Development of a Real-Time PCR-Based Method for Analyzing Semen-Specific Unmethylated DNA Regions and Methylation Status in Aged Body Fluid Stains

Application of a new composite genetic marker semen-specific methylation-microhaplotype in the analysis of semen-vaginal fluid mixtures

DNA mixtures containing semen and vaginal fluid are common biological samples in forensic analysis. However, the analysis of semen-vaginal fluid mixtures remains challenging. In this study, to solve these problems, it is proposed to combine semen-specific CpG sites and closely related microhaplotype sites to form a new composite genetic marker (semen-specific methylation-microhaplotype). Six methylation-microhaplotype loci were selected. To further improve discrimination power, five methylation-SNP loci were also included. The methylation levels and genotypes of these selected loci were obtained using massively parallel sequencing technology. Except for loci MMH04ZHA019 and MMH17ZHA059, the remaining nine loci were successfully sequenced. For the successfully sequenced loci, they performed well in identifying individuals and body fluids. An allele categorization model was developed using K-nearest neighbour algorithm, which was then used to predict allele types in semen-vaginal fluid mixtures. These loci were able to confirm the presence of semen and link semen to a true donor in semen-vaginal fluid mixtures with mixing ratios of 10:1, 9:1, 5:1, 4:1, 1:1, 1:3, 1:4, 1:8 and 1:9 (semen:vaginal fluid). This preliminary study suggests that this new composite genetic marker has great potential as a supplementary tool to commonly used genetic markers (STR, etc.) for analysing semen-vaginal fluid mixtures.

Validation of a novel fluorescent probe-based real-time PCR assay to detect saliva-specific unmethylated CpG sites for saliva identification

The identification of saliva from forensic samples is often important to establish what happened at a crime scene, especially in sexual assault cases. Recently, CpG sites that are specifically methylated or unmethylated in saliva have been reported as markers for saliva identification. In this study, we designed a fluorescent probe-based real-time polymerase chain reaction (PCR) assay for analyzing the methylation status of two neighboring CpG sites, which we previously found were saliva-specifically unmethylated. Specificity analysis using various types of body fluid/tissue samples demonstrated a probe detecting the unmethylation of the two CpG sites reacted only to saliva DNA, indicating this probe as an all-or-nothing marker for the presence of saliva DNA. Sensitivity analysis demonstrated that the detection limit was 0.5 ng saliva DNA as input for bisulfite conversion, while we confirmed a negative effect of larger amounts of non-saliva DNA on sensitivity in the analysis of saliva-vaginal DNA mixtures. We finally validated the applicability of this test to swabs from licked skin and bottles after drinking as mock forensic samples in comparison with other saliva-specific markers. We confirmed the potential usefulness of this test for skin samples, from which a saliva-specific mRNA was not detected reliably, while the ingredients in several beverages might affect methylation analysis. Given the simplicity of real-time PCR as well as the high specificity and sensitivity of the test, we believe the developed method is suitable for routine forensic analysis and can play an important role in saliva identification.

Typing of semen-containing mixtures using ARMS-based semen-specific CpG-InDel/STR markers

Mixed traces are common biological materials found at crime scenes, and their identification remains a significant challenge in the field of forensic genetics. In recent years, DNA methylation has been considered as a promising approach for body fluid identification, and length polymorphic loci are still the preferred markers for personal identification. In this study, we used tissue-specific CpG sites with linked insertion or deletion (InDel) or short tandem repeat (STR) markers (CpG-InDel/STR) for both body fluid and individual identification. The tissue-specific CpG loci, which were all selected from the previous reports, were analyzed using a combination of bisulfite conversion and amplification refractory mutation system-multiprimer-PCR technology. InDels or STRs, which were selected within 400 bp upstream or downstream of the semen-specific CpG loci, were analyzed using a capillary electrophoresis platform. Eventually, we successfully constructed a panel containing 17 semen-specific CpG-InDel/STR compound markers compassing 21 InDels/STRs, 3 body-fluid positive controls (vaginal secretion-, saliva-, and blood-specific CpG), and 1 gender identification locus. Using this panel, full genotyping of individuals could be obtained successfully with 50 ng DNA input. Semen stains stored at room temperature for 7 months and degraded samples that were heat treated for up to 6 h were still identified efficiently. For semen containing mixed stains, it is also useful when the semen content is as low as 3.03%. Moreover, the cumulative discrimination power of this panel is 0.9999998. In conclusion, it is a robust panel enabling the validation of both the tissue source and individual identification of semen containing mixed stains and can be employed as an alternative solution for forensic case investigation.

A new approach for forensic analysis of saliva-containing body fluid mixtures based on SNPs and methylation patterns of nearby CpGs

Saliva samples obtained from crime scenes often contain body fluids from other people, which makes it difficult to not only interpret the obtained DNA profiles, but also interpret saliva identification test results. α-amylase activity, an indicator of most saliva identification methods, can be slightly detected in other body fluids. This study aimed to overcome these difficulties. Here, we identified 13 saliva-specific methylated regions and five saliva-specific unmethylated regions neighboring common single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) by array-based genome-wide methylation analysis of pooled saliva, blood, semen, or vaginal swab samples. Bisulfite sequencing by massively parallel sequencing (MPS) technology was then performed using individual body fluid samples to evaluate the saliva-specificity of each CpG of the three regions selected from the identified candidates. Although no single CpG demonstrated complete saliva-specificity, we found that the reads that were simultaneously (un)methylated at the selected neighboring two to three CpGs of each region were highly specific for saliva DNA. Based on these findings, we then designed MPS-based bisulfite sequencing assays for each region to analyze the selected CpGs and SNP(s) on the same read. These assays could identify the saliva of a target person from body fluid mixtures of known contributors (individual-specific saliva identification) by calculating the ratios of simultaneous (un)methylation at the selected CpGs within the reads containing SNP alleles unique to the target person. Moreover, these assays could indicate the SNP types of saliva DNA (saliva-specific genotyping) from body fluid mixtures by analyzing the alleles of the reads simultaneously (un)methylated at the selected CpGs, while careful attention should be paid to interpret the results of heterologous genotypes. Although further regions should be identified, especially for saliva-specific individual identification, the CpG-SNP approach may be an effective method to interpret the complicated results obtained from saliva-containing body fluid mixtures.

Application of fragment analysis based on methylation status mobility difference to identify vaginal secretions

Identifying vaginal secretions attaching or adhering to a suspect's belongings would be beneficial for reconstructing the events that have taken place during a sexual assault. The present study describes a novel approach to identify vaginal secretions by fragment analysis using capillary electrophoresis, based on the mobility differences of PCR amplicons from bisulfite-treated DNA depending on methylation status. We targeted three genome regions including each of three vaginal secretion-specific methylated CpG sites reported previously: cg25416153, cg09765089, and cg14991487. In all three genome regions, the amplicon peaks for methylated genomic DNA (gDNA) sequences were only detected in vaginal samples, whereas samples of other body fluids (blood, saliva, semen, and deposit on skin surface) only showed amplicon peaks for unmethylated gDNA sequences. In vaginal secretions, the methylation ratio of each of the three targeted regions between samples was variable, while the ratios at the three regions in each sample were similar. Furthermore, commercial vaginal epithelial cells were completely methylated at the three regions. Therefore, vaginal secretion-specific methylation may derive from vaginal epithelial cells present in the sample. In forensic cases with a limited amount of DNA, the reproducibility of a detected peak using the present method is not high due to degradation of DNA by bisulfite treatment and subsequent stochastic PCR bias. However, it was possible to detect peaks from methylated DNA sequences by performing PCR and capillary electrophoresis in triplicate after bisulfite treatment, even when bisulfite treatment was performed using 0.5 ng of gDNA from vaginal secretions. In addition, the level of methylation at each targeted region was found to be stable in vaginal secretions stored for 1 year at room temperature. Therefore, we conclude that detection of the visual peak from vaginal secretion-specific methylated DNA sequence is useful to prove the presence of vaginal secretions. This approach has the potential to analyze multiple marker regions simultaneously, and may provide a new multiplex assay to identify various body fluids.

Rapid semen identification from mixed body fluids using methylation-sensitive high-resolution melting analysis of the DACT1 gene

In forensic genetics, a suspect is assigned to a component of a DNA mixture profile, and a probabilistic interpretation is then usually performed. However, it is difficult to determine what types of body fluid the component is from. Previous studies have reported that the fourth exon of the Dishevelled binding antagonist of beta catenin 1 (DACT1) gene is hypomethylated in a semen DNA-specific manner. In the present study, we evaluated whether the DACT1 gene could be effectively used to identify semen in body fluid mixtures and were able to semi-quantify the semen DNA content in mixed fluids. Our results showed that the DACT1 gene was useful in discriminating semen from venous blood and saliva. However, the amount of sperm in semen can affect semen identification. In addition, SI (the semen DNA content index), which we developed, was useful to determine whether the semen compromised majority, almost half, or was in the minority of the components in a mixed fluid. This technique is based on the methylation-sensitive high-resolution melting (MS-HRM) technology, which is time-, cost-, and labour-effective, and could be adopted in routine criminal investigations.

Current Methods for Body Fluid Identification Related to Sexual Crime: Focusing on Saliva, Semen, and Vaginal Fluid

Although, DNA typing plays a decisive role in the identification of persons from blood and body fluid stains in criminal investigations, clarifying the origin of extracted DNA has also been considered an essential task in proving a criminal act. This review introduces the importance of developing precise methods for body fluid identification. Body fluid identification has long relied on enzymatic methods as a presumptive assay and histological or serological methods as a confirmatory assay. However, because the latest DNA typing methods can rapidly obtain results from very small and even old, poorly preserved samples, the development of a novel corresponding body fluid identification method is required. In particular, an immunochromatographic method has been introduced to identify saliva and semen from sexual crimes. In addition, for vaginal fluid identification, attempts have been made in the past decade to introduce a method relying on body fluid-specific mRNA expression levels. At present, the development of molecular biological methods involving microRNA, DNA methylation, and resident bacterial DNA is ongoing. Therefore, in criminal investigations, body fluid identification is an essential task for correctly applying the results of DNA typing, although further research and development are required.

Exploring a multiplex DNA methylation-based SNP typing method for body fluids identification: As a preliminary report

In forensic investigation, identification of the cellular origin from body fluid can be essential in the crime scene reconstruction. Recently, DNA methylation could potentially be used as a novel marker for body fluid identification. The simultaneous analysis of CpGs and neighboring single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) has been proposed as an efficient assay for body fluids identification. In this study, a multiplex DNA methylation-based SNP typing system was developed. The specificity, sensitivity and detectability in mixtures and degraded samples were explored in our study. As results, four DNA methylation-based semen-specific SNP (SE1-4) showed good specificity, but two markers associative with saliva (SA1) and vaginal fluid (VA3) was observed cross-reactivity sporadically. Interesting, VA3 were found only presented in the female which may be useful for sexual identification. Moreover, this multiplex system successfully amplification in mixtures and aged samples which proves it be used as a valuable protocol in the identification of actual forensic samples. The strategy indicated that the approach was suitable and reliable for the body fluids analysis in mix stains in Han Chinese for forensic purposes.

Evaluation of a co-extraction kit for mRNA, miRNA and DNA methylation-based body fluid identification

Recently, messenger RNA (mRNA), micro RNA (miRNA), and DNA methylation (DNAm) have been reported as novel markers for body fluid identification (BFID). Comprehensive analysis of these markers should be a flexible and reliable BFID method for various types of forensic samples. However, independent extraction of all targets can be difficult depending on the usable amounts of samples. In this study, the applicability of a co-extraction kit for these molecules, the AllPrep DNA/RNA/miRNA Universal Kit (APU), was evaluated by comparing RNA and DNA extracted from blood and saliva stains by the APU with those extracted by standard kits for each molecule and by previously reported methods for mRNA/DNA or miRNA/DNA co-extraction. Electrophoresis using the Bioanalyzer platform and real-time PCR analysis revealed that the APU performed almost equivalently to each standard kit in the quality of RNA or DNA extracted and extraction efficiency of mRNAs, miRNAs, and DNA. Moreover, the APU outperformed the co-extraction methods, especially in RNA integrity and miRNA extraction efficiency. In addition, pyrosequencing revealed that the methylation ratios of DNA extracted by the APU were not different from those extracted by standard DNA extraction kits. Overall, the APU is applicable to comprehensive analysis of mRNA/miRNA/DNAm markers for BFID analysis. Because the DNA eluate can also be used for DNA typing, the APU may be among the best choices for forensic examination of body fluid samples in terms of its flexibility and reliability in BFID and efficiency in sample consumption.

Forensic Epigenetic Analysis: The Path Ahead

Unlike DNA fingerprinting, which scores for differences in the genome that are phenotype neutral, epigenetic variations are gaining importance in forensic investigations. Methylation of DNA has a broad range of effects on the lifestyle, health status, and physical appearance of individuals. DNA methylation profiling of forensic samples is useful in determination of the cell or tissue type of the DNA source and also for estimation of age. The quality and quantity of the biosample available from the crime scene limits the possible number of DNA methylation tests and the selection of the technology that can be used. Several techniques have been used for DNA methylation analysis for epigenetic investigations of forensic biological samples. However, novel techniques are needed for multiplex analysis of epigenetic markers as the techniques that are currently available require a large amount of high-quality DNA and are also limited in their multiplexing capacities that are often insufficient to fully resolve a forensic query of interest.

Development of a DNA methylation-based semen-specific SNP typing method: A new approach for genotyping from a mixture of body fluids

Genotyping from samples containing different types of body fluids is a major difficulty in forensic investigations. Recently, CpG sites that are specifically methylated or unmethylated in different types of body fluids have been reported as novel markers for body fluid identification. In this study, we hypothesized that the simultaneous analysis of CpGs and neighboring polymorphic sites on the same molecule could be useful for individual DNA typing from mixed samples. We performed a proof-of-concept study of this approach by searching the genome-wide methylation dataset deposited at the National Center for Biotechnology Information Gene Expression Omnibus repository for semen-specific CpG markers adjacent to common single nucleotide polymorphisms. From the identified candidates, we selected 5 regions on different chromosomes and validated the presence of semen-specific methylation or unmethylation in each region by pyrosequencing analyses. By combining methylation-specific polymerase chain reaction and pyrosequencing technology, we developed a semen-specific DNA typing method for two semen-specific methylated regions and one semen-specific unmethylated region. Finally, the method successfully identified semen-derived alleles from mixed stains, indicating that this methylation-based approach can be applicable to actual forensic samples. Since existing separation techniques physically isolate cells derived from each type of body fluid, this approach may be useful when existing methods cannot be performed due to the degradation of samples.

Recent progress, methods and perspectives in forensic epigenetics

Forensic epigenetics, i.e., investigating epigenetics variation to resolve forensically relevant questions unanswerable with standard forensic DNA profiling has been gaining substantial ground over the last few years. Differential DNA methylation among tissues and individuals has been proposed as useful resource for three forensic applications i) determining the tissue type of a human biological trace, ii) estimating the age of an unknown trace donor, and iii) differentiating between monozygotic twins. Thus far, forensic epigenetic investigations have used a wide range of methods for CpG marker discovery, prediction modelling and targeted DNA methylation analysis, all coming with advantages and disadvantages when it comes to forensic trace analysis. In this review, we summarize the most recent literature on these three main topics of current forensic epigenetic investigations and discuss limitations and practical considerations in experimental design and data interpretation, such as technical and biological biases. Moreover, we provide future perspectives with regard to new research questions, new epigenetic markers and recent technological advances that - as we envision - will move the field towards forensic epigenomics in the near future.

STAT3 methylation in white blood cells as a novel sensitive biomarker for the toxic effect of low-dose benzene exposure

Alterations in DNA methylation patterns play an essential role in disease process and are associated with cancer risk. To explore the toxic effect and early sensitive biomarker of the health effects of low-dose benzene exposure (LDBE), and investigate the correlation between DNA methylation and the toxic effect of LDBE, a cross-sectional study was conducted in a sample of 571 workers; 312 workers who were exposed to a 1.82 ± 1.16 mg m-3 air benzene concentration were assigned to the LDBE group, while 259 non-known benzene exposure (NBE) workers were assigned to the control group, with an air benzene concentration of 0.06 ± 0.01 mg m-3. Routine blood indexes, alanine transaminase (ALT), oxidative stress parameters and signal transducer and activator of transcription 3 (STAT3) methylation were detected. Compared with the NBE population, the STAT3 methylation level (P = 0.001), Platelets (PLTs) (P = 0.002) and 8-isoprostane-PGFs (8-iso-PGF2a) (P = 0.001) manifested a significant reduction, while ALT (P = 0.002) and 8-hydroxy-2 deoxyguanosine (8-OHdG) (P = 0.002) showed a significant rise in the LDBE population. In addition, a significant correlation was observed between STAT3 methylation and oxidative stress, namely 8-OhdG and 8-iso-PGF2a. Furthermore, a multivariate analysis showed that the STAT3 methylation (structure loadings = 0.909) was the most strongly correlated with the other set of variables, especially with white blood cells (WBCs) (structure loadings = 0.675). Taken together, STAT3 methylation may be the underlying mechanism involved in the early toxic effect of LDBE, therefore, STAT3 methylation can be a novel sensitive biomarker for the toxic effect of low-dose benzene exposure.