Comparing the adult and pre-pubertal testis: Metabolic transitions and the change in the spermatogonial stem cell metabolic microenvironment

Mapping the Development of Human Spermatogenesis Using Transcriptomics-Based Data: A Scoping Review

In vitro maturation (IVM) is a promising fertility restoration strategy for patients with nonobstructive azoospermia or for prepubertal boys to obtain fertilizing-competent spermatozoa. However, in vitro spermatogenesis is still not achieved with human immature testicular tissue. Knowledge of various human testicular transcriptional profiles from different developmental periods helps us to better understand the testis development. This scoping review aims to describe the testis development and maturation from the fetal period towards adulthood and to find information to optimize IVM. Research papers related to native and in vitro cultured human testicular cells and single-cell RNA-sequencing (scRNA-seq) were identified and critically reviewed. Special focus was given to gene ontology terms to facilitate the interpretation of the biological function of related genes. The different consecutive maturation states of both the germ and somatic cell lineages were described. ScRNA-seq regularly showed major modifications around 11 years of age to eventually reach the adult state. Different spermatogonial stem cell (SSC) substates were described and scRNA-seq analyses are in favor of a paradigm shift, as the Adark and Apale spermatogonia populations could not distinctly be identified among the different SSC states. Data on the somatic cell lineage are limited, especially for Sertoli cells due technical issues related to cell size. During cell culture, scRNA-seq data showed that undifferentiated SSCs were favored in the presence of an AKT-signaling pathway inhibitor. The involvement of the oxidative phosphorylation pathway depended on the maturational state of the cells. Commonly identified cell signaling pathways during the testis development and maturation highlight factors that can be essential during specific maturation stages in IVM.

The limitations of testicular organoids: are they truly as promising as we believe?

Organoid systems have revolutionised various facets of biological research by offering a three-dimensional (3D), physiologically relevant in vitro model to study complex organ systems. Over recent years, testicular organoids have been publicised as promising platforms for reproductive studies, disease modelling, drug screening, and fertility preservation. However, the full potential of these systems has yet to be realised due to inherent limitations. This paper offers a comprehensive analysis of the current challenges associated with testicular organoid models. Firstly, we address the inability of current organoid systems to fully replicate the intricate spatial organisation and cellular diversity of the in vivo testis. Secondly, we scrutinise the fidelity of germ cell maturation within the organoids, highlighting incomplete spermatogenesis and epigenetic inconsistencies. Thirdly, we consider the technical challenges faced during organoid culture, including nutrient diffusion limits, lack of vasculature, and the need for specialised growth factors. Finally, we discuss the ethical considerations surrounding the use of organoids for human reproduction research. Addressing these limitations in combination with integrating complementary approaches, will be essential if we are to advance our understanding of testicular biology and develop novel strategies for addressing reproductive health issues in males.

Favorable culture conditions for spermatogonial propagation in human and non-human primate primary testicular cell cultures: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Introduction: Autologous transplantation of spermatogonial stem cells (SSCs) isolated from cryopreserved testicular biopsies obtained before oncological treatment could restore fertility in male childhood cancer survivors. There is a clear necessity for in vitro propagation of the limited SSCs from the testicular biopsy prior to transplantation due to limited numbers of spermatogonia in a cryopreserved testicular biopsy. Still, there is no consensus regarding their optimal culture method. Methods: We performed a systematic review and meta-analysis of studies reporting primary testicular cell cultures of human and non-human primate origin through use of Pubmed, EMBASE, and Web of Science core collection databases. Of 760 records, we included 42 articles for qualitative and quantitative analysis. To quantify in vitro spermatogonial propagation, spermatogonial colony doubling time (CDT) was calculated, which measures the increase in the number of spermatogonial colonies over time. A generalized linear mixed model analysis was used to assess the statistical effect of various culture conditions on CDT. Results: Our analysis indicates decreased CDTs, indicating faster spermatogonial propagation in cultures with a low culture temperature (32°C); with use of non-cellular matrices; use of StemPro-34 medium instead of DMEM; use of Knockout Serum Replacement; and when omitting additional growth factors in the culture medium. Discussion: The use of various methods and markers to detect the presence of spermatogonia within the reported cultures could result in detection bias, thereby potentially influencing comparability between studies. However, through use of CDT in the quantitative analysis this bias was reduced. Our results provide insight into critical culture conditions to further optimize human spermatogonial propagation in vitro, and effectively propagate and utilize these cells in a future fertility restoration therapy and restore hope of biological fatherhood for childhood cancer survivors.