Computationally Efficient Implementation of Aperture Domain Model Image Reconstruction

Separation of mainlobe and sidelobe contributions to B-mode ultrasound images based on the aperture spectrum

Purpose

Isolating the mainlobe and sidelobe contribution to the ultrasound image can improve imaging contrast by removing off-axis clutter. Previous work achieves this separation of mainlobe and sidelobe contributions based on the covariance of received signals. However, the formation of a covariance matrix at each imaging point can be computationally burdensome and memory intensive for real-time applications. Our work demonstrates that the mainlobe and sidelobe contributions to the ultrasound image can be isolated based on the receive aperture spectrum, greatly reducing computational and memory requirements.

Approach

The separation of mainlobe and sidelobe contributions to the ultrasound image is shown in simulation, in vitro, and in vivo using the aperture spectrum method and multicovariate imaging of subresolution targets (MIST). Contrast, contrast-to-noise-ratio (CNR), and speckle signal-to-noise-ratio are used to compare the aperture spectrum approach with MIST and conventional delay-and-sum (DAS) beamforming.

Results

The aperture spectrum approach improves contrast by 1.9 to 6.4 dB beyond MIST and 8.9 to 13.5 dB beyond conventional DAS B-mode imaging. However, the aperture spectrum approach yields speckle texture similar to DAS. As a result, the aperture spectrum-based approach has less CNR than MIST but greater CNR than conventional DAS. The CPU implementation of the aperture spectrum-based approach is shown to reduce computation time by a factor of 9 and memory consumption by a factor of 128 for a 128-element transducer.

Conclusions

The mainlobe contribution to the ultrasound image can be isolated based on the receive aperture spectrum, which greatly reduces the computational cost and memory requirement of this approach as compared with MIST.

A Real-Time, GPU-Based Implementation of Aperture Domain Model Image REconstruction

Multipath and off-axis scattering are two of the primary mechanisms for ultrasound image degradation. To address their impact, we have proposed Aperture Domain Model Image REconstruction (ADMIRE). This algorithm utilizes a model-based approach in order to identify and suppress sources of acoustic clutter. The ability of ADMIRE to suppress clutter and improve image quality has been demonstrated in previous works, but its use for real-time imaging has been infeasible due to its significant computational requirements. However, in recent years, the use of graphics processing units (GPUs) for general-purpose computing has enabled the significant acceleration of compute-intensive algorithms. This is because many modern GPUs have thousands of computational cores that can be utilized to perform massively parallel processing. Therefore, in this work, we have developed a GPU-based implementation of ADMIRE. The implementation on a single GPU provides a speedup of two orders of magnitude when compared to a serial CPU implementation, and additional speedup is achieved when the computations are distributed across two GPUs. In addition, we demonstrate the feasibility of the GPU implementation to be used for real-time imaging by interfacing it with a Verasonics Vantage 128 ultrasound research system. Moreover, we show that other beamforming techniques, such as delay-and-sum (DAS) and short-lag spatial coherence (SLSC), can be computed and simultaneously displayed with ADMIRE. The frame rate depends upon various parameters, and this is exhibited in the multiple imaging cases that are presented. An open-source code repository containing CPU and GPU implementations of ADMIRE is also provided.

Plane-Wave Ultrasound Beamforming Through Independent Component Analysis

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Beamforming in coherent plane-wave compounding (CPWC) is an essential step in maintaining high resolution, contrast and framerate. Adaptive methods have been designed to achieve this goal by estimating the apodization weights from echo traces acquired by several transducer elements.

METHODS

Herein, we formulate plane-wave beamforming as a blind source separation problem, where the output of each transducer element is considered as a non-independent observation of the field. As such, beamforming can be formulated as the estimation of an independent component out of the observations. We then adapt the independent component analysis (ICA) algorithm to solve this problem and reconstruct the final image.

RESULTS

The proposed method is evaluated on a set of simulations, real phantom, and in vivo data available from the plane-wave imaging challenge in medical ultrasound. Moreover, the results are compared with other well-known adaptive methods.

CONCLUSIONS

Results demonstrate that the proposed method simultaneously improves the resolution and contrast.

Iterative Model-Based Beamforming for High Dynamic Range Applications

Clutter produced using bright acoustic sources can obscure weaker acoustic targets, degrading the quality of the image in scenarios with high dynamic ranges. Many adaptive beamformers seek to improve image quality by reducing these sidelobe artifacts, generating a boost in contrast ratio or contrast-to-noise ratio. However, some of these beamformers inadvertently introduce a dark region artifact in place of the strong clutter, a situation that occurs when both clutter and the underlying signal of interest are removed. We introduce the iterative aperture domain model image reconstruction (iADMIRE) method that is designed to reduce clutter while preserving the underlying signal. We compare the contrast ratio dynamic range (CRDR) of iADMIRE to several other adaptive beamformers plus delay-and-sum (DAS) to quantify the accuracy and reliability of the reported measured contrast for each beamformer over a wide range of contrast levels. We also compare all beamformers in the presence of bright targets ranging from 40 to 120 dB to observe the presence of sidelobes. In cases with no added reverberation clutter, iADMIRE had a CRDR of 75.6 dB when compared with the next best method DAS with 60.8 dB. iADMIRE also demonstrated the best performance for levels of reverberation clutter up to 0-dB signal-to-clutter ratio. Finally, iADMIRE restored underlying speckle signal in dark artifact regions while suppressing sidelobes in bright target cases up to 100 dB.