Cardiomyopathy in patients with epidermolysis bullosa simplex with mutations in KLHL24

KLHL24 associated cardiomyopathy: Gene function to clinical management

BACKGROUND

KLHL24 (Kelch-like protein 24) is a significant component of the ubiquitin-proteasome system (UPS), involved in regulating protein turnover through targeted ubiquitination and degradation. Germline mutations in KLHL24 gene have been known to cause Epidermolysis Bullosa Simplex characterized by skin fragility but has recently been found to cause Cardiomyopathy.

MAIN BODY

Various cardiomyopathies, including hypertrophic cardiomyopathy and dilated cardiomyopathy, leading to abnormal protein degradation and affecting the stability and function of essential cardiac proteins which finally results into structural and functional abnormalities in cardiac muscle. In this review, in order to understand the disease association of germline mutations of KLHL24, we summarize all the studies performed with KLHL24 gene including studies from 2016 when KLHL24 was first identified to be associated with epidermolysis bullosa simplex till the recent studies in 2024 by using keywords such as KLHL24 gene, hypertrophic cardiomyopathy, dilated cardiomyopathy and epidermolysis bullosa simplex. Furthermore, we explored the proposed molecular mechanisms and pathophysiologies of KLHL24 associated diseases. Patients with KLHL24 mutations were usually presented with variable clinical symptoms. The main clinical presentations have been cutaneous lesions, cardiac symptoms associated with cardiomyopathies and there have been reports of skeletal muscle weakness and neurological symptoms as well. Current treatments focus on managing clinical symptoms and preventing complications through medications, lifestyle changes, and surgical interventions. In addition, researches have also been conducted cell culture based in vitro studies for reducing the clinical symptoms of KLHL24 associated diseases. However, currently there are no specific clinical trials going on regarding the therapeutic strategies among patients with KLHL24 mutations. Understanding the role of KLHL24 in cardiomyopathies is very important for developing targeted diagnostic approach with therapeutic strategies.

CONCLUSION

This review emphasizes the importance of KLHL24 mutations as a newly recognized cause of cardiomyopathy, paving the way for improved clinical diagnosis, targeted therapies, and ultimately, for better patient outcomes.

Evolution of genome diagnostics in epidermolysis bullosa: Unveiling the power of next-generation sequencing

BACKGROUND

Genome diagnostics is considered gold standard diagnostics for epidermolysis bullosa (EB), a phenotypically and genetically heterogeneous group of rare disorders characterized by blistering and wounding of mucocutaneous tissues. EB is caused by pathogenic variants in genes encoding proteins of the dermo-epidermal junction. Accurate genetic diagnosis of EB is crucial for prognostication, counselling and precision-medicine. Genome diagnostics for EB started in 1991 with the introduction of Sanger sequencing (SS), analysing one gene at a time. In 2013, SS was superseded by next-generation sequencing (NGS), that allow for high-throughput sequencing of multiple genes in parallel. Several studies have shown a beneficial role for NGS in EB diagnostics, but its true benefit has not been quantified.

OBJECTIVES

To determine the benefit of NGS in EB by systematically evaluating the performance of different genome diagnostics used over time based on robust data from the Dutch EB Registry.

METHODS

The diagnostic performances of SS and NGS were systematically evaluated in a retrospective observational study including all index cases with a clinical diagnosis of EB in whom genome diagnostics was performed between 01 January 1994 and 01 January 2022 (n = 308), registered at the Dutch EB Expertise Centre.

RESULTS

Over time, a genetic diagnosis was made in 289/308 (94%) EB cases. The diagnostic yield increased from 89% (SS) to 95% (NGS). Most importantly, NGS significantly reduced diagnostic turnaround time (39 days vs. 211 days, p < 0.001). The likelihood of detecting variants of uncertain significance and additional findings increased from 5% and 1% (SS) to 22% and 13% (NGS) respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study quantifies the benefit of NGS-based methods and demonstrate they have had a major impact on EB diagnostics through an increased diagnostic yield and a dramatically decreased turnaround time (39 days). Although our diagnostic yield is high (95%), further improvement of genome diagnostics is urgently needed to provide a genetic diagnosis in all EB patients.

Gene-edited cells: novel allogeneic gene/cell therapy for epidermolysis bullosa

Epidermolysis bullosa (EB) is a group of rare genetic skin fragility disorders, which are hereditary. These disorders are associated with mutations in at least 16 genes that encode components of the epidermal adhesion complex. Currently, there are no effective treatments for this disorder. All current treatment approaches focus on topical treatments to prevent complications and infections. In recent years, significant progress has been achieved in the treatment of the severe genetic skin blistering condition known as EB through preclinical and clinical advancements. Promising developments have emerged in the areas of protein and cell therapies, such as allogeneic stem cell transplantation; in addition, RNA-based therapies and gene therapy approaches have also become a reality. Stem cells obtained from embryonic or adult tissues, including the skin, are undifferentiated cells with the ability to generate, maintain, and replace fully developed cells and tissues. Recent advancements in preclinical and clinical research have significantly enhanced stem cell therapy, presenting a promising treatment option for various diseases that are not effectively addressed by current medical treatments. Different types of stem cells such as primarily hematopoietic and mesenchymal, obtained from the patient or from a donor, have been utilized to treat severe forms of diseases, each with some beneficial effects. In addition, extensive research has shown that gene transfer methods targeting allogeneic and autologous epidermal stem cells to replace or correct the defective gene are promising. These methods can regenerate and restore the adhesion of primary keratinocytes in EB patients. The long-term treatment of skin lesions in a small number of patients has shown promising results through the transplantation of skin grafts produced from gene-corrected autologous epidermal stem cells. This article attempts to summarize the current situation, potential development prospects, and some of the challenges related to the cell therapy approach for EB treatment.

Gigaxonin, mutated in Giant Axonal Neuropathy, interacts with TDP-43 and other RNA binding proteins

Giant Axonal Neuropathy (GAN) is a neurodegenerative disease caused by loss-of-function mutations in the KLHL16 gene, encoding the cytoskeleton regulator gigaxonin. In the absence of functional gigaxonin, intermediate filament (IF) proteins accumulate in neurons and other cell types due to impaired turnover and transport. GAN neurons exhibit distended, swollen axons and distal axonal degeneration, but the mechanisms behind this selective neuronal vulnerability are unknown. Our objective was to identify novel gigaxonin interactors pertinent to GAN neurons. Unbiased proteomics revealed a statistically significant predominance of RNA-binding proteins (RBPs) within the soluble gigaxonin interactome and among differentially-expressed proteins in iPSC-neuron progenitors from a patient with classic GAN. Among the identified RBPs was TAR DNA-binding protein 43 (TDP-43), which associated with the gigaxonin protein and its mRNA transcript. TDP-43 co-localized within large axonal neurofilament IFs aggregates in iPSC-motor neurons derived from a GAN patient with the 'axonal CMT-plus' disease phenotype. Our results implicate RBP dysfunction as a potential underappreciated contributor to GAN-related neurodegeneration.

Heterozygous nonsense variants in laminin subunit 3α resulting in Ebstein's anomaly

Ebstein's anomaly is a rare congenital heart disease characterized by tricuspid valve downward displacement and is associated with additional cardiac phenotypes such as left ventricle non-compaction. The genetic basis of Ebstein's anomaly has yet to be fully elucidated, although several genes (e.g., NKX2-5, MYH7, TPM1, and FLNA) may contribute to Ebstein's anomaly. Here, in two Ebstein's anomaly families (a three-generation family and a trio), we identified independent heterozygous nonsense variants in laminin subunit 3 α (LAMA3), cosegregated with phenotypes in families with reduced penetrance. Furthermore, knocking out Lama3 in mice revealed that haploinsufficiency of Lama3 led to Ebstein's malformation of the tricuspid valve and an abnormal basement membrane structure. In conclusion, we identified a novel gene-disease association of LAMA3 implicated in Ebstein's anomaly, and the findings extended our understanding of the role of the extracellular matrix in Ebstein's anomaly etiology.

Towards a Better Understanding of Genotype-Phenotype Correlations and Therapeutic Targets for Cardiocutaneous Genes: The Importance of Functional Studies above Prediction

Genetic variants in gene-encoding proteins involved in cell−cell connecting structures, such as desmosomes and gap junctions, may cause a skin and/or cardiac phenotype, of which the combination is called cardiocutaneous syndrome. The cardiac phenotype is characterized by cardiomyopathy and/or arrhythmias, while the skin particularly displays phenotypes such as keratoderma, hair abnormalities and skin fragility. The reported variants associated with cardiocutaneous syndrome, in genes DSP, JUP, DSC2, KLHL24, GJA1, are classified by interpretation guidelines from the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics. The genotype−phenotype correlation, however, remains poorly understood. By providing an overview of variants that are assessed for a functional protein pathology, we show that this number (n = 115) is low compared to the number of variants that are assessed by in silico algorithms (>5000). As expected, there is a mismatch between the prediction of variant pathogenicity and the prediction of the functional effect compared to the real functional evidence. Aiding to improve genotype−phenotype correlations, we separate variants into ‘protein reducing’ or ‘altered protein’ variants and provide general conclusions about the skin and heart phenotype involved. We conclude by stipulating that adequate prognoses can only be given, and targeted therapies can only be designed, upon full knowledge of the protein pathology through functional investigation.

KLHL24-Mediated Hair Follicle Stem Cells Structural Disruption Causes Alopecia

KLHL24 is an E3 ubiquitin ligase. Variants in the start codon of KLHL24 result in truncated KLHL24 protein lacking the initial 28 amino acids (KLHL24-ΔN28). KLHL24-ΔN28 is more stable than wild-type KLHL24 and causes excessive degradation of keratin 14, leading to epidermolysis bullosa. Patients with KLHL24-related epidermolysis bullosa usually develop alopecia, which is uncommon in patients with epidermolysis bullosa. The mechanisms by which KLHL24 variants cause alopecia is currently unclear. In this study, we show that KLHL24 regulates hair maintenance by mediating the stability of keratin 15. Using a Klhl24c.3G>T knock-in mouse model, we identify that KLHL24-ΔN28 disrupts the structure of hair follicle stem cells (HFSCs). Destructed HFSCs cannot anchor hairs and cause premature hair loss. Long-term destruction of HFSCs causes their exhaustion and hair follicle degeneration. Mechanically, KLHL24 mediates the ubiquitination and proteasomal degradation of keratin 15, an intermediate filament composing the HFSC cytoskeleton network. Keratin 15 is dramatically decreased in the skin of Klhl24c.3G>T mice and in patients with KLHL24-related epidermolysis bullosa. These findings show that KLHL24 plays a role in hair maintenance by regulating the cytoskeleton structure of HFSCs and highlight the importance of the ubiquitin‒proteasome system in the stability of HFSCs.

Epidermolysis Bullosa—A Different Genetic Approach in Correlation with Genetic Heterogeneity

Epidermolysis bullosa is a heterogeneous group of rare genetic disorders characterized by mucocutaneous fragility and blister formation after minor friction or trauma. There are four major epidermolysis bullosa types based on the ultrastructural level of tissue cleavage: simplex, junctional, dystrophic, and Kindler epidermolysis bullosa. They are caused by mutations in genes that encode the proteins that are part of the hemidesmosomes and focal adhesion complex. Some of these disorders can be associated with extracutaneous manifestations, which are sometimes fatal. They are inherited in an autosomal recessive or autosomal dominant manner. This review is focused on the phenomena of heterogeneity (locus, allelic, mutational, and clinical) in epidermolysis bullosa, and on the correlation genotype–phenotype.

Identifying Epidermolysis Bullosa Patient Needs and Perceived Treatment Benefits: An Explorative Study Using the Patient Benefit Index

Epidermolysis bullosa (EB) is a genetic blistering skin condition for which no cure exists. Symptom alleviation and quality of life are therefore central to EB care. This study aimed to gain insight into EB patient needs and benefits from current clinical care. Two questionnaires were administered cross-sectionally to adult EB patients at the Dutch expertise centre for blistering diseases. Patient needs and benefits were analyzed using the patient benefit index survey (PBI-S). Ancillary data were compiled pertaining to self-reported EB severity, pain and pruritus, as well as current and previous treatments. In total, 104 participants were included (response rate 69.8%). Sixty-eight participants comprised the analyzed cohort (n = 36 omitted from analysis). The needs given the highest importance were to get better skin quickly (64.7%) and to be healed of all skin alterations (61.8%). A positive correlation between pain and EB severity and the importance of most needs was observed. Minimal clinically important differences within the PBI-S, relating to reported benefits from clinical care, were reported by 60.3% of the cohort. This study highlights a discrepancy between patient needs and feasible treatment outcomes. Utilizing the PBI-S in conjunction with well-established multidisciplinary care may catalyze the process of tailoring treatments to the needs of individual patients.

Proteasome-mediated degradation of keratins 7, 8, 17 and 18 by mutant KLHL24 in a foetal keratinocyte model: Novel insight in congenital skin defects and fragility of epidermolysis bullosa simplex with cardiomyopathy

Epidermolysis bullosa simplex (EBS) with cardiomyopathy (EBS-KLHL24) is an EBS subtype caused by dominantly inherited, gain-of-function mutations in the gene encoding for the ubiquitin-ligase KLHL24, which addresses specific proteins to proteasomal degradation. EBS-KLHL24 patients are born with extensive denuded skin areas and skin fragility. Whilst skin fragility rapidly ameliorates, atrophy and scarring develop over time, accompanied by life-threatening cardiomyopathy. To date, pathogenetic mechanisms underlying such a unique disease phenotype are not fully characterized. The basal keratin 14 (K14) has been indicated as a KLHL24 substrate in keratinocytes. However, EBS-KLHL24 pathobiology cannot be determined by the mutation-enhanced disruption of K14 alone, as K14 is similarly expressed in foetal and postnatal epidermis and its protein levels are preserved both in vivo and in vitro disease models. In this study, we focused on foetal keratins as additional KLHL24 substrates. We showed that K7, K8, K17 and K18 protein levels are markedly reduced via proteasome degradation in normal foetal keratinocytes transduced with the mutant KLHL24 protein (ΔN28-KLHL24) as compared to control cells expressing the wild-type form. In addition, heat stress led to keratin network defects and decreased resilience in ΔN28-KLHL24 cells. The KLHL24-mediated degradation of foetal keratins could contribute to congenital skin defects in EBS-KLHL24. Furthermore, we observed that primary keratinocytes from EBS-KLHL24 patients undergo accelerated clonal conversion with reduced colony forming efficiency (CFE) and early replicative senescence. Finally, our findings pointed out a reduced CFE in ΔN28-KLHL24-transduced foetal keratinocytes as compared to controls, suggesting that mutant KLHL24 contributes to patients’ keratinocyte clonogenicity impairment.

Case Report: De novo KLHL24 Gene Pathogenic Variants in Chinese Twin Boys With Epidermolysis Bullosa Simplex

Objectives: The aim of this study was to determine the molecular etiology and clinical manifestations of a pair of Chinese twins affected with epidermolysis bullosa simplex. Pediatricians should pay attention to the early genetic diagnosis of this disease. Methods: Histopathological examination of HE-stained skin, electron microscopy of biopsied normal skin, and whole-exome sequencing was performed to assess pathogenicity and conservation of detected mutations. Two years later, the cutaneous and extracutaneous manifestations of the twins were comprehensively evaluated. Results: A de novo pathogenic variant c.2T>C (p.M1T) in KLHL24 (NM_017,644) was identified in both twins. The characteristics of extensive skin defects on the extremities at birth and the tendency to lesson with increasing age were confirmed. No positive sensitive markers, such as B-type natriuretic peptide, cardiac troponin I, for cardiac dysfunction were detected. Conclusions: The de novo pathogenic variants c.2T>C (p.M1T) in KLHL24 (NM_017,644) contributes to the development of epidermolysis bullosa. Genetic diagnosis at birth or early infancy can better predict the disease prognosis and guide the treatment.

Gain-of-function mutation in ubiquitin-ligase KLHL24 causes desmin degradation and dilatation in hiPSC-derived engineered heart tissues

The start codon c.1A>G mutation in KLHL24, encoding ubiquitin-ligase KLHL24, results in the loss of 28 N-terminal amino acids (KLHL24-ΔN28) by skipping the initial start codon. In skin, KLHL24-ΔN28 leads to gain of function, excessively targeting intermediate filament keratin-14 for proteasomal degradation, ultimately causing epidermolysis bullosa simplex (EBS). The majority of these EBS-patients are also diagnosed with dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM), but the pathological mechanism in the heart is unknown. As desmin is the cardiac homologue of keratin-14, we hypothesized that KLHL24-ΔN28 leads to excessive degradation of desmin, resulting in DCM. Dynamically loaded engineered heart tissues (dyn-EHTs) were generated from human induced pluripotent stem cell (hiPSC)-derived cardiomyocytes from two patients and three (non)familial controls. Ten-fold lower desmin protein levels were observed in patient-derived dyn-EHTs, in line with diminished desmin levels detected in patients' explanted heart. This was accompanied by tissue dilatation, impaired mitochondrial function, decreased force values and increased cardiomyocyte stress. HEK293 transfection studies confirmed KLHL24-mediated desmin degradation. KLHL24 RNA interference or direct desmin overexpression recovered desmin protein levels, restoring morphology and function in patient-derived dyn-EHTs. To conclude, presence of KLHL24-ΔN28 in cardiomyocytes leads to excessive degradation of desmin, affecting tissue morphology and function, that can be prevented by restoring desmin protein levels.

Inherited epidermolysis bullosa: update on the clinical and genetic aspects

Inherited epidermolysis bullosa is a group of genetic diseases characterized by skin fragility and blistering on the skin and mucous membranes in response to minimal trauma. Epidermolysis bullosa is clinically and genetically very heterogeneous, being classified into four main types according to the layer of skin in which blistering occurs: epidermolysis bullosa simplex (intraepidermal), junctional epidermolysis bullosa (within the lamina lucida of the basement membrane), dystrophic epidermolysis bullosa (below the basement membrane), and Kindler epidermolysis bullosa (mixed skin cleavage pattern). Furthermore, epidermolysis bullosa is stratified into several subtypes, which consider the clinical characteristics, the distribution of the blisters, and the severity of cutaneous and extracutaneous signs. Pathogenic variants in at least 16 genes that encode proteins essential for the integrity and adhesion of skin layers have already been associated with different subtypes of epidermolysis bullosa. The marked heterogeneity of the disease, which includes phenotypes with a broad spectrum of severity and many causal genes, hinders its classification and diagnosis. For this reason, dermatologists and geneticists regularly review and update the classification criteria. This review aimed to update the state of the art on inherited epidermolysis bullosa, with a special focus on the associated clinical and genetic aspects, presenting data from the most recent reclassification consensus, published in 2020.

Genotype-phenotype correlations on epidermolysis bullosa with congenital absence of skin: A comprehensive review

Congenital absence of skin (CAS) is a clinical sign associated with the main types of epidermolysis bullosa (EB). Very few studies have investigated the genetic background that may influence the occurrence of this condition. Our objective was to investigate genotype-phenotype correlations on EB with CAS through a literature revision on the pathogenic variants previously reported. A total of 171 cases (49 EB simplex, EBS; 23 junctional EB, JEB; and 99 dystrophic EB, DEB), associated with 132 pathogenic variants in eight genes, were included in the genotype-phenotype analysis. In EBS, CAS showed to be a recurrent clinical sign in EBS with pyloric atresia (PA) and EBS associated with kelch-like protein 24; CAS was also described in patients with keratins 5/14 alterations, particularly involving severe phenotypes. In JEB, this is a common clinical sign in JEB with PA associated with premature termination codon variants and/or amino acid substitutions located in the extracellular domain of integrin α6β4 genes. In DEB with CAS, missense variants occurring close to non-collagenous interruptions of the triple-helix domain of collagen VII appear to influence this condition. This study is the largest review of patients with EB and CAS and expands the spectrum of known variants on this phenomenon.

Cardiomyopathy with lethal arrhythmias associated with inactivation of KLHL24

Hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM) is the most common inherited cardiovascular disorder, yet the genetic cause of up to 50% of cases remains unknown. Here, we show that mutations in KLHL24 cause HCM in humans. Using genome-wide linkage analysis and exome sequencing, we identified homozygous mutations in KLHL24 in two consanguineous families with HCM. Of the 11 young affected adults identified, 3 died suddenly and 1 had a cardiac transplant due to heart failure. KLHL24 is a member of the Kelch-like protein family, which acts as substrate-specific adaptors to Cullin E3 ubiquitin ligases. Endomyocardial and skeletal muscle biopsies from affected individuals of both families demonstrated characteristic alterations, including accumulation of desmin intermediate filaments. Knock-down of the zebrafish homologue klhl24a results in heart defects similar to that described for other HCM-linked genes providing additional support for KLHL24 as a HCM-associated gene. Our findings reveal a crucial role for KLHL24 in cardiac development and function.

KLHL24: Beyond Skin Fragility

KLHL24 mutations have recently been associated with epidermolysis bullosa simplex. Initial studies focused on skin fragility. However, the picture of KLHL24 mutations causing extracutaneous human disease is emerging, with dilated cardiomyopathy as a strong association. In addition, neurological disease is suspected as well. Careful clinical follow-up and functional studies of (mutated) KLHL24 in these tissues are needed.

Phenotypic Spectrum of Epidermolysis Bullosa: The Paradigm of Syndromic versus Non-Syndromic Skin Fragility Disorders

The heritable forms of epidermolysis bullosa (EB), a phenotypically heterogeneous group of skin fragility disorders, is currently associated with mutations in as many as 21 distinct genes. EB is primarily a disorder affecting the epithelial layers of skin and mucous membranes, without extracutaneous manifestations, and thus is nonsyndromic. However, recent demonstrations of skin blistering in multisystem disorders with single gene defects highlight the concept of syndromic EB. Here, we review the phenotypic and genotypic features of syndromic forms of EB to delineate the concept of syndromic versus nonsyndromic skin fragility disorders.