Consensus statement on intra-operative electrophysiological recurrent laryngeal nerve monitoring during thyroid surgery

Intraoperative Facial Nerve Monitoring during Parotidectomy: The Current Practices and Patterns of the Korean Society of Head and Neck Surgery (KSHNS)

Objectives: This study aimed to evaluate the current practices and trends of intraoperative facial nerve (FN) monitoring (IOFNM) during parotidectomy. Methods: A questionnaire containing 33 questions collecting information on the usage, indications, settings, techniques, loss of signal (LOS) management, anesthesiologist cooperation, and perception of usefulness of IOFNM was distributed among 348 members of the Korean Society of Head and Neck Surgery (KSHNS) via a dedicated website. Results: The response rate was approximately 25.6%, and 97% of the respondents reported using IOFNM selectively or routinely during parotidectomy. IOFNM usage decreased as the surgeon's level of experience increased (p = 0.089), from 100% in those with less than 5 years of experience to 75% in those with 20 or more years. Approximately 95% of respondents reported that the initial event threshold for electromyography activity used was 50-149 μV. Moreover, 52.4% of respondents performed neural mapping of the FN before visual identification. Initial management of LOS in visually intact FNs included checking the IOFNM system (75.3%), confirmation of muscle relaxant dosage (75.3%), and facial twitch identification (58.8%). Further management included proceeding with surgery regardless of persistent LOS (81.2%) and steroid administration sometimes or all of the time (72.9%). Overall, 98.8% of respondents found IOFNM beneficial for safe execution of parotidectomy. Conclusions: The majority of KSHNS surgeons used IOFNM during parotidectomy, although the clinical implementation of the procedure and LOS management varied between practitioners. This could be attributed to the lack of standardized protocols for IOFNM, emphasizing the need for the development of evidence-based consensus guidelines for all institutions.

Patterns and indications of intraoperative nerve monitoring usage during thyroidectomy and parathyroidectomy in Spain: results of a national survey of endocrine surgeons

We investigated the use patterns and indications of intraoperative neural monitoring (IONM) among endocrine surgeons in Spain. We sent an anonymous web-based survey to endocrine surgeons' members of the Spanish Association of Surgery by email. We analysed 79/ 269 surveys. Respondents had a median age of 52 years and 13 years of surgical experience. Only 32% of respondents performed routinely preoperative laryngoscopy in all thyroidectomies and 19% in all parathyroidectomies. Seventy-five percent of respondents used the intermittent-IONM, and 9.7% used the continuous-IONM. All respondents identified recurrent laryngeal nerve during surgery, and 40% of surgeons routinely identified external branch superior laryngeal nerve (EBSLN) during thyroidectomy. Seventy-eight percent of respondents used IONM always for all thyroidectomies. Only 11% stimulated EBSLN in all cases. Forty-nine percent used IONM always for all parathyroidectomies. The most frequent reasons for not using IONM were the unavailability of IONM, the high cost, and the lack of adding value to their clinical practice. Almost 10% declared not having IONM. The IONM is a reality in Spain, especially the intermittent mode. Its use is superior in thyroid surgery than in parathyroid. Its standardized use is not yet fully established, and routine adherence to standardized guidelines should increase.

Proving the Superiority of Intraoperative Recurrent Laryngeal Nerve Monitoring over Visualization Alone during Thyroidectomy

Vocal fold paralysis after thyroid surgery is still a dangerous complication that significantly reduces patients’ quality of life. Since the intraoperative neuromonitoring (IONM) technique has been introduced and standardized, the most frequently asked question is whether its use has significantly reduced the rate of RLN injury during thyroid surgery compared to visual identification alone (VA). The aim of this study was to attempt to prove the superiority of IONM over VA of the RLN during thyroid surgery in the prevention of vocal fold paralysis, taking into account risk factors for complications. The medical records of 711 patients (1265 recurrent laryngeal nerves at risk of injury) were analyzed retrospectively: in 257 patients/469 RLNs at risk, thyroid surgery was performed with IONM; in 454 patients/796 RLNs at risk, surgery was performed with VA. The statistical analysis showed that in the group of patients with IONM only one risk factor—the surgeon’s experience—proved statistically significant (OR = 3.27; p = 0.0478) regarding the overall risk of vocal fold palsy. In the group of patients where only visualization was used, 5 of the 12 factors analyzed were statistically significant: retrosternal goiter (OR = 2.23; p = 0.041); total thyroid volume (OR = 2.30; p = 0.0284); clinical diagnosis (OR = 2.5; p = 0.0669); gender (OR = 3.08; p = 0.0054) and risk stratification (OR = 3.30; p = 0.0041). In addition, the cumulative risk, taking into account the simultaneous influence of all 12 factors, was slightly higher in the group of patients in whom only VA was used during the procedure: OR = 1.78. This value was also considerably more statistically significant (p < 0.0001) than that obtained in the group of patients in whom IONM was used: OR = 1.73; p = 0.004. Conclusions: Risk factors for complications in thyroid surgery are not significant for any increase in the rate of vocal fold paralysis as long as surgery is performed with IONM, in contrast to thyroid surgery performed only with VA, thus proving the superiority of IONM over VA for safety.

Intra-operative nerve monitoring and recurrent laryngeal nerve injury during thyroid surgery: a network meta-analysis of prospective studies

PURPOSE

Recurrent laryngeal nerve (RLN) injury is a feared complication of thyroid surgery occurring in 1-5% of cases. The present approaches to RLN preservation include RLN visualization with no nerve monitoring (No-NM), intermittent intra-operative nerve monitoring (I-IONM) and continuous intra-operative nerve monitoring (C-IONM). There is ambiguity as to which of these strategies should be the preferred method of RLN preservation.

METHODS

A systematic review of the PubMed, Embase and the Cochrane Collaboration databases was undertaken with network meta-analysis (NMA) performed according to the PRISMA and Cochrane Collaboration guidelines. A Bayesian NMA was conducted using R packages netmeta with outcomes expressed as odds ratios (ORs) with 95% credible intervals (CrI). Only prospective studies were included.

RESULTS

Eighteen studies met inclusion criteria, including 22,080 patients and 40,642 nerves at risk (NAR). Overall, 23,364 NARs (57.5%) underwent I-IONM, 17,176 (42.3%) No-NM and 98 (0.2%) underwent C-IONM. There were no significant differences between groups regarding the incidence of permanent RLN injury following thyroid surgery (I-IONM vs.No-NM, OR 0.84, 95% CrI 0.55-1.19; C-IONM vs. No-NM, OR 0.44, 95% CrI 0.02-5.00). Pooled analysis showed that IONM (I-IONM or C-IONM) demonstrated a protective effect versus No-NM in reducing the incidence of transient RLN injury (OR 0.75, 95% CI 0.59-0.97, p = 0.03).

CONCLUSIONS

IONM strategies did not significantly reduce the incidence of permanent RLN injury following thyroid surgery. However, the small number of C-IONM NARs limits conclusions that may be drawn. Further well-designed prospective studies will be required to definitively assess the utility of C-IONM.

Intraoperative Neuromonitoring: Evaluating the Role of Continuous IONM and IONM Techniques for Emerging Surgical and Percutaneous Procedures

Intraoperative nerve monitoring (IONM) is a tool used during thyroid surgery to assist in the identification of the recurrent laryngeal nerve (RLN). Multiple IONM systems that exist for thyroidectomy require intubation with an endotracheal tube. Given that one of the advantages of thermal ablation procedures, such as radiofrequency ablation, is that they can be done safely without the use of general anesthesia, nerve monitoring systems that utilize cutaneous surface electrodes have been developed, though are not widely available in the United States. This article will review the use of IONM for RFA including the cutaneous surface electrode system.

Low-Dose of Rocuronium During Thyroid Surgery: Effects on Intraoperative Nerve-Monitoring and Intubation

BACKGROUND

Intraoperative Neurophysiological Monitoring (IONM) reduces the incidence of Recurrent Laryngeal Nerve (RLN) injuries during thyroid surgery. To preserve nerve function, long acting neuromuscular blocking agents (NMBA) should be avoided. However, NMBA are necessary for laryngoscopy and endotracheal intubation. We designed this double-blinded, randomized, placebo-controlled trial to assess if a low-dose of rocuronium given at intubation would affect the IONM data recorded before the thyroid dissection.

METHODS

Hundred patients undergoing elective thyroid surgery were randomized to receive either 0.3 mg kg^-1 of low dose rocuronium (intervention) or no-NMBA (control). Intubation was performed with video-laryngoscopy. IONM was placed on RLN and nerve stimulation was performed before and after thyroid dissection. The presence of a valid amplitude prior to dissection was defined when the IONM signal was >100 μV. Occurrence of difficult laryngoscopy was reported together with intubation details including time, difficulty and failure. The lowest peripheral saturation (SpO₂) and the number of desaturation episodes during the intubation were also registered.

RESULTS

No patients showed impaired IONM signal before dissection in both groups. Cormack-Lehane grade was higher in the intervention group (1^1;2) compared to control one (1^1;1; P = 0.046). No-NMBA patients had increased number of difficult laryngoscopies (21% versus 6%, P = 0.041) and intubations (34% versus 8%; P = 0.003) as well as a longer time to intubation (78 [55; 175] versus 55 [31; 110] sec; P = 0.006). Lower values of peripheral SpO₂ during intubation attempt were registered in the no NMBA group (99 [97; 100] versus 99 [99; 100] %; P = 0.020). However, the number of intubation failure was similar between groups (p=0.495).

CONCLUSIONS

Low-dose of rocuronium does not compromise pre-dissection IONM signal and improves intubation condition when compared to a relaxant free strategy.

Intraoperative nerve monitoring in thyroid surgery-shifting current paradigms

Over the past two decades, intraoperative neural monitoring (IONM) has matured into a powerful risk minimization tool. Meta-analyses of studies, most of which were limited by poor study designs and the sole use of intermittent nerve stimulation, failed to demonstrate superiority of IONM over anatomic recurrent laryngeal nerve (RLN) dissection in the absence of IONM. With the advent of continuous IONM (CIONM), intraoperative nerve electromyographic tracings, registered almost in real time during the operation, accurately predict postoperative vocal fold function when International Neural Monitoring Study Group quality standards are adhered to. CIONM aids in avoiding permanent traction-related nerve injury by urging surgeons to reverse harmful surgical maneuvers. CIONM also forms an integral part in the surgical concept of staged thyroidectomy. Delaying completion surgery on the other side until nerve function has recovered mitigates the risk of bilateral vocal fold palsy. CIONM has greatly furthered our understanding of functional RLN injury, enabling conception of effective risk minimization strategies tailored to the individual patient. The review summarizes the advances of continuous IONM technology that caused a quantum leap in risk minimization for thyroid surgery, shifting current paradigms.

Intraoperative nerve monitoring in endocrine surgery: prevalence and reasons for its use in Australia and New Zealand

BACKGROUND

Intraoperative nerve monitoring (IONM) has increasingly been used in thyroid surgery by general, endocrine and head and neck surgeons. The purpose of this paper was to explore the prevalence and reasons for the usage of IONM in endocrine surgery in Australia and New Zealand.

METHODS

A survey was sent to general surgeons registered with the Royal Australasian College of Surgeons involved in endocrine surgery and members of the Australian and New Zealand Endocrine Surgeons. Users were divided into surgeon type, area of work, hospital type and volume of surgery. These data were analysed with univariate and multivariate logistic regression models.

RESULTS

Significant differences in IONM usage levels were observed between endocrine and general surgeons, area of work and volume of surgery performed. Endocrine surgeons are significantly more likely to use IONM than general surgeons. Surgeons who work in tertiary hospitals are more likely to use IONM as compared to those working in district hospitals. Surgeons who perform less than 100 thyroidectomies were more likely to be users of IONM.

CONCLUSION

IONM is not routinely used in thyroid surgery in Australia and New Zealand. The main reasons for the use of IONM given in our study by routine users were to establish familiarity of equipment and medicolegal reasons. Selective users chose as the most common reasons, a documented pre-existing unilateral nerve paresis or a hostile surgical field. Non-users stated that there was conflicting evidence that it improves outcomes and increased costs.

Utility of intraoperative nerve monitoring in thyroid surgery: 20-year experience with 1418 cases

PURPOSE

The efficacy of intraoperative nerve monitoring is controversial in the literature. This study of a single surgeon's experience seeks to determine if the use of intraoperative nerve monitoring influences recurrent laryngeal nerve injury during thyroid surgery.

METHODS

Six hundred fifty-seven patients with normal pre-operative vocal fold function underwent thyroid surgery without the use of intraoperative nerve monitoring from September 1997 to January 2007, while 761 patients underwent thyroid surgery from February 2007 to February 2016 with routine use of nerve monitoring. Patients were followed for a minimum of 6 months after surgery, and postoperative nerve function was determined by fiberoptic laryngoscopy. A Fisher test was used to determine if nerve injury was statistically different between both groups.

RESULTS

In patients operated on without nerve monitoring, 21 patients were found to have postoperative vocal fold paralysis with nine regaining functioning. In patients operated on with nerve monitoring, 27 were found to have vocal fold dysfunction with 17 regaining function. Fisher test analysis, both with and without patients regaining function, showed no difference in nerve injury between groups (p > 0.05, p > 0.05).

CONCLUSION

Intraoperative monitoring during thyroidectomy may not prevent injury to the recurrent laryngeal nerve.

Total Endoscopic Thyroidectomy with Intraoperative Laryngeal Nerve Monitoring

Objective. To evaluate the clinical efficacy of laryngeal nerve (LN) monitoring (LNM) during total endoscopic thyroidectomy via breast approach, with emphasis on the identification rates for RLN and EBSLN and the incidence of RLN paralysis. Materials and Methods. This retrospective study included 280 patients who underwent endoscopic thyroidectomy with or without LNM. RLN and EBSLN were identified using endoscopic magnification in the control group, while they were localized additionally by LNM in the LNM group. Demographic parameters and surgical outcomes were analyzed by statistical methods. Patients in the control group were also stratified by the side of thyroidectomy to determine difference in left and right RLN injury rates. Results. All procedures were successfully conducted without permanent LN damage. The identification rates for RLN and EBSLN were high in the LNM group compared to those of the control group, and the risk difference (RD) of temporary RLN injury between two groups was 6.3%. The risk of damage was slightly higher for the left RLN than for the right RLN in the control group, which was performed by a right-hand surgeon. Conclusion. The joint application of LNM and endoscopic magnified view endows total endoscopic thyroidectomy with ease, safety, and efficiency.

Postoperative vocal fold palsy in patients undergoing thyroid surgery with continuous or intermittent nerve monitoring

Background

Continuous monitoring of electromyographic (EMG) amplitudes of the vocal muscles detects impending injury of the recurrent laryngeal nerve (RLN) during thyroid operations earlier than intermittent EMG monitoring. This may alert the surgeon to stop a manoeuvre causing stretching or pressure on the RLN, with better recovery of nerve function.

Methods

Patients with intact preoperative RLN function who underwent thyroid surgery for benign disease between January 2011 and September 2014 under continuous intraoperative nerve monitoring (CIONM) or intermittent intraoperative nerve monitoring (IIONM) were included in this observational study conducted at a tertiary surgical centre. For CIONM, combined EMG events indicative of imminent nerve injury were defined as an EMG amplitude decrease of 50 per cent or more and a latency increase of 10 per cent relative to baseline values. The rates of early and permanent palsy for the two groups of patients were compared.

Results

There were 1526 patients, 788 of whom (1314 nerves at risk) underwent thyroid surgery using CIONM and 738 (965 nerves at risk) had IIONM. With the use of CIONM, 63 (82 per cent) of 77 combined events were reversible during the operation. No permanent vocal fold palsy occurred with CIONM, whereas four unilateral permanent vocal fold palsies (0·4 per cent) were diagnosed after IIONM (P = 0·019).

Conclusion

Operation with CIONM resulted in fewer permanent vocal fold palsies compared with IIONM after thyroid surgery in patients with benign disease.