Fetal scalp blood sampling during labor: an appraisal of the physiological basis and scientific evidence

Association between intrapartum fetal pulse oximetry and adverse perinatal and long-term outcomes: a systematic review and meta-analysis protocol

Background

Current methods of intrapartum fetal monitoring based on heart rate, increase the rates of operative delivery but do not prevent or accurately detect fetal hypoxic brain injury. There is a need for more accurate methods of intrapartum fetal surveillance that will decrease the incidence of adverse perinatal and long-term neurodevelopmental outcomes while maintaining the lowest possible rate of obstetric intervention. Fetal pulse oximetry (FPO) is a technology that may contribute to improved intrapartum fetal wellbeing evaluation by providing a non-invasive measurement of fetal oxygenation status.

Objective

This systematic review and meta-analysis aims to synthesise the evidence examining the association between intrapartum fetal oxygen saturation levels and adverse perinatal and long-term outcomes in the offspring.

Methods

We will include randomised control trials (RCTs), cohort, cross-sectional and case-control studies which examine the use of FPO during labour as a means of measuring intrapartum fetal oxygen saturation and assess its effectiveness at detecting adverse perinatal and long-term outcomes compared to existing intrapartum surveillance methods. A detailed systematic search of PubMed, EMBASE, CINAHL, The Cochrane Library, Web of Science, ClinicalTrials.Gov and WHO ICTRP will be conducted following a detailed search strategy until February 2024. Three authors will independently review titles, abstracts and full text of articles. Two reviewers will independently extract data using a pre-defined data extraction form and assess the quality of included studies using the Risk of Bias tool for RCTs and Newcastle-Ottawa Scale for observational studies. The grading of recommendations, assessment, development, and evaluation (GRADE) approach will be used to evaluate the certainty of the evidence. We will use random-effects meta-analysis for each exposure-outcome association to calculate pooled estimates using the generic variance method. This systematic review will follow the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-analyses and MOOSE guidelines.

PROSPERO registration

CRD42023457368 (04/09/2023).

Pathophysiological interpretation of fetal heart rate tracings in clinical practice

The onset of regular, strong, and progressive uterine contractions may result in both mechanical (compression of the fetal head and/or umbilical cord) and hypoxic (repetitive and sustained compression of the umbilical cord or reduction in uteroplacental oxygenation) stresses to a human fetus. Most fetuses are able to mount effective compensatory responses to avoid hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy and perinatal death secondary to the onset of anaerobic metabolism within the myocardium, culminating in myocardial lactic acidosis. In addition, the presence of fetal hemoglobin, which has a higher affinity for oxygen even at low partial pressures of oxygen than the adult hemoglobin, especially increased amounts of fetal hemoglobin (ie, 180-220 g/L in fetuses vs 110-140 g/L in adults), helps the fetus to withstand hypoxic stresses during labor. Different national and international guidelines are currently being used for intrapartum fetal heart rate interpretation. These traditional classification systems for fetal heart rate interpretation during labor are based on grouping certain features of fetal heart rate (ie, baseline fetal heart rate, baseline variability, accelerations, and decelerations) into different categories (eg, category I, II, and III tracings, "normal, suspicious, and pathologic" or "normal, intermediary, and abnormal"). These guidelines differ from each other because of the features included within different categories and because of their arbitrary time limits stipulated for each feature to warrant an obstetrical intervention. This approach fails to individualize care because the "ranges of normality" for stipulated parameters apply to the population of human fetuses and not to the individual fetus in question. Moreover, different fetuses have different reserves and compensatory responses and different intrauterine environments (presence of meconium staining of amniotic fluid, intrauterine inflammation, and the nature of uterine activity). Pathophysiological interpretation of fetal heart rate tracing is based on the application of the knowledge of fetal responses to intrapartum mechanical and/or hypoxic stress in clinical practice. Both experimental animal studies and observational human studies suggest that, just like adults undertaking a treadmill exercise, human fetuses show predictable compensatory responses to a progressively evolving intrapartum hypoxic stress. These responses include the onset of decelerations to reduce myocardial workload and preserve aerobic metabolism, loss of accelerations to abolish nonessential somatic body movements, and catecholamine-mediated increases in the baseline fetal heart rate and effective redistribution and centralization to protect the fetal central organs (ie, the heart, brain, and adrenal glands), which are essential for intrauterine survival. Moreover, it is essential to incorporate the clinical context (progress of labor, fetal size and reserves, presence of meconium staining of amniotic fluid and intrauterine inflammation, and fetal anemia) and understand the features suggestive of fetal compromise in nonhypoxic pathways (eg, chorioamnionitis and fetomaternal hemorrhage). It is important to appreciate that the timely recognition of the speed of onset of intrapartum hypoxia (ie, acute, subacute, and gradually evolving) and preexisting uteroplacental insufficiency (ie, chronic hypoxia) on fetal heart rate tracing is crucial to improve perinatal outcomes.

Fetal heart rate monitoring in labor: from pattern recognition to fetal physiology

The journey of human labor involves hypoxic and mechanical stresses as a result of progressively increasing frequency, duration and strength of uterine contractions and resultant compression of the umbilical cord. In addition, occlusion of the spiral arteries during myometrial contractions also leads to repetitive interruptions in the utero-placental circulation, predisposing a fetus to progressively worsening hypoxic stress as labor progresses. The vast majority of fetuses are equipped with compensatory mechanisms to withstand these hypoxic and mechanical stresses. They emerge unharmed at birth. However, some fetuses may sustain an antenatal injury or experience a chronic utero-placental insufficiency prior to the onset of labor. These may impair the fetus to compensate for the ongoing hypoxic stress secondary to ongoing uterine contractions. Non-hypoxic pathways of neurological damage such as chorioamnionitis, fetal anemia or an acute fetal hypovolemia may potentiate fetal neurological injury, especially in the presence of a super-imposed, additional hypoxic stress. The use of utero-tonic agents to induce or augment labor may increase the risk of hypoxic-ischemic injury. Clinicians need to move away from "pattern recognition" guidelines ("normal," "suspicious," "pathological"), and apply the knowledge of fetal physiology to differentiate fetal compensation from decompensation. Individualization of care is essential to optimize outcomes.

Fetal scalp blood sampling: Do pH and lactates provide the same information?

OBJECTIVE

Assess the discordance between scalp pH and lactates performed from the same sample during labor.

METHOD

This single-center retrospective study included all women with a singleton fetus who had at least one fetal blood sample taken during labor. Some of them had up to seven samples. Scalp pH was the reference parameter for obstetric decision-making. The correlation between the pH and lactates was studied using Pearson coefficient. By categorizing the values as normal, pre-acidosis and acidosis, we were able to estimate agreement with Cohen's kappa coefficient. The frequency of discordance in the categorization and the factors related to it were studied with univariate and multivariable analyses. Cases of severe acidosis at birth (cord pH < 7.00) and cases with acidosis scalp lactates but normal scalp pH were analyzed.

RESULTS

We analyzed 480 samples from 268 fetuses among the 2644 deliveries during the study periode. Fetal blood sampling represented 10 % of deliveries. The scalp pH and lactates results were strongly correlated (r=-0.83), but their agreement was only fair (K = 0.36). In 29.4 % of cases, pH and lactates were discordant. Factors related to discordance were meconium-stained fluid, sampling at full dilation and multiple sampling. Six infants (2.2 %) had severe acidosis at birth. Cases' analyses did not allow to conclude severe acidosis could have been avoided using scalp lactates for obstetric decision-making.

CONCLUSION

For more than a quarter of the samples, results were discordant between scalp pH and lactates, especially when cervix was full dilated and when the amniotic fluid was meconium-stained. A randomized controlled trial comparing the relevance of each parameter according to the obstetrical situation would be necessary.

Earlier and improved screening for impending fetal compromise

OBJECTIVE

The use of pH and base excess (FSSPHBE) from fetal scalp sampling (FSS) was abandoned when cardiotocography (CTG) was believed to be sufficiently accurate to direct patient management. We sought to understand the fetus' tolerance to stress in the 1st stage of labor and to develop a better and earlier screening test for its risk for developing acidosis. To do so, we investigated sequential changes in fetal pH and BE obtained from FSS in the 1st stage of labor as part of a research protocol from the 1970s. We then examined the utility of multiple of the median (MoM's) conversion of BE and pH values, and the capacity of Fetal Reserve Index (FRI) scores to be a proxy for such changes. We then sought to examine the predictive capacity of 1st stage FRI and its change over the course of the first stage of labor for the subsequent development of acidosis risk in the 2nd stage of labor.

METHODS

Using a retrospective research database evaluation, we evaluated FSSPHBE data from 475 high-risk parturients monitored in labor and their neonates for 1 h postpartum. We categorized specimens according to cervical dilatation (CxD) at the time of FSSPHBE and developed non-parametric, multiples of the median (MOMs) assessments. FRI scores and their change over time were used as predictors of FSSPHBE. Our main outcome measures were the changes in BE and pH at different cervical dilatations (CxD) and acidosis risk in the early 2nd stage of labor.

RESULTS

FSSPHBE worsens over the course of the 1st stage. The implications of any given BE are very different depending upon CxD. At 9 cm, -8 Mmol/L is 1.1 MOM; at 3 cm, it would be 2.0 MOM. The FRI level and its trajectory provide a 1st stage screening tool for acidosis risk in the second stage.

CONCLUSIONS

Fetal acid-base balance ("reserve") deteriorates beginning early in the 1st stage of labor, irrespective of whether the fetus reaches a critical threshold of concern for actual acidosis. The use of MoM's logic improves appreciation of such information. The FRI and its trajectory reasonably approximate the trajectory of the FSSPHBE and appears to be a suitable screening test for early deterioration and for earlier interventions to keep the fetus out of trouble rather than wait until high risk status develops.

Fetal scalp blood sampling during second stage of labor - analyzing lactate or pH? A secondary analysis of a randomized controlled trial

Background: Cardiotocography (CTG) is a widely used method for assessing fetal wellbeing during labor. It is well-known that CTG has high sensitivity but low specificity. To avoid unnecessary operative interventions, adjunctive methods such as fetal blood sampling (FBS) are used. Few studies have looked into whether FBS can be used during second stage of labor, and in that case, which of the methods (lactate or pH) are preferred.Objective: To evaluate clinical effectiveness of measuring lactate versus pH in preventing birth acidemia when FBS was performed during second stage of labor.Methods: Secondary analysis of a randomized controlled trial . Thousand three hundred and thirty-eight women with a singleton pregnancy, cephalic presentation, gestational age ≥34 weeks, and indication for FBS during second stage of labor were included.Main outcome measures: Metabolic acidemia (pH <7.05 and base deficit >12 mmol/l) or pH < 7.00 in cord arterial blood at birth.Secondary outcomes: A composite outcome (metabolic acidemia, pH <7 or Apgar score <4), and rates of operative deliveries.Results: Metabolic acidemia occurred in 4.1% in the lactate versus 5.1% in the pH group (relative risk (RR): 0.80; 95% confidence interval (CI): 0.48-1.35) and pH <7 in 1.4% versus 2.8% (RR: 0.51, 95% CI: 0.23-1.13). Composite outcome was found in 3.8 versus 4.9%, respectively (RR: 0.76; 95% CI: 0.46-1.26). No difference in total operative interventions was found. More cesarean deliveries were performed in the lactate group (16.5 vs. 12.4%; RR: 1.33; 95% CI: 1.02-1.74).Conclusion: When analyzing lactate or pH in fetal scalp blood during second stage of labor neonatal outcomes were comparable. The frequency of total operative interventions was similar but more cesarean deliveries were performed in the lactate group.

Comparing the effect of STan (cardiotocographic electronic fetal monitoring (CTG) plus analysis of the ST segment of the fetal electrocardiogram) with CTG alone on emergency caesarean section rates: study protocol for the STan Australian Randomised controlled Trial (START)

BACKGROUND

Cardiotocography is almost ubiquitous in its use in intrapartum care. Although it has been demonstrated that there is some benefit from continuous intrapartum fetal monitoring using cardiotocography, there is also an increased risk of caesarean section which is accompanied by short-term and long-term risks to the mother and child. There is considerable potential to reduce unnecessary operative delivery with up to a 60% false positive diagnosis of fetal distress using cardiotocography alone. ST analysis of the fetal electrocardiogram is a promising adjunct to cardiotocography alone, and permits detection of metabolic acidosis of the fetus, potentially reducing false positive diagnosis of fetal distress.

METHODS

This study will be a single-centre, parallel-group, randomised controlled trial, conducted over 3 years. The primary hypothesis will be that the proportion of women with an emergency caesarean section on ST analysis will not equal that for women on cardiotocography monitoring alone. Participants will be recruited at the Women's and Children's Hospital, a high-risk specialty facility with approximately 5000 deliveries per annum. A total of 1818 women will be randomised to the treatment or conventional arm with an allocation ratio of 1:1, stratified by parity. The primary outcome is emergency caesarean section (yes/no). Statistical analysis will follow standard methods for randomised trials and will be performed on an intention-to-treat basis. Secondary maternal and neonatal outcomes will also be analysed. Additional study outcomes include psychosocial outcomes, patient preferences and cost-effectiveness.

DISCUSSION

Approximately 20% of Australian babies are delivered by emergency caesarean section. This will be the first Australian trial to examine ST analysis of the fetal electrocardiogram as an adjunct to cardiotocography as a potential method for reducing this proportion. The trial will be among the first to comprehensively examine ST analysis, taking into account the impact on psychosocial well-being as well as cost-effectiveness. This research will provide Australian evidence for clinical practice and guideline development as well as for policy-makers and consumers to make informed, evidence-based choices about care in labour.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

ANZCTR, ACTRN1261800006268 . Registered on 19 January 2018.

National survey of routines for intrapartum fetal monitoring in Norway

INTRODUCTION

This study describes clinical routines for intrapartum fetal monitoring in Norway and compliance with national clinical recommendations.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A national survey of all (n = 48) birth units in Norway, using a self-reporting questionnaire about fetal monitoring methods and devices available in the birth units, admission cardiotocography (CTG) use, intrapartum fetal monitoring methods for women with and without risk factors, the availability of fetal scalp blood sampling facilities, and umbilical cord blood sampling routines.

RESULTS

All birth units responded. They all had access to Pinard stethoscopes, hand-held Doppler devices, and CTG. Half of the units used ST waveform analysis (STAN) as an adjunct to CTG. Furthermore, 23 of 48 units analyzed fetal blood samples and 43 of 48 umbilical cord blood gas samples. In 11 units, admission CTG was routinely offered to all women. No units used continuous CTG during labor in low-risk women. However, three units routinely used intermittent CTG during the first stage of labor. Three units used CTG without having access to fetal blood samples or STAN.

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings indicate some deviations from clinical recommendations in the use of intrapartum fetal monitoring in Norway. Three units used intermittent CTG for women without risk factors. Almost one in four units routinely used admission CTG, despite national clinical recommendations. The lack of access to fetal blood samples or STAN in units using CTG is of concern.

Diagnostic accuracy of fetal scalp lactate for intrapartum acidosis compared with scalp pH

OBJECTIVE

To determine the diagnostic accuracy of fetal scalp lactate sampling (FSLS) and to establish an optimal cut-off value for intrapartum acidosis compared with fetal scalp pH.

METHODS

A 20-month retrospective cohort study was conducted of all neonates delivered in our institution for whom fetal scalp blood sampling (FSBS) was performed, matching their intrapartum gasometry to their cord gasometry at delivery (n=243). The time taken from the performance of scalp blood sampling to arterial umbilical cord gas acquisition was 45 min at most. Five arterial cord gasometry patterns were set for assessing the predictive ability of both techniques. Subsequent obstetric management for a pathological value was analysed considering the use of both techniques.

RESULTS

The optimal cut-off value for FSLS was 4.8 mmol/L: this value has 100% sensitivity and 63% specificity for umbilical arterial cord gas pH≤7.0 and base deficit (BD)≥12 detection, and 100% sensitivity and 64% specificity for umbilical arterial cord gas pH≤7.10 and BD≥12 detection, with a false negative rate of <1.3%, improving fetal scalp pH performance. FSLS showed the best area under the curve (AUC) of 0.86 and 0.84 for both arterial cord gasometry patterns, respectively. Expedite birth following lactate criteria would have been the same as following pH criteria (92 obstetric interventions) with no cases of missed metabolic acidosis. In the cohort, 19.8% of cases were discordant, but no cases of metabolic acidosis were in this group.

CONCLUSIONS

FSLS improves the detection of metabolic acidosis via fetal scalp pH with an optimal cut-off value of 4.8 mmol/L. FSLS can be used without increasing obstetrical interventions or missing metabolic acidosis.