Immunoglobulin A deposition in jejunal mucosa of children with dermatitis herpetiformis

Antibodies in celiac disease: implications beyond diagnostics

Celiac disease is a multisystemic dietary, gluten-induced autoimmune disorder characterized by the presence of transglutaminase (TG) 2 serum autoantibodies. Distinct autoantibodies targeting members of the TG family (TG2, TG3 and TG6) are found deposited in small-bowel mucosa and in extraintestinal tissues affected by the disease. Serum autoantibodies against other self-antigens also emerge in untreated celiac disease patients. Although villous atrophy and crypt hyperplasia in small-bowel biopsy samples are still the gold standards in diagnostics, celiac disease-specific antibodies are widely used as diagnostic aids. Gluten-induced small-bowel mucosal T-cell response is the cornerstone in the pathogenesis of the disorder, but humoral immunity may also play a central role. This review article is focused on the autoantibodies that occur in the context of celiac disease. The article summarizes the diagnostic utility of different celiac-related antibodies and discusses their roles in the pathogenesis of the disease.

Diagnostic methods beyond conventional histology in coeliac disease diagnosis

BACKGROUND

Coeliac disease diagnostic criteria currently require the detection of small bowel mucosal villous atrophy and crypt hyperplasia.

AIMS

To compare conventional histological examination to the determination of small bowel mucosal intraepithelial lymphocytes (IELs) and to serum and intestinal coeliac autoantibodies in untreated coeliac disease with villous atrophy and in mild enteropathy coeliac disease.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Study comprised consecutive adult patients with coeliac disease suspicion; villous height-crypt depth ratio (Vh/CrD), the densities of CD3+, gammadelta+ and villous tip IELs and serum and intestinal transglutaminase 2 (TG2)-targeted autoantibodies were studied. Coeliac disease was diagnosed in 223 and excluded in 608 patients. Further, 66 patients were considered to suffer from mild enteropathy coeliac disease. Control group consisted of 138 patients.

RESULTS

Vh/CrD determination detected 77% of untreated coeliac disease patients. Serum coeliac autoantibodies had 84% sensitivity for untreated coeliac disease with villous atrophy and 70% sensitivity for mild enteropathy coeliac disease; the specificity was 100%. Intestinal TG2-targeted autoantibodies had sensitivities of 100% and 93%, and 100% specificity, respectively. gammadelta+ and villous tip IELs proved more reliable than CD3+ IELs.

CONCLUSIONS

Conventional histological examination as the golden standard in coeliac disease diagnosis is questionable. Serum and especially intestinal TG2-targeted autoantibodies seem promising in future coeliac disease diagnostics.

Immunoglobulin A autoantibodies against transglutaminase 2 in the small intestinal mucosa predict forthcoming coeliac disease

BACKGROUND

Reliable markers of early developing coeliac diseases are needed. Coeliac autoantibodies in the serum or Marsh I inflammation may be indicators of subsequent coeliac disease.

AIM

To investigate whether determination of intestinal transglutaminase 2-targeted autoantibody deposits would detect early developing coeliac disease better than previous methods.

METHODS

The study investigated patients previously excluded for coeliac disease: 25 had positive serum coeliac autoantibodies (endomysial), 25 antibody-negative had Marsh I, and 25 antibody-negative had Marsh 0 finding. Seven (median) years after baseline investigation, new coeliac cases were recorded, and small bowel biopsy was offered to the rest of the patients. Serum and intestinal coeliac autoantibodies and intraepithelial lymphocytes were assessed as indicators of developing coeliac disease.

RESULTS

Seventeen patients had developed coeliac disease: 13 in the autoantibody-positive group, three in the Marsh I group and one in the Marsh 0 group. At baseline, intestinal coeliac autoantibody deposits had a sensitivity and specificity of 93% and 93% in detecting subsequent coeliac disease, CD3+ 59% and 57%, gammadelta+ 76% and 60%, and villous tip intraepithelial lymphocytes 88% and 71%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Endomysial antibodies with normal histology indicates early developing coeliac disease. Transglutaminase 2-targeted intestinal autoantibody deposits proved the best predictor of subsequent coeliac disease.

Dermatitis herpetiformis: close to unravelling a disease

Dermatitis herpetiformis is characterised by granular IgA precipitates in the papillary dermis. In contrast to other autoimmune blistering diseases, where tissue-deposited and circulating autoantibodies recognise the same target within the skin, in dermatitis herpetiformis a serum IgA reacting with a component of the healthy papillary dermis has not been detected. Recently, the antigenic specificity of pathognomic skin-bound IgA has been clarified: the immune precipitates contain epidermal transglutaminase, an enzyme not previously detected in the papillary region of normal skin. Furthermore, serum IgA in dermatitis herpetiformis has been found to bind epidermal transglutaminase. These findings may relate to the fact, that dermatitis herpetiformis is associated with gluten sensitive enteropathy, coeliac disease, which is characterised by IgA type autoantibodies to a closely related enzyme, tissue transglutaminase. The two transglutaminases are highly homologous, and therefore, cross reactivity of the two antibodies might explain why patients with gluten sensitive enteropathy, with or without skin disease, generally have serum autoantibodies to both enzymes. There is growing evidence that dermatitis herpetiformis should be considered as the skin manifestation of gluten sensitivity developing in those patients with mild coeliac disease, who produce epidermal transglutaminase autoantibodies of high avidity and affinity. Both the skin and the small bowel diseases are gluten dependent and are strongly associated with HLA DQ with no genetic differences to explain the two phenotypes. The question should be asked whether the rash in dermatitis herpetiformis is a classic autoimmune blistering disease or whether it has an immune complex basis, which is the most likely alternative.

The role of the immune response against tissue transglutaminase in the pathogenesis of coeliac disease

The development of autoimmunity to tissue transglutaminase (TGase 2) is a striking feature of coeliac disease, an enteropathy that develops in genetically susceptible individuals upon exposure to dietary gluten. IgA anti-TGase 2 autoantibodies are present in at least 98% of coeliac patients on a gluten-containing diet and provide a valuable tool for the diagnosis of the disorder. During disease development, the formation of TGase 2-gliadin complexes through TGase 2 activity appears to be central for B-cell epitope spreading from gliadin to TGase 2. However, the potential role of an immune response against TGase 2 in the pathogenesis of coeliac disease and for the development of the intestinal lesion remains unclear. Recently, an inhibitory effect of anti-TGase 2 autoantibodies from coeliac patients on TGase 2 activity in vitro has been described. Here, we report that a cellular and humoral response against TGase 2 can be induced in TGase 2 (-/-) and wildtype mice on a C57BL/6 background by s.c. immunization with human recombinant or guinea pig TGase 2 in complete Freund's adjuvant. Immunized wildtype, but not TGase 2 (-/-) mice develop periductal lymphocytic infiltrates in lacrimal glands. Although no intestinal lesions were found, this observation lends support to the concept that the development of autoimmunity against TGase 2 is a pathological event that might ultimately lead to organ damage.

Prospective significance of antiendomysium antibody positivity in subsequently verified celiac disease

BACKGROUND

In order to assess their long-term predictability for the diagnosis of celiac disease, antiendomysium antibody results were compared with the outcome of the Interlaken diagnostic process.

METHODS

Prospective gluten challenge was performed in 153 children with previously diagnosed flat small-intestine mucosa. In 90 patients (Group A), endomysium antibodies were initially positive, in seven (Group B) they were negative, and 56 patients (Group C) had no initial serological results. In IgA-deficient persons, IgG antibodies were also assayed, both by the immunofluorescent method.

RESULTS

Histological relapse rates were 100% (90/90), 14.3% (1/7), and 76.8% (43/56), p < 0.001, in Groups A, B, and C, respectively. Each patient with relapse also exhibited endomysium antibody positivity during the challenge. Patients in whom celiac disease could be finally ruled out remained consistently endomysium-antibody negative. The celiac disease patient in Group B had severe secondary immunoglobulin deficiency at entry, which explained the initial negativity. Diagnosis based on antiendomysium antibody positivity and flat mucosa gave a higher applicability (92.8 vs. 50.3%) and reliability (relapse rate 100 vs. 89.6%) than the 1990 European Society of Paediatric Gastroenterology and Nutrition (ESPGAN) criteria among these patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Endomysium antibody positivity at presentation has been found to be as useful as gluten challenge in the diagnosis of celiac disease, even in patients under the age of 2 years. Challenge is still advisable in patients with a flat small intestinal mucosa when antiendomysium antibody results are negative or have not been done, as among these patients significantly lower relapse rates were found.

The humoral immune system in coeliac disease

IgA is transported into intestinal secretions to perform exclusion of luminal antigens. The prerequisites are antigen sampling by the Peyer's patch M cells, antigen processing by antigen-presenting cells, and presentation of antigenic peptides by HLA class II molecules to immunocompetent T-cells. The basis for intestinal immunity is the maturation cycle of specifically primed T and B cells from the gut-associated lymphoid tissue via mesenteric lymph nodes and peripheral blood back to the intestinal lamina propria. In coeliac disease, patients are sensitized against gluten and serum gliadin antibodies are often detected. Gliadin antibodies are also found in other gastrointestinal diseases, other disorders and in healthy individuals not carrying the coeliac disease-specific DQA/DQB alleles. On the other hand, serum reticulin and endomysium autoantibodies are both sensitive and highly disease-specific. Positivity in patients with normal jejunal morphology indicates latency of coeliac disease. These tissue autoantibodies are directed against fibroblast-derived extracellular matrix proteins. The immune system is involved in the amplification and perpetuation of the abnormalities of the intestinal mucosa in coeliac disease. The role of antibody in the pathogenesis remains unknown. The author hypothesizes gluten-triggered autoimmune mechanism to be operative.

IgA antibodies to jejunum. Specific immunity directed against target organ of gluten-sensitive enteropathy

Serum IgA antibodies to jejunum (JAB) were found in 78 (96%) of 81 adults and children with untreated celiac disease. Not only did IgA JAB display a significant higher prevalence than IgA antigliadin antibodies (AGA) (72%) in untreated gluten-sensitive enteropathy, but they also allowed us to identify another three celiacs in addition to those detected by IgA antiendomysial antibodies (EmA). Like IgA EmA, IgA JAB persisted at low titer in seven (14%) of 50 celiacs tested after 12 months of gluten-free diet (GFD) despite the regrowth of jejunal villi, whereas IgA AGA disappeared in all these patients consistently with the normalization of intestinal mucosa. IgA JAB and EmA reappearance was close to 100% in the 13 celiacs studied after six months of gluten challenge, while IgA AGA reached the highest prevalence (about 70%) after one month of gluten ingestion without any increase in the following months. All disease and healthy controls were always negative for the three IgA antibodies. Our results prove that IgA JAB and EmA are the best screening tests for active (untreated and on gluten challenge) celiac disease, whereas IgA AGA should be used for monitoring the response to gluten withdrawal. IgA JAB are an expression of a specific immunity directed against the target organ of gluten-sensitive enteropathy, but, before ascribing them a role in the pathogenesis of celiac disease, it should be ascertained whether their production is a primary event leading to jejunal lesions or whether it is a secondary phenomenon due to antigen release from a previously damaged jejunal mucosa.

Association of subepithelial deposition of activated complement and immunoglobulin G and M response to gluten in celiac disease

Patients with celiac disease produce not only immunoglobulin A (IgA) but also immunoglobulin G (IgG) and M (IgM) antibodies to gluten. Intake of dietary gluten may hence induce local complement activation and mucosal damage. Jejunal tissue sections from adult patients with celiac disease were examined by immunofluorescence with monoclonal antibodies to activation neoepitopes in C3b and the terminal complement complex (TCC). Subepithelial deposition of TCC was observed in 93% of 28 untreated and in 57% of 23 partly treated study subjects. The immunofluorescence staining intensity was well correlated with the serum level of gluten-specific IgG and IgM (but not IgA), the number of mucosal IgG-producing cells, and the degree of villous atrophy. Similar immune deposits were not observed in 5 successfully treated patients with celiac disease, 5 patients with dermatitis herpetiformis without jejunal villous atrophy, and 90% of 21 control patients with histologically normal jejunal mucosa. Gluten challenge increased the amount of subepithelial TCC and produced additional C3b deposition, suggesting recent complement activation. Ingested gluten might thus, via Ig-mediated subepithelial complement activation, damage the surface epithelium in celiac disease and induce compensatory crypt hyperplasia.

Ultrastructural binding sites of endomysium antibodies from sera of patients with dermatitis herpetiformis and coeliac disease

The ultrastructural binding sites of endomysium antibodies, specific serological markers of gluten sensitive enteropathy, were investigated in the rabbit oesophagus using the immunogold technique. Endomysium antibodies from sera of patients with dermatitis herpetiformis and with coeliac disease bound in an identical manner in a non-fibrillar material closely associated with fine collagenous-reticulin fibrils and also with similar fibrils connecting smooth muscle cells and elastic tissue in the endomysial connective tissue. These observations suggest that IgA antibodies in sera from patients with dermatitis herpetiformis and coeliac disease recognise a common antigen in an amorphous component associated with the reticular connective tissue of oesophageal lamina muscularis mucosae and thus confirm the probable identity of IgA class endomysium and jejunal antibodies.

Extracellular binding sites of IgA anti-jejunal antibodies on normal small bowel detected by indirect immunoelectronmicroscopy

Patients with dermatitis herpetiformis (DH) have IgA deposition in the papillary dermis and in the lamina propria of the small bowel. In addition, most of DH patients' sera contain IgA class anti-reticulin antibodies, anti-endomysium antibodies (EMA), and anti-jejunal antibodies (JAB) during times of gluten intake. In previous studies, JAB and EMA seemed to be identical and related to the group of anti-reticulin antibodies. In the present study, pre-embedding en bloc immunoelectronmicroscopic methods were applied for analysis of the ultrastructural binding sites of JAB on monkey and rabbit small bowels. These substrates were incubated with sera from DH patients strongly positive for JAB. Simultaneous investigations with the PAP technique and with 5 nm gold-labeled protein A or second antibodies visualized the bound IgA identically: it was associated with collagen fibrils underlying the epithelial and cryptal basement membranes and with collagen fibrils around capillaries. Staining was also detected along the endomysial collagen fibrils of smooth muscle layers, around elastica and smooth muscle cells of blood vessel walls, and along collagen fibrils near smooth muscle cells in the lamina propria. Neither the peroxidase product nor gold deposition was detected directly on the fibers, but was associated with amorphous material surrounding collagen fibers of different diameters. The distribution of JAB-stained structures corresponded to the localization of reticulin network of the small bowel. Our data indicate that JAB recognize an antigen or antigens associated with an amorphous component of the reticulin-collagen structure of jejunum and may have identical binding sites, as anti-reticulin antibodies and EMA.

Binding to human jejunum of serum IgA antibody from children with coeliac disease

Jejunal histology and the presence of serum IgA antibodies (JAB) binding to human jejunum in vitro were studied in 139 children with severe malabsorptive symptoms. Among 33 children with confirmed coeliac disease (ESPGAN criteria), 13 (93%) of 14 sampled before starting on a gluten-free diet had JAB, none of 21 sampled had JAB while on a gluten-free diet of long duration, and 90% of 30 sampled during gluten challenge had JAB. 53 children had severe jejunal villous atrophy (probable coeliac disease): 71% of those younger than 2 years and 94% of those aged 2-18 years had JAB during gluten intake. JAB could not be detected in 53 disease control patients (normal jejunal histology) and in 3 coeliac disease patients with selective IgA deficiency. Simultaneous determination of antigliadin (AGA) and antiendomysium (EMA) levels, and gliadin and tissue absorption studies, showed that JAB and AGA are different, whereas JAB and EMA are probably identical. IgA JAB could be the target-organ-related autoantibodies in coeliac disease.