Implant-associated osteomyelitis: Development, characterisation, and application of a porcine model

The potential of sheep in preclinical models for bone infection research - A systematic review

Background

Reliable animal models are critical for preclinical research and should closely mimic the disease. With respect to route of infection, pathogenic agent, disease progression, clinical signs, and histopathological changes. Sheep have similar bone micro- and macrostructure as well as comparable biomechanical characteristics to humans. Their use in bone research is established, however their use in bone infection research is limited. This systematic review will summarise the key features of the available bone infection models using sheep, providing a reference for further development, validation, and application.

Method

This systematic review was designed according to the PRISMA guidelines and registered with PROSPERO. Quality was assessed using SYRICLE's risk of bias tool adapted for animal studies. PubMed, MEDLINE, Web of Science and EMBASE were searched until March 2022.1921 articles were screened by two independent reviewers, and 25 were included for analysis.

Results

Models have been developed in nine different breeds. Staphylococcus aureus was used in the majority of models, typically inoculating 108 colony forming units in tibial or femoral cortical defects. Infection was established with either planktonic or biofilm adherent bacteria, with or without foreign material implanted. Most studies used both radiological and microbiological analyses to confirm osteomyelitis.

Conclusions

There is convincing evidence supporting the use of sheep in bone infection models of clinical disease. The majority of sheep studied demonstrated convincing osteomyelitis and tolerated the infection with minimal complications. Furthermore, the advantages of comparable biology and biomechanics may increase the success for translating in vivo results to successful therapies.

The Translational potential of this article

In the realm of preclinical research, the translation to viable clinical therapies is often perilous, and the quest for reliable and representative animal models remains paramount. This systematic review accentuates the largely untapped potential of sheep as large animal models, especially in bone infection research. The anatomical and biomechanical parallels between sheep and human bone structures position sheep as an invaluable asset for studying osteomyelitis and periprosthetic joint infection. This comprehensive exploration of the literature demonstrates the robustness and translational promise of these models. Furthermore, this article underscores the potential applicability for sheep in developing effective therapeutic strategies for human bone infections.

Intraoperative tissue sampling for histology in chronic osteomyelitis shows high neutrophil infiltration centrally and low remains in debrided presumed infection-free regions

INTRODUCTION

Histology of debrided bone tissue is a confirmatory diagnostic criterion for fracture related infection (FRI) and prosthetic joint infection (PJI). The aim of the present study was to describe the histopathology of the first and last debrided bone tissue in chronic osteomyelitis (CO) according to the international diagnostic guidelines for FRI and PJI.

METHODS

15 patients with CO were allocated to surgical treatment using a one-stage protocol including extensive debridement. Suspected infected bone tissue eradicated early in the debridement procedure was collected as a clearly infected sample (S1). Likewise, the last eradicated bone tissue was collected as a suspected non-infected sample (S2). The samples were processed for histology. HE-stained sections were patho-morphologically examinated. Immunohistochemistry with MAC-387 antibodies towards calprotectin was used for estimation of neutrophil granulocyte (NP) score (0, 1, 2 or 3).

RESULTS

S1 samples showed a mean NP score of 2.6 (3 is confirmatory for infection). Following debridement, the NP score was significantly (p = 0.005) reduced to a mean NP score of 1.6. The S1 samples showed a mix of fibrovascular tissue, dense fibrosis, viable bone, bone necrosis and bone debris. S2 samples contained mostly viable bone tissue, however, often small fragments of necrotic bone or bone debris were present.

CONCLUSION

The inflammatory response of CO still exists after debridement, although the response fades from the center. Therefore, sampling of debrided bone tissue for histology must be performed initially during surgery, otherwise there is a risk for underestimation of NP infiltration. The present results might also be highly relevant for FRI and PJI.

A Journey into Animal Models of Human Osteomyelitis: A Review

Osteomyelitis is an infection of the bone characterized by progressive inflammatory destruction and apposition of new bone that can spread via the hematogenous route (hematogenous osteomyelitis (HO)), contiguous spread (contiguous osteomyelitis (CO)), and direct inoculation (osteomyelitis associated with peripheral vascular insufficiency (PVI)). Given the significant financial burden posed by osteomyelitis patient management, the development of new preventive and treatment methods is warranted. To achieve this objective, implementing animal models (AMs) of infection such as rats, mice, rabbits, avians, dogs, sheep, goats, and pigs might be of the essence. This review provides a literature analysis of the AMs developed and used to study osteomyelitis. Historical relevance and clinical applicability were taken into account to choose the best AMs, and some study methods are briefly described. Furthermore, the most significant strengths and limitations of each species as AM are discussed, as no single model incorporates all features of osteomyelitis. HO’s clinical manifestation results in extreme variability between patients due to multiple variables (e.g., age, sex, route of infection, anatomical location, and concomitant diseases) that could alter clinical studies. However, these variables can be controlled and tested through different animal models.