Definitive lobectomy without frozen section analysis is a treatment option for large or deep nodules selected carefully with clinical diagnosis of malignancy

Lobectomy for Suspected Lung Cancer Without Prior Diagnosis

BACKGROUND

We describe use, patients, and outcome of diagnostic lobectomy for suspected lung cancer without pathologic confirmation.

METHODS

A retrospective review of consecutive lobectomy or bilobectomy for suspected or confirmed primary pulmonary malignancy was conducted using our participant's sample of The Society of Thoracic Surgeons database. Surgeons performed lobectomy based on clinical diagnosis or confirmation on a biopsy specimen. Lung cancer confirmed by biopsy specimen was compared with cases clinically suspected. Univariate and multivariate analyses identified variables associated with lobectomy without biopsy specimen confirmation.

RESULTS

Among 2651 lobectomies performed between 2006 and 2019 in 2617 patients, lung cancer was confirmed by preoperative biopsy specimen in 51.6% (1368 of 2651) or was clinically suspected before the operation in 48.4% (1283 of 2651). The intraoperative biopsy specimen in 585 of 1283 cases (45.6%) proved lung cancer before lobectomy, whereas lobectomy proceeded in 698 cases (54.4%) without a diagnosis. Final pathology proved lung cancer in 90% (628 of 698) without a diagnosis before lobectomy and nonmalignant disease in 10% (70 of 698). Nonneoplastic pathology included granulomas (30 of 70 [43%]), pneumonia (12 of 70 [17%]), bronchiectasis (7 of 70 [10%]), and other lesions (21 of 70 [30%]). Operative mortality was 0.94% (25 of 2651) for the cohort and 1.0% (7 of 698) for diagnostic lobectomy only. Multivariate analysis identified patient age, type of lobectomy (right middle lobe), and the intermediate study tercile as associated with diagnostic lobectomy.

CONCLUSIONS

Lobectomy for suspected lung cancer without diagnosis is common, represents practice variation, and infrequently (10% diagnostic, 2.6% all lobectomies) removes nonmalignant disease. Tissue confirmation before lobectomy is preferred, particularly when operative risk is increased. Diagnostic lobectomy is acceptable in carefully selected patients and lesions.

Intraoperative rapid immunohistochemistry with noncontact antibody mixing for undiagnosed pulmonary tumors

Knowledge of the histologic type and primary origin of pulmonary tumors is essential when preparing a surgical strategy. Intraoperative diagnosis of hematoxylin and eosin (H&E)-stained frozen sections is the gold standard, but reliable pathology requires time-consuming immunohistochemistry (IHC) to distinguish among histological types/organ origins and to analyze molecular status. The aim of this study was to evaluate the clinical reliability of a new rapid-IHC technique for intraoperative diagnosis of pulmonary tumors. In total, 169 patients with undiagnosed pulmonary tumors were enrolled in a multicenter prospective observational study. At three institutes, pulmonary tumor samples were collected through core needle biopsy and/or surgery to determine surgical strategies. Using a new device for rapid IHC, we applied a high-voltage, low-frequency alternating current (AC) field, which mixes the available antibody as the voltage is switched on/off. Rapid IHC can provide tumor histologic type/origin diagnoses within 20 min, as opposed to the 3-6 h required for conventional IHC. No false diagnoses of malignancy were rendered in any of the cases when using simple H&E staining. With H&E staining alone, the overall definitive diagnosis rate, the rate of defined tumor origin, and the rate of determined histological type were 76.92%, 85.80%, and 90.53%, respectively. When rapid IHC was added, those rates were significantly improved to 88.76%, 94.67%, and 91.72%, respectively. By providing prompt and accurate intraoperative histological/molecular analysis, rapid IHC driven by AC mixing could serve as an effective clinical tool guiding the surgical strategy for undiagnosed pulmonary tumors.

Application of an Ultrasensitive NGS-Based Blood Test for the Diagnosis of Early-Stage Lung Cancer: Sensitivity, a Hurdle Still Difficult to Overcome

Simple Summary

Currently, an accurate diagnosis of lung cancer relies on the microscopic examination of tissue biopsies. These samples can, however, only be obtained by invasive procedures. The aim of our study was to evaluate the use of a liquid biopsy for early-stage lung cancer detection in patients with a lung lesion on imaging. This approach would be particularly relevant for suspected lung lesions that are difficult to reach for a tissue-based diagnosis. Despite technical improvements for the use of liquid biopsy-based cell-free DNA analysis, its application for the detection of early-stage lung cancer is currently limited by sensitivity and a biological background of somatic variants.

Abstract

Diagnosis of lung cancer requires histological examination of a tissue sample, which in turn requires an invasive procedure that cannot always be obtained. Circulating tumor DNA can be reliably detected in blood samples of advanced-stage lung cancer patients and might also be a minimally invasive alternative for early-stage lung cancer detection. We wanted to explore the potential of targeted deep sequencing as a test for the diagnosis of early-stage lung cancer in combination with imaging. Mutation detection on cell-free DNA from pretreatment plasma samples of 51 patients with operable non-small cell lung cancer was performed and results were compared with 12 control patients undergoing surgery for a non-malignant lung lesion. By using a variant allele frequency threshold of 1%, somatic variants were detected in 23.5% of patients with a median variant allele fraction of 3.65%. By using this threshold, we could almost perfectly discriminate early-stage lung cancer patients from controls. Our study results are discussed in the light of those from other studies. Notwithstanding the potential of today’s techniques for the use of liquid biopsy-based cell-free DNA analysis, sensitivity of this application for early-stage lung cancer detection is currently limited by a biological background of somatic variants with low variant allele fraction.

Surgery without preoperative histological confirmation of lung cancer: what is the current clinical practice?

Background

There are discordances in the guidelines regarding the need to acquire histological diagnosis before surgical treatment of (presumed) lung cancer. Preoperative histological confirmation is always encouraged in this setting to prevent unnecessary surgery or when sublobar resection for small-sized tumors is considered. The aim of this retrospective cohort study was to assess the proportion of patients undergoing lung cancer resection in the Netherlands without preoperative pathological confirmation, based on the intraoperative pathological diagnosis (IOD) rate, and to determine characteristics that may influence IOD frequency.

Methods

Data on 10,226 patients, who underwent surgical treatment for lung cancer from 2010 to 2015, were retrieved from the Netherlands National Cancer Registry. We registered an IOD when the date of diagnosis equaled the date of the first surgical intervention. Tabulations and multivariable logistic regression were used to identify predictive parameters for IOD.

Results

36% of surgical procedures were classified as IOD, and decreased with increasing tumor size and extent of surgery (57% for segmentectomy, 39% for lobectomy and 11% for pneumonectomy). IOD was more frequently observed in adenocarcinoma (41%), varied between hospitals from 13% to 66% and was less common when patients were referred from a hospital where thoracic surgery was not performed. Previous history of cancer did not affect IOD.

Conclusions

More than one-third of patients with suspected lung cancer in the Netherlands was operated without preoperative histological confirmation. There was significant variation in IOD rates between different hospitals, which deserves further detailed analysis when striving for uniform surgical quality of care for patients with lung cancer.