A review of current concepts in radiofrequency chondroplasty

Radiofrequency-Based Chondroplasty Creates a Precise Area of Targeted Chondrocyte Death With Minimal Necrosis Outside the Target Zone: A Systematic Review

Purpose

To systematically examine the effects of radiofrequency (RF) ablation or coblation (controlled ablation) on chondrocyte viability following knee chondroplasty in preclinical literature to determine the effectiveness and safety of RF-based techniques.

Methods

A literature search was performed in September 2022 using PubMed and Scopus using the following search terms combined with Boolean operators: "chondroplasty," "radiofrequency," "thermal," "knee," "chondral defect," "articular cartilage," and "cartilage." The inclusion criteria consisted of preclinical studies examining the effect of RF ablation or coblation on chondrocytes during knee chondroplasty. Exclusion criteria consisted of studies reporting chondroplasty in joints other than the knee, clinical studies, in vitro studies using animal models, case reports, non-full-text articles, letters to editors, surveys, review articles, and abstracts. The following data were extracted from the included articles: author, year of publication, chondral defect location within the knee and chondral characteristics, RF probe characteristics, cartilage macroscopic description, microscopic chondrocyte description, and extracellular matrix characteristics.

Results

A total of 17 articles, consisting of 811 cartilage specimens, were identified. The mean specimen age was 63.4 ± 6.0 (range, 37-89) years. Five studies used monopolar RF devices, 7 studies used bipolar RF devices, whereas 4 studies used both monopolar and bipolar RF devices. Time until cell death during ablation at any power was reported in 5 studies (n = 351 specimens), with a mean time to cell death of 54.4 seconds (mean range, 23.1-64) for bipolar RF and 56.3 seconds (mean range, 12.5-64) for monopolar RF devices. Chondrocyte cell death increased with increased wattage, while treatment time was positively correlated with deeper cell death.

Conclusions

In this systematic review, histologic analysis demonstrated that RF-based chondroplasty creates a precise area of targeted chondrocyte death, with minimal evidence of necrosis outside the target zone. Caution must be exercised when performing RF-based chondroplasty due to the risk of cell death with increased application time and wattage.

Clinical Relevance

Although RF ablation has demonstrated favorable results in preliminary trials, including smoother cartilage and less damage to the surrounding healthy tissue, the risks versus benefits of the procedure are largely unknown. Caution must be exercised when performing RF-based chondroplasty in the clinical setting due to the risk of cell death with increased application time and wattage.

Use of a Novel Variable Power Radiofrequency Ablation System Specific for Knee Chondroplasty: Surgical Experience and Two-Year Patient Results

Introduction Although stabilisation of knee cartilage lesions (chondroplasty) may be performed with an arthroscopic shaver, more recently, radiofrequency (RF) ablation has gained in popularity. However, their remain some concerns about the avoidance of thermal injury, chondrolysis, and osteonecrosis with the use of RF devices. Methods We reviewed the outcomes of 85 knee chondroplasties performed with a new RF ablation wand designed for knee chondroplasty. Lesion details and Chondropaenia Severity Score (CSS) were recorded for each patient. We evaluated the occurrence of adverse outcomes, post-operative complications, and the need for further surgery. Post-operative outcomes scores (Oxford Knee Score [OKS], Knee injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score [KOOS], and International Knee Documentation Committee [IKDC] subjective knee outcome) were recorded at a minimum of one-year follow-up. Results At the final mean follow-up of 27.5 months (range: 12-46.6 months), 12 (14%) knees had undergone or were listed for further surgery. Four patients had corticosteroid injections for ongoing pain at a median 7.5 months (range: 5-20 months) post-operatively. There were no observed re-operations considered to be caused by complications related to thermal injury. Of the six patients listed for or undergoing knee arthroplasty, five (83%) had grade 4 lesions found at the arthroscopic chondroplasty. A negative correlation was noted between CCS, and post-operative IKDC subjective score (R=-0.35), KOOS Sports (R=-0.39), and KOOS QoL (R=-0.36). Conclusions We found that RF chondroplasty appeared safe, and there were no concerns with regard to thermal injury. Functional outcome appeared to be related to the quality of chondral and meniscal tissue throughout all knee compartments, with better results for isolated grade 2 and 3 cartilage lesions.

Does radiofrequency ablation (RFA) epiphysiodesis affect adjacent joint cartilage?

PURPOSE

To test the hypothesis that epiphysiodesis made with radiofrequency ablation (RFA) is a safe procedure that disrupts the growth plate without damaging the adjacent joint articular cartilage.

METHODS

RFA epiphysiodesis was done during 8 min in vivo in 40 growing pig tibia physis. In addition, three tibiae were ablated for 16 min and three more for 24 min. As a burned cartilage reference, six tibiae were ablated on the joint articular cartilage for 8 min. After the procedure, the animals were terminated and the tibiae were harvested. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) was done ex vivo to evaluate the joint articular cartilage in all samples. We used T1-weighted, T2-weighted, and water content sequences under a 1.5 T magnetic field.

RESULTS

On the burned articular cartilage, intensity changes were observed at MRI. We found no evidence of articular cartilage damage on the 40 8-min RFA procedures. The tibiae ablated for 16 min and 24 min showed intact joint cartilage.

CONCLUSIONS

Epiphysiodesis using RFA is safe for the adjacent articular cartilage. This study shows that RFA can be done safely in the growing physis of pigs, even with triple duration procedures.

Mechanical debridement versus radiofrequency in knee chondroplasty with concomitant medial meniscectomy: 10-year results from a randomized controlled study

PURPOSE

We compared the effectiveness of mechanical debridement (MD) and bipolar radiofrequency chondroplasty (RF) with regard to clinical outcome, rate of revision, and progression of knee osteoarthritis.

METHODS

Sixty patients with MRI-detected grade III cartilage lesions on the medial femoral condyle were considered for the study. For MD (group 1; n = 30), each lesion was debrided using a mechanical shaver. For RF (group 2; n = 30), each lesion was smoothed using a temperature-controlled RF probe set at 50 °C.

RESULTS

The 10-year follow-up was available for 47 patients (78.3 %). Sixty per cent of group 1 (n = 18) underwent revision during the follow-up period. In contrast, the revision rate in group 2 was 23.3 % (n = 7; p = 0.061). The mean survival was 94.1 months (95 % CI 77.1-111.3) and 62.5 months (95 % CI 45.9-79.2) for group 2 and group 1, respectively. Patients who did not require revision (group 1, n = 9; group 2, n = 13) were assessed before surgery and 1, 4, and 10 years after surgery using the knee injury and osteoarthritis outcome score (KOOS). At follow-up, the KOOS was higher for group 2 than group 1. At the time of surgery, no patient showed any radiological signs of osteoarthritis. The width of the medial joint was 5.4 mm (95 % CI 4.3-6.5) and 5.6 mm (95 % CI 4.9-6.3) in the MD and RF groups, respectively (n.s.). During the follow-up period, the joint space width narrowed continuously in both groups (p < 0.001), but more rapidly in the group 1 (n.s).

CONCLUSION

Compared to conventional MD, 50° RF treatment appears to be a superior method based on short- and medium-term clinical outcomes and the progression of knee osteoarthritis. Clear predictors for the indications of different cartilage treatments and more randomized clinical trials are needed.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

I.

What are the current indications for use of radiofrequency devices in hip arthroscopy? A systematic review

The role of radiofrequency energy (RFE) devices has been minimally studied in hip arthroscopy. The purpose of this study was to determine the role of RFE devices in hip arthroscopy through a systematic review of the literature. We searched the PubMed database using the following Medical Subject Heading terms: hip arthroscopy, hip radiofrequency, thermal capsulorrhaphy, thermal chondroplasty and radiofrequency debridement. Two authors independently reviewed the literature and included articles based on predetermined inclusion criteria. We excluded review, technique and experimental articles. After title and abstract review, we selected 293 articles for full-text review. Ten articles met the inclusion and exclusion criteria. For the included articles, a total of 305 hips underwent arthroscopy with concomitant RFE treatment at a mean age of 25.7 years. Eight articles presented patient-reported outcome (PRO) instruments, one study did not report an outcome instrument but utilized an evaluation of postoperative range of motion (ROM) and 1 year magnetic resonance image (MRI) and computed tomography (CT) imaging. The remaining article measured only the ROM pre- and postoperatively. Only one of the articles reviewed reported complications. Current evidence on the safety and indications for use of RFE devices in hip arthroscopy is insufficient. The literature shows mixed results regarding its use in hip arthroscopy. Although the use of thermal energy is not without risk, if used judiciously and appropriate precautions are taken to avoid damage to adjacent tissues, those devices can be useful for the treatment of certain intra-articular hip pathologies arthroscopically.

Radiofrequency energy in the arthroscopic treatment of knee chondral lesions: a systematic review

INTRODUCTION

Cartilage debridement is one of the recommended procedures for the management of chondral defects. Radiofrequency probes allow to debride the cartilage, but may induce subchondral bone necrosis.

SOURCES OF DATA

Medline, Cochrane and Google Scholar were searched to identify studies on arthroscopic debridement of the articular cartilage of the knee using radiofrequency chondroplasty. The methodological quality of the studies was assessed using the Coleman methodology score (CMS).

AREAS OF AGREEMENT

Monopolar and bipolar radiofrequency devices provide significantly better clinical outcomes, especially for patients with high-grade chondral lesions, compared with mechanical shaver only. Despite the original concerns regarding subchondral bone necrosis, low complication rates are reported.

AREAS OF CONTROVERSY

Heterogeneity in terms of type of device does not allow sound comparison of the published results. There is lack of evidence on the long-term effects of radiofrequency chondroplasty.

GROWING POINTS

Study methodology should be improved: the average Coleman methodology score was 56.2 out of 100.

RESEARCH

More comparative, well-designed and larger cohort trials are needed to ascertain whether radiofrequency chondroplasty offers long-term benefits over other simpler and more economical alternatives.