental time budget. This study hypothesized that a function of foot contact force, the symmetric foot force-time integral (FFTI), could be used as a cost function for HIL optimization to rapidly estimate the physical effort of walking. We found that the new cost function presents a reasonable correlation with measured metabolic cost. When we employed the new cost function in HIL ankle-foot prosthesis stiffness parameter optimization, 8 individuals with simulated amputation reduced their metabolic cost of walking, greater than 15% (p < 0.02), compared to the weight-based and control-off conditions. The symmetry cost using the FFTI percentage was lower for the optimal condition, compared to all other conditions (p < 0.05). This study suggests that foot force-time integral symmetry using foot pressure sensors can be used as a cost function when optimizing a wearable robot parameter.

Coordination Between Partial Robotic Exoskeletons and Human Gait: A Comprehensive Review on Control Strategies

Lower-limb robotic exoskeletons have become powerful tools to assist or rehabilitate the gait of subjects with impaired walking, even when they are designed to act only partially over the locomotor system, as in the case of unilateral or single-joint exoskeletons. These partial exoskeletons require a proper method to synchronize their assistive actions and ensure correct inter-joint coordination with the user’s gait. This review analyzes the state of the art of control strategies to coordinate the assistance provided by these partial devices with the actual gait of the wearers. We have analyzed and classified the different approaches independently of the hardware implementation, describing their basis and principles. We have also reviewed the experimental validations of these devices for impaired and unimpaired walking subjects to provide the reader with a clear view of their technology readiness level. Eventually, the current state of the art and necessary future steps in the field are summarized and discussed.

Robotic Systems for the Physiotherapy Treatment of Children with Cerebral Palsy: A Systematic Review

Cerebral palsy is a neurological condition that is associated with multiple motor alterations and dysfunctions in children. Robotic systems are new devices that are becoming increasingly popular as a part of the treatment for cerebral palsy. A systematic review of the Pubmed, Web of Science, MEDLINE, Cochrane, Dialnet, CINAHL, Scopus, Lilacs and PEDro databases from November 2021 to February 2022 was conducted to prove the effectiveness of these devices for the treatment of motor dysfunctions in children who were diagnosed with cerebral palsy. Randomized clinical trials in Spanish and English were included. In total, 653 potential manuscripts were selected but only 7 of them met the inclusion criteria. Motor dysfunctions in the lower limbs and those that are specifically related to gait are the main parameters that are affected by cerebral palsy and the robotic systems Lokomat, Innowalk, Robogait and Waltbox-K are the most commonly used. There is no consensus about the effectiveness of these devices. However, it seems clear that they have presented a good complement to conventional physical therapies, although not a therapy as themselves. Unfortunately, the low quality of some of the randomized clinical trials that were reviewed made it difficult to establish conclusive results. More studies are needed to prove and test the extent to which these devices aid in the treatment of children with cerebral palsy.

Bilateral vs. Paretic-Limb-Only Ankle Exoskeleton Assistance for Improving Hemiparetic Gait: A Case Series

People with lower-limb hemiparesis have impaired function on one side of the body that affects their walking ability. Wearable robotic assistance has been investigated to treat hemiparetic gait by applying assistance to the paretic limb. In this exploratory case series, we sought to compare the effects of bilateral vs. paretic-limb-only ankle exoskeleton assistance on walking performance in a case series of three heterogeneous presentations of lower-limb hemiparesis. A secondary goal was to validate the use of a real-time ankle-moment-adaptive exoskeleton control system for effectively assisting hemiparetic gait; the ankle moment controller accuracy ranged from 72 - 90% across all conditions and participants. Compared to walking without the device, both paretic-limb-only and bilateral assistance resulted in greater average total ankle power (up to 72%), improved treadmill walking efficiency (up to 28%), and increased over-ground walking distance (up to 41%). All participants achieved a more symmetrical, efficient gait pattern with bilateral assistance, indicating that assisting both limbs may be more beneficial than assisting only the paretic side in people with hemiparetic gait. The results of this case series are intended to inform future clinical studies and exoskeleton designs in a wide range of patient populations.

Application of Wearable Sensors in Actuation and Control of Powered Ankle Exoskeletons: A Comprehensive Review

Powered ankle exoskeletons (PAEs) are robotic devices developed for gait assistance, rehabilitation, and augmentation. To fulfil their purposes, PAEs vastly rely heavily on their sensor systems. Human–machine interface sensors collect the biomechanical signals from the human user to inform the higher level of the control hierarchy about the user’s locomotion intention and requirement, whereas machine–machine interface sensors monitor the output of the actuation unit to ensure precise tracking of the high-level control commands via the low-level control scheme. The current article aims to provide a comprehensive review of how wearable sensor technology has contributed to the actuation and control of the PAEs developed over the past two decades. The control schemes and actuation principles employed in the reviewed PAEs, as well as their interaction with the integrated sensor systems, are investigated in this review. Further, the role of wearable sensors in overcoming the main challenges in developing fully autonomous portable PAEs is discussed. Finally, a brief discussion on how the recent technology advancements in wearable sensors, including environment—machine interface sensors, could promote the future generation of fully autonomous portable PAEs is provided.

Visual guidance can help with the use of a robotic exoskeleton during human walking

Walking is an important activity that supports the health-related quality of life, and for those who need assistance, robotic devices are available to help. Recent progress in wearable robots has identified the importance of customizing the assistance provided by the robot to the individual, resulting in robot adaptation to the human. However, current implementations minimize the role of human adaptation to the robot, for example, by the users modifying their movements based on the provided robot assistance. This study investigated the effect of visual feedback to guide the users in adapting their movements in response to wearable robot assistance. The visual feedback helped the users reduce their metabolic cost of walking without any changes in robot assistance in a given time. In a case with the initially metabolic expensive (IMExp) exoskeleton condition, both training methods helped reduce the metabolic cost of walking. The results suggest that visual feedback training is helpful to use the exoskeleton for various conditions. Without feedback, the training is helpful only for the IMExp exoskeleton condition. This result suggests visual feedback training can be useful to facilitate the use of non-personalized, generic assistance, where the assistance is not tuned for each user, in a relatively short time.

Improving the Energy Cost of Incline Walking and Stair Ascent with Ankle Exoskeleton Assistance in Cerebral Palsy

OBJECTIVE

Many individuals with cerebral palsy (CP) experience gait deficits resulting in metabolically-inefficient ambulation that is exacerbated by graded walking terrains. The primary goal of this study was to clinically-validate the accuracy and efficacy of adaptive ankle exoskeleton assistance during steady-state incline walking and stair ascent in individuals with CP. Exploratory goals were to assess safety and feasibility of using adaptive ankle exoskeleton assistance in real-world mixed-terrain settings.

METHODS

We used a novel battery-powered ankle exoskeleton to provide adaptive ankle plantar-flexor assistance during stance phase. Seven ambulatory individuals with CP completed the study.

RESULTS

Adaptive controller accuracy was 85% for incline walking and 81% for stair-stepping relative to the biological ankle moment. Assistance improved energy cost of steady-state incline walking by 14% (p = 0.004) and stair ascent by 21% (p = 0.001) compared to walking without the device. Assistance reduced the muscular demand for the soleus and vastus lateralis during both activities. All participants were able to safely complete the real-world mixed-terrain route, with adaptive ankle assistance resulting in improved outcomes compared to walking with the device providing zero-torque; no group-level differences were found compared to walking without the device, yet individuals with more impairment exhibited a marked improvement.

CONCLUSION

Adaptive ankle exoskeleton assistance can improve the energy cost of steady-state incline walking and stair ascent in individuals with CP.

SIGNIFICANCE

As the first study to demonstrate safety and performance benefits of ankle assistance on graded terrains in CP, these findings encourage further investigation in free-living settings.

Electromechanical and Robotic Devices for Gait and Balance Rehabilitation of Children with Neurological Disability: A Systematic Review

In the last two decades, a growing interest has been focused on gait and balance robot-assisted rehabilitation in children with neurological disabilities. Robotic devices allow the implementation of intensive, task-specific training fostering functional recovery and neuroplasticity phenomena. However, limited attention has been paid to the protocols used in this research framework. This systematic review aims to provide an overview of the existing literature on robotic systems for the rehabilitation of gait and balance in children with neurological disabilities and their rehabilitation applications. The literature search was carried out independently and synchronously by three authors on the following databases: MEDLINE, Cochrane Library, PeDro, Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, ScienceDirect, and Google Scholar. The data collected included three subsections referring to clinical, technical, and regulatory aspects. Thirty-one articles out of 81 found on the primary literature search were included in the systematic review. Most studies involved children with cerebral palsy. Only one-third of the studies were randomized controlled trials. Overall, 17 devices (nine end-effector systems and eight exoskeletons) were investigated, among which only 4 (24%) were bore the CE mark. Studies differ on rehabilitation protocols duration, intensity, and outcome measures. Future research should improve both rehabilitation protocols’ and devices’ descriptions.

Wearable Lower-Limb Exoskeleton for Children With Cerebral Palsy: A Systematic Review of Mechanical Design, Actuation Type, Control Strategy, and Clinical Evaluation

Children with a neurological disorder such as cerebral palsy (CP) severely suffer from a reduced quality of life because of decreasing independence and mobility. Although there is no cure yet, a lower-limb exoskeleton (LLE) has considerable potential to help these children experience better mobility during overground walking. The research in wearable exoskeletons for children with CP is still at an early stage. This paper shows that the number of published papers on LLEs assisting children with CP has significantly increased in recent years; however, no research has been carried out to review these studies systematically. To fill up this research gap, a systematic review from a technical and clinical perspective has been conducted, based on the PRISMA guidelines, under three extended topics associated with "lower limb", "exoskeleton", and "cerebral palsy" in the databases Scopus and Web of Science. After applying several exclusion criteria, seventeen articles focused on fifteen LLEs were included for careful consideration. These studies address some consistent positive evidence on the efficacy of LLEs in improving gait patterns in children with CP. Statistical findings show that knee exoskeletons, brushless DC motors, the hierarchy control architecture, and CP children with spastic diplegia are, respectively, the most common mechanical design, actuator type, control strategy, and clinical characteristics for these LLEs. Clinical studies suggest ankle-foot orthosis as the primary medical solution for most CP gait patterns; nevertheless, only one motorized ankle exoskeleton has been developed. This paper shows that more research and contribution are needed to deal with open challenges in these LLEs.